Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why the hell energy companies keep desperately trying to push SMART METERS?

244 replies

Peekaboo3 · 02/03/2018 20:51

Just that.

Why?

Hell will freeze over before I have them.

My energy provider has sent me a letter saying ...

'We are now ready to install your smart meters. Just one phone call, and we will install the meters at your convenience yada yada.'

With the way they've worded it, it sounds almost like you have no choice.

We do have a choice of course. And my choice is no.

It is NOT compulsory. So they can piss off bugging me.

But WHY do they keep pushing these bloody things?

WHY?

OP posts:
Tianc · 04/03/2018 21:06

Demand side response is a thing, but it is not really to do with domestic consumers

That's completely untrue. Managing demand by domestic consumers through peak pricing is one of the main purposes of domestic smart meters. It was very well covered in the government's own documents.

I haven't time just now to pick out the relevant refs from my previous thread, but feel free to check for yourself (a lot of the DECC documents have been moved, but I gave full refs and you should be able to find them via google).

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/other_subjects/1327330-Anyone-having-a-gas-leccy-meter-replaced-with-a-Smart-Meter-Something-you-need-to-know

melj1213 · 04/03/2018 21:04

it won’t be so funny when you’ve buggered off on holiday and Alexa and the smart meter have had their mates round, trashed your house and drunk all your naice gin

Don't worry, they will have teamed up with your computer, hacked your online banking and ordered an Ocado delivery to replace the gin and an Amazon delivery to replace everything else before you get back ... they're just not very good with opening boxes or power tools.

Time4adrink · 04/03/2018 21:03

I agreed to have a smart meter installed, waited in all day and the fuckers never turned up. So they can whistle for it now. I plan on being the last household in the uk without one.

Squishysquirmy · 04/03/2018 21:02

It truly is a brave new world;
Alexa, self service "bagging area" pedants, sat navs, prudish spell checkers and now nosy smart meters... Who'd have predicted that the robot apocalypse would be so damn passive agressive?
Grin

Squishysquirmy · 04/03/2018 20:56

My wifi enabled thermostat is far more of a risk (and more interesting to hackers) than a smart meter....

I'm taking my chances with it though.
I'm sure il regret it when Putin boils me alive as I sleep.

TheHauntedFishtank · 04/03/2018 20:40

You laugh now kalapattar but it won’t be so funny when you’ve buggered off on holiday and Alexa and the smart meter have had their mates round, trashed your house and drunk all your naice gin....

kalapattar · 04/03/2018 20:37

I can just see it now, down at ISIS HQâ„¢: "right, we're switching off the power in the South East, that'll teach 'em

I'd be more worried about our limited gas security and Russia or North Korea hacking our nuclear power stations. Turning off the power in a few streets seems less of a challenge Grin

kalapattar · 04/03/2018 20:33

Plus, they could monitor specific households, when they go out, go to bed etc

I bet you haven't got Alexa either, have you Grin

Alexa must know our house habits really well. It knows when we are out in the day and when we are going on holiday.

LightastheBreeze · 04/03/2018 20:28

Maybe someone could hack in and make my meter smart again, Eon can’t and it’s their meter, once it’s dumb it’s dumb apparently

NotACleverName · 04/03/2018 20:20

Did a smart meter run over your dog, Peekaboo3? You seem unnecessarily angry about them.

Theoretically a terrorist organisation could hack in and turn off the power from half the country at the press if a button.

I can just see it now, down at ISIS HQâ„¢: "right, we're switching off the power in the South East, that'll teach 'em."

LightastheBreeze · 04/03/2018 20:13

The Smart meter now dumb wasn’t ever smart enough to know my daily movements and bedtime, It didn’t know what I was using it just showed high or low usage it didn’t say tumble dryer on now or anything like that. it was never that smart

melj1213 · 04/03/2018 20:03

Theoretically a terrorist organisation could hack in and turn off the power from half the country at the press if a button.

And if they have managed to hack into a power company's systems they will be able to fuck with the powers whether you have a smart meter or not. And I don't let my energy decisions be determined by theoretical terrorists either.

they could monitor specific households, when they go out, go to bed etc

What absolute bullshit conspiracy theorizing!

They can monitor people in far easier ways than tapping into the smart meter sitting in a kitchen sideboard!

The meter doesn't tell you anything except what is currently running in any given house ... not who is in the house or their daily routine. I often have the slow cooker and washing machine on timers to go on while I'm out at work so my meter would show I was home (as energy consumption would rise) when I was nowhere near the house.

Squishysquirmy · 04/03/2018 19:21

arena.gov.au/blog/demand-response-2/

Squishysquirmy · 04/03/2018 19:20

I'm not an expert but I understood it to be voluntary.

Squishysquirmy · 04/03/2018 19:18

Google "demand side response" or "demand side response australia" Beetlejizz

Beetlejizz · 04/03/2018 19:14

In Australia, it’s so that they can selectively choose who to cut off in the event of a power shortage.

Can you tell us more about this chalkitdown? People keep talking about companies choosing who and what to cut off in the event of power shortages, how would/does this work?

LightastheBreeze · 04/03/2018 18:58

I imagine most of the smart meters are dumb now as anyone invested in saving money will be changing suppliers anyway to get a good deal

couchparsnip · 04/03/2018 18:54

DH won't get one. He works in electronic security for the government and doesn't believe the potential hacking problem has been addressed. Theoretically a terrorist organisation could hack in and turn off the power from half the country at the press if a button.
Plus, they could monitor specific households, when they go out, go to bed etc.
When that's addressed (if ever) we might get one.

mummyhaschangedhername · 04/03/2018 18:31

It's a government push, they have a goal to have everyone on one by 2020.

Squishysquirmy · 04/03/2018 18:26

There's been some very informed points made on this thread. There's also been some utter nonsense.

I understand why some people have specific reasons for not wanting a smart meter (as explained on this thread). eg, they have poor mobile signal, they rent, they can't be bothered waiting in, they want to wait for a better, next generation one.
Makes sense - no-one is going to force you to have one and for a small minority of people they will not be suitable anyway.

However, I do find the "I will NEVER get one" brigade a bit harder to understand.
It reminds me of people I know who swore that they would never, ever use a mobile phone/broadband/internet shopping/chip and pin/self service tills... etc etc they couldn't see the point of the technology and they were deeply suspicious of it. Almost everyone uses all those things now without thinking about it.

And Grin that getting a pre-payment meter fitted is more convenient than a smart meter! A pre-payment meter is a terrible idea unless you are forced to have one. They exacerbate fuel poverty as the rates are generally less competitive and it is harder to switch (although this is getting better) whilst the people most likely to have one are (often) poorer. www.moneysupermarket.com/gas-and-electricity/prepayment-meters/

Worse case scenario with a smart meter is that if it can't cope with you switching it becomes a dumb meter.

"So they can selectively cut you off, if the supplier has a shortage in the future. That's what I was told."

Demand side response is a thing, but it is not really to do with domestic consumers; the idea is that if there are serious shortages in supply during times of peak demand (a serious future risk), participating businesses can reduce their usage. There is a financial incentive for them to do so, and they are not forced to participate. www.nationalgrid.com/uk/electricity/balancing-services/demand-side-response-dsr

Tbh, if we found ourselves in the scenario where the supply during peak demand was so insufficient that they were forcibly cutting off domestic consumers, we'd all be in the shit anyway. In that hypothetical scenario it would be a choice between reducing supply in a controlled, time-limited way (eg it would take longer to boil your kettle) or rolling blackouts.

If energy security in the future takes a hit, refusing en-masse to get smart meters is not going to protect us from blackouts and brown outs. Quite the opposite!

specialsubject · 04/03/2018 17:53

There is no evidence for the 'radiashun will give my kiddies cancer' idea. Science - true however much you scream.

TheCatsMother44 · 04/03/2018 16:46

I've never had it pushed on me, in fact, I don't think my provider has ever even mentioned it to me but as I can easily enter my meter readings online I don't see the benefit anyway.

Now I've read this thread I definitely won't be getting one till there's a universal smart meter for all energy companies just in case I do move supplier in the future.

Backscratchesforever · 04/03/2018 16:33

I would never have one, a lot of evidence to back up the risks.
Energy costs money, so we only use what we can afford. I don’t need a meter to tell me that or give me cancer

LightastheBreeze · 04/03/2018 16:19

hereyougosuckmyassforensics

Exactly what I thought Grin Very ANGRY

LightastheBreeze · 04/03/2018 16:12

I do find my Smart (now dumb) meter easier to read so glad I had a new one fitted, it works (well did) with economy 7 also. Family hasn't grown 2 heads because of radiation and wifi always worked OK, the main thing against them is that I change supplier every year to get a good fixed rate so unfortunately it remains dumb. It didn't really change my fuel saving habits though for the 3 months it was smart.

Swipe left for the next trending thread