Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
UndomesticHousewife · 11/02/2018 13:48

I also got 20 profit

Note3 · 11/02/2018 13:44

Until then I had the profit as $10

Note3 · 11/02/2018 13:44

It was only when FinancialDad (think that's their name) from earlier in the thread broke it down that it made sense!

If each purchase/sale is viewed as a different transaction e.g. the first time he buys and sells a horse and you work out the profit. Then the second time he buys and sells a cow and you work out that profit then it makes total sense!

Elendon · 11/02/2018 13:29

Buys a horse for 60 means a minus 60 which = -60
Sells a horse for 70 means a plus 70 which = +70
Buys a horse for 80 means a minus 80 which = -80
Sells a horse for 90 means a plus 90 which =+90

Which = +20

runningoutofjuice · 11/02/2018 13:26

ohfortuna Cuisenaire are all the rage now! In fact, we have been using them for the last two weeks in year 2 while we work on part + part = whole and the inverse. The children love them!

floriad · 11/02/2018 13:11

Here's where the mistake lies. Let's assume that Bill (the guy buying and selling the horses) has $60 at the beginning of this little horse- trading. So he spends it on the horse. Then he gets $70 for it. If he wants to buy it again for $80, you're right that he has to borrow $10 from someone else (or from himself - perhaps from he had some other money he had planned to use for another purchase), but we have to keep track of this debt. See, he's not even now, he actually has -10 dollars. So then he gets $90 back for the horse. But since he had -$10, the net effect of getting that $90 is to make him have 80 dollars (you might think about that as paying back the $10 he owed). So since he started out with $60, and he has $80 at the end, the overall effect was to gain $20.

I thought I understood it. Also got the right result.

(simply by regarding them separately and assuming that the man does indeed have enough money / doesn't need to borrow etc...)

But this explanation...?

mine would be something like this:

70 - 60 = 10.- (put it in the "profit wallet" or whatever)

90 - 80 = 10.- (put that in the same wallet)

The content of the wallet will be 20.- (unless there was money in there before we started the horse trading scenario...)

user1472333009 · 11/02/2018 13:06

This explains it Confused

To think that this sum is super simple
brizzledrizzle · 11/02/2018 12:28

Just add together the money he spent and then the money he received and take one away from the other. £20 profit.

(My DC tells me this is like the year 5 maths questions)

TenancyTroublesAgain · 11/02/2018 12:23

...Or $20.

TenancyTroublesAgain · 11/02/2018 12:23

He made $10.

LoisWilkersonsLastNerve · 11/02/2018 12:18

From a math forum:

Here's where the mistake lies. Let's assume that Bill (the guy buying and selling the horses) has $60 at the beginning of this little horse- trading. So he spends it on the horse. Then he gets $70 for it. If he wants to buy it again for $80, you're right that he has to borrow $10 from someone else (or from himself - perhaps from he had some other money he had planned to use for another purchase), but we have to keep track of this debt. See, he's not even now, he actually has -10 dollars. So then he gets $90 back for the horse. But since he had -$10, the net effect of getting that $90 is to make him have 80 dollars (you might think about that as paying back the $10 he owed). So since he started out with $60, and he has $80 at the end, the overall effect was to gain $20.

IntelligentYetIndecisive · 11/02/2018 12:00

He buys a horse for $60. 0-60 =-60
He sells the horse for $70 -60+70=10
He buys the horse back for $80 10-80 =-70
He then sells the horse for $90 -70+90=20

He's gained $20

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 11/02/2018 11:50

It’s the fact that it’s the same animal involved in each purchase and sale that is confusing people, I think. If I said that a farmer went to market and bought a pig for $60 and a goat for $80 and sold a sheep for $70 and a donkey for $90, and asked how much more money the farmer had in his wallet at the end of the day people wouldn’t be as bamboozled – but the calculation required would be identical.

alpineibex · 11/02/2018 11:49

PeerieBreeks

Thank you. Numbers definitely take a while to 'click' in my head. Wink

Elendon · 11/02/2018 11:49

so
-6 + 7 = 1
-8 + 9 = 1

add the two together and you get

2

Brittanyspears · 11/02/2018 11:45

Feeling like a genius for once!

Elendon · 11/02/2018 11:43

So - 6 +7 - 8 + 9 = 2

Sagethyme · 11/02/2018 11:41

dadx3 Grin

upside because presumably if you start with nothing you have to borrow? I should add I am no mathematician but surely logic dictates if you start with zero where do you get $60 from? You have to borrow it.
I completely get the answer by the way, but I can also see why others are getting a differen result. In fact taking it at face value it would make much more sense to have just the numbers without the language. The language is the issue because the assumption is the man starts with $60, he therefore needs to borrow $10, he'd then need to give the $10 back, therefore his profit is $10, unless of course he does as dadx3 suggests and has no fines/ interest to pay in which case profit is $20....
And this is why I hate doing my tax returns!

OutyMcOutface · 11/02/2018 11:40

*-80

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 11:40

@alpineibex I love that you are now explaining it absolutely correctly to someone else :) Star

OP posts:
Elendon · 11/02/2018 11:40

He is down £60 on the purchase = -60
He then sells for £70 so = + 70 which = +10
He buys again for £80 so = -£70
Sells again for £90 so = +£20

OutyMcOutface · 11/02/2018 11:40

£20

-60
+70
80
+90
= 20

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 11:36

@purplerobe it's still not a loss in the middle. If he started with 60, then when he pays 80 he clearly owes 10 to someone, but then he ends up with 90, less the 60 he started with is 30, less the 10 he owes is 20.

OP posts:
DadDadDad · 11/02/2018 11:34

Totally off topic, but Curious, your name has bought back memories. Family holiday when I was a child in Norfolk, seeing these signs saying "S A M P H I R E" - maybe a samp was some kind of flat-bottomed boat (cf punt) and you could hire it to explore the local marshes etc? The truth was much better, and I enjoyed tucking in to some freshly cooked samphire once we realised!

ohfortuna · 11/02/2018 11:31

@runningoutofjuice, those blocks remind me of the cuisenaire rods that we had at school when I was a child