Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the hell energy companies keep desperately trying to push SMART METERS?

244 replies

Peekaboo3 · 02/03/2018 20:51

Just that.

Why?

Hell will freeze over before I have them.

My energy provider has sent me a letter saying ...

'We are now ready to install your smart meters. Just one phone call, and we will install the meters at your convenience yada yada.'

With the way they've worded it, it sounds almost like you have no choice.

We do have a choice of course. And my choice is no.

It is NOT compulsory. So they can piss off bugging me.

But WHY do they keep pushing these bloody things?

WHY?

OP posts:
Tianc · 03/03/2018 09:35

By the way, "trickle disconnection" gets its name from the water industry, where providers reduce water supply to a household by inserting a blocker in the pipe, allowing through only a tiny trickle of water which can be slowly collected in a bucket all day.

Thus meeting any statutory or humanitarian requirements not to cut off water supplies, while still sanctioning the household.

Tianc · 03/03/2018 09:29

DerbyshireDad, I'm not talking about isolating the supply.

I'm talking about "trickle disconnection," ie using the smart meter to severely limiting supply without actually turning it off.

This does not require presence of a utility company engineer, any more than it requires the presence of a utility company engineer when a prepay meter runs out or comes back on after payment.

The utility companies were very enthusiastic about trickle disconnection – I've covered it briefly in my thread that I linked.

A PP on this thread seemed to say trickle disconnection had now been banned by the regulator. I've asked for more details of that, and whether the physical capability will still be there even if not currently supported by regulation.

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 09:24

Genuinely enjoyed this conversation all, please don't take my words as gospel, as with any subject - do your own research and balance all sides of the discussion... and never ever believe what you read in the daily fucking mail :-)

Alas i have to go now, a shopping trip with the kids on the cards! Maybe ill pop up on the next one to throw my tuppence in!

Have a safe and warm snow day everyone!

LizzieSiddal · 03/03/2018 09:23

I agree completely, but again, as its government mandated then they really should have set up an intermediary right at the beginning as the major players were never ever going to be able to agree

So why didn’t the companies go back to the govt and say “We can’t agree, we need you to intervene” that’s what grown up people would do, whereas they blindly carried on pushing a product that they knew would be obsolete.

They need to take responsibility for this mess.

specialsubject · 03/03/2018 09:22

It's not a conspiracy, it is fact. Too many people, not enough resources. And that is planet wide.

Rationing better than none at all.

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 09:21

Tianc

Absolutely not possible. Even if customers owe thousands of pounds, legislation strictly forbids remotely isolating supply. This is founded in safety as remotely there would be no way of knowing what is currently switched on/being depended on.

This is somewhere the regulator actually has done excellent work, I'd m reading the Smart Metering Industry Code Of Practice (SMICOP)
This sets out the principles suppliers must adhere to, with prime focus on customer safety, and energy efficiency.

Tianc · 03/03/2018 09:21

You can get power under control

Yeah. You already have your power under your control.

This is the energy company being disingenuous: it's the electricity company that will get your power usage under it's control.

Which of course means taking some control away from you.

LightastheBreeze · 03/03/2018 09:19

This control seems a few years away though, they can't even make my dumb meter smart at the moment

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 09:18

LizzieSiddal

I agree completely, but again, as its government mandated then they really should have set up an intermediary right at the beginning as the major players were never ever going to be able to agree.

BeyondThePage

Definitely it will sit there happily until it needs replacing - the thing most people aren't aware of is that every meter in every home has a cost attached to its life-span.

Energy suppliers do not own your meter, they 'rent' it. If a meter has 17 years left to run, and the supplier remove it, then they have to in effect pay up the rest of the financial obligation for that meter. Just like trying to leave a phone contract early.
This means the oldest, and out of contract meters tend to be targeted for upgrade first as its less costly. (some meters have a life span of 5 years, some 25 etc etc)

Tianc · 03/03/2018 09:16

Its about control of the whole energy network.

Yep. Energy company wants to be able to switch off appliances in your home at a time of its choosing so it doesn't have to produce enough energy to run them. In a nutshell.

LightastheBreeze · 03/03/2018 09:15

Are gas meters harder to swap as BG couldn't offer me a smart meter even if I wanted one but Electric ones seem to be easily installed, I have never been pushed for a gas smart meter.

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 09:12

kalapattar

Excellent, and you can continue to use that happily until the meter legally is at the end of its life, then a new meter will have to be installed.
If at that point you still don't want one, then a Smart meter will be fitted, with the smart functionality disabled and you can continue to read it yourself etc. (at some point soon, old style meters will no longer be produced)

As i said before, honestly, the motivation isn't necessarily for YOU to save usage. Its about control of the whole energy network.

BeyondThePage · 03/03/2018 09:12

My current gas meter has around 17 years left of its lifespan. They can replace it when it needs replacing.

Otherwise it is not exactly "green" is it? Replacing perfectly good equipment before it reaches the end of it's life.

kalapattar · 03/03/2018 09:11

See - personally I have never found it difficult to read the meter and then out my readings online.

The adverts seem to be trying to persuade people that:

a) Meter reading is a faff
b) You can get power under control
c) You can see how much power you use and use less

It must be scary to see how much power is costing you - and it might make you use less power. I bet people who have pay as you use meters that you top up already have that feeling.

AnnaMagnani · 03/03/2018 09:11

We've got one. Sits in the cupboard, never use the 'smart' capacity, functions exactly like the old meter except I don't have to bother giving meter reading anymore. Which I like.

We already had a smart water meter which saved us a lot of money but TBH the electricity was never going to do the same, so it wasn't a big deal to us to change.

At no point did we see it as some giant government/EU conspiracy.

GrooovyLass · 03/03/2018 09:11

I've worked for Blank Energy for 18 years - I've seen a lot of changes. When smart metering first came out I wasn't fussed at all but I've come round to the benefits.

Btw just because I can see your current readings in an instant doesn't mean I do unless I need to. Nobody is sitting monitoring what you're using.

Tianc · 03/03/2018 09:10

The reason the companies want to minutely assess your usage is in order to change it, in real time.

The example someone gave above of someone on a low income switching off their fridge when they turn the hob on is WHAT THE UTILITY COMPANIES & GOVT WANT.

There'll be technology to do this, for those that can afford it: "smart" sockets or fridges which turn themselves off when the house's consumption per minute gets too high. And nominally turn themselves back on when the consumption drops. No one seems to have discussed what happens if it doesn't drop all night.

Because one of the significant things here is that it will be consumption in ££s that's used as the off-trigger, not KWhr usage. The price will go up during peak periods, and the fridge or washing machine will switch off because it's costing more, not using more.

Unlike countries which manage electricity shortages with rolling brown-outs affecting whole districts in turn, or like coupons during WWII when no matter how rich you were, you couldn't buy up all the ham in the butcher, the UK's smart meter system plans to use purely money to ration the scarce resource.

So it will hit the less well off disproportionately, while having almost no effect on people who don't need to worry how to pay the bills.

What I also haven't seen discussed (maybe that's just me missing it), is how long pricing "peaks" will stay in place. If the wind drops, will the peak be all day? Three days? Will the fridge or washing machine still be off 12 hours later? 12 hrs later? How often will this happen?

LizzieSiddal · 03/03/2018 09:07

Derbyshire
Definitely: the roll out began without a standard system. Some companies pushed first for their system. The others didn't agree.

This is what infuriates me and shows the companies are to blame for the fact people are refusing these metres. I believe that the companies who didn’t agree initially to a standard system, did it as they thought it would mean people wouldn’t want the hassle of swapping meters and would just stick with the first company who provided them with one. It took the Regulator to intervene and demand one standard system.

That behaviour is absolutely disgraceful.

LightastheBreeze · 03/03/2018 09:06

So now I have a Smart meter, though it is now dumb, suppliers won't bother me about having another one. That is probably why Eon didn't seem to care that their smart meter had turned dumb as they had fulfilled their obligation to offer one.

lynmilne65 · 03/03/2018 09:06

natasha
GrinGrinGrin

AJPTaylor · 03/03/2018 09:05

we had one installed by ovo recently.
it avoids the faff of reading it and results in accurate bills.
we change supplier frequently. worst case scenario is that it wont be compatible and ill have to go back to meter readings.

kalapattar · 03/03/2018 09:04

And again - consumers do not have to have one... the suppliers have to demonstrate they have made every effort to offer you one

I've got a meter that attaches to plugs so I know how much power they consume. I don't need a smart meter for that - I know which devices consume a lot.

I can't do that for the gas obviously - but I am capable of reading the gas meter at the start and the end of the day and knowing how many units were used and what that cost me.

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 08:56

kalapattar

Absolutely right - smart meters aren't magic, people have to pay attention to them if they want to cut their own energy use, and subsequently their own costs.

And again - consumers do not have to have one... the suppliers have to demonstrate they have made every effort to offer you one.

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 08:54

Peekaboo3

Thanks for that. I don't work in the Smart Metering sector, and don't remember my brainwashing on my company induction, though thats maybe all part of the devious plan!

Maybe jet fuel really doesn't melt steel beams...

DerbyshireDad17 · 03/03/2018 08:52

Pleasebeafleabite

Fair question: the answer is that simply, running different systems as an infrastructure wouldnt work. the costs in maintaining two or three different measuring capabilities, would be completely inefficient.

ITs not just domestic consumers, the program to upgrade all businesses across all industries is also already massively underway.

Theres also the issue of accuracy. there are still several million mechanical meters for gas and electricity, which degrade over time, and lose accuracy, and also provide potential safety problems. The upgrade program provides an opportunity to ensure all new meters and more importantly, the wiring/piping that supports them are up to current standards and safe.

This is why many people will find brand new cables, and or pipes installed following their meter upgrade. (the state of some households installations would truly shock people - figuratively and literally)

Swipe left for the next trending thread