Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can someone be too fertile?

418 replies

ByTheBlueBay · 14/02/2018 12:13

I was on the pill for 6 years before I came off it. We conceived DD when we didn't use a condom once. Literally, once. I know once is all it takes but it was a shock.

Anyway since having DD we always used a condom. However it wasn't used straight away, there'd be a few pumps first (TMI). We'd only have sex once a month or so but I still managed to fall pregnant on DH's precum.

Am I super fertile? I had a termination and we haven't had sex since. I'm too scared. I'm considering the implant but I'm not sure how the hormones will affect me with depression and anxiety.

OP posts:
Namechangedtoscream · 16/02/2018 09:27

Thank you jaygee I think both ends of the curve are horrible and traumatic for those going through it.

Namechangedtoscream · 16/02/2018 09:26

Hyperfertility IS a thing and it's devastating. Many women with it lose high numbers of pregnancies as a result. I'm pregnant at the moment - we had sex once that month - which gives further evidence to being hyperfertile. It's not a sleight of insult to infertile women it's our own horrible cross to bear.

Jaygee61 · 16/02/2018 09:25

Sorry for your losses Namechangrdtoscream.

I’m definitely at the superbarren end - my body has never held on to anything.

DustyMaiden · 16/02/2018 09:23

The fertility fairy is a bitch. One niece had sterilisation and abelation, got pregnant. Other niece needed 3 years and drugs.
It’s life.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 09:23

WHAT was the insensitive bit of what she said? The phrase 'super fertile'? Which lots of people have said is a phenomenon.

Namechangedtoscream · 16/02/2018 09:19

My consultant at the recurrent miscarriage clinic explained fertility is a bell curve with hyper fertile women one end infertile the other. I fall under the hyperfertile end which is the likely cause of the high number of miscarriages I've had - my body holds onto everything regardless of quality

TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 09:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 09:14

You weren't expressing surprise though were you? You said it was 'cunty to be rubbing other peoples face in it' among other things.

TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 08:23

I think I’m so surprised because I’m only 23, yet I know a lot about this. So it seems incredulous that other adult women, no doubt older than myself, do not.

However, I’ve had gynae problems my entire life, so I probably know more about periods and pregnancy than most people in general.

Just seems very surprising that OP was ...surprised

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/02/2018 08:15

Maisy
You’re still judging op for the use of language. Perhaps she isn’t as eloquent or educated as you. Or as good as googling as you or I. We aren’t all the same.

TheCatsPaws
As with Maisy, you’re still looking at ops posts through your filters and knowledge of pregnancy, fertility etc.

In fairness, as Harvey said I didn’t know anything about the withdrawal method, pre ejaculation or much about the fertility window until I met someone, who practised the withdrawal method for religious reasons and I was around 30.

TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 08:03

To be fair, I use withdrawal. However I use it because I can’t take the pill, want to ttc again soon once I find out why I’ve had four losses, and don’t like the idea of something I have to get removed. I completely trust my DP and so for us, it’s the best method.

However I’m well aware I could get pregnant from it, and I also know when I ovulate and we avoid any sex during that time.

I’m still aware that, even by doing that, I could randomly ovulate early or late, DP could mess up and I could get pregnant. Especially as like OP, I seem to conceive quickly (staying pregnant is sadly another matter).

I would not, however, act surprised if I did get pregnant. At the end of the day, it’s not a reliable method and OP wasn’t even avoiding fertile times!

MaisyPops · 16/02/2018 07:57

In which case why not just ask 'is it possible to get pregnant if he doesn't ejaculate?'
That's my issue. The tone feels off to me. Why not ask a question to clarify a biological fact which needs answering? Why go down the 'i must havr some special fertilitt power this was such a surprise' route?

I remember our sex ed in school and thr message was 'if you aren't prepared ti hsve a baby then no penis goes in without contraception'. It's the same as what we teach in schools now.

So i get wanting to ask if it's possible to conceive pre ejaculation but don't get 'oh i must be super fertile'. One's clarifying a fact and the other is total nonsense.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 07:51

She had unprotected sex and got pregnant with her DD.

Then when they had sex they would put condoms on before he ejaculated. She thought she was having 'protected' sex because he wasn't ejaculating inside her - hence her question about whether she was very fertile.

Loads of posts on MN over the years about people successfully using the withdrawal method (which is basically what the OP is talking about, unprotected sex but not having him ejaculate inside you) for years and never getting pregnant from pre-ejaculate. Not a 100% reliable method of contraception and yes I might think well yeah, of course you got pregnant! but it is widely used so the OP wasn't being a dick for querying why she got pregnant when lots of women using the same method don't.

MaisyPops · 16/02/2018 07:31

Mummyoflittledragon
As i've said, had they said 'DH and I didn't use contraception and had an unplanned pregnancy. We thought we'd be ok but clesrly not. Can someone explain?' then I'd get that. (Although a quick google would probably tell you the answer)

Even 'We've been careless with contraception and had an unplanned pregnancy'

And I say this as someone who doesn't mind people TTC saying 'he just looks at me and i fall pregnant' because no contraception + sex = chance of baby. Some conceive quicker than others. That's life.

But 'i had unprotected sex and got pregnant. This is such a surprise and I must be super fertile' is annoying.

Some people manage to conceive quicker than others. But not using contraception and falling pregnant isn't because of super fertility. It's having unprotected sex. So I get asking 'is ir true you can still conceive with precum?' But I don't get 'oops silly me i clearly got pregnant because i have sone super fertility' when someone gets pregnant from unprotected sex.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/02/2018 06:14

TheCatsPaws
MaisyPops

The mere title would suggest op knows very little about the fertility. I really don’t understand why you are so upset with someone, who has neither read nor received the relevant education. Many many people on threads ask questions, which are answerable in two seconds on google. They usually don’t get shouted down. Having been through ivf (3 times), she, in comparison to me is very fertile. I think if op were comparing herself to someone like me, and what appears to be her current knowledge, the question is a legitimate one.

I don’t know what you’re hoping to achieve apart from shame her for her lack of knowledge. You definitely haven’t tried to educate her. Ironic really considering that this site is primarily to make eachothers lives better.

Bubblegum89 · 15/02/2018 23:30

Late to the party but been reading this thread and as someone who is suffering with infertility myself, I don’t find the concept of this thread particularly offensive however the OP’s lack of basic biologally is pretty criminal. If a peen goes in a vag with no method of protection, you can get pregnant. Nowt to do with being super fertile (though a good title for a new superhero comic strip, perhaps?) It’s to do with sperm meeting egg equalling a pregnancy. You’re welcome.

DropItLikeASquat · 15/02/2018 20:55

I have conceived on the pill twice (two different brands) and with a copper coil. Don't know if that makes me crazy fertile or not but I have 8 kids so yeah I suppose. lol

HarveyKietelRabbit · 15/02/2018 20:45

No you didn't say she couldn't talk about it TheCatsPaws but you did say:

The title is a slap in the face to those struggling to conceive as is saying you had unprotected sex once and terminated.

You didn't have to have an abortion (you then listed some reasons you think are good enough to be considered 'having to have' an abortion)

Stop rubbing it in peoples faces. It's cruel.

I'm not the only one who said her thread is stupid.

This site has a lot of people who are struggling (to conceive - suggesting the OP shouldn't have posted?)

I find the OPs thread childish.

I have a problem with what seems like her 'bragging'. It's insensitive.

SO I DO think you objected to her talking about it and you say ' what was she asking'.
The OP had a clear point to it even if it was poorly worded and seemed ridiculous or stupid or teenaged. She got pregnant when she didn't think she could because she hadn't had her DP ejaculate inside her and asked if she was more fertile because she got pregnant when he hadn't done that. She got loads of replies.

Some were less than sympathetic (I was a bit incredulous) but the idea that she was insensitive towards women struggling to conceive or offensive or bragging is what many of us objected to when she did have a query no matter how silly it seemed.

TheCatsPaws · 15/02/2018 20:37

Maisy well said, again. I feel similarly.

ohhereweareagain · 15/02/2018 20:36

pengggwn Star

MaisyPops · 15/02/2018 20:35

HarveyKietelRabbit
As I say, I can only talk about what irritated me from the thread.
I'm 18 months or so into TTC but am still happy to share in other people's happiness (even though on some days it feels really crap and i get down).

For me what I found irritating was the 'oh i must be super fertile to have got pregnant. What a surprise' vs 'DP and I chose not to use contraception and had an unplanned pregnancy'. Thr latter is true and the former is just irritating and insensitive at best or sheer goady at worst.
(Should add I don"t have an issue with people who do ttc and get a positive quickly saying 'i swear he only has to look at me to conceive' because they stopped using contraception and had a good shot at it. Equally, i have no negative feelings to people who manage to get a bfp due to contraception failure. Life is like that. But if someone doesn't use contraception and carries on like 'oh what a shock!' then it pisses me off. No contraception = not a surprise)

goose1964 · 15/02/2018 20:26

I got pregnant 3 times on the pill. Not a major problem as we wanted a few children, but one of them we only had sex once that month. I know you can get pregnant any time you have sex but it's not usually that easy

TheCatsPaws · 15/02/2018 20:15

I still stand by my question

“What was OP asking with this thread?”

If she’d said “I need some contraception help” or “I was reckless and subsequently had a termination, I need some support” or even “can someone help me understand sex and safe sex?” I don’t think anyone would’ve complained.

It looks like it’s been written by someone with very little knowledge of sex and very little sensitivity imo.

TheCatsPaws · 15/02/2018 20:13

It’s the way she talked about it.

I don’t think anyone is saying she can’t talk about it. Even I’m not saying that!

HarveyKietelRabbit · 15/02/2018 19:42

Maisy - I agree it could be annoying the OP didn't seem to have the basic knowledge about biology and conception. I wasn't particularly sympathetic in that regard. But that's a separate issue that wasn't the basis of a lot of posts. Lots of people don't have knowledge of things that other people do - yeah it may seem obvious but clearly isn't to some people.

But it wasn't annoyance at lack of knowledge that led to the attack on the OP.

What happened on this thread is that within 9 posts there was a call to take the thread down because ' a lot of women on MN have fertility issues and it could be upsetting for those who are desperate to be in your shoes'

More posts:

I agree this is insensitive for the many posters who struggle with infertility issues.

The title is a smack in the face to those struggling to conceive, as is saying you had unprotected sex once and then terminated.

It is thoughtless to post about being 'too fertile'

I agree with the thread being taken down, a lot of women struggling to conceive may be upset by it.

Stop rubbing it in peoples faces, it's cruel.

The OP is insensitive, immature and ignorant.

Those don't sound like comments irritated that the OP didn't use contraception and got pregnant - they sound like comments finding it offensive that the OP is talking about finding it easy to conceive when others don't.

Which isn't fair and is suggesting that women shouldn't talk about getting pregnant easily - let alone not wanting to be pregnant because it might upset women who want to be. And there is literally no comparative situation where other women are expected to not talk about something affecting them on a chat forum because some other women may be upset by it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread