Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bookaboo · 11/02/2018 09:54

I've looked at it again and still get the same answer!

He makes $10 profit when he sells for $70, but this is cancelled out when he buys for $80 because it's costing him another $10.

So when he sells the last time for $90 he is really only $10 better off.
To me, this answers the question of how much he made "in the end".

I agree that it is an issue of comprehension and interpretation, as these problems are designed to be so that everyone disagrees and argues about the answer Grin

frankchickens · 11/02/2018 09:52

AIBU not give a flying fig about this and all similar twaddle on facebook etc?

Will it satisfy OP and all other smug folk if I just admit I am thick?

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 09:52

Surely we need to know how much he started with to know what he made.

No it’s the same whatever he started with. He is still $20 up!

BeyondThePage · 11/02/2018 09:52

He had the POSSIBILITY of a $30 profit.

He sold and re-bought, so MISSED out on that, but still made $20 overall.

He never lost $10

Abra1de · 11/02/2018 09:51

I thought it was $20.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 09:51

Surely we need to know how much he started with to know what he made? No! Even if he had no money and had borrowed $80 on the Friday morning and paid it back he still would have had $20 profit on Monday morning.

Had 80 in hand , spent 60, his return was 70, profit 10, overall holding now 90.

Spent 80, return was 90, overall holding 100, pay off debt of 80, left with $20 clear profit (assuming no interest on the original loan)

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 09:51

There is no $10 loss. A loss happens when you sell something for less than you bought it for. That didn't happen.

There is a point where he spends 10 more than he had just received, but it's not a loss.

OP posts:
DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 09:50

bakingaddict (and ThreeHours) - there is no loss; you can't use the same transaction twice to calculate a profit or loss. He bought for $60 and sold for $70 - profit $10. Those transactions have therefore been accounted for, and you can only look at new transactions, ie bought for $80 and sold for $90, for another $10 profit.

FatBottomedGal · 11/02/2018 09:48

I don’t understand how people are getting 20 Blush

First transaction: 10 up
Second transaction: 10 down (now no profit)
Third transaction: 10 up

Overall 10 up

BuckingFrolicks2 · 11/02/2018 09:48

10 dollars

BeyondThePage · 11/02/2018 09:47

There is still the problem of the $10 loss.

he has not made a $10 loss.

He made 2 separate transactions - both of which were profitable. The fact that someone ELSE made a $10 profit meantime does not affect his balance sheet.

BitOutOfPractice · 11/02/2018 09:47

@Ifailed of course you know I was joking don't you?

The profit figure also depends on whether he's reporting to the bank manager to get a loan, or the tax man

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 09:46

baking That has really rattled my brain... I can't make any sense of it at all Smile

LockedOutOfMN · 11/02/2018 09:45

20

bakingaddict · 11/02/2018 09:44

There is still the problem of the $10 loss. He'd have to somehow negate the loss against the profit to have a truer sense of profit in real terms not as a hypothetical maths problem. Losses do have to be put in context of profit

Fuckwheresitgone · 11/02/2018 09:44

Surely we need to know how much he started with to know what he made?

c75kp0r · 11/02/2018 09:44

Wow I dont know how my horse did that

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 09:43

IShould Yes, I know that but my friend here with me, who put forward that scenario, wasn't convinced, which was what I found interesting and is why we are still discussing our relative confidence in maths!

c75kp0r · 11/02/2018 09:43

if your maths fails you, use teaspoons or 10p pieces (each worth 10 dollars) and “sell” something to your dc with the spoons - see how many more spoons you have at the end than the 7 you needed to buy the original ‘ほrせ

Threehoursfromhome · 11/02/2018 09:43

My instant response was $20 profit. He spent $140; he gained $160.

Then I over complicated it, and reasoned. -
1st transaction $10 profit;
2nd transaction $10 loss
3rd transaction $10 profit

Overall profit $10

It's that second transaction which is tripping me up. I think I am assuming he has borrowed $10 and therefore has to repay it to someone else - is that the trap I'm falling in to?

claraschu · 11/02/2018 09:41

Surely the spiritual anguish of this series of transactions costs him at least a tenner. So net profit would feel more like $10.

bruffin · 11/02/2018 09:37

But 8 agree we dont know whete he got the extra £10 as it may have been a result of investing the original £60 when he sold the horse the first time.

5plusMeAndHim · 11/02/2018 09:36

People saying £10 are , I think, taking off £10 to buy the horse a second time, when they don't need to

Moonandstars84 · 11/02/2018 09:35

20 up

MilesJuppIsMyBitch · 11/02/2018 09:33

I love this thread (partly because I got $20, which made me feel smug, which is - after all - the point).

I agree that the sum is simple, but the wording clouds this.

It helps that I've been going through worded maths problems with DS this week, who spends most of his time shouting things like "but WHY would anyone drive from Cornwall to Scotland to deliver two curries? WHY??????"

Swipe left for the next trending thread