Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to be baffled, sad and angry that Paris Lees is speaking at the Women's March tomorrow?

212 replies

ArcheryAnnie · 20/01/2018 21:07

So, Paris Lees has been invited to address the "Time's Up" rally opposite Downing Street tomorrow, organised by the Women's March London. The "Time's Up" initiative "provides advice and support to women across all industries who have experienced sexual harassment or abuse at work."

But wait! Paris Lees is in favour of street harrassment of women, and writes articles in places like Vice, making sure lots of men know that catcalls are cool and sexy, and making sure lots of women know they have been "infantilised", and aren't nearly as brave as cool, sexy Paris, if they don't like it.

www.vice.com/sv/article/zn7b79/enjoying-catcalls-paris-lees-column

AIBU to be absolutely baffled, as well as sad and angry, that Paris Lees has been asked to speak for women at an event opposing sexual harrassment?

OP posts:
Datun · 21/01/2018 09:47

Personally I'm baffled sad and angry that the rampant transphobia that has made FWR pretty much unreadable, is now spilling over so much into all other parts of Mumsnet.

Just report any transphobia you see. Mumsnet will delete it.

LardyMardy · 21/01/2018 09:44

Thanks for that. So have I.

As a survivor of street violence, I don’t feel particularly safe at an event with a speaker who advocates steer harassment.

Feelitstill · 21/01/2018 09:30

Datun
Ok I’m sorry. I only know what I saw on that program.

I’ll read the links.

MrGrumpy01 · 21/01/2018 09:29

feel I have no issue with people who are trans. I have issue with someone standing up to speak at a march to address issues about sexual harassment towards women who has openly written an article saying we should not just accept cat calling we should encourage it as well.

It is a shame some people are unable to separate the trans person from the abhorrent views We shouldn't allow abhorrent views to stand just because of the group type person saying it.

WidowWadman · 21/01/2018 09:28

Personally I'm baffled sad and angry that the rampant transphobia that has made FWR pretty much unreadable, is now spilling over so much into all other parts of Mumsnet.

Datun · 21/01/2018 09:25

Feelitstill

I don't think there is a woman alive who can't empathise with gender dysphoria. Our bodies are always under the spotlight. Not thin enough, not blonde enough, not the right size boobs.

Almost every teenage girl has a negative attitude towards their body at some point. It may not be as severe as gender disphoria, but it can certainly make you empathise with the condition.

But Paris Lees is a different kettle of fish altogether.

Perhaps read the links where they say how hot it is to fuck someone who is crying. Or how street harassment is empowering.

Paris Lees not representative of the people on Transformation Street.

SaskiaRembrandtWasFramed · 21/01/2018 09:23

After watching the documentary ‘Transformation Street’ I feel desperately sad for trans people. Who would put themselves through so much pain ( mental & physical ) if they didn’t feel they were genuinely born in the wrong body?
Personally, I welcome trans women & wish them all the very best.

That's nice dear, but what has this got to do with street harassment? Generally transwomen don't like it either. Should they just put up with it too because it gives Paris the warm and fuzzies?

CAAKE · 21/01/2018 09:22

Why are these fuckers everywhere now, in every single women's space, event, action group claiming to speak for women? I thought they represented less than 1% of the population? I'm fucking livid at this stage, even more so at the handmaidens colluding in it.

Yes, there actually truly is "one in every crowd".

CertainHalfDesertedStreets · 21/01/2018 09:17

I have emailed the organisers to express my disappointment.

[email protected]

I think if we all did that the strength of feeling might be appreciated.

Feelitstill · 21/01/2018 09:13

YABU.
After watching the documentary ‘Transformation Street’ I feel desperately sad for trans people. Who would put themselves through so much pain ( mental & physical ) if they didn’t feel they were genuinely born in the wrong body?
Personally, I welcome trans women & wish them all the very best.

LardyMardy · 21/01/2018 09:07

That certainly is a wide range of issues. So wide as to render a march a little... dare one say, pointless? Not to say they're not all worthy causes and all that, but you might as well just go there with a banner saying "Down with this sort of thing" and let it all mean whatever you want it to.

@AnnieGetYourGun yes, I suppose there is that danger, except

I think that the MOST important thing about these marches is that there are thousands of women - in the majority - visible, in public, speaking out, and claiming space.

I’m an historian and I could drone on forever about how radical this sort of claiming of public space is. I won’t Grin thank goodness!

But for example, this is partly why the lavatory issue is significant. In the 19th century, the lack of safe identified female sex-segregated lavatories in public spaces (anywhere outside the home really) meant that women’s abolity to participate in public life was severely curtailed. Some of the documentation of —the lack of— conditions for menstruating women in factories etc just make you weep when you read in the archive.

And so on.

So yes, the specific focal points of these marches might be in danger of dilution. But the big thing is women filling the streets. And the pink pussy hats mean that the visual effect is even more striking (see the footage of the NYC march yesterday). And in a world where male/masculine is the norm, replacing this visually- even just for one day - is wonderful.

StoneColdDiva · 21/01/2018 09:07

The "spring a boner" comment by PARIS is surely autogynophilia par excellence?

crisscrosscranky · 21/01/2018 09:00

A phobia is an irrational or extreme fear or aversion to something.

I am petrified of spiders. I'm not scared of transwomen I just don't believe they are "real women" with "real women" experiences or feelings. Whilst they still have a penis they are male and being male and being a woman ARE mutually exclusive even if you don't want them to be.

Datun · 21/01/2018 08:58

such a person would be talking on transwomen's behalf, not mine, about their own experience
which won't be mine

There is an insidious extra layer to this.

A transwoman, such as Paris, would very much struggle to talk specifically about trans issues.

Because it 'us and thems' them.

They can't talk about their issues without naming women as the problem. Because they already have every human right they are entitled to. What they want is women's rights.

So they have to keep up the fiction they are women, so the only people they are othering is some women.

Some nebulous group of dreadful, witchy, not-to-be-borne, bigoted fascists.

Not, 'just about any woman who might have the slightest problem'.

Which would end up being most women.

A divide and conquer technique.

CharizMa · 21/01/2018 08:55

REading this thread I feel like what the hell is wrong with being transphobic. is it better or worse than being pro-harrassment?

CharizMa · 21/01/2018 08:54

paris lee thinks like a man. and shows aggression like a man too (the head butt!)

LardyMardy · 21/01/2018 08:52

Ugh, bold fail. My post was in response to @HangingRoundInABoAlors

marillacuthbert2018 · 21/01/2018 08:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LardyMardy · 21/01/2018 08:49

such a person would be talking on transwomen's behalf, not mine, about their own experience
which won't be mine

In the current madness, many trans activists would regard your perfectly reasonable statement as “transphobic” because they infer from it that you don’t believe that “Transwomen are women #NoDebate”

It’s bonkers and bollocks

crisscrosscranky · 21/01/2018 08:42

YANBU. That article is disgusting but unsurprising- Paris is looking for confirmation that he looks female and men cat calling him gives him that. I feel sorry for anyone who feels that way as their self-esteem/self-worth must be shot.

KERALA1 · 21/01/2018 08:39

I was sexually assaulted by a brad Pitt lookalike whilst on holiday. Norwegian man yes gorgeous but I think on drugs or something followed me into the sea and groped me and would not stop. It was awful the fact he was good looking neither here nor there. Put me unfairly off Brad Pitt though.

Redonionricedpotato · 21/01/2018 08:37

I also feel as if I’m living in some sort of nightmare parallel universe in all this.

ATeardropExplodes · 21/01/2018 08:33

It will hit before 50 years time, it will hit when all these kids that Mermaids are pumping full of puberty blockers want kids. And realise what the NHS [if it still exists] did to them.

It will hit when a man gets cancer that would have picked up at a screening if only he hasn't signed up as a woman at the GP's. It won't hit when a woman gets cervical cancer because they weren't called for a smear because they signed up as a man...no, that will be completely glossed over.

Lime19 · 21/01/2018 08:28

Her latest tweet talks about trans women and women of colour... oh and other women. So as a white female, I'm last on the list am I? This march sounds utter crap. It should be about Times Up campaign. Not about trans issues.

I hate hate hate that men/trans women are allowed to speak on behalf of women. It's not on. It's almost laughable it's so bad.

I hope in 50 years time we look back at this period in time as a mistake. And things go back to normal. I'm starting to think I'm living in a nightmare! It's all about the monorities. You cannot say anything anymore without someone being offended. Paris does not speak on my behalf.

Battleax · 21/01/2018 08:23

Yes, and it reeks to high heaven of autogynophilia.

And at the same time it's all put across with such masculine aggression. Paris says so. Paris is right. Paris is a woman. Argue if you dare.