Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can someone be too fertile?

418 replies

ByTheBlueBay · 14/02/2018 12:13

I was on the pill for 6 years before I came off it. We conceived DD when we didn't use a condom once. Literally, once. I know once is all it takes but it was a shock.

Anyway since having DD we always used a condom. However it wasn't used straight away, there'd be a few pumps first (TMI). We'd only have sex once a month or so but I still managed to fall pregnant on DH's precum.

Am I super fertile? I had a termination and we haven't had sex since. I'm too scared. I'm considering the implant but I'm not sure how the hormones will affect me with depression and anxiety.

OP posts:
TheCatsPaws · 17/02/2018 10:04

I’m not pissed off she finds it easy. I find it easy. I’m pissed off at the ignorance and lack of concern.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 09:58

Mummy - much respect btw for your very early post basically saying 'yep I'm pissed off you find it easy and I didn't but of course you can ask a question on MN'.

Self-aware and honest. Not saying 'well of course I don't care if you find it easy, it's the tone/wording/lack of knowledge that is pissing me off.

Flowers
Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2018 09:42

on reflection it was probably crap wording. A bit like some of your posts perhaps? Especially your first post on this thread. Your posts have projection written all over them. I’ve said I think you should step away from the thread. Clearly you’re not interested in anyone’s mental health. Including your own.

Olga81 · 17/02/2018 09:34

Whenever there are statistics about failure rates with different contraceptives I was always a bit puzzled by the 'typical use' rates for condoms as opposed to 'perfect use' as condoms are fairly simple to use. After this thread I'm guessing typical use includes those people who put them on part way through!

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 09:27

Even if the OP had said 'I must be the most fertile person in the world, my DP came in a sock and I touched it and had triplets' it makes NO difference at all to the infertility of other people and is not insensitive or offensive on an open anonymous internet forum.

If she worked in an office and was saying that to her colleague who can't have a baby then yes, maybe. But on an internet forum full of strangers? Who can quickly read the OP and click off it if they don't like it?

No, it isn't offensive or insensitive.

The same as it isn't insensitive on a forum to post that you earn a 6 figure salary when other people are earning 15 grand. Or to say that you don't know which handbag to buy for hundreds of pounds when some people have only a fiver to feed their kids this week. Or that you find it hard to put weight on when others are struggling to lose it. Or any number of things.

NotSureThisIsWhatIWant · 17/02/2018 09:11

Op has mentioned she is worried about depression, so don’t make things more difficult for her. If you have fertility problems this is NOT your thread. OP has not asked posted on your threads about her fertility so don’t come and post on hers about your lack of, it goes both ways.

Hormonal implants are not for everyone, I’m one of those who can get on wild mood swings on them. The copper coil has been the answer for me, yeah you get a couple of extra days menstruating but I, my family, the world and my dog will take that over the swings 100 times.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 08:41

kirinm
I'm not ascribing malice. Just that on reflection it was probably crap wording.
HarveyKietelRabbit
Not doing all of that stuff, no. But we are on 18 months (some months in thay have been write offs because DH has been away etc) Aware of CM because we looked into natural family planning a few years back but I don't really want to go down the obsessively tracking route (I left a job because of stress and the impact on my health so there's no way i'm going to stress myself out over this).
I know it's not always simple and I've not downplayed any of the other issues in her post. I just feel like it was poor phrasing and read to me a bit i must be super fertile.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 08:32

Maisy - you've been trying ti conceive for 18 months? So probably tracking ovulation, checking mucus, taking temperatures, spacing out sex, maybe lying down with a pillow under your bum or whatever? So conceiving can be quite a complicated business and you know that better than most? Egg and sperm quality matters, age, weight etc etc Yes it's a sperm meets egg situation but loads of people without being
infertile try for months and months shagging like rabbits.

The OP had sex one time and he didn't ejaculate inside her. She wasn't saying oh I don't understand how I got pregnant. She knew how she got pregnant. She was saying that surely the odds were stacked against it happening so she wondered why that was. She wasn't being insensitive and she definitely wasn't bragging as she said she felt she'd had to go through the trauma of a termination and has depression and anxiety and now feels too scared to have sex.

kirinm · 17/02/2018 08:19

But @MaisyPops the OP only asked the question. She hasn't insisted that she's super fertile. It's the rest of the posters that piled on and started using wording like 'hyper fertility'. It's clear to me that the OP didn't know that super fertility is a condition much less its consequences (I didn't know either and have been treated for recurrent miscarriages so it's not like I'm completely unaware of fertility issues). I honestly don't think there was anything other than perhaps a lack of knowledge behind the question certainly no malice.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 08:14

HarveyKietelRabbit
For me it's just the sort of throwaway comment that could cause upset because it's a bit i got pregnant because i am superfertile when the reality is i got pregnant because i had unprotected sex. It places the onus of getting pregnant on some a factual inaccuracy which annoys me and sounds a bit 'wow what a surprise. There must be something special about me' rather than the boring fact of 'no contraception = chance of pregnancy'.

But i also feel that way when people say they had missed pills and had a 'surprise' pregnancy. It's not a surprise. You didn't use contraception properly. No contraception = chance of pregnancy

I'm not a misery guts who thinks nobody should talk about pregnancies. Someone who's TTC and conceives quickly saying 'we're surprised we managed it first month' doesn't bother me. Neither do jokes about DH just looking at me and we have a baby. But thry don't annoy me because they're not based on the idea of 'oh gosh i didn't use contraception and now i'm pregnant. What a shocker. Who'd have thought? It's a surprise baby. What a lovely surprise'. Argh. It's not a surprise.

I hope that better explains my frustration. But we probably will have to agree to disagree.

kirinm · 17/02/2018 08:13

It can @HarveyKietelRabbit - I had some real issues in agreeing to see my SILs who both had babies recently and very easily. DP couldn't understand it and I knew I was just horribly jealous and whilst understandable, it isn't an easy way to live.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 08:10

kirinm 🤗 I've seen long standing friendships destroyed by this very issue and it is so unecessary and as I keep saying, it only ever happens around infertility and no other life struggle.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2018 08:04

Maisy
You were unjustly targeted and on the receiving end of some self righteous parents on a recent education threads. Now you’re doing the and to the op. Have you forgotten how that feels?

Yes it’s rubbish to be 18 months in on TTc. I really think you’re losing perspective when you’re far more level headed on other threads. I saw women going through ivf at the same time as me also losing perspective, driving themselves crazy and in need of therapy. I really think you need to take a step back for your own mental health.

The op asked a question about her fertility. She didn’t state any facts because she simply didn’t know any. Idk what you’re hoping to achieve by thrashing the same point over and over again apart from shouting your anger to the world. Op can’t retrospectively make her a question more palatable to you, struggling with fertility anymore that you can change your circumstances.

kirinm · 17/02/2018 08:02

@HarveyKietelRabbit for what it's worth, I am in total agreement with you.

kirinm · 17/02/2018 08:01

And several of us on this thread have been 'through' what cats has said she's been through and therefore DO know what she is talking about and still don't think it's appropriate to be as rude, aggressive and she has been. There's no excusing the rudeness that the OP has faced regardless of personal circumstances. Believe me, I've had this moan. But I had it on the miscarriage board not at someone who asked a question on AIBU.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 08:00

We'll have to agree to disagree then because I don't think I'll ever understand why it would be tactless. I hope you get your wish fulfilled soon Flowers

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 07:55

HarveyKietelRabbit
I thought i was in the pregnancy forum, hence being a bit Hmm, and when someone pointed out to me it wasn't, I appologised for that (like pages ago just after my post) and said I still think it's factually wrong and tactless, which I do.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 07:50

But people weren't complaining about her having used the term incorrectly (a term which most people also hadn't heard of) until later in the thread. People were complaining that she got pregnant easily, some people can't and her talking about that on AIBU on a massive forum was insensitive or offensive.

It's that I disagree with and it is only ever suggested about infertility, no other life struggle. And I think that's strange and I think it's wrong and I don't think it does any favours for any party involved.

It's why people get upset in RL about pregnant people announcing it on FB or something and that being 'insensitive' to the family member or friend that can't have a baby. Or why the pregnant friend avoids telling the friend because they don't want to upset them and then they feel worse because they had been treated differently and left out. The idea that you must walk on eggshells around someone struggling with infertility and change your language or behaviour just causes so much damage.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 07:37

Absofrigginlootly
People have chosen to miss the point on what i've said.
Penis goes in vagina without contraception = chance of pregnancy
Explaining an unplanned pregnancy due to no contraception as a surprise due to superfertility is tactless and naive and quite frustrating (see also teenagers claiming their pregnancy was a surprise because 'we only had sex once', but they are kids.)
Conception isn't a tally chart thing where 'just once and you'll be fine' is a thing. It takes one sperm at the right time. Conceiving without contraception isn't a miracle.
E.g. if DH and I had sex once in 6 months and I got pregnant, it wouldn't be a surprise, nor would it mean I am super fertile. It would just mean that the one time we did have unprotected sex over a number of months happened to be at the right time. Nothing more. Nothing less. If i explained the pregnancy as my own brilliant fertility it would be factually wrong and tactless

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 07:02

It's possible to understand and also think that doesn't mean that people can't ask a genuine question on an open website in a non-infertility forum.

Someone falling pregnant easily or having a pregnancy they do not feel able to continue with or even just don't want to proceed with isn't offensive or insensitive or 'rubbing it in the faces' of those that are struggling to conceive or maintain a pregnancy.

Absofrigginlootly · 17/02/2018 05:02

Whist sat down to read the thread properly (I'm 5 hours behind the uk)....

Wowsas!!!!! Thecats and maisie FlowersCakeWine Jesus people have really missed the point here haven't they?

Fwiw I agree with what you're both saying about the tone of the OPs post. I genuinely don't think she intended to cause any offense with her wording (although using the word super fertile in the context of her situation is tactless and ignorant and I think the gracious thing would have been to say sorry for the unintended offense when it had been pointed out)....

I also don't see thecats posts as being grossly offensive - you can tell she is becoming increasingly frustrated and I can empathize with her position after what she's said she's been through. For your own peace it's probably better to hide the thread now cats, go outside and take some deep breaths and try to forget about it.

Hopefully people reading this will have learnt some things:
If a penis goes in a vagina and no contraception is used, you can get pregnant.
Preejactulatory fluid co rains active semen
Hyper/super fertility is a real condition where ones endometrium is super receptive and unable to distinguish between low and high quality fertilized eggs. Symptoms are short time to conception and recurrent miscarriage

OP if you're still reading you need to contact the department where you had your termination. You should not be waking up soaked through with blood 6 weeks later. You need to be rescanned to check for retained placenta/tissues

Flowers to anyone affected by infertility, sub fertility and hyper fertility. Fertility issues are a special type of shite that I don't think anyone whose not been through it can understand

Dobbythesockelf · 16/02/2018 21:22

Life doesn't work like that, one person's suffering doesn't trump another person's because we all cope differently with different things. I and other posters have said that we understand that you are hurting etc but you never acknowledge this. I hope you get some help with your feelings because if you carry on being so angry with the world it could really harm you.

Strokethefurrywall · 16/02/2018 21:15

I don’t feel upset as such

Your other comments on this thread point to completely the opposite reaction. Your posts have been far more aggressive than the OPs, despite her acknowledgement that she perhaps had used the wrong language.

I don't understand why you keep returning to the thread. This is the OP's thread, you don't have to keep coming back to it!

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/02/2018 21:05

TheCatsPaws
Some posters including myself sent you our sympathies despite not agreeing with you. You didn’t acknowledge my post, I don’t remember if you acknowledged any of the others. So please don’t say it’s all one sided. I also cannot believe you are back to minimising the nastiness in some of your posts. As I said if you wish to elicit an apology from the op, you should go first but it would appear you would rather continue to argue. If op is starting to become a little disgracious it is because you are continuing to attack her despite she having previously said she didn’t mean to cause offence.

Absofrigginlootly · 16/02/2018 21:04

Only read about 1/3 way down and I suspect this thread has turned into a bun fight and gone off on tangents...

Anyway OP your use of the word "super fertile" is a little ignorant shall we say.

"Super fertility" is a real thing as previous posters have said. It results in recurrent miscarriage. It's very distressing.

If anyone is interested in finding out more this is a useful study

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3405140/#!po=29.8913

Swipe left for the next trending thread