Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 09:12

I always find, when people say something is really simple, that those people don't all agree on the same answer, but that doesn't seem to affect their view that its simple and they're right!

I didn't find it totally obvious what the answer was, and took a minute to work it out - as if I had an account with $100 to start with, then did the 4 transactions in turn.

I was not super fast, but I am really confident I know what the answer is. $20 profit.

You can get the numbers to say all sorts depending on what you want them to

Not so - it really doesn't depend how you look at it with numbers - they are consistent and logical!

Sofabitch · 11/02/2018 09:11

Buys for $60 ($0-$60) has -$60
Sells for $70 (-60+70) has +$10
Buys for $80 (10-80) has -$70
Sells for $90 (-70+90) has $20

SweetIcedTea · 11/02/2018 09:10

When did everything become super?

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 09:09

Illustration using Believeitornot's suggestion. (Back on page 2 - there have been quite a few posts while I was creating this!).

He starts the day with (an arbitrary) $200 in his pocket and will finish after all the transactions with $220. So $20 profit.

To think that this sum is super simple
IShouldGoToBed · 11/02/2018 09:09

Curious - he didn't have only $60 tobhis name to begin with - unless a team some point he went $10 into his overdraft!! (Sounds like me)!

APerfectSky · 11/02/2018 09:08

I also got 10 (maths is not my strong point either!) because he paid out 60, got back 70, so up 10. Then he paid out 80, so paid the 70 he now has, plus another 10 from his money, so he's 10 down. Then he gets back 90, which is his 70 from the last transaction, then one of the extra 10s goes to paying off the extra 10 he needed from the second transaction, which leaves 10.

I think Confused I've now massively confused myself...

Paleblue · 11/02/2018 09:07

20 profit

TheIrregularChoice · 11/02/2018 09:07

The farmer is £20 better off at the end than he was at the start. No matter how I look at it, I can’t get to any other answer.
Have I missed something, like misread a word, and the answer is actually five magic beans or a pig?

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 09:06

The question asks in the end, so surely it's net profit, not gross profit?

No, net profit would take into account his expenses and, as someone said unthread, transporting the horses would normally incur a loss.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 09:05

Oooh! Interesting perspective:

You only have $60 dollars to your name. Over weekend you buy and sell a horse and on Monday morning you have $90... so your profit is $30.

But, as I tried to explain to the friend who is here pondering this..... you only had $60, then $70. But the second purchase was $80, so you had to borrow $10 from me and pay me back...

Not sure our morning is going as we planned Grin

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 09:04

Bookaboo, the net and gross profit in this case are the same, as there are no other costs.

Bookaboo it is two separate transactions, which is why it is helpful to view them as such.

The people that are getting it wrong are the people that are doing something funny in the middle with a perceived loss.

Instead of doing something with a perceived loss try adding and subtracting the total amounts paid /received to get the profit figure.

OP posts:
IShouldGoToBed · 11/02/2018 09:04

Sorry - that means he was $20 up by the end!! ( well done him - but buying and sellling horses is quite a complex and labour intensive way to make $20! Unless it's all online!!)

goose1964 · 11/02/2018 09:03

broke even made 2 £10 profits and 2 £10 losses

UnmitigatedBollocks · 11/02/2018 09:02

I’m really thick at maths but even I got it.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 11/02/2018 09:02

It is easy, yes.
$20 profit.

To avoid confusion, he spends out $140 in total, and gets back $160 in total.

BookHelpPlease · 11/02/2018 09:01

This isn't even maths, it's a really basic logic question. I am shocked at the amount of people confused by it.

Bookaboo-
He spent 60 + 80 = 140
he earns 70 + 90= 160

He makes 20 in profit.

They are separate transactions. Once he's sold the horse, he could be buying anything the second time.

Imagine he bought a horse for 60, sold it for 70 makes £10.
Then buys a cow for 80, sold it for 90, makes another £10.

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 09:01

I don't think it helps to look at it as 2 separate transactions because it's not

Yes it is!

ManagedTeaCups · 11/02/2018 09:00

I thought the wording of the question wanted the final profit the final amount ‘up’

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:59

The $40 I sat was someone saying 90-60 =40.

The break even people generally say

He spent 60, got back 70 which was 10 profit plus his 60. He then spends 80 which is the 70 plus 10, then he gets 90 which gives him his 70 plus the two extra 10's that he already spent.

Which is super complicated and doesn't make sense...

OP posts:
BadLad · 11/02/2018 08:59

Like I said I’m not good at maths he paid out 80 for the horse then got 90 back so the final difference was 10 that’s how I got 10 profit overall

Why are you ignoring the first time he bought and sold the horse?

IShouldGoToBed · 11/02/2018 08:58

$10 - he gained

Bookaboo · 11/02/2018 08:57

The question asks in the end, so surely it's net profit, not gross profit?

Drinaballerina · 11/02/2018 08:56

This encapsulates the problem with the financial system. You can get the numbers to say all sorts depending on what you want them to - I say this as an accountant!

ManagedTeaCups · 11/02/2018 08:55

Like I said I’m not good at maths he paid out 80 for the horse then got 90 back so the final difference was 10 that’s how I got 10 profit overall

BadLad · 11/02/2018 08:55

He made 20 profit.

Twice he bought something and then sold it for then more than he paid.