Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can someone be too fertile?

418 replies

ByTheBlueBay · 14/02/2018 12:13

I was on the pill for 6 years before I came off it. We conceived DD when we didn't use a condom once. Literally, once. I know once is all it takes but it was a shock.

Anyway since having DD we always used a condom. However it wasn't used straight away, there'd be a few pumps first (TMI). We'd only have sex once a month or so but I still managed to fall pregnant on DH's precum.

Am I super fertile? I had a termination and we haven't had sex since. I'm too scared. I'm considering the implant but I'm not sure how the hormones will affect me with depression and anxiety.

OP posts:
TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 20:56

Like if someone told me something I’d said offended them because it reminded them of a traumatic experience or upsetting time, I would shut up and apologise. Not argue the toss, no matter how minor it was to me.

TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 20:55

OP lmao okay. You genuinely don’t see why what you said was offensive, do you? You had it explained several times, by people nicer than I.

TheDailyMailIsADisgustingRag · 16/02/2018 20:54

Oh leave off her @op. I actually agree with her last post. I didn’t find your op offensive either, but some of your responses to @thecats are a little less than gracious.

ByTheBlueBay · 16/02/2018 20:51

This isn't sympathy top trumps @TheCatsPaws. Is sounds like it is you who needs to grow up.

OP posts:
TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 20:42

I don’t feel upset as such, I just find it interesting the sympathy lies with OP rather than Maisie and I. OP has had, at worst, a few people online say she’s been an idiot. That is nothing close to what I’ve gone through and is nothing compared to what Maisie is struggling with being over 12 months ttc.

Whether others think it’s insensitive or not, if people who ARE suffering say they think it is, the polite thing to do would’ve been to apologise. Even if OP thinks we are being over sensitive, surely knowing where we are coming from, that wouldn’tve hurt.

I don’t want one now, as I said, however I hope OP does think to be careful with this topic.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/02/2018 20:34

Well if they do feel beleaguered, it’s a feeling of their own making. I don’t see anyone piling on either of them.

AnElderlyLadyOfMediumHeight · 16/02/2018 20:14

I dunno, if I were Maisy (and Cats for that matter, though I do agree with you about her becoming aggressive and offensive) I'd be feeling pretty beleagured. I'm not necessarily agreeing with everything they've said, just saying that I think I know where it comes from.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 20:13

Nobody piled on Maisy. Lots of people disagreed but I can't see piling.

No-one piled on Cats either. People disagreed and explained why and she became more offensive and aggressive but nobody responsed to her in the way she'd responsed to the OP though it could easily be said that she warranted it more than the OP.

AnElderlyLadyOfMediumHeight · 16/02/2018 19:53

And FWIW I didn't find the OP 'offensive', but I'm not keen on the piling on Maisy.

AnElderlyLadyOfMediumHeight · 16/02/2018 19:51

The 'only' 25% chance is considered a huge risk in many other contexts. I've been at both ends of this - getting pregnant first month of trying several times (and it's possible that the hyperfertility thing played a role in some of my mcs - so I also assumed the thread might be about that and first came on to advise) and going a year with no luck. The idea that it can't, or rather won't, happen if sex is had without contraception once is akin to the idea that you won't get a 6 if you throw a dice once. It's illogical and tbh a little superstitious. What I think Maisy was responding to was the illogicality in that combined with the idea that that has to mean one is 'too fertile'. The OP doesn't need to be scared to have sex, she just needs to use decent contraception, properly.

Badbadtromance · 16/02/2018 17:36

I'll be honest. I didn't know that you could get pregnant from pre cum either

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 17:21

Thanks Stroke. Yes, generally only people struggling with fertility know all the ins and outs and it's not offensive if not everyone does.

I know diagnostic criteria for psychiatric disorders inside and out.

There are threads all the time on MN saying does this sound like bi-polar/OCD/PTSD/ADHD/PD and the majority of the time the answer is no from me. And sometimes I post but usually don't bother.

Cats I think had her own thread recently querying whether she has PTSD which I think is entirely likely. But it shows that she needed advice about something she doesn't fully understand or have a lot of knowledge about.

But would it have been okay for me or anyone to go onto any thread (and there are many) querying psychiatric problems and say 'no this isn't OCD (for example) and follow it with grow up, how could you not know this?, this is really insensitive to people who actually have OCD, I thought this thread was an actual problem, you not having OCD is rubbing it in the face of people who do, your ignorance is shocking, your wording and tone is insensitive to people who actually have OCD and are struggling, I think it's shocking that anyone even needs to ask.

No it wouldn't.

Strokethefurrywall · 16/02/2018 16:47

HarveyKietelRabbit - I agree with every one of your posts.

There was nothing offensive about the OP at all. I'd hazard a guess that most women who aren't trying to conceive don't know the ins and outs of their bodies. We spend our teens being told that sex at any time can/will lead to pregnancy. Well that's crap isn't it?

I fell pregnant with DS1 the only time we didn't use protection. I had NO idea that each time you have unprotected sex, there is only approximately 25% of an egg being fertilised, so you can imagine my surprise and frustration when I didn't get pregnant with DS2 immediately after we decided to TTC.

This entire thread boils down to the OP being shouted out for terminology. That's it. Which makes it incredibly pathetic.

BackToThe90s · 16/02/2018 16:14

What is wrong with someone starting a thread in AIBU about thinking they might be super fertile ( as silly as it may or not sound?) Had the op gone onto someone's thread about struggling to conceive saying how fertile she is then that would be a problem.

If you're struggling with infertility then why click on a thread about being fertile other than to make yourself offended? 🤔 It seems like a really silly to do.

I think the reason people assume you can't get pregnant if the guy hasn't actually cum inside you is because they don't realise pre-cum can get you pregnant also or they don't realise pre-cum is even a thing that happens. Every day is a school day and all that..

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 15:54

I was on the pill for 6 years before I came off it. We conceived DD when we didn't use a condom once. Literally, once. I know once is all it takes but it was a shock.

Anyway since having DD we always used a condom. However it wasn't used straight away, there'd be a few pumps first (TMI). We'd only have sex once a month or so but I still managed to fall pregnant on DH's precum.

Am I super fertile? I had a termination and we haven't had sex since. I'm too scared. I'm considering the implant but I'm not sure how the hormones will affect me with depression and anxiety.

That's the OP. Nothing offensive or insensitive. Nothing.

NotASingleFuckToGive · 16/02/2018 15:28

It’s upsetting when people don’t understand mental health. It’s more uosetting to lose babies and have someone then post this stupid fucking thread.

I find threads where people lovingly talk about their parents make me upset and resentful, as my own childhood was not a happy one. So when I see threads of parental appreciation, I fucking ignore them because I'm not a masochist.

The fact is other people don't deserve to have their experiences invalidated, or be put on a guilt trip because I wasn't as lucky as they were growing up. Their lovely parents are in no way responsible for the failings of my own.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 16/02/2018 15:20

The OP didn't use offensive language in any way and has nothing to apologise for or be 'more mindful' of.

This strange idea that people need to change their language or behaviour to protect the sensitivities of women struggling with fertility isn't right and it is ONLY ever suggested about infertility.

She asked a question. On an internet forum. Using non offensive language. That's not insensitive. Dancing round with scan pictures while there is a woman in your office struggling to conceive could perhaps be insensitive. Not this OP.

If you feel people should not ask questions on the internet using completely normal language because you project your own problems onto it and it upsets you, perhaps the internet isn't the best place for you to be.

MaisyPops · 16/02/2018 14:35

LOL After my 4th my Dad asked if I'd consider shaking hands with DH at bedtime
Grin

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/02/2018 14:35

Maisy
Those comments exactly described how op reacted when she got pregnant with her dd. Having had one termination, she doesn’t want another pregnancy or termination and right now is very sensibly abstaining from sex. As a result, she asked a question about her fertility to the very intelligent and knowledgable mumsnet community. Where some see a woman being stupid and inconsiderate, I see a woman, who doesn’t want to make another mistake.

Cats
If you want that, I think you need to go first.

ColaCube22 · 16/02/2018 14:28

Sorry I hit post...
Gone in with such a hostile sounding post then maybe she might have

ColaCube22 · 16/02/2018 14:25

Well I think maybe you hadn't gone in

TheCatsPaws · 16/02/2018 14:21

Perhaps I was blunt and insensitive in my wording too, and no, I don’t want an apology from the OP. A “didn’t realise, I’ll be a bit more mindful in the future” wouldn’t be unappreciated though.

ColaCube22 · 16/02/2018 14:19

thecatspaws

Are you not even angrier, more upset and pissed off than if you had just read it, shrugged it off and moved on? It's clear the vast majority of responses to the thread are in disagreement that it's insensitive and offensive.
I don't see what you want from this, a grovelling apology from the OP?
She wasn't even aware that being super fertile was a thing, she was asking under AIBU...as in Am i being unreasonable to think that there is such a thing. I'm 33 and had no clue about this even though we have really struggled and had discussions with women that have been unable to carry a pregnancy to term even though getting pregnant was not an issue, not once did they mention this.

What you have gone through it terrible, truly awful and it's heartbreaking...I hope you get the answers as to why it's happening and that they can stop you suffering anymore heartache.

Isadora666 · 16/02/2018 14:17

I find it frightening that in 2018 there are grown women who don't know that semen in your vagina may result in a pregnant. Clearly our education system is failing somewhere.

FlightStrike · 16/02/2018 14:08

It’s upsetting when people don’t understand mental health. It’s more uosetting to lose babies and have someone then post this stupid fucking thread.

It's more upsetting to /you/, and the reason it's upsetting is that it is having a bad effect on your mental health.

You object to the OP expressing that she felt she had to have a termination rather than choosing one. However almost all terminations, including the examples you gave, are choices. There are women who choose not to abort babies who are unlikely to survive and who choose to forego chemotherapy in order to continue a pregnancy. Your insistence that she say she "chose" rather than "had" to have an abortion reveals only that you have decided her circumstances (despite knowing little about them) aren't worthy of your sympathy.

Your insistence that she is bragging about her fertility and termination likewise show more about your assumptions (because she didn't express herself in a way you found sympathetic) than the actual emotions she is expressing.

We can disagree about whether it makes her naive or stupid (personally I don't think misjudging the efficacy of the withdrawal method is worthy of quite the scorn displayed on this thread) but the OP is clearly distressed by her circumstances and currently too scared to be intimate with her partner. That is in no way a brag.

Swipe left for the next trending thread