Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 09:33

Dad, those diagrams make it look so complicated!

They're not complicated but they do make it look long-winded.

Unfortunately, many have given the kind of succinct and perfectly correct explanation that you have given, but others still are saying $10 or $30. I was trying to show it step by step for those people, but I don't expect anyone will bother. Sad

floriad · 11/02/2018 09:30

20 ? But I want to say 10 emotionally / instinctually for some weird reason.

AnnieAnoniMouse · 11/02/2018 09:30

I love reading the explanations for the answers, it’s fascinating to see how other people’s minds work.

But, in all honesty, this is quite worrying. Those of you getting it wrong, don’t you get yourself in a lot of trouble in the real world?

I get that not everyone is good at everything, there’s plenty I’m properly crap at or have no interest in, but this isn’t high level maths. It’s very basic. Do you not constantly end up in financial trouble?

Ifailed · 11/02/2018 09:29

BitOutOfPractice true, and as we don't know the time periods between transactions, we could add in all sorts of other issues, is he borrowing to fund this, what about any earnings he makes from horse ownership, does he invest the initial $10 profit etc?

However, we can only deal with the facts presented, this is primarily a logic and reasoning issue, the mathematics are a side-show.

NewYearNiki · 11/02/2018 09:28

He makes a $10 profit on each sale right. So $20

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 09:28

Dad, those diagrams make it look so complicated! To make it simple, say he starts the day with $70. He spends 60 so still has 10. He then sells for 70, so now has 80. He spends the entire 80, so now has nothing! He sells for 90 which means he is $20 better off than when he started.

bruffin · 11/02/2018 09:26

Yes i realised that a minute after i posted Blush

bakingaddict · 11/02/2018 09:26

I agree with all the others who say it's a logic, interpretation problem rather than a maths problem

BadLad · 11/02/2018 09:25

Its 30
He started off with 60 and ended up with 90

Nope. In that case he wouldn't have been able to afford the horse when it sold for 80.

He made the profit when the horse increased in value from 60 to 70.
So he made 10.

Someone else made the profit when the horse increased in value from 70 to 80.

He made the profit when the horse increased in value from 80 to 90. Another 10.

Ergo, he made 20 profit.

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 09:25

bruffin - but he lost $10 in the middle buying it back, so net result $20.

I've got maths A-level and I think there's an argument for saying that he made either 10 or 20.

Sorry, blackberry, to do this, but I've got two Maths A-levels, a first class Maths degree, qualified as an actuary and work full-time in Finance. The argument for $10 doesn't stack up.

My pictorial illustration upthread encapsulates what many have said. If you physically follow it through with dollars in the pocket, you end up $20 better off than you started. No clever accounting arguments required.

Ifailed · 11/02/2018 09:24

He started off with 60

I'm afraid that is your mistake, nowhere is that stated, it's an assumption.

emmcan · 11/02/2018 09:22

$20. Helps if you split the sum up.
Man starts with $100, buys horse for $60. Has $40.
Sells horse for $70. Has $110
Buys horse for $80. Has $30.
Sells horse for $90. Has $120.
So a profit of $20.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/02/2018 09:22

Depreciation obv

BadLad · 11/02/2018 09:21

I've got maths A-level and I think there's an argument for saying that he made either 10 or 20. It depends on whether you see it as 1 or 2 transactions. Because if it's one transaction, he lost 10 by buying it back for 80 when he'd sold for 70.

It doesn't matter how many transactions you see it as. When all the transactions are over and done with, the bloke is 20 better off than he was at the start.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/02/2018 09:21

Well, we don't know his actual profit because the horse cost him to feed.
Then there's deperciation of the asset... Grin

Pengggwn · 11/02/2018 09:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 09:20

Haha, love the 'backlash'.

@SweetIcedTea in not sure that everything has become super. I'll watch the news and get back to you.

@LS83 I do care. Deeply. It saddens me to the very core that people are calling other people out when they in fact have the wrong answer themselves. It's traumatising. I'm not sure how I'm going to get through the day.

Grin
OP posts:
bruffin · 11/02/2018 09:20

Its 30
He started off with 60 and ended up with 90

Danglingmod · 11/02/2018 09:19

Yeah, I agree. You don't get this wrong by being weak at maths (the maths involved is very, very basic). You get it wrong by being weak at comprehension and/or logic skills.

XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 09:18

You can look at it a number of ways. You can either say he made $20 profit by taking the transactions as independent variables or by looking at in as cumulative profit in the context of all the transactions.

But the correct answer will be the same either way, so it doesn't matter which way you look at it surely?

blackberryfairy · 11/02/2018 09:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

brizzledrizzle · 11/02/2018 09:17

Broke even ?

bakingaddict · 11/02/2018 09:15

It's too ambiguous as a statement though isn't it. You can look at it a number of ways. You can either say he made $20 profit by taking the transactions as independent variables or by looking at in as cumulative profit in the context of all the transactions.

splendide · 11/02/2018 09:15

I’m fairly innumerate but found this easy. It’s not at all a maths problem
(assuming you can add and subtract simple numbers), it’s a reading comprehension/ logic problem.

It’s ok to be bad at those things too.

LS83 · 11/02/2018 09:12

Yanbu but I'm not sure why you care so much that some people are getting it wrong. It's Facebook.