Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 10:22

alpineibex - no, because you recognise profit and loss by matching up transactions and only counting each transaction once.

After the first purchase and sale, he is $10 up. After the next purchase, he has spend $70 but he owns a horse, so we aren't in a position to close off the profit and loss. Once he sells that horse, he recognises a further $10 profit.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:22

Xmas

How? As I said, not good at maths.

If he made a tenner profit from selling it for £70, then he buys it back again for £80, surely the tenner profit is spent in buying back the horse? (Can you tell I'm bad?)

BadLad · 11/02/2018 10:21

Buying it back again for £80 surely means he loses that tenner profit, and is back to 0.

No.

By your logic, stockbrokers would never again buy shares that they have bought in the past.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 10:21

Oops! My friend and I apologise for adding a layer of confusion... it was her who suggested he only had $60 to start off with.

But she does now see he made $20 profit... we used real £10 notes to work through it, though we did consider Rich Tea biscuits as currency Smile, and she was quite surprised that the higher price for the second purchase of the horse made no difference to the profit margin.

We would both suggest that anyone still ruminating do what we did, role play it rather than work out like a maths problem.

Fuckwheresitgone · 11/02/2018 10:21

So assuming he starts with $70 capital:
He buys for $60
He sells for $70
He has $10 profit + his original $ 10
He buys for back for $80 ( he now has no profit or left over capital)
He sells for $90 so he has $10 profit.
....but he now has $90 capital so he's up by $20 but now my head is going to explode because clearly it's $20 but my brain says $10!

BitOutOfPractice · 11/02/2018 10:21

@XmasInTintagel I know, but take pity on a poor woman who didn't press the shift key for the $ Blush

XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 10:20

Buying it back again for £80 surely means he loses that tenner profit, and is back to 0.
By that logic he'd be 'back to -10', not 0 though!

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 10:19

@PurpleRobe

He has an extra 20 in his hand

So that 20 is profit

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:18

I don't get it actually..

He originally makes a tenner profit from buying it for £60 and selling it for £70.
Buying it back again for £80 surely means he loses that tenner profit, and is back to 0.
Selling it on again for £90 takes him back to a tenner profit.

That's how I read it anyway

Royalfuckup · 11/02/2018 10:18

The misdirection is in mentioning that it is the same horse.

XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 10:17

buys it for 80.00 voiding his 10.00 profit.

Not true, sounds so logical and certain, but buying something does not wipe out all money made in the past.

PurpleRobe · 11/02/2018 10:16

He has an extra 20 in his hand

But only 10 is profit

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:16

But I'm shit at maths anyway so

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:15

He made a tenner.

lottiegarbanzo · 11/02/2018 10:15

Hah, $20 profit (140 spent vs 160 taken)

But, I can see how one could arrive at 'break even', if one ignores the first purchase price and only starts calculating profit and loss once he already owns the horse. There is no reason to do that though.

Royalfuckup · 11/02/2018 10:15

baking, you are conflating 2 separate issues.

First sale, he ends up with $10.

2nd sale, he ends up with $10.

There is no loss involved in the repurchase of the horse. Besides, he could have renivested that $10 in a donkey meanwhile and is possibly quids up from that too Grin

BeyondThePage · 11/02/2018 10:14

Problem I have is where does he get the capital from to buy back at a higher price.

NOWHERE does it state that he only had $60 to start with. He could have had a couple of million dollars to play with.

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 10:13

No, Lois, as has already been explained, you can't use the $70 transaction twice. Once it's been used to derive a $10 profit, you can't then pair that same transaction with the $80 purchase and identify a $10 loss.

ohfortuna · 11/02/2018 10:13

So I bought a pair of shoes for $60, and I bought a handbag for $80
I decided I don't like the shoes or the handbag so I put them on eBay
I sold the shoes for $70 and then I sold the handbag for $90
I've made $20
nice one 😁

XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 10:13

that#s 420 more than he started with
Wow, I this maths better Grin

Originalfoogirl · 11/02/2018 10:12

To me, it really is unbelievable that such simple arithmetic causes such debate.

A-B+C-D= cannot possibly have any other result.

I hate the "oh I'm terrible at maths" that people say with pride and as if that's that. First of all, this isn't maths, it is arithmetic. Second of all, there is no such thing as a brain which cannot learn maths but can learn all other subjects fine. Sure, perhaps the more complex mathematical equations might be a struggle, but pretty much everyone who is capable of learning to read and write is capable of learning arithmetic.

LoisWilkersonsLastNerve · 11/02/2018 10:11

Here is why I thought 10.00 up-
The question was has he made, lost or broken even. He has a horse worth 60 he sells for 70 so is 10 up. Next day he wants the horse back so buys it for 80.00 voiding his 10.00 profit. He sells for 90 making his 10.00 back hence although he made 10.oo twice, he lost 10.00 and is only 10.00 up over all. Confused

XmasInTintagel · 11/02/2018 10:11

Bakingaddict, no one ever said 'a man has only $60' at the start.
When there were questions at school about 'Jane gave tom 3 sweets, then gives Cedric 2 sweets', no one worried that she didn't have enough sweets to do that! Its the same sort of thing - assume that if he is buying something, he had enough money.

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 10:11

bakingaddict - but you didn't have a problem wondering where we had $60 to make the first purchase? Hmm

If you start with say $100 in hand and work it through you end up with $120 at the end. No need to borrow, and definitely $20 profit.

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 10:09

He doesn't need to borrow anythig if he started the day with $70. As fer as we know he has not incurred any expenses so net profit is a total irrelevance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread