Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Ann Widdecombe is truly vile

233 replies

BlueSkiesAndWhiteCliffs · 27/01/2018 23:00

Celeb Big Brother.

Anyone else saying the things she has said would have had people screaming at them.

She doesn't think women should work if they have children.

She doesn't agree with gay marriage.

She thinks being gay is disgusting.

She is so backwards in her thinking, she is truly horrible.

Now whilst I don't agree with the language that Andrew used about her, I agree with his sentiment and I can't believe everyone is pussy footing around her!

OP posts:
Thierryhenryneedisaymore · 28/01/2018 10:14

Sooty

I don't consider myself an AW supporter but defend her rights to religious freedom.

Many many many politicians have made bad decisions. Indefensible ones. AW does not have an unblemished record. I dont think anyone is saying that here.

I agree that shacking female prisoners was an extreme policy and not one i agreed with. I think it was inhumane as clearly do you.

I imagine that in the vast majority of circumstances that measure was not a proportionate response to the risk of prisoner flight.

Before i get flamed for that, the only circumstance where i can think it might have been justified as necessary would be where there had been previous attempts to flee in hospital or in circumstances where the assessed risk of harm to general public / medical / prison staff should the prisoner flee was high and outweighed prisoner's own human rights if she was a violent or dangerous offender.

BeyondWitchbitchterf · 28/01/2018 10:13

I have no issue with people having a problem with political decisions of Ann's. What's annoying me is the comments like Ann is racist/homophobic based on things she said that weren't necessarily racist/homophobic in the CBB house. I do agree that she has been sexist in there, but she is far from a minority of one on that.

BeyondWitchbitchterf · 28/01/2018 10:10

Well again I disagree with it entirely, but I believe the thinking behind that decision was that it was safer for them to give birth in a hospital (where they'd need to be kept from escaping, hurting others or accessing drugs) than unshackled on a prison ward, where they wouldn't have immediate access to adequate surgeons etc

ohfortuna · 28/01/2018 09:59

I can't get past her voice
it's very shrill

ilovesooty · 28/01/2018 09:57

I note that her supporters haven't commented on her defence of shackling pregnant female prisoners in 1996 when she was Secretary of State for Prisons.

And that isn't vitriol. It's documented fact.

DreamyMcDreamy · 28/01/2018 09:55

Not contributed on this thread yet but delurking to say well said Ronald.
If people are indeed presenting as fact utter horse s**t, that's awful and even though I love social media it is one of the ugly sides I really hate.
I feel we cannot accept difference anymore. Even from an older very religious woman. If she doesn't agree she's the problem I disagree wholeheartedly with this

Thierryhenryneedisaymore · 28/01/2018 09:52

Well said Ronald

RonaldMcDonald · 28/01/2018 09:50

When you look at the behaviour of others in the house she's a shining light
She isn't saying she'd smash that about any girl who walks out of earshot
She isn't making sexualised innuendo
She isn't backstabbing or manipulating
She isn't being anyone other than who she is and living by a moral code that speaks to many regligious people
She speaks up for fairness in the house and is able to hold views about a situation but not project them onto the person in front of her

I feel we cannot accept difference anymore. Even from an older very religious woman. If she doesn't agree she's the problem
I disagree wholeheartedly with this.
We all need to be able to understand that others hold differing opinions and that's okay - it doesn't make them vile or evil

Thierryhenryneedisaymore · 28/01/2018 09:47

Rainbow
Your post is very interesting, it's based on up close experience.

Eleanor -
Where is your evidence that AW made racist comments about Meghan Markle? I didn't think she had but wasn't certain i hadn't missed something... other posters seem to agree she wasn't racist so come on. Can you stand by that post or do you just like getting the boot in to follow the pack?

I have not watched BB but unless she has changed her views recently IIRC she was actually in the past quite supportive of the struggle to juggle and outspoken that mothers should be able to spend more time at home and have better options to support that choice. Many many people think like that. I say that as a working mother.

But why not just attack her on that too if it adds to portraying her as a monster, regardless of whether based on fact or not??

Rita
You clearly do think she is fair game and anything goes in terms of attacking her because her views differ from yours. She is a devout catholic. Maybe you don't like that she follows those teachings. But she is entitled to her views as you are yours.

Your statement about her not being a critical thinker and blindly accepting doctrines is utterly utterly ridiculous. I can't even find the words at this time of the morning to articulate how silly that statement is. Maybe someone else more awake than me can! I am not quite sure where to start ....

She has her own moral compass and it isn't the same as yours. Big deal. She has an opinion on gay marriage that is different from yours. Get over yourself.

The vitriol against AW in some of this thread is apalling. Like a pack mentality.

JJPP123 · 28/01/2018 09:39

I met Ann when having a manicure done in Debenhams close by to Westminster Cathedral. I was about to go to my adult confirmation class and she chatted to me about it and seemed to be a lovely woman.

k2p2k2tog · 28/01/2018 09:33

She has very fixed opinions and is not scared of expressing them. No she doesn't believe in same sex marriage, or abortion, or sex before marriage and a whole lot of other things that most people think are OK. She is obviously very uncomfortable with public displays of affection of any type and thinks that should all be behind closed doors.

However while she has been in CBB she has been happy to spend time with the gay people in the house - Amanda, Wayne, ShaneJ. She's never been cruel or unkind to them or called them names. She's respectfully disagreed with them, and that's fine.

She's not "vile". She is a much nicer person than someone like Andrew who has been horribly sexist throughout and Anne was quite right by saying his mother would be horrified. I would if my son was on telly making those types of comments.

LifeBeginsAtGin · 28/01/2018 09:28

IfyouseeRitaMoreno

That's not what you said. You said she should question the church but the whole point is you accept it. She is celibate as she does not believe in sex outside of marriage.

But you've change believing in the doctrines to being kind and Christian to others - Ann does both. She believes in the bible and interacts with gay people.

DullAndOld · 28/01/2018 09:20

" She is the ultimate reactionary."

you lot sound pretty 'reactionary' to me tbh. If more women ignored sexism in the workplace and just got on with the job, then the world of work would be a better place for all of us.

hooliodancer · 28/01/2018 09:18

I agree, she is awful. She has a very closed mind.

For me, the worst thing about her is how she doesn't believe that women are at a disadvantage in the workplace. She dismisses sexism completely.

She thinks that everyone is like her. She says she never experienced sexism so there for no one does.

And yes, her views are backward. She is the ultimate reactionary.

DullAndOld · 28/01/2018 09:17

Blue skies you sound a bit simple tbh.
re HW there are lots of women who could have walked away but chose to 'eat the biscuit' in order to get the part...now they are crying about it.
Sorry but I agree with her. Are you suggesting that women are so weak and stupid that they have no agency? What kind of 'feminism' is that?

IfyouseeRitaMoreno · 28/01/2018 09:17

Er, OK then. Have you ever been to church? hmm

Of course! Many times. And met people who see the overriding ethos of Christianity as one of inclusion and love. And of accepting people who are different to you, or who have made different choices to the ones that you would’ve made in that same situation.

But AW isn’t one of those people.

DullAndOld · 28/01/2018 09:14

honestly if people don't have 100 per cent 'correct' opinions these days, then you get a crowd of screaming 'liberals' howling abuse at them.

She seems OK to me, a bit old fashioned but so what?

InfiniteSheldon · 28/01/2018 09:10

She did not say women shouldn't go back to work she said it was a shame they couldn't afford the choice in our modern world
She wasn't racist about MM she was possibly judgemental about Divorcees
She doesn't think gay people care disgusting she just doesnt approve of gay marriage, wrongly imo but a view held by a sizeable chunk of our multicultural population.
You on the other hand are showing zero critical think skills, amazing examples of fauxrage and a stunning level of shudup shudup shudup I'm enjoying my baseless lies

latara23 · 28/01/2018 09:09

I disagree with Ann's politics & views but I totally don't think she's in the closet!

I know at least 2 women who are definitely straight but still virgins & celibate- one is a best mate of mine.
One is very religious & won't have sex outside marriage or marry outside her religion so basically she's in her 50s now & probably won't ever have sex.
My best mate is physically disabled & it makes her too shy to approach men or go OLD. She's never had a long term boyfriend also due to being very shy around men. I would really like her to meet a decent man - she's 41 now so it could still happen. She definitely fancies men & has had crushes so she's not asexual.

I think Ann is just very religious with old fashioned morals.

LifeBeginsAtGin · 28/01/2018 09:08

Chipstick

I agree.

Not every man at the Presidents Club that night was letching and sexually assaulting the waitresses.

Not every waitress was a naive little girl, some knew it was a quick £200 (exc tips!!) and was prepared to put up with it.

Maybe Carrie Gracy just wasn't as tough at negotiating her contracts?

But you can't say these things, you have to tut loudly and shake your head because that is what everyone else is doing.

IfyouseeRitaMoreno · 28/01/2018 09:07

Having a different view on homosexuality should not warrant getting abused.

Well no, but religion isn’t a get out of jail free card for espousing viewpoints that are nasty. Especially when as a politician she can use her viewpoints to damage other people’s lives.

It’s not only that. Her views on women and Harvey Weinstein were just reactionary nonsense. She kept saying “why don’t they walk away? They have a choice!” which indicates to me that she’s not a deep thinker. Not only can she not understand the complexity of the unequal choices that women face but she’s also not bright enough to seek out the facts. Many women did walk away. That doesn’t absolve HW of his heinous actions.

People who blame victims for their reactions rather than the perps for their actions are either hard of thinking or haven’t hung round Mumsnet enough Smile

LifeBeginsAtGin · 28/01/2018 09:01

She’s not exactly a critical thinker if she blindly accepts doctrines that were written for ancient cultures without being able to judge for herself whether they are morally correct.

Er, OK then. Have you ever been to church? Hmm

BeyondThePage · 28/01/2018 08:55

I'm sure the program is edited to only show what a person is really like, a nice balanced approach, for people's education rather than entertainment. Hmm Hmm Hmm

Feelitstill · 28/01/2018 08:55

Anyone else saying the things she has said would have had people screaming at them

I find this attitude deeply disturbing.
Having a different view on homosexuality should not warrant getting abused.

BlueSkiesAndWhiteCliffs · 28/01/2018 08:53

Well I don't agree that churches should be forced to agree to marry gay couples as that is their religion and you can't force them to change their beliefs but why is two people getting married in a hotel or a garden or a beach etc wrong?

Ann has also said a lot of nasty things about women, she IS VERY BACKWARDS in her thinking about women's rights... why shouldn't a woman go back to work after having children?
What she was saying about Weinstein aswell was victim blaming BS!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread