Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is terrible that Americans with health insurance have such high deductibles

107 replies

crunchymint · 03/01/2018 10:26

I have been reading this article about American healthcare.

www.motherjones.com/politics/2018/01/go-fund-yourself-health-care-popularity-contest/

It says -

"With health care costs and high-deductible plans on the rise for more than a decade, medical expenses are the largest single cause of bankruptcies nationwide. Despite Obamacare’s efforts to rein in costs, the average deductible on a typical plan under the Affordable Care Act is $2,550—nearly as much as the entire monthly take-home pay of the average American worker. President Donald Trump’s efforts to destabilize Obamacare have already raised premiums, and experts predict the cost of a deductible under some versions of Republican health care legislation would rise to an average of at least $4,100."

Basically when someone has health insurance, they still have to pay a certain amount out of their own pocket. Typically they have to pay a certain amount to visit a Dr and for any treatment - with insurance covering the rest. So even someone with insurance who has a chronic or serious illness, still has to pay a substantial amount of money out on top of their insurance premiums.

OP posts:
Boarderingmadness · 03/08/2021 14:45

We in the UK have voted to move to this type of system, so i hope it works out well.

Darbs76 · 03/08/2021 14:42

I’m in pancreatitis groups and it’s terrible the Americans often avoid getting treatment due to cost or having no insurance anymore as they’ve lost their job thanks to health issues and then lost their insurance. It’s awful.

ShamelessCurtainTwitcher · 03/08/2021 14:40

We aren’t covered 100% for hospital stays.

We had met our deductible but we were responsible for a small percentage of a very very expensive overnight in the ICU.

HmmmmmmInteresting · 03/08/2021 14:26

@ShamelessCurtainTwitcher

American here as well. My family has wonderful insurance through DH’s employer.

It didn’t save us from a $40,000 hospital bill when he had to spend a night in the ICU due to an allergic reaction to surgical anesthesia.

What can we do other than pay it and be glad he’s alive?

Could you explain this please? How is your insurance wonderful if you got landed with a $40k bill?
oneglassandpuzzled · 03/08/2021 14:19

I have a friend whose child is studying to become a doctor in the UK and I am shocked at how much easier it is in every way to become a physician in your country than ours. It takes fewer years, and the residencies are much less grueling. In the US, it is incredibly competitive and serious. I was really not impressed with what I saw. Doctors from other countries have to retrain to become doctors here.

Gosh, in the UK any old person can become a doctor. Just roll up and they'll hand you a scalpel.

MissConductUS · 03/08/2021 14:18

@PrincessNutella

I am American and have mixed feelings about our healthcare system. I hate how many people fall through the cracks and the ways they can fall through the cracks. There are ways that people can get tricked into having high bills. I don't really mind the deductible part, I figure that somewhere along the line, it is part of what one has to pay for healthcare, whether it is through taxes or insurance or whatever.

On the plus side, I think good U.S. health care is probably the best in the world, and that's why people with serious conditions will flock here if they can. I have a friend whose child is studying to become a doctor in the UK and I am shocked at how much easier it is in every way to become a physician in your country than ours. It takes fewer years, and the residencies are much less grueling. In the US, it is incredibly competitive and serious. I was really not impressed with what I saw. Doctors from other countries have to retrain to become doctors here. From what I read on a thread here, this is true for nursing, also. My mother and SIL were nurses and they were/are incredibly smart and technically proficient. Nursing is a very competitive profession as well. I have had some experience as a patient of having hard to diagnose problems, and found that sometimes, going to the absolute best doctors can cut right to the chase. Because I have good insurance, I could go to a top rheumatologist, and in one visit, he diagnosed my autoimmune disease and got me appropriate medication. I could also get care in Sloan-Kettering, the best cancer hospital in the world when I needed it. I felt very reassured that the smartest people possible were giving me personalized care.

It is difficult. I want everyone to have a basic level of healthcare. So in that sense, it's fine to have a system that is basic and provides a certain level of care for all. But if I had a kid with an unusual form of cancer, I would want to be in a reasonable American healthcare plan where I could access top level American- medical specialists.

I'm also an American and agree with this completely. I'm an HCP who has proved care for many foreigners, including many Brits, who have come here for treatments that are simply unavailable under their own national health care systems. And as @PrincessNutella points out, the care is generally excellent and we don't have waiting lists. We also do more cancer screening than seems to be the case in the UK.

The American system of providing and paying for health care is quite complex, so it's easy to look at part of it in isolation without understanding how it relates to the rest. High deductible insurance plans are designed to be used with Health Savings Accounts, to which you make tax deductible contributions to fund your initial costs. The money carries over if you don't use it and can also be used to pay insurance premiums.

High Deductible Health Plans (HDHPs) & Health Savings Accounts (HSAs)

The attraction is that the premiums are much, much lower than standard plans and you can use the savings to fund your HSA. I know people who have them and love them. My own health insurance has a $500 per person annual deductible and an out-of-pocket maximum of $5,000. I'm fine with both.

I think there is more work to do to expand coverage, but it's not really the dystopian nightmare it's made out to be on MN. I think the Biden administration will improve access by allowing people to buy into Medicare, the Federal insurance program for the elderly.

ShamelessCurtainTwitcher · 03/08/2021 14:17

American here as well. My family has wonderful insurance through DH’s employer.

It didn’t save us from a $40,000 hospital bill when he had to spend a night in the ICU due to an allergic reaction to surgical anesthesia.

What can we do other than pay it and be glad he’s alive?

PrincessNutella · 03/08/2021 14:00

I am American and have mixed feelings about our healthcare system. I hate how many people fall through the cracks and the ways they can fall through the cracks. There are ways that people can get tricked into having high bills. I don't really mind the deductible part, I figure that somewhere along the line, it is part of what one has to pay for healthcare, whether it is through taxes or insurance or whatever.

On the plus side, I think good U.S. health care is probably the best in the world, and that's why people with serious conditions will flock here if they can. I have a friend whose child is studying to become a doctor in the UK and I am shocked at how much easier it is in every way to become a physician in your country than ours. It takes fewer years, and the residencies are much less grueling. In the US, it is incredibly competitive and serious. I was really not impressed with what I saw. Doctors from other countries have to retrain to become doctors here. From what I read on a thread here, this is true for nursing, also. My mother and SIL were nurses and they were/are incredibly smart and technically proficient. Nursing is a very competitive profession as well. I have had some experience as a patient of having hard to diagnose problems, and found that sometimes, going to the absolute best doctors can cut right to the chase. Because I have good insurance, I could go to a top rheumatologist, and in one visit, he diagnosed my autoimmune disease and got me appropriate medication. I could also get care in Sloan-Kettering, the best cancer hospital in the world when I needed it. I felt very reassured that the smartest people possible were giving me personalized care.

It is difficult. I want everyone to have a basic level of healthcare. So in that sense, it's fine to have a system that is basic and provides a certain level of care for all. But if I had a kid with an unusual form of cancer, I would want to be in a reasonable American healthcare plan where I could access top level American- medical specialists.

FedUpAtHomeTroels · 03/08/2021 13:46

All depends on the plan you are on.
Years ago we had to buy our own cover for the family, the deductable was $10,000 not that we actually paid it. Use the plan preffered family doc and each visit was $20 Prescriptions from their preffered pharmacy were $10 each after we had paid our $200 on prescriptions, etc etc.
Right before coming back to UK we had great cover through Dh work.
Two people in the family paid $50 deductable for the year and then the rest was free for the year. Dentist was £12 a visit, doctor was free after the first £50 paid. Hospitals free (after the $50 paid) Chiroprator free after the £50 too Optical was good too but I can't remember what that cost, definitly a lot less that the normal bills.
NHS needs a shake up but it doesn't need a US style system, I've heard good things about some EU country systems, like France and Germany

CraftyGin · 03/08/2021 13:45

All healthcare has to be rationed as it is scarce resource.

In the UK, we ration by waiting list and research (NICE). In the US, they ration by ability to pay.

Pick your system.

Quickchangeartiste · 03/08/2021 13:36

I am surprised at OPs surprise on this issue.

While DH & I lived in the US our annual deductible was $3000, and that was on a gold standard health plan, more than 10 years ago. We could pick any practitioner who would accept our insurance ( pretty much anyone) and self refer to any specialists . DH got a diagnosis for a long standing problem which our UK GP was unwilling to pursue.I would not go back to that though.
I have friends who are bankrupt after one suffered cancer ; friends who stuck in crap jobs because they needed the insurance etc.
It’s a country & system which favours the wealthy massively.
I agree the NHS needs a rethink, but we are very lucky to have an expectation of social healthcare.

veeeeh · 03/08/2021 13:32

NHS care is very good (and free), once you get timely treatment and a bed for surgery/procedures.
GPs are free but you cannot get an appointment.
Emergency out of hours care is free but not timely in a lot of cases.

NHS is not perfect but it is free, when you can avail of it.

There will be co payment introduced in UK at some point I think. Current costs are unsustainable and it shows.

Penistoe · 03/08/2021 13:25

That's incredibly high! I have private healthcare (in the uk) and my deductible's £100 and that's for everything from a course of physio through to huge surgeries

It’s not the same, private healthcare in the uk only tops up nhs care. It’s more like premium seats rather than first class iyswim.

M4J4 · 03/08/2021 13:22

@LIZS

Normal for any private healthcare policy.
Not normal for the UK.

I pay £125 excess.

The American system is beyond shit. Who benefits the most, the hospitals or the doctors/consultants?

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 03/08/2021 13:21

I think it's terrible. People shouldn't be in a position where they have to decide whether they can afford to see a doctor.

rinegills · 03/08/2021 13:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TroelsLovesSquinkies · 03/01/2018 10:59

Our annual deductible/excess was $10,000 for a few years while we lived in US, doctor visits and treatments cost us 80% of the full cost each visit so long as the doctors we used were part of the insurance plan, so we'd pay 80% each time till we'd spent $10,000 in a year then it was free for the rest of the year. We did spend $22,000 one year, but that included our monthly insurance payments.
Then Dh got a job with fantastic insurance, our annual dedutible was £50 for two of the family then the whole family was free.
The NHS has loads of problems, but is still better than the nothing that a lot of people have.

crunchymint · 03/01/2018 10:55

A private GP appointment can cost as little as £25, so of course the co pay is not going to be extremely high.

OP posts:
sparechange · 03/01/2018 10:47

Co-pay is common in lots of countries

The co-pay/excess for things like GP appointments is quite low, as in Ireland, France etc
But it can rise a lot for operations

BarbaraofSevillle · 03/01/2018 10:45

And the irony is that, despite citizens having to have insurance and pay large deductables, the US Government spends more per capita on healthcare than countries such as Canada, Sweden and probably the UK that have NHS healthcare (or equivalent) due to the involvement of highly profitable private sector providers and insurance companies.

uk.businessinsider.com/us-spends-more-public-money-on-healthcare-than-sweden-or-canada-2017-4?r=US&IR=T

RavingRoo · 03/01/2018 10:40

US hospitals also offer their own repayment plans for certain treatment, if you don’t have insurance, and often have their own charitable trusts so eligible low income people can have some (or all) of their work completed pro bono. It’s still shit though - the US should have free healthcare. It certainly has the money to offer this.

averylongtimeago · 03/01/2018 10:40

Well this is what we are heading for in this country.
The NHS is being systematically sabotaged so it can be sold off to the highest bidder, under the guise of "reform".

Ifailed · 03/01/2018 10:35

Hardly surprising when healthcare is run as a profit-making business.

crunchymint · 03/01/2018 10:34

But in the UK, plenty of healthcare treatment is only given by the NHS, and you will be transferred there by your private healthcarer. That is why deductibles are much lower.

OP posts:
SantanicoPandemonium · 03/01/2018 10:32

That's incredibly high! I have private healthcare (in the uk) and my deductible's £100 and that's for everything from a course of physio through to huge surgeries.