Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
safariboot · 12/02/2018 18:29

I got this wrong first of all.

Incorrect logic:

I buy it for $60 and sell for $70, gaining $10.

I sell for $70 and buy back for $80, losing $10, so I'm back to zero.

I buy for $80 and sell for $90, gaining $10, meaning I'm up $10 overall.

The thing is, I know this is wrong, but I'm not entirely sure why. But I think it might be that I basically count the same transactions twice?

A correct approach is to consider each transaction individually in turn:

I start with $0.

I pay $60 so I'm -$60.

I sell for $70 so I'm +$10.

I pay $80 so I'm -$70.

I sell for $90 so at the end of it all I'm +$20.

Sparks46th · 12/02/2018 18:28

I like this. While I know it is $20, I can sort of convince myself it is $10, but I can't quite work out what the logical mistake I'm making.

What I would say is that if you can't see how it might be something other than $20, you're not thinking enough Wink

Mulberrybaby · 12/02/2018 18:25

He made a profit of $10 for each horse therefore he made $20

Buttons44 · 12/02/2018 18:24

He bough for $60 sold for $70 thus making $10 then bought the same house for $80 meaning he had to put the $70 to it plus an extra $10 dollars to it then sold it for $90 which means he broke even.

UnmitigatedBollocks · 12/02/2018 18:20

I don’t understand how people are getting anything other than 20 😐

whitecremeegg · 12/02/2018 18:20

$10 profit

I don't understand people saying $20?

Worrals · 12/02/2018 18:17

Started with 60, made transactions, now has 90. Profit 30.

WeirdAndPissedOff · 12/02/2018 18:16

That was always the part I struggled with. People would explain that your original odds haven't changed, but I would think "they have, though, because now you know your door is one of only two possibilities".

But the remaining two doors aren't equal - you chose yours at random, whereas the one left is the "best" choice of the remaining 2/3.
I've seen it explained this way before: imagine you are playing against the host, and there are 100 doors. You pick a door at random, then the host looks behind all the other doors and picks one. The others are all opened to reveal goats (as expected, since either you have the car or the host picked the winning door) leaving your two choices. Who has the greater chance of having the winning door now, and would you switch with the host given the chance?

Or if there are 3 party bags, and 3 DC. 2 bags have a single sweet, and the 3rd has a chocolate egg. The DC are told to close their eyes and pick a bag at random. Dc1 does so first, then DC2 peeps in both bags, picks one and gives the remaining bag to DC3.
DC1 has a 1/3 chance of having the better bag. DC3 has a 0/3 chance - either DC1 picked it at random or DC2 knowingly picked the better one. DC2 has a 2/3 chance, since they got to look through the 2 bags and pick the best 1.
So if DC3's bag is opened to reveal a sweet/goat, and DC1 is given the chance to swap with DC2, what should they do?

XmasInTintagel · 12/02/2018 18:09

I just need to find some goats, cars and doors (plus a teenager to be the show host..), and I'll try this out, and see just how many cars I win...

LancelotLink · 12/02/2018 18:03

I'll give you the qualified accountants answer.

How much do you want him to have made?

kissbeforelippy · 12/02/2018 17:57

Does no-one care about the poor bloody horse in all this? He won't know if he's coming or going!

$20 by the way.

KarmaStar · 12/02/2018 17:54

It's eighty quid in profit!

LoisWilkersonsLastNerve · 12/02/2018 17:50

I have a horse, £20, a car and a unicorn. I'm a happy gal.

BeyondThePage · 12/02/2018 17:48

Xmas it is because you had a choice of 3 doors when YOU picked.

1 in 3 chance that you picked the right one - so you with a 66% probability (better than even odds) picked the WRONG one. So there is a 66 or 2 out of 3 chance that the door you picked is wrong (that it is one of the other doors, a mere 1 in 3 or 33% probability that you are right..

The host opens one of the other 2 doors - one that YOU DID NOT PICK - a door they KNOW has a goat behind - there is still that 66% probability that the car is behind the other door, and still only 33% that it is behind the door you first picked.

So you have a better chance if you switch.

XmasInTintagel · 12/02/2018 17:43

Dadadad
Can't... comprehend...brain imploding...Grin

XmasInTintagel · 12/02/2018 17:41

€800, and there's no goat, a unicorn ate it

DadDadDad · 12/02/2018 17:41

Xmas - before the host opens a door, the probability that the car is behind one of the two doors you haven't selected is 2/3. When he opens the door, the probability that the car is behind one of the two doors you haven't selected is still 2/3. So it makes sense to switch from your door to the other doors (which means the remaining closed door, because clearly it's not the visible goat that you are picking).

Fluffyunicorns · 12/02/2018 17:37

20

Punkatheart · 12/02/2018 17:37

But it's not 20, surely? He loses 10 then he gains it back so at this stage he has broken even. He then sells a horse for 90 that he bought for 60 - so he has made 30.

XmasInTintagel · 12/02/2018 17:35

But, but...my problem with the doors is that, surely, once he opens that goat door, the probabilities ARE different, because the door he opened now has probability of 1, of housing a goat, not 1/3?
So we then have one goat, and one car, behind 2 doors, everything else is known, so why are they not 0.5 probability goat and .5 probability car?
I know I'm wrong, but I don't understand why?!

readyforapummelling · 12/02/2018 15:07

Disclaimer: I know the answer is $20 just in case anybody thought I was being serious.

readyforapummelling · 12/02/2018 15:03

Awaits a thrashing haha.

readyforapummelling · 12/02/2018 15:03

Well he made $90....

whatsthecomingoverthehill · 12/02/2018 14:51

Firesuit, I meant the maths behind the question is simple, but the logic is very counter-intuitive ("there's two doors left so it must be 50-50") which is the joy of the question and why so many people with phds etc get it wrong.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 12/02/2018 14:43

Dad3 or the one about 2 objects never being able to actually collide, cos you can always halve the distance, can't you? Grin