Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Can someone be too fertile?

418 replies

ByTheBlueBay · 14/02/2018 12:13

I was on the pill for 6 years before I came off it. We conceived DD when we didn't use a condom once. Literally, once. I know once is all it takes but it was a shock.

Anyway since having DD we always used a condom. However it wasn't used straight away, there'd be a few pumps first (TMI). We'd only have sex once a month or so but I still managed to fall pregnant on DH's precum.

Am I super fertile? I had a termination and we haven't had sex since. I'm too scared. I'm considering the implant but I'm not sure how the hormones will affect me with depression and anxiety.

OP posts:
MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 20:43

Mummyoflittledragon
My issue on here is the flippant lack of contraception and the explanation of pregnancy being to do with something special rather than 'unprotected sex can lead to pregnancy'.
As i said, there are multiple options if someone doesn't want a baby starting with using contraception and if you make a decision to have unprotected sex then there's the morning after pill. Not taking those optipns and explaining as super fertility hit a nerve because it's quite insensitive to take no responsibility for contraception and then act like conception is a surprise. (Put it this way, when i was worried a condom might have failed because I was very paranoid, the first thing I did was think 'morning after pill' because I don't want a baby. Wait and see wouldn't have entered my head)

We didn't get much either.
We had 'this is how sex works' and 'if you don't want a baby for the love of God use contraception'.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2018 20:30

pringlecat
Put much better than me Smile

Maisie that’s possibly the biggest understatement on the thread.

FYI I, like many others didn’t have the sex Ed, which now appears to be on offer in schools. We were given a photocopy of a drawing of the inside of the uterus/fallopian tubes at secondary. And watched a video of a woman giving birth when we were about 10. That was it.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 20:19

pringlecat
Put much better than me. Smile

pringlecat · 17/02/2018 20:13

OP, you don't sound unusually fertile - you just don't seem to be using contraception properly. The statistics on how contraception prevents pregnancy are based on actually following the instructions - so you're not in the 2% of women who fall pregnant when using condoms. You're in the much larger group of women who fall pregnant when they don't use any contraception whatsoever.

Your DH chose to have unprotected sex with you, so either he is also ignorant of how babies are made, or he is relaxed about you falling pregnant. It sounds like getting pregnant right now would be a disaster for you, so if you do want to have sex, you need to have a conversation with him.

If you are unwilling to try hormonal contraception, he needs to understand that you are only prepared to have sex using condoms properly and this means no penis anywhere near your vagina unless it has a condom on it. Have you spoken to him about how the termination has affected you physically and mentally? Have you spoken to him about how he is feeling?

Any decent man will understand why you're anxious and how to help, if you sit down and have that conversation. An unplanned and unwanted pregnancy is a horrible situation for any woman.

If he doesn't understand why you're so anxious and that he needs to support you in this by putting a condom on before he enters you, then it's probably your women's intuition telling you never to sleep with him again because he doesn't deserve you. Chances are though that he will get it if you have that awkward conversation.

It would be nice if we knew everything about everything all the time, wouldn't it? You've had the facts pointed out to you now (albeit not in a particularly kind way by most posters); now you can go off and do something about it if you want to. I suggest the starting point is opening a line of communication with your DH.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 19:47

I stand by my view that adults are responsible for their contraception choices.

If someone doesn't want a baby then they should use contraception.

If someone doesn't want a baby, has contraception failure then the morning after pill exists (unless it's a failure unknown until a missed period).

If someone doesn't want a baby and as unprotected sex then the morning after pill exists.

If someone chooses not to use contraception, opts not to get the morning after pill and conceives then that is a consequence of unprotected sex. It is not a surprising consequence.

It's hardly a revolutionary view. It is the basics of sex ed we do in schools. We aren't about to start telling our y11s 'use contraception preferably but if you've not got something to hand then it's fine, just withdraw and hope for the best'.

April229 · 17/02/2018 19:41

Do you honestly think that there is some kind of counter that says it’s only by the 10th time of unprotected sec you get pregnant?

I don’t mean to be rude but do you understand how your cycle works? It’s not a build up of sperm over time, it’s one sperm from an ejaculation of millions at a time when there is an egg to fertilise.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 19:11

Still happy with yourself then? Okay I'm done now. See you on the education boards Wine

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 18:59

Someone chose not to use contraception and opted to have unprotected sex. If anyone doesn't want a baby and opts not to use contracrption then it is being too lazy to use contraception. If someone doesn't want to get pregnant then it doesn't matter how unlikely it is or whether you think it's just once or just twice, you use contraception. Want a baby or are open to having a baby, don't use contraception. Don't want a baby, use contraception.

The outcome was an abortion.

My hmm-ness is over the choice not to bother using contraception, not the subsequent abortion (as I said, I'm pro choice).

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 18:44

A woman said she had got pregnant when she thought it was unlikely, she felt she had to have a termination, was now too scared to have sex and has depression and anxiety.

You first accused her of posting on the pregnancy forum to wind people up. Then realising you were wrong and it was in AIBU and not apologising to OP (you said I thought this was in the pregnancy forum, my mistake) which is not an apology. You went on to say.

It's hardly an AIBU either. It's 'look at me being smug about super fertility which isn't super fertility at all. I was just too lazy to use contraception so had an abortion'.

If you are genuinely happy with what you said and think it was an appropriate response to a vulnerable ESPECIALLY considering that you went on and on and on later about the OPs wording being 'insensitive' and how she should have thought about the feelings of others, then there's not much else to say is there.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 18:12

HarveyKietelRabbit
Less of the et al please
I certainly don't want to be lumped in with claims of calling the poster cunty or bragging about a termination.
I disagree with an element of their post and have clarified why I feel as I do but have not made such nasty attacks like that on the OP so don't be lumping 'anyone who disagrees with the OP' into a group who call people cunts.

Namechangedtoscream
I agree that the difference is huge.
It's why (to me) it's important to discus things in terms of biological fact. E.g. conceiving after unprotected sex isn't some super fertility thing. It's more likely that sperm met egg at the right time and isn't some sort of surprising outcome if anyone chooses to have unprotected sex.

For some women, they do have a fertility issue in that area and it sounds heartbreaking for you. But then they wouldn't take the approach of 'i had unprotected sex and i'm surprised i'm pregnant'. If that makes sense.

Absofrigginlootly · 17/02/2018 16:00

harvey yes that why I said compassion has been lacking from both sides on this thread.

Namechangedtoscream · 17/02/2018 15:53

The difference between hyperfertility and "oops no contraception" @maisypops is huge.

For me unprotected sex once in a month WILL end up in a pregnancy and for the last 5 times that has happened the quality of the embryo has been insufficient to result in a successful pregnancy. My womb just grabs every fertilised egg whereas yours will use a bit more discretion about it.

An "oops" moment is highly likely NOT to result in pregnancy in the vast majority of women unless the oops happens multiple times over the course of the month. Then if the egg is fertilised chances of her body implanting it are slim unless it's a viable embryo.

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 15:51

Have you not seen the earlier posts from TheCats et al in response to a vulnerable woman asking a question and her vulnerability and trauma being ignored while she was accused of 'bragging about having a termination' and called ignorant, insensitive and cunty' because THEY were upset she hadn't used the wording they wanted?

That's what I've been objecting to and the fact they wanted her to apologise or feel sorry for her wording yet did not once acknowledge the utter shit trauma she has been through but kept coming back to say well what she said IS insensitive while being fucking horrible to her and about her.

So as long as they keep coming back to say 'well I am right' without acknowledging what the OP has been through and that they behaved badly and just might have been even a bit in the wrong or oversensitive then yes, I'll keep arguing with their assertion they're right.

Absofrigginlootly · 17/02/2018 15:25

Harvey you seem determined to have an argument about the very minuscule and specific details of what exactly pp may or may not have said - are you a lawyer irl? Grin

I don't think posters are offended that she used the term ignorantly (not being aware of something is the definition of ignorance) it was more the rather casual and flippant (?) tone of the whole thing and then the defensive aggression when it was pointed out, rather than apologizing for any unitended offence. (Which would be the nice way to respond.)

Rather this thread has descended into a bun fight about how the fuck was she supposed to know about this condition get over yourself no one owes you an apology get the fuck off the thread of it offends you. And posters from the other side getting increasingly upset and defensive precisely because it is an emotive issue for them. A little bit of human compassion goes a long way on both sides. This thread has been sorely lacking in it

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 15:12

This OP had NO idea about a condition called hyperfertilty (hardly anyone on the thread did). She wasn't asking if she had a particularly condition, she asked if it was possible to be 'too fertile' as she wondered if she was.

Which is why all the offence about her wondering if she had hyper fertility is ridiculous because she'd never even heard of it!

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 14:54

Just the other day I saw a thread about OCD where posters were complaining how they hated the casual way people say "oh I'm so tidy I just be OCD lol"
When to them OCD is a debilitating mental illness
I agree.
I'm so clean and tidy I'm so OCD. I like my cupboards stacked neatly abd line up my knives and forks on the table so they're just right. I'm so OCD about things would get a tetchy reaction and understandably so.

I find myself getting panicky and stressed over tiny details and it's affecting how i get on with day ti day life. Do you think it would be worth speaking to the doctor in case these are part of OCD or something similar? Probably wouldn't get a a negative response.

That's my take anyway.

FlissMumsnet · 17/02/2018 14:24

Absofrigginlootly

Thanks so much for that brilliantly kind and wise post.

We've been saddened by the casual meanness on this thread too and we will continue to zap any posts reported which break our TGs.

In the meantime, there's always Cake

HarveyKietelRabbit · 17/02/2018 14:22

Abso - completely different issue to this thread. If this was a 'AIBU to get annoyed that people don't know what hyperfertilty is? thread then you'd be right in that comparison.

An accurate comparison to this thread would be 'I think I might have OCD?' and people going on there and saying ' no of course you haven't and it's offensive and insensitive of you to ask when OCD is a real thing affecting people and that isn't what you're describing and it's shocking you don't know enough about it. I want you to apologise for asking about it and what you have said is offensive to people who do have OCD.

Absofrigginlootly · 17/02/2018 14:03

Excuse typos

Absofrigginlootly · 17/02/2018 14:01

I didn't come on MN for nearly a year and I think I'm probably going to step away from it again. Every time I come back this place has gotten worse.

It used to be a kinder more supportive place. Where posters were encouraged to be gentle. When I was as struggling with the early days of DD and had no support irl (very critical family) this place was quite literally a lifeline for me. Without it I don't know if I would have got DDs silent reflux diagnosed for e.g.

This thread has gone severely down hill with bitchy fighting and over analysis about he said she said.

I don't think people are being oversensiive to draw the OPs attention to the fact that in fertility terms hyper fertility actually means something medically and to use it in a flippant way is insensitive.

Just the other day I saw a thread about OCD where posters were complaining how they hated the casual way people say "oh I'm so tidy I just be OCD lol"
When to them OCD is a debilitating mental illness.

I don't think pouting that out is expecting special snowflake status, it's just education and spreading awareness isn't it?

I just wish everyone from big sides could post in a more gentle and respectful way. Rather than this sort of aggressive "I can say what I want and if it offends you then just fuck off the thread!" Style of posting.

But that seems to be MN (and the world at large) these days.

A little kindness goes a long way. As they say, In a world where you can be anything, be kind

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2018 13:56

I was actually talking about what GreatScottie has said. And I stand by what I said to you upthread. You have not liked it at all when you’ve felt singled out on education threads. But have no qualms in doing the same now to op.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 13:51

mummy
I'm not sure why that needs announcing.
It is not bullying to explain to another poster why something has been considered insensitive by some posters.
It is not bullying for me to clarify to other posters that I find any references to surprise pregancies due to no contraception to be annoying and insensitive (especially if linked to claims of unusual fertility) because they are hardly surprises and happen as a result of unprotected sex not magic fertility dust. It isn't bullying to explain that was the logic behind my earlier reaction (especially after i apologised for thinking i was on the pregnancy board).
Equally i clarified i have zero issue with baby talk and wouldn't say people should never discuss babies for fear of offending. That is not bullying.
That is explaining my personal view that linking pregnancy caused by unprotrcted sex to someone being unusually fertile is insensitive and not a surprising outcome. Stating that is not bullying.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/02/2018 13:04

I am now reporting this thread. The bullying is becoming intolerable.

MaisyPops · 17/02/2018 12:41

GreatScottie18
Personally, i think your analogy overstates but then others think mine was.

ignoring or dismissing the mental health issues the OP stated having in her first post. It's being ignored or played down as unimportant just so some people can justify having a go at her
Or people have said 'this is the issue i have with speculating about super fertility as an idea. Unprotected sex has a chance of pregnancy' and that's what people have been discussing in return.

I am more than capable of thinking it's annoying and insensitive for people (and i have said this is my general view not specific to OP) to act like pregnancy is a surprise when they choose to have unprotected sex.
(I also observed that when an unplanned pregnancy happens and the father is unsure thr standard response is 'if he didn't want a baby then he should have worn a condom or had a vasectomy' even if thr baby occured due to the pill not working because people say "don't put it in if you're not up for a baby".

Now people may cope with the fall out of an unplanned pregnancy in different ways. Some may really struggle. Others get on fine. However, the fact remains that to me when anyone chooses to not use protection and they conceive this is not a random occurance, nor is it a surprise, nor is it some fertility magic fairy dust.

GreatScottie18 · 17/02/2018 12:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread