Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this sum is super simple

536 replies

PeerieBreeks · 11/02/2018 08:26

and can't understand how so many people on Facebook have it so completely wrong (and can justify it to themselves).

Without adding your reasoning, tell me what you think the answer is.

To think that this sum is super simple
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
Frabbits · 07/04/2023 14:29

Mjenlew · 07/04/2023 14:11

My above math is correct.
But so is this:
$60 loan to get horse, sell horse for $70, pay off $60 loan, have $10 profit.
Now have $10, need $70 loan to buy $80 horse. Then decide to sell horse for $90 and pay off $70 loan which leaves me with $20.

Where the money comes from to fund the purchase of the horse is irrelevant.

You just add up the credit and debits and the answer is always $20, because maths.

BMXsummoner · 07/04/2023 14:24

I think this guy needs to make up his mind about whether he wants the horse or not…

Mjenlew · 07/04/2023 14:11

My above math is correct.
But so is this:
$60 loan to get horse, sell horse for $70, pay off $60 loan, have $10 profit.
Now have $10, need $70 loan to buy $80 horse. Then decide to sell horse for $90 and pay off $70 loan which leaves me with $20.

BadLad · 07/04/2023 13:07

ghostyslovesheets · 07/04/2023 11:40

@Mjenlew you bumped a five year old thread?

And bumped it with the wrong answer as well.

-60
+70
-80
+90

He made 20.

ghostyslovesheets · 07/04/2023 11:40

@Mjenlew you bumped a five year old thread?

Mjenlew · 07/04/2023 11:35

You math is incomplete because you forgot he lost $10 in the 2nd purchase.

Here’s the breakdown by transaction:
1st transaction he bought horse = $-60 loss.
2nd transaction sold $-60 horse for $70 = $10 gain.
3rd transaction had $70, bought horse back for $-80 = $-10 loss (bc he had to add an additional 10 to his 70 to meet 80).
4th transaction had $-80 horse but sold for $90 = $10 gain.

in the end, he gain $10.

Peripeteia · 24/07/2018 14:06

Thank you Beehived - perfect explanation.
Off to lie down now and give my brain a rest Grin

MaryShelley1818 · 24/07/2018 13:48

$20 profit...my maths is terrible but I’m totally confused how anyone gets anything else...

wellBeehivedWoman · 24/07/2018 13:44

He buys a horse for 60 so he is down to -60 dollars.

Then he sells the horse for 70 so he is up +10 dollars.

Then he buys the horse for 80 so that's down to -70 dollars.

Then he sells it for 90 so he's up 20 dollars.

$20 profit!

Excited0803 · 24/07/2018 13:34

$1 = 76p more or less at today's exchange rate, so he made £15.24 less any currency exchange fees; say he's paying £2 in fees that'll be £13.24.

BadLad · 24/07/2018 13:19

BUT if the man needed to spend his first $10 profit to afford the second purchase, surely that original profit is cancelled out and he’s left with an overall profit of $10

No.

Perhaps it would help you to think that the buyers, who paid the man 70 and 90, paid him in advance.

He was paid 70 to find a horse for someone. He spent 60 on the horse. So he made 10 profit.

Later another person paid him 90 to find them a horse. He went to the person to whom he sold the horse in the first place. He spent 80 on the horse. So he made another 10 profit.

9amTrain · 24/07/2018 13:14

I got 20 the second time around.

Yeah my maths is shit.

JaneJeffer · 24/07/2018 13:12

He lost $120 and now he hasn't even got a horse.

5foot5 · 24/07/2018 13:11

Seriously these kind of answers lowers my faith in people's ability to do basic arithmetic.

What about reading and understanding dates!?

This thread is quite old - possibly not quite old enough to qualify as ZOMBIE but definitely entering slightly enfeebled old age.

9amTrain · 24/07/2018 13:11

I get 10 too....

Peripeteia · 24/07/2018 13:06

I know the answer is $20 I believe you all Grin
But doesn’t the answer depend on whether the second transaction was dependent on the profit made in the first or not?

Ie. 2 separate transactions with 2 separate pots of money, $10 made on each transaction = $20 profit.

BUT if the man needed to spend his first $10 profit to afford the second purchase, surely that original profit is cancelled out and he’s left with an overall profit of $10.

Does that make sense?? Or is it only in my scrambled brain?

Bibesia · 24/07/2018 07:57

I was never taught commutative, associative, distributed, identity, and inverse properties even back in the dark ages when I was at school, but I find it easy enough to work out that it's $20. I worked on the basis of assuming the horse buyer started with $100 and took it from there.

stayathomer · 24/07/2018 07:30

*"Do they not teach commutative, associative, distributed, identity, and inverse properties anymore?"

What???*
Grin

stayathomer · 24/07/2018 07:30

Oh my god there is something wrong with me-I'm so disorientated reading that and trying to figure it out!!!!

Fivelittleduckies · 24/07/2018 07:25

Dang got it wrong Blush he makes $20! Grin

Fivelittleduckies · 24/07/2018 07:22

He broke even

Gwenhwyfar · 24/07/2018 07:18

"Do they not teach commutative, associative, distributed, identity, and inverse properties anymore?"

What???

Gwenhwyfar · 24/07/2018 07:17

My first thought was that he broke even because he then bought the horse for 20 dollars more than the first time, cancelling out the two sets of ten dollars he made from it, but I'm not sure if that's how I'm supposed to look at it.

dudsville · 24/07/2018 06:54

20 profit.

ForalltheSaints · 24/07/2018 06:52

I think the OP should apply to be on Countdown!

Swipe left for the next trending thread