Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CecilyP · 11/02/2018 10:36

Yes I see theoretically he has made $20 profit but.....surely when he buys back the horse at a higher price than he's sold that has to be balanced against something else to get a true overview of my day's profit

There is no theoretical about it. The profit is the profit! It might be balanced by his disappointment at not selling for 90 in the first place but that has no effect on the actual profit.

Dothedamnthang · 11/02/2018 10:36

He made a profit of $10 in the end

NutElla5x · 11/02/2018 10:36

He made $10.

NoSquirrels · 11/02/2018 10:35

Well this is reassuring! On the BIDMAS/BODMAS thread I was rather worried about my sub Yr 6 calculation standard, but even I got $20!

I did it in my head, but if you’re struggling if you divide it into 2 columns, outgoings and income, it is crystal clear.

I think it might be a comprehension/reading issue rather than a maths one!

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:35

Oh! Ok. God this really confused me GrinGrinGrin

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 10:35

It doesn't matter!

It just might be easier to work through it if you imagine a 2nd horse, sack of spuds, pair of shoes etc.

It is the thought of a single item that is the deliberate confusing factor. It is irrelevant but human nature means we are likely to feel continued ownership at the 2md transaction!

Please get 10 'somethings' and work it through!

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:34

It implies the same horse. So what is the point in thinking he still owns the first hose and is buying a second horse, when the question implies he loses the first horse and then buys it back?

BadLad · 11/02/2018 10:34

Where is the implication of a second horse?

There isn't one. Suggesting thinking of it as a second horse is an attempt to simplify the problem for people who can't see that the answer is 20.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:34

But the way it's written, it makes no sense for there to be two horses.

Royalfuckup · 11/02/2018 10:33

@alpine

That’s the point really. The misdirection is in mentioning that it is the SAME horse. If you think of it as two different horses then it doesn’t confuse the solution.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:32

'He buys a horse'
'He sells the horse'
'He buys back the horse again
'He sells the horse'

Where is the implication of a second horse?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 10:32

As I said earlier, that makes no difference. He'd have had to borrow $10 for the second purchase and, even after paying it back is still $20 up!

He could have had no money at all to start off with... see above!

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:30

Ah, also I'm assuming he has no more money other than the original 60 too!

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/02/2018 10:29

That is what causes the confusion... it encourages people to see that higher 2nd purchase price as a continuation of the first purchase.

But if you role play it you can see that is not the case - honest!

runningoutofjuice · 11/02/2018 10:28

Anyone still having trouble, play horse traders with your dc. Each trader has 10 coins or Lego bricks or whatever and each coin or brick is worth £10. Play out the transactions remembering you are the 'man'. How much do you have after the 4 transactions? You will have £120 so £20 profit. Grin

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:28

So, reading it as 'the horse' being sold and rebought, not multiple horses, then he doesn't own a horse after he sells it back?

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 10:28

baking - there's no "theoretically" about it: on the most basic, practical level of cashflow, he has made a profit of $20.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:27

OK, now I'm confused. Where does it say that there another horse that he buys? The way it is written it implies that there is only one horse - 'he buys a horse', and all subsequent lines are 'he sells the horse' which would reference that one horse that has already be mentioned... Otherwise they should have always used 'a horse' not 'the horse'.

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 10:26

He has an extra 20 in his hand. But only 10 is profit

So what exactly is the other $10?

AfterSchoolWorry · 11/02/2018 10:26

€10

DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 10:26

If he made a tenner profit from selling it for £70, then he buys it back again for £80, surely the tenner profit is spent in buying back the horse?

If you want to put it that way, then he uses the $10 profit towards buying the horse and only needs to put $70 of new money into the purchase. As he then sells for $90, that means his $70 has made him $20 profit. But that's not the most obvious way to think about it!

bakingaddict · 11/02/2018 10:24

Yes I see theoretically he has made $20 profit but.....surely when he buys back the horse at a higher price than he's sold that has to be balanced against something else to get a true overview of my day's profit

BeyondThePage · 11/02/2018 10:23

He takes $60 out of his wallet. Pays for horse.
Sells horse for $70

Puts $10 profit on the table.

Takes $80 out of his wallet. Pays for horse
Sells horse for $90

Puts $10 profit on the table.

$20 up over all

HE has never made a loss. He has missed out on a POSSIBLE $30 up overall if he had held onto the horse the full time, but he has never made a loss.

Royalfuckup · 11/02/2018 10:23

@alpine Think of it this way.

He makes a $10 profit on the sale of a horse.

The later buys another horse. Horses are now worth $10 more than what they were valued at when he sold his horse.

So he buys the 2nd horse at market value then later sells it for $10 more than he paid.

The second sale has nothing to do with the first sale, other than the possibility that he invested his original profit in the purchase of the new horse.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 11/02/2018 10:23

Forget about horses

Let the initial sum the man has be Sstart

At the end of transaction 1 he has Sstart – 60

At the end of transaction 2 he has Sstart – 60 +70

At the end of transaction 3 he has Sstart – 60 + 70 - 80

At the end of transaction 4 he has Sstart - 60 + 70 – 80 + 90 = Sstart + 20

So by the end the man has Send = Sstart + 20

Therefore he makes $20 overall