Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

would you walk behind a car with its reversing lights on?

212 replies

Slartybartfast · 17/02/2018 08:25

well?
i was trying to reverse out of a car park, as you do, i ended up letting the car behind me reverse first, kept looking, then again start to reverse, only for people to be walking directly behind the car! of course i stopped but they walked and the woman looked back at me, while walking, for ages, glaring.!
and no i dont have eyes in the back of my head, and yes i do have reverse lights!

if you take the risk of walking behind a car with its reverse lights on, you are taking a risk imo, and you dont turn and glare angrily at the reversing driver.

OP posts:
Grimbles · 17/02/2018 14:04

So, is there anybody here who would actually walk behind a reversing vehicle then?

I assume most of us wouldn't because we understand it's a dangerous thing to do.

happy2bhomely · 17/02/2018 13:55

I would not walk behind a car that had reverse lights on. That is just common sense. If I did it accidentally I wouldn't glare at the driver but I would expect the driver to stop without moaning at me.

But as a driver, I know that it is my responsibility to make sure it is safe to reverse before I start to reverse and the whole time I am reversing. If a pedestrian approaches I stop immediately, whether they are in my way or not. I allow them to cross. They have right of way.

In the same way that if I am reversing out of a space and another car appears, I stop and allow the car to pass me. I don't assume that because my lights are on that I can just keep going!

The fact is if you hit someone while reversing, you are at fault. It doesn't matter that you can't see well. If you can't see then you should get someone to assist you.

Grimbles · 17/02/2018 13:51

nor buse,s as I remember a case where the bus driver braked so sharply at the zebra crossing that at least three pensioners and a dog were sprawled across the inside of the windscreen...

This is exactly why I don't just step out onto a zebra crossing, if there's a vehicle close enough to be able to hit me I wait until it has stopped or gone past before stepping out. I'm not going to trust that my judgement of there being enough room for a vehicle to brake safely is correct.

grannytomine · 17/02/2018 13:40

No YANBU it seems commonsense to me that people aren't going to have as wide a view when reversing so pedestrians should be wary.

steff13 · 17/02/2018 13:37

If youa re doing your reversing obervations properly, people do not appear out of nowhere

If they're a few spaces away when you begin reversing, you may not be able to see them because of other cars. Or, they were in a car themselves when you begin reversing, and they get out and start walking across the parking lot. They don't come out of nowhere, but they certainly can come from somewhere where you didn't have the ability to see them at first.

steff13 · 17/02/2018 13:34

In a parking lot you can start backing out of the space with no one behind you, and someone can walk into your path while you're actively moving. It happens all the time. Yes, drivers need to be aware of their surroundings, but I don't think it's too much to expect a pedestrian not to wake into the path of a moving vehicle. I mean that's just common sense, right?

Rubbish! There are there to illuminate the rear of the vehicle to aid the driver.

The white lights only come on when your car is in reverse. They're to notify those around you that your car is in reverse. They don't illuminate anything.

KurriKurri · 17/02/2018 13:24

If youa re doing your reversing obervations properly, people do not appear out of nowhere. Especially pedestrians (unless they are Usain Bolt).
Hazard perception is part of the theory test and that includes being aware of potential hazards. People are hazards because they may be ignorant (of such things as reversing lights) unobservant, and behave unpredictably. You are the one in the big metal thing, they are made of softer stuff - so it's up to you to do you robservation properly.

And glaring is a fairly standard reaction to someone reversing at you, people do it because they are momentarily alarmed and unsure whether you will stop or not.

And carparks are full of pedestrians - going to and from their cars or walking to the beauty spot.Presumably in a beauty spot car park there are no designated pedestrian areas ?

Drainedandconfused · 17/02/2018 13:17

ThumbWitchesAbroad.... it really shook me up and as silly as it sounds I don’t shop in Sainsbury’s anymore, the experience affected me that badly. I could have killed a child, it certainly makes you a more cautious and observant driver. The mother was clearly rushing and probably didn’t think, she missed it all.

BlackeyedSusan · 17/02/2018 13:11

nor buse,s as I remember a case where the bus driver braked so sharply at the zebra crossing that at least three pensioners and a dog were sprawled across the inside of the windscreen...

BlackeyedSusan · 17/02/2018 13:09

it is the drivers responsibility to look around and ensure people are not there.

however a pedestrian also has responsibility for themselves. walking behind a car that is reversing is silly as cars have blind spots, drivers can make mistakes.

I am always talking to my children about bliond spots on cars, especially on one pedestrian crossing near a corner. I have wathced the cars coming towards me as I walk and I can manage to approach the crossing entirely hidden behind the front pillar between the winscreen and window of the car as it turns the corner. well a skinnier shorter child could

I also teach them that cars do not always want to stop .

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 17/02/2018 12:58

Bloody hell, Drained, that's terrible! Why on earth didn't the ridiculous mother have her toddler under control? And to not even say sorry or thank you to you! Dear god. Shock

A time to be grateful for the modern technology, definitely! (My car is too old for them - that would have been a bad outcome :( )

Drainedandconfused · 17/02/2018 11:47

I had a horribly scary experience last summer in Sainsbury’s car park, if my car hadn’t had reversing beepers I dread to think what would have happened. I was parked in a disabled bay next to the parent/child parking bays, I checked all round for cars and people so started to reverse, my bleeper went so I immediately braked, there didn’t seem to be anything behind me so I put the car into park and jumped out, there was a toddler behind my car!!! The mother was 3 cars along putting her shopping in the boot of her car, why oh why didn’t she strap the child into her seat before unloading her shopping, I called out to the mother to get her child, she came running, picked her up and walked off, no thank you, no sorry. I got back into my car and had to sit for 10 minutes to pull myself together, I felt sick and was shaking, if I hadn’t had reversing beepers I would have hit the child. If you are the driver and reversing it’s your responsibility to not hit anything! A busy parent with 3 kids and a loaded trolley will not always be looking out for reversing cars.

aRespectableBureaudeChange · 17/02/2018 11:45

Yes non drivers don't understand. I used to do running commentaries in busy areas interacting with my kids to predict which pedestrian was being sensible and which idiot was about to step out without looking .

They would see from drivers' point of view how someone uses good body language and to communicate between pedestrian and driver - both have their part- but us as the driver has the "weapon" ie could cause serious harm to others it is our duty to avoid those idiots - for their own good. Doesn't mean they'll be grateful - usually think it's our fault, but you let it go because there's another one ahead!

so don't worry about the glaring, as per my sentence above.

LoniceraJaponica · 17/02/2018 11:29

I agree safariboot

safariboot · 17/02/2018 11:27

Now that I drive, if I'm on foot and see a car reversing I'll give them room to do so. But I think non-drivers don't realise how much of a pain in the arse reversing is. Or, it seems, what reversing lights are.

aRespectableBureaudeChange · 17/02/2018 11:17

Legally, in a civil case the driver should be driving at an appropriate speed to avoid a collision, even if someone runs out in front of you from nowhere - it can be a percentage of fault, but still responsible for not having avoided the collision. - not technically classed as 'accidents' for that reason legally.

Think may be misunderstanding between a criminal case and a civil case though - the police telling you one thing does not mean there isn't a case via the insurance where you'd have percentage of fault etc.

Anyway being 'right or wrong' kind of misses something: any decent person would suffer emotionally from hitting a pedestrian even if they say 'fuck 'em' on this thread - different in real life - unless prone to psychopathic tendencies, of course.

brownelephant · 17/02/2018 10:56

I wouldn't but I would expect a driver in a car park to let pedestrians past before reversing.

so yabu

Slartybartfast · 17/02/2018 10:53

And antagonist

OP posts:
Slartybartfast · 17/02/2018 10:52

Exactly roundabout, it was unnecessary

OP posts:
roundaboutthetown · 17/02/2018 10:50

Well, it would have to be a rather heartless legal system to blame a pedestrian for getting run over and thus charge them for the damage to the car as well as allowing them no compensation for their injuries. Although if you were trying to commit suicide and failed...

There is more often than not fault on both sides when accidents happen. And when accidents are avoided, it does not reflect well on anyone to rile others by staring at them in a passive aggressive fashion in a pathetic attempt to shame them into thinking the near accident is all their fault, when that is unlikely to be the case.

SoupDragon · 17/02/2018 10:42

soupdragon Don't be stupid.

I’m not the one who drives and claimed not to know what reversing lights are.

crunchymint · 17/02/2018 10:40

In Wells v Trinder [2002] (unreported) CA, a pedestrian ran out in front of a speeding motorist. The CA said that the failure of the driver to see the pedestrian until he was 10 metres away was “self-evidently negligent when she had been crossing the carriageway for some second before impact”.

In Eagle v Chambers (see above), Miss Eagle was struck whilst walking along (not across) a dual carriageway in a "distressed and emotional state". The court emphasised the high burden that was on drivers, to reflect the fact that the car was potentially a dangerous weapon. Car drivers, said LJ Hale, had to be on the lookout for pedestrians in the road.
In Goddard & Walker v Greenwood [2003] RTR 10, the CA found a pedestrian liable for 80% of his injuries for crossing with the lights against them. The CA said that the fact that the lights were green (in the car driver’s favour) was not an absolute use of reasonable care – in other words, just because the crossing lights are green does not obviate the need to keep a close look out.
In Lightfoot v Go-Ahead [2011] EWHC 11 (QB) a drunken pedestrian stepped out into the path of a bus on a dark country lane, to flag it down. The Judge held that if a claimant acted in a careless way by reason of his having consumed alcohol, that careless conduct could give rise to an allegation of contributory negligence. However, he noted that it was important to distinguish that from the mere fact of his being under the influence of alcohol. It was necessary to look at the claimant’s act of walking into the carriageway rather than the drunken state in which it had been done.

crunchymint · 17/02/2018 10:36

In England? I am very surprised at that.

ILostItInTheEarlyNineties · 17/02/2018 10:35

In practice..no one is liable

There have been cases where a pedestrian has emerged suddenly into the road and the pedestrian has been liable for damages to the car because it had been forced to swerve into something to avoid them.

PrimalLass · 17/02/2018 10:35

I backed into another car in a car park a couple of years ago. Because she had driven past, then decided to reverse back down the one-way road to reverse into a space. I saw her pass me the first time and started backing out. V annoying as it was deemed my fault even though she changed direction down a one-way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread