Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CuriousaboutSamphire · 12/02/2018 14:41

ermmmmmm, but you just explained it! Nope! As I said, I remembered it, follow the rules as I remember them and hope I remembered it right!

I didn't 'explain' it. I might be able to, in an hour or so, but at the time of typing, I was merely remembering, parrot fashion! Grin

Firesuit · 12/02/2018 14:37

Even though I already knew the correct answer, it took me a few minutes to work out again why.

I would state the solution as follows:-

When you make your initial choice, there is a 2/3 probability the car is behind one of the other doors. That is not changed by one of those doors being opened. Given you now know the car is definitely not behind the opened door, there must be a 2/3 probability it is behind the other door you didn't choose.

DadDadDad · 12/02/2018 14:36

OK, that's Monty Hall wrapped up. Shall we move on to:

A. Why 0.9 recurring (ie 0.9999999.... ) is equal to 1

or

B. Can a plane on a conveyor belt take off?

Grin
BeyondThePage · 12/02/2018 14:33

I have no idea why though!!!

ermmmmmm, but you just explained it!

had a door with 1 chance in 3 - switch for the door with 2 chances in 3... common sense.

Firesuit · 12/02/2018 14:32

According to wikipedia, among the people who protested that the published answer to Monty Hall was wrong were 1000 Phds. Nobel prize winning physicists were willing to state in print that the answer was wrong. A famous mathematian said the answer was wrong.

These people all disgreed with the answer, after being told it. They were wrong.

I think that counts as a difficult problem.

Obviously if you take the right approach, it seems simple. The trick is taking the right approach in the first place.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 12/02/2018 14:26

Oh yes! I remember that one... not sure I always remember the solution.

You pick a door, it has a 1/3 probability of being the car
He opens a door he knows is a goat

So now you think, the 2 remaining doors are 50:50... well, no. Your door still has a 1/3 probability of being the car. Just because you now know what 1 of the others had that hasn't changed.

So yes, change your choice... it has a 2/3 probability of being the car!

I have no idea why though!!! I just follow the probability rules and keep my fingers crossed Smile

whatsthecomingoverthehill · 12/02/2018 14:15

I wouldn't say difficult so much as counter-intuitive. Lois, the problem is:

Suppose you're on a game show, and you're given the choice of three doors: Behind one door is a car; behind the others, goats. You pick a door at random, and the host, who knows what's behind the doors, opens one of the other doors, which has a goat. He then says to you, "Do you want to stay with your choice or switch?". If you want to win the car, what do you do?

Firesuit · 12/02/2018 14:10

Monty Hall is actually difficult, even for people who (think they) understand probability.

LoisWilkersonsLastNerve · 12/02/2018 13:34

Monty Hall? Oh go on then. I love making a fool of myself.Grin

DianaPrincessOfThemyscira · 12/02/2018 12:51

I lost interest in it before the end so I’ll go with the majority vote Grin

whatsthecomingoverthehill · 12/02/2018 12:20

If this question can get over 350 replies I wonder how many the Monty Hall problem would get...

CuriousaboutSamphire · 12/02/2018 11:58
Grin

Should we start re typing the explanations, reposting the clicky links with all the pretty bits, or just allow that some people only read page 1... and then their post looks strange when it appears on page 14 Smile

BadLad · 12/02/2018 11:54

£10 profit surely?

To think that this sum is super simple
Eolian · 12/02/2018 11:50

I'm rubbish at maths, but I realised straight away that it would be easier for me to work out if I started with an imaginary actual amount of money to spend, rather than dealing with more abstract gains and losses. So I started with $100 and then found out how much more than $100 I had at the end. $20.

macbethh · 12/02/2018 11:41

£10 profit surely?

BadLad · 12/02/2018 11:41

You are forgiven, seeing as you have a Captain Picard username.

makeitso · 12/02/2018 11:39

Badlad - "You are correct as far as "he's only up 10".

If he then spends 80, and sells it for (ie gets) 90, he's up another 10.

Hence 20 profit."

If he spends 80 that means he's spent the 10 he had plus another 70 and then gets 90 for it - ah I see so it's 20 profit.

It's lucky I have an accountant Grin

BadLad · 12/02/2018 11:36

I'd say he broke even. He "lost" 60 st the start and got back 70 so he's only up 10. Then he spent 80 and sold it for 90 so it ends up being even.

Oh, God.

You are correct as far as "he's only up 10".

If he then spends 80, and sells it for (ie gets) 90, he's up another 10.

Hence 20 profit.

makeitso · 12/02/2018 11:31

I'd say he broke even. He "lost" 60 st the start and got back 70 so he's only up 10. Then he spent 80 and sold it for 90 so it ends up being even.

WeirdAndPissedOff · 12/02/2018 11:29

@RunYouJuiceBitch

I always find those ones confusing, too. I think it's because it's designed to confuse, rather than being simple maths - you're actually trying to solve a problem that doesn't exist, but rather trying to get two different sums to match, if that makes sense?

So I think:
You now owe both parents £49 each.
2x £49 = £98.

The £100 is no longer relevant, you now have borrowed £98 as you paid back £1 each.
The cost of the T-shirt is £97, plus your £1 change = £98.

So £49+£49=£98, and £97 + £1 also = £98.

Or, the sum in the question is written slightly incorrectly - you would minus off £1 because you owe £49 + £49, but have £1.
£49 + £49 - £1 = £97. (The cost of the T-shirt).

If that actually makes any sense?

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 12/02/2018 11:15

He’s up twenty

Beerwench · 12/02/2018 11:14

@Dipitydoda

With the cost of keeping a horse he’s probably about £5k down😂.

GrinGrinGrin

At least!

But I get $20

LoisWilkersonsLastNerve · 12/02/2018 11:05

Oh god help me....Grin

RunYouJuiceBitch · 12/02/2018 10:51

I agree with $20 for the horse sum.

The one that really confuses me (I'm not good at maths) is the T-shirt one:

You see a T-shirt for £97. You can't afford it, so you borrow £50 from your mum and £50 from your dad, which equals £100. You buy the T-shirt and get £3 change, so you give your dad £1 and your mum £1 back. You keep the other pound. So now you owe your mum £49 and dad £49. 49+49 =98 + your £1 =99. Where's the missing £1?

XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 19:45

I'm ashamed to say this took me longer to calculate that it should do
You shouldnt be ashamed :-). I reckon its a lot better to have to take a minute, to be sure, and get it right, than to be sure its simple and get it wrong!

Swipe left for the next trending thread