Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
alpineibex · 11/02/2018 11:03

So I end up with £90 from my £60, but my friend wants her tenner back.

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 11:01

You would have had to go to the brick bank for another brick inbetween the sales, so still only 2 bricks profit!

Or as she put it much more succinctly!

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 11:01

(I think)

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 11:01

You can do it that way Elendon

But how can you buy the horse back for 80 when you only sold it for 70? By 'borrowing a tenner' which then needs to be subtracted from the profit at the end.

BadLad · 11/02/2018 11:01

I think I know how to make it clear to those not getting.

Imagine the buyers paid the man, who is a horse expert, in advance.

Buyer 1 pays the man 70 to find a horse. The man spends 60 on the horse, and gives it to buyer 1. The man keeps the 10 as profit.

Buyer 2 pays the man 90 to find him a horse. The man now has 100 in his pocket (10 profit from the first sale plus the 90 Buyer 2 has just given him) The man spends 80 of that on the same horse. He gives the horse to Buyer 2, and keeps the 20 profit.

runningoutofjuice · 11/02/2018 10:59

Alpine, with 10 bricks it is simpler to see your profit because you don't have to borrow any money from a friend or even an unscrupulous lender who might charge outrageous interest rates.

Elendon · 11/02/2018 10:59

I'm starting with the premise that £60 is the investment, and that's all the money he has.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:59

Might need to invest me in some of those clicky-cube things they used in primary school.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:57

Ohhhh, I am SO looking forward to my DDs maths homework Blush

Elendon · 11/02/2018 10:57

Ah yes two different transactions would make it £20 profit.

CecilyP · 11/02/2018 10:57

^I give six bricks to someone, get a horse.
I get seven bricks back, they get the horse.
I give eight bricks back, I have the horse.
I get nine bricks, they have the horse.

So... That's a £30 pound profit? I started with 6 bricks and now have 9. Why is this so confusing to me!?!? ^

If you only started with 6 bricks where did you get your 8th brick from to complete your third transaction? If you borrowed it, you now have to pay it back reducing your bricks to 8 and your profit £20.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:57

Floyd

Yep, I forgot that bit about needing to borrow a brick! (Sorry, I'm using Duplo)

NoSquirrels · 11/02/2018 10:56

The man has £60 in his pocket. He buys a horse for that amount and sells it on again for £70 making a profit of £10.

He then buys back the horse for £80, thus losing the profit so is down £10. He sells it on for £90 regaining the the loss.

He broke even.

Noooo! He “broke even” when he “lost the profit” by reinvesting. He makes $10, he spends $10. THEN he made $20 on the final transaction.

Marcine · 11/02/2018 10:56

Elendon if he starts off with 60 then spends 60 he has 0.
Sells for 70, he has 70.
Buys for 80, he's got - 10.
Sells for 90, pays off the - 10 and has 80 left.
So he's 20 up on his original 60.

liz70 · 11/02/2018 10:55

I worked it out like this:

Assume man starts with $60.
He buys a horse for $60 - now he has $0.
He then sells the horse for $70 - now he has +$10.
He then buys the horse back for $80 - now he has -$70 i.e. a loss of $70.
He then sells horse once more for $90, turning his $70 loss to +$20,
So at the end of it all he has $20 in his pocket, and no horse. So $20 profit.

FloydOnThePull · 11/02/2018 10:55

Alpine, start with 6 bricks. You'll run into problems when you have to pay 8 bricks and only have 7 in your hand. You will have to borrow a brick from someone, so at the end you have 9 bricks in your hand but you owe your friend a brick. Once you've given them their brick back you have 8 bricks. 2 more than you started with.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:55

Firesuit

Yeah, I'm no good with money at all. I can't even work out what change I'm owed.

LoisWilkersonsLastNerve · 11/02/2018 10:54

I get it now. No more trading horses for me.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:53

Huggybear

Ah! I forgot about that middle bit during my "transactions", so yes. I stared with 6 bricks, ended up with nine bricks, take away a brick, 8 bricks, £20 profit.

Elendon · 11/02/2018 10:52

The man has £60 in his pocket. He buys a horse for that amount and sells it on again for £70 making a profit of £10.

He then buys back the horse for £80, thus losing the profit so is down £10. He sells it on for £90 regaining the the loss.

He broke even.

Marcine · 11/02/2018 10:52

Start at zero
-60
+70 (10)
-80 (-70)
+90 (20)

NoSquirrels · 11/02/2018 10:52

I give six bricks to someone, get a horse.
-6 (initial outlay)

I get seven bricks back, they get the horse.
+1

I give eight bricks back, I have the horse.
- 8

I get nine bricks, they have the horse.
+9

Initial outlay
6

Minuses/outgoings
-8

Positives/income
+10

Profit
=2

Firesuit · 11/02/2018 10:51

I am a bit gobsmacked that anyone is struggling with this.

It appears to be the fact that he buys the same horse that leads to people getting this wrong.

Can people really not see that he's bought and sold things twice, so there are two profits/losses that need to be added together to get the answer, and that it's completely irrelevant to the overall calculation that the thing bought and sold was the same both times?

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 10:51

Why am I starting with ten bricks? Where does ten come from?

FloydOnThePull · 11/02/2018 10:51

Assume you run a shop, during the year you sell sweets to customers and take a total of £160 from customers in exchange for sweets, however you have to buy the sweets from the wholesaler and over the year you paid £140 for the sweets. At the end of the year you have made £20 profit from selling sweets.

Now substitute the word sweets for horse.