Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to be baffled, sad and angry that Paris Lees is speaking at the Women's March tomorrow?

212 replies

ArcheryAnnie · 20/01/2018 21:07

So, Paris Lees has been invited to address the "Time's Up" rally opposite Downing Street tomorrow, organised by the Women's March London. The "Time's Up" initiative "provides advice and support to women across all industries who have experienced sexual harassment or abuse at work."

But wait! Paris Lees is in favour of street harrassment of women, and writes articles in places like Vice, making sure lots of men know that catcalls are cool and sexy, and making sure lots of women know they have been "infantilised", and aren't nearly as brave as cool, sexy Paris, if they don't like it.

www.vice.com/sv/article/zn7b79/enjoying-catcalls-paris-lees-column

AIBU to be absolutely baffled, as well as sad and angry, that Paris Lees has been asked to speak for women at an event opposing sexual harrassment?

OP posts:
Datun · 21/01/2018 08:16

Battleax

It's a very male misconception, in my experience.

It's not harassment if the person is good looking.

Which, unsurprisingly, entirely misses the point.

It's not harrassment if you welcome the advance.

Which could be based on looks, charm, humour. Any number of differentials.

What's really cynical about this is it assumes that a good looking man can't harass. Which is patently, manipulatively, absolute bollocks.

That being good looking gives you a pass for being a cunt.

It's so male centric to place such pivotal importance on what someone looks like.

Part and parcel of the harassers' come back of I wouldn't rape you, you're too ugly.

Absolutely clueless.

Battleax · 21/01/2018 08:06

From that 'article';

Nichi Hodgson, author of Bound to You, Men's Health sex columnist and director of the Ethical Porn Partnership, says there’s a certain kind of middle-class woman that finds catcalls particularly galling: “There’s a sense of being sullied if an uncouth or lower-class kind of man – a white van man, for example – heckles. But if it's a Roger Sterling type who can just about pull it off with a certain retro-sexist panache, the offence isn't experienced the same.”

So objecting to the harassment culture is frigid snobbery in Paris' worldview?

Okay then Hmm

Datun · 21/01/2018 07:57

Are there going to be marchers saying cunt a lot and dressing up like vaginas?

Let's hope so. Thanks for the suggestion.

Anniegetyourgun · 21/01/2018 07:14

That certainly is a wide range of issues. So wide as to render a march a little... dare one say, pointless? Not to say they're not all worthy causes and all that, but you might as well just go there with a banner saying "Down with this sort of thing" and let it all mean whatever you want it to.

Redonionricedpotato · 21/01/2018 05:43

Nope. There is literally nothing that’s for women these days that transwomen haven’t invaded. Nothing.

thebewilderness · 21/01/2018 05:40

Can't have a women's march without a male dominance display, eh?

Redonionricedpotato · 21/01/2018 05:33

YANBU. The women’s march has been completely hijacked by the trans movement. Some of them have banned pink pussy hats for being transphobic. There’s a trans dominatrix speaking at one in Canada. Janet Mock, the transwoman who described women as ‘fish’ spoke at one last year. They don’t represent me.

Not at all surprised a sex obsessed misogynyist male like Lees has been invited to speak. How he represents women, I do not know. But this is becoming the new normal. Women aren’t allowed anything for themselves any more.

LettersAndNumbers · 21/01/2018 03:11

Where was the 'trans thread' warning. It's so much easier to ignore the repetitive echo chamber when we know.

I feel tricked.

Oh, and I don't care who speaks. Are there going to be marchers saying cunt a lot and dressing up like vaginas?

crunchymint · 21/01/2018 00:53

It makes no sense at all to ask Paris Lees to speak out against sexual harassment. I have never understood why Paris gets invited to speak at feminist events, since Paris seems pretty anti feminist in the views expressed.

Datun · 21/01/2018 00:46

HangingRoundInABofAlorsStance

I don't disagree with anything in your post.

Perhaps Lees won't dare try anything on that will piss off women. Let's hope not.

HangingRoundInABofAlorsStance · 21/01/2018 00:13

However, the Time’s Up rally in London on Sunday will not focus solely on sexual harassment and abuse. According to the event organisers, protesters will be marching against a wide range of issues including gender-based violence, sexual harassment and abuse; Islamophobia, anti-Semitism, transphobia, homophobia and ableism; the gender pay gap; underfunding for domestic violence services; menstrual poverty and climate change denial.

Other speakers at the rally will include Women’s Equality Party leader Sophie Walker, comedian Ava Vidal and Marchu Girma of Women for Refugee Women.

So given the above, it is not surprising a transwoman has been invited to speak - if transphobia is also on the remit - such a person would be talking on transwomen's behalf, not mine, about their own experience
which won't be mine. Same as a muslim speaking about islamophobia would not be representing me personally.
Nonetheless it still should not be Paris Lees.

saladdays66 · 21/01/2018 00:12

This is kind of my problem with the debate around street attention. It’s part of a culture that infantilises women and teaches them to be constantly afraid. I wasn’t brought up that way and I don’t feel frightened when some spunky dude comes and talks to me. I hate this idea that all men are rapists-in-waiting and that all women are victims-in-waiting. It’s patronising and doesn’t help anyone.

He wasn’t brought up that way because he was brought up as a fucking man! And that’s how he still thinks!!!

And i’m Deliberately keeping male pronouns because Paris lees deliberately thinks like a man.

Ffs. Depressing as hell.

The event organisers should be fucking ashamed. Was there no WOMAN they could have asked to speak?

Datun · 21/01/2018 00:10

Abuse is abuse - we will have to agree to disagree on that one as there are probably transwomen out there who do 'pass' so the bloke who chooses to abuse or harass does so, not necessarily knowing they are harassing someone without female reproductive potential.

That's true. It does however make you transphobic. Apparently.

I agree that if a man passes the motivation from the cat caller will be misogyny.

But I still disagree that it is the same.

There is no fear of pregnancy if raped. A man stands a better chance of fighting off his attacker. And a man, with male socialisation, will not be walking around constantly afraid. Lees is living proof.

Lees is also not at all unusual in finding cat calling validating. It's a common refrain.

All abuse is bad. All of it.

But misogyny is the basis of women's abuse. Based on their biology.

You don't find women representing gay men and deciding to talk on their behalf about homosexual abuse.

The gay community would think it was a bloody cheek.

EnthusiasmIsDisturbed · 21/01/2018 00:09

How many transwomen have been sexualised from a young age

From the age of 12 (when I still looked about 9) until a few years ago I have been harassed and catcalled

Maybe some transwomen have as adults but not so as a child as a self conscious painfully shy teenager will they had to deal with daily remarks because they have big breasts no

Why can’t transwomen set up their own groups to discuss their issues I wouldn’t feel I could talk on their behalf my experiences are different and I wouldn’t want to claim I could so why should they for me or feel that they can

SmileEachDay · 20/01/2018 23:59

Ach. Don’t be so silly, wimmz.

There were probs no women available who had any opinions worth listening to about sexual harassment. I mean, if we all just loosened the fuck up, there wouldn’t be any sexual harassment, would there?

It’s down to us being all prudey and shit. We should listen to someone who does womaning better than us,

HangingRoundInABofAlorsStance · 20/01/2018 23:59

I object to somebody born male talking on my behalf about abuse they will never have received. Because it's not on the basis of their female reproductive potential. Whereas mine is.

Abuse is abuse - we will have to agree to disagree on that one as there are probably transwomen out there who do 'pass' so the bloke who chooses to abuse or harass does so, not necessarily knowing they are harassing someone without female reproductive potential.

Paris Lees is nonetheless not the right speaker for this event. Same as Brigitte Bardot would also not be credible as an ally.

CherryChasingDotMuncher · 20/01/2018 23:58

Not to mention the twat is a thief too, not a very good one seeing as they spent 8 months in prison. I could weep for womankind. This idiot is who we are supposed to look up to?

CherryChasingDotMuncher · 20/01/2018 23:57

That sex article is grim. So blokey and half bullshit because a pseudo vagina/inverted penis doesn't self lubricate or do half the things Paris claims. I can't believe Paris is 'a new suffragette'. What have they (I won't call Paris she as transwomen are not women) actually done to merit that? Does Paris have something on Vogue? Gross little bastard.

lolaflores · 20/01/2018 23:50

Right then.
Put on a bra, panties and some lippy and that ought to cover all aspects of femininity. Oh, and don't forget simpering at the cat calls. All in a days work for a proper woman.

HangingRoundInABofAlorsStance · 20/01/2018 23:47

particularly hypocritical

incidentally Hucknall is a shithole and I thought she had spoken of having a bloody tough time there so not sure why in the article she speaks of not being brought up in fear as I thought she at some point was afraid there - given the amount of abuse some transwomen get I would not resent a transwoman talking about their experiences of harassment but given what Paris wrote about catcalling, even if it was a provocateur piece of clickbait designed to make a quick buck that is why she should not be invited to the Time'sUp march. The organisers either have not done their homework or don't give a fuck.

Datun · 20/01/2018 23:44

That's the pink pussycat that they claim was exclusionary. They are now deciding that black women's vaginas aren't pink, which they are.

Confusing vulvas with vaginas. Yet another biology 101 they missed.

Plus appropriating intersectionality which was designed to demonstrate how you can be oppressed for being both black and a woman, on two separate axes.

Not by being a man.

CAAKE · 20/01/2018 23:40

Fucking hell. Munroe tweeting this shite about the march -

"I also want to stress that if you do attend, it is CRUICIAL that you do with an INTERSECTIONAL mindset. Centering reproductive systems at the heart of these demonstrations is reductive and exclusionary."

"Not all women have reproductive systems, not all women have a vagina, not all women's vagina's are pink. Think about your message, use your voice for ALL women. Not just yourself."

Vaginas are all pink Munroe! Not so hot on the old biology are we?!

Datun · 20/01/2018 23:38

It is not about a transwoman speaking out against abuse it is about this particularly transwoman speaking out about abuse.

No of course. Transwomen should absolutely have a platform to talk about abuse they receive.

But that generally stems from homophobia. Men do not like to see gender nonconforming men.

Women's abuse stems from misogyny. It's completely different.

I object to somebody born male talking on my behalf about abuse they will never have received. Because it's not on the basis of their female reproductive potential. Whereas mine is.

I would have absolutely no problem, and fully support, transwomen calling out men who abuse them for being trans.

lolaflores · 20/01/2018 23:33

Reproductive systems centered?

My head has just imploded. It really bloody has.
That sentence just makes no sense, on any level to me.
What am I missing, will someone tell me?
Is this about women or not about women. Is it about men's reproductive systems or not.
Are women reproductive systems the problem, the issue, our fault?
When, or fucking when, does my reproductive system stop being some other fuckers issue...they either hate it, mutilate it, shut it down, start it up or steal it.
When can it just be mine? Please.

Datun · 20/01/2018 23:33

LardyMardy

Ahhhh. Thanks for that. Someone said Munro and I just thought Jack.