Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
000bourneFarm · 15/02/2018 20:23

The information is too limited. It ignores bank charges. After they have been applied it is about $17.60 profit.

PeerieBreeks · 14/02/2018 20:10

Has anyone been following the literal zombie thread, ie the woman that was declared dead by a 'drama llama'? It has been picked up by the sun - and at the end of the article it mentions this thread. So hello to any Sun readers that have popped over for a look!

OP posts:
OutwiththeOutCrowd · 14/02/2018 19:06

I'm a bit wobbly when it comes to probability problems but I found it illuminating to compare the 3 door scenario as given with Monty in the know about where the car is with the case where Monty doesn’t know what’s behind the doors.

In the latter case if Monty happens to open the door on a goat and invites the contestant to swap, there is no advantage in doing so. The probability of getting the car is the same for swapping and not swapping. (This is the same as the intuitive answer.)

Comparing these two situations (Monty in the know versus not in the know) and seeing how the latter case had to be modified to produce the former gave me a better understanding of what was going on and why swapping was an advantage in the former case.

5plusMeAndHim · 14/02/2018 18:52

it might help to understand if you imagine there are one hundred doors.
h ha yes I've read that explanation online too, and it's the only way I can get my head round it.

DC marvel I thinkthis sort of problem is actually a lot easier for young children because they have not got the higher understanding which complicates problems for adults.

Chrys2017 · 14/02/2018 12:50

Forget about Monty opening a door—that's just a distraction. Basically he's offering you the choice of keeping your original door, or swapping it for all the other doors (whether there are two or 200).

wooo69 · 13/02/2018 21:56

$20 up

Fromage · 13/02/2018 21:11

I have not RTFT and I see we are now onto game shows but he needs to stop fucking about with this horse and just buy a cat.

They're $20 and he won't manage to sell because it's a cat and will have fucked off out when they buyer comes round.

This means he's now spent $20 on a fucked-off-out cat, in addition (and subtraction) to the hokey-cokey horse and he's no good for a round in the pub because he's broke.

Meanwhile, I have snuck behind Monty's door, stolen the car and replaced it with the horse.

3EyedRaven · 13/02/2018 20:57

Yes, Monty knows which door has the car before you start, so if he opened all the other 98 doors they would all be goats. I simplified it in my head by having him eliminate the other doors and then offer to swap, but I agree it demonstrates the point better by opening the 98 doors first, and the logic is the same ( 1/100 and 99/100 rather than 1/3 and 2/3)

DadDadDad · 13/02/2018 20:35

Ah, that makes sense - and is equivalent to my scenario (mine just makes it explicit that all but one goat is now eliminated).

HarveySchlumpfenburger · 13/02/2018 20:27

I think in 3Eyed version, Monty picks a door and offers you to swap with him. But it only works if Monty has to pick the door with the car if one of the 99 doors you didn’t pick has the car behind it.

DadDadDad · 13/02/2018 20:20

3EyedRaven - I'm not sure your version makes sense. Are you saying Monty opens a single door (with a goat behind it)? That still leaves 98 doors behind which the car might lie.

Your example would work if Monty opens 98 doors showing goats - so now there are two doors still closed, the one you initially picked and one other that Monty chose not to open. In that scenario, then, yes that other door has a 99/100 chance of being the door with the car. It's obvious that you almost certainly should swap.

makeitso · 13/02/2018 19:47

My 10 year old can speak Spanish (we're not native speakers and don't live there btw) I don't make fun of adults who can't.

3EyedRaven · 13/02/2018 19:47

Anyone struggling with the Monty door question, it might help to understand if you imagine there are one hundred doors.
You pick one at random. Odds of it being correct are 1/100. Monty then gives you a chance to swap with another door. The door you chose was random. One in a hundred. The door he chose is not random, as he knows where the car is. Your door is still one in a hundred, therefore as one of the doors must have the car, the door he picks must be odds of 99/100. So you always swap.
Does that make it easier?

MyDcAreMarvel · 13/02/2018 19:21

Makeitso it's not a case of being brilliant at maths. It's maths my 7 year old can do. She is clever but not exceptionally so.

makeitso · 13/02/2018 19:12

Wow. I take it all of the PP who are brilliant at maths and can't believe anyone would get anything wrong are 100% perfect at everything. I'd hate to live in such judgemental minds.

Abra1de · 13/02/2018 17:31

Assuming, in scenario 2, that Jack first bought the horse using his business account, not on his private account? In which case there is only one transaction.

Jack buys for $70 and sells for $80 so personally makes ten.

TeaMakesMeHappy · 13/02/2018 17:28

@jcyclops no it wasn’t that one, it was a couple of years ago I think. But yes, that one would definitely be 1.

jcyclops · 13/02/2018 17:19

@TeaMakesMeHappy
Was the BIDMAS problem you mentioned 6÷2(1+2)=?
and were you in the "1" camp or the "9" camp?
The answer is 1 - The first "two" is the numerator of the expression in brackets just as the two in 6÷2a=? is the numerator of "a" and if a=3 then the answer is 1.

jcyclops · 13/02/2018 17:00
  1. Anybody who doesn't get $20, what about this:- Man buys horse for $80 and sells for $90. He then buys horse back for $60 and sells for $70. In the end how much has he made or lost, or has he broke even?
  2. Everybody else who gets $20, what about this:- Jack buys horse for his business from Tom for $60 . Jack's business then sells it to Jack personally for $70. Jack sells it back to his business for $80, and it is then sold to Harry for $90. In the end how much has he made or lost, or has he broke even?
Rebeccaslicker · 13/02/2018 16:57

$20 up - I think maybe people forget he had an outlay at the beginning?

Or maybe I fucked it up Grin

smilingontheinside · 13/02/2018 16:28

20 up by !y reckoning

UnmitigatedBollocks · 13/02/2018 14:40

Those who can’t work out that is.

UnmitigatedBollocks · 13/02/2018 14:39

I hope none of you are in business 😆

MirriVan · 13/02/2018 12:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 13/02/2018 12:22

I think I've been hearing ghostly whinnies emanating from this thread for quite some time ...

To think that this sum is super simple