Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is terrible that Americans with health insurance have such high deductibles

107 replies

crunchymint · 03/01/2018 10:26

I have been reading this article about American healthcare.

www.motherjones.com/politics/2018/01/go-fund-yourself-health-care-popularity-contest/

It says -

"With health care costs and high-deductible plans on the rise for more than a decade, medical expenses are the largest single cause of bankruptcies nationwide. Despite Obamacare’s efforts to rein in costs, the average deductible on a typical plan under the Affordable Care Act is $2,550—nearly as much as the entire monthly take-home pay of the average American worker. President Donald Trump’s efforts to destabilize Obamacare have already raised premiums, and experts predict the cost of a deductible under some versions of Republican health care legislation would rise to an average of at least $4,100."

Basically when someone has health insurance, they still have to pay a certain amount out of their own pocket. Typically they have to pay a certain amount to visit a Dr and for any treatment - with insurance covering the rest. So even someone with insurance who has a chronic or serious illness, still has to pay a substantial amount of money out on top of their insurance premiums.

OP posts:
Fauvist · 03/08/2021 17:48

@GeorgiaGirl52

We do pay a high price, but we also have a faster response. My 18 year-old son went to the doctor after three bad stomach aches/cramps/nausea in two week period. Called doctor on day 1, got appointment on day 2. Doctor recommended sonogram and scheduled at hospital on day 5. Sonogram done and results back to doctor by day 8. Surgery recommended so off to specialist on day 9, gallbladder out on day 12. Done as an outpatient and home in evening. Less than two weeks from first visit to surgery. Cost $28, 650 total. Cost after insurance paid $2,865 with 12 month payment plan of $225/mo. NHS is free, but is it that fast?
If it was life threatening, it might be faster. The NHS reacts fast and well to anything life threatening. The slower areas tend to be things that aren't going to matter if they are delayed a bit.

For comparison, my relative had a (single) very bad long-lasting headache when she was 11. Within hours she had a CAT scan showing a bleed on the brain. She was immediately admitted to hospital and they operated as soon as it was safe to do so (think a day or two later as soon as the bleed was stable - they had treated her to stop the bleed). She was in hospital for about three to four weeks, received intensive care and made a full recovery.

Cost £0.

Cameleongirl · 03/08/2021 17:46

@CraftyGin Who's gloating? I'm certainly not with a $6K deductible to pay every year, plus the monthly insurance premiums!

What I'm saying is that you need serious money to access good healthcare and if DH and I lost our jobs, we'd be in immediate trouble.

I'd much rather be under the NHS as I was in the UK, despite the problems it currently faces. It's horrific that good healthcare is tied to wealth in the US.

NurseButtercup · 03/08/2021 17:42

@oneglassandpuzzled

I have a friend whose child is studying to become a doctor in the UK and I am shocked at how much easier it is in every way to become a physician in your country than ours. It takes fewer years, and the residencies are much less grueling. In the US, it is incredibly competitive and serious. I was really not impressed with what I saw. Doctors from other countries have to retrain to become doctors here.

Gosh, in the UK any old person can become a doctor. Just roll up and they'll hand you a scalpel.

Wow what an exaggeration & watering down of the training that UK dr's undergo. I think you'll find the qualified dr's will explain how competitive it is to get a place to study & that any old person definitely CANNOT roll up and become a Dr.
GeorgiaGirl52 · 03/08/2021 17:42

We do pay a high price, but we also have a faster response. My 18 year-old son went to the doctor after three bad stomach aches/cramps/nausea in two week period. Called doctor on day 1, got appointment on day 2. Doctor recommended sonogram and scheduled at hospital on day 5. Sonogram done and results back to doctor by day 8. Surgery recommended so off to specialist on day 9, gallbladder out on day 12. Done as an outpatient and home in evening.
Less than two weeks from first visit to surgery. Cost $28, 650 total.
Cost after insurance paid $2,865 with 12 month payment plan of $225/mo.
NHS is free, but is it that fast?

Fauvist · 03/08/2021 17:40

When you look at that life expectancy chart on Worldometer, it is pretty shocking that the US scores lower than eg Puerto Rico (where more than 40% of the population lives below the poverty line).

MissConductUS · 03/08/2021 17:32

The costs for identical surgery in the US with no overnight stay was in the region of $100,000. I was horrified (as were they when they heard my price!)

That would be the hospital's list price for the surgery. Insurance companies negotiate much lower prices.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chargemaster

RickJames · 03/08/2021 17:18

Germany has a pretty good system unless you are self employed. If you are self employed then health insurance is very expensive and it isn't charged on a sliding scale of income so you'd pay the same if you were earning 10k pa or 40k pa. Tbf all taxes and insurances here are way higher if you are self employed. There's no perfect system IMO.

Also, I've found that here, if you have a broken leg or something they are brilliant. It's still hard to see specialists for particular chronic illnesses.

Ridingthegravytrain · 03/08/2021 17:18

I remember when I was on a forum for a specialist surgery I was having to chat to other people about post op care. Most were in the US. I had mine done privately through Bupa in the uk, my excess was £100 and the total cost of surgery was £4000 including 24hr stay in hospital as I got the itemised bill.

The costs for identical surgery in the US with no overnight stay was in the region of $100,000. I was horrified (as were they when they heard my price!)

FrogsHiccups · 03/08/2021 17:02

@Anonymous48
Sorry, I didn’t word that quite right. It was the highest cost per person in the world (I’m pretty sure). Life expectancy was the lowest of the nations the video was comparing the USA healthcare system to IYSWIM. I think the nations were Uk, Germany, Sweden, Singapore, Japan and a couple more.

Here is the link anyway 🙂

oneglassandpuzzled · 03/08/2021 16:54

Getting back to the training of US v UK doctors. They actually spend a similar time being trained in medicine. US doctors have to do an undergraduate course first, but on the other hand, UK students generally finish school at a higher academic level than US students (not saying they are more intelligent, just that the English, in particular, system is more geared to passing academic exams at an earlier stage). The medical students and doctors I know are among the very brightest of the academic crop: the kids who could have done almost anything they wanted.

UK medical students often intercalate (take an extra degree in a year) during their five-year medical degree course. Quite a number switch from other undergraduate degrees, too.

As far as are they as good... Obviously the US system has more money behind it and a bigger population so more strength in depth. Perhaps there are rarer cancers where American doctors have expertise because there's funding for research that there isn't in a smaller economy.

To work in the US British doctors have to sit very rigorous exams, but that's not the same as saying they have to 'retrain'.

Don't know as much about nurses as none currently in the family.

gwenneh · 03/08/2021 16:48

@FrogsHiccups

I watched a really interesting video not so long ago about the American healthcare system in comparison to healthcare around the world, and I found it quite shocking. It said that healthcare in USA cost more per person than anywhere in the world and yet the life expectancy was the lowest. But the part that really got me was a story about a young man who needlessly died. He was type 1 diabetic and when he turned 21 he was no longer covered on the health insurance provided by his parents work. He went to purchase a months worth of insulin and was told the list price was $2000+. He couldn’t afford it and later died of Diabetic Ketoacidosis. This struck a particular chord with me as my son is type 1 diabetic, he had DKA (that was how he was diagnosed), received exceptional care at our local NHS hospital, has a team of specialists looking after him, a dietician and a psychologist available as and when he needs it. He’s just been fitted with a continual glucose monitor and an insulin pump. All funded by the NHS. He will never need to worry about whether or not he can afford his insulin, purely by virtue of the country he was born in to. I get very emotional if I stop and think about it for too long because I’m so immensely grateful that the NHS provide all of this!
My prior insurance company did not cover insulin (I am not diabetic but have had gestational diabetes while in the US) because with GD it is considered "medically unnecessary" even though my clinician wanted me on it for the best results. It was indeed $2000 per prescription.

The insurance company's appeals process denied it multiple times. Their approved treatment plan for gestational diabetes was cheaper and did not match my particular situation or diagnosis.

So I guess insurance works if you've never needed something the insurance didn't want to cover, but the second you do, it's an argument -- even if it saves your baby's life.

Anonymous48 · 03/08/2021 16:48

@FrogsHiccups

I watched a really interesting video not so long ago about the American healthcare system in comparison to healthcare around the world, and I found it quite shocking. It said that healthcare in USA cost more per person than anywhere in the world and yet the life expectancy was the lowest. But the part that really got me was a story about a young man who needlessly died. He was type 1 diabetic and when he turned 21 he was no longer covered on the health insurance provided by his parents work. He went to purchase a months worth of insulin and was told the list price was $2000+. He couldn’t afford it and later died of Diabetic Ketoacidosis. This struck a particular chord with me as my son is type 1 diabetic, he had DKA (that was how he was diagnosed), received exceptional care at our local NHS hospital, has a team of specialists looking after him, a dietician and a psychologist available as and when he needs it. He’s just been fitted with a continual glucose monitor and an insulin pump. All funded by the NHS. He will never need to worry about whether or not he can afford his insulin, purely by virtue of the country he was born in to. I get very emotional if I stop and think about it for too long because I’m so immensely grateful that the NHS provide all of this!
I agree with you that the American health care system is broken. It's better than it was thanks to the efforts of President Obama. For example, kids can stay on their parents insurance until they are 26 now. But yes, it still needs a lot of work.

But you are completely wrong about life expectancy being lower here than anywhere else in the world! If you stop and think about it for a second, you'll realize that that can't possibly be true.

www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/

FrogsHiccups · 03/08/2021 16:41

I watched a really interesting video not so long ago about the American healthcare system in comparison to healthcare around the world, and I found it quite shocking. It said that healthcare in USA cost more per person than anywhere in the world and yet the life expectancy was the lowest.
But the part that really got me was a story about a young man who needlessly died. He was type 1 diabetic and when he turned 21 he was no longer covered on the health insurance provided by his parents work. He went to purchase a months worth of insulin and was told the list price was $2000+. He couldn’t afford it and later died of Diabetic Ketoacidosis. This struck a particular chord with me as my son is type 1 diabetic, he had DKA (that was how he was diagnosed), received exceptional care at our local NHS hospital, has a team of specialists looking after him, a dietician and a psychologist available as and when he needs it. He’s just been fitted with a continual glucose monitor and an insulin pump. All funded by the NHS. He will never need to worry about whether or not he can afford his insulin, purely by virtue of the country he was born in to. I get very emotional if I stop and think about it for too long because I’m so immensely grateful that the NHS provide all of this!

Anonymous48 · 03/08/2021 16:34

I'm surprised that you were surprised by this @crunchymint . Did you think that us Americans with health insurance, even good health insurance, just waltz in to our doctor's offices and never pay a penny? I have pretty good coverage. I have to pay a $25 co-pay to see my primary care physician, and $50 to see a specialist. (That's every time I have a visit.) Medications are $10 for generics and $30 for name brand.

ShamelessCurtainTwitcher · 03/08/2021 16:21

[quote MissConductUS]The healthcare system is shameful here in the US. Deductibles are the least of people's worries - even worse are the hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills that a person can rack up just for being sick. I have a terminally ill cousin who has finally exhausted the family finances, and simply cannot keep up with the bills. So on top of worrying about dying, he and his family have to worry about losing their home.

Did the cousin not have insurance at all, not even Medicaid? Since 2011 there has been a limit on annual out of pocket expenses.

www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-limit/[/quote]
My best guess would be multiple providers and treatments as well as any number of loopholes designed to protect profits.

gwenneh · 03/08/2021 16:21

@MissConductUS

Even if you have insurance and can pay, you will still deal with the same gatekeeping through the insurer. It can take months for a routine procedure to be approved. This isn't just anecdata, though I can provide you with plenty of examples. The insurance does a good job of preserving their profits through gatekeeping. And even if your insurance does approve a procedure without question, you still have to wait for a provider and a facility, same as the NHS. Some areas are better resourced than others, same as the NHS.

I've never experienced this with any American insurance company. The only grounds they have for denying coverage for a procedure is if it is experimental or medically unnecessary, and it they do, there is an appeals process. I recently had hip surgery and no prior approval was required. I had to wait 10 days for the surgery to be scheduled because the surgeon was on holiday for a week.

I'm glad you've never experienced it. I have. I know others who have.

What an insurance company deems "medically unnecessary" can be deemed "critical" by your care team, and unless your care team can do the peer-to-peer and you have the energy to fight the insurance company, it isn't happening.

For example, my ultrasounds and gestational diabetes treatment weren't considered "medically necessary" and did not fall inside of the "maternity is 100% covered" of Aetna. Without them, what would the outcome of my pregnancy have been? What would have happened if I hadn't been in a position to pay 100% out of pocket?

I've a friend who was supposed to have a CT scan for her debilitating migraines yesterday, but insurance says it's not medically necessary. So she will go through the appeals process, while she is in pain. Another friend who did win the appeals process was initially denied for his follow up cancer care. You can't tell me insurance doesn't gatekeep, or that these are frivolous procedures.

The NHS wait times are nothing compared to this.

MissConductUS · 03/08/2021 16:13

The healthcare system is shameful here in the US. Deductibles are the least of people's worries - even worse are the hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills that a person can rack up just for being sick. I have a terminally ill cousin who has finally exhausted the family finances, and simply cannot keep up with the bills. So on top of worrying about dying, he and his family have to worry about losing their home.

Did the cousin not have insurance at all, not even Medicaid? Since 2011 there has been a limit on annual out of pocket expenses.

www.healthcare.gov/glossary/out-of-pocket-maximum-limit/

MissConductUS · 03/08/2021 16:09

Even if you have insurance and can pay, you will still deal with the same gatekeeping through the insurer. It can take months for a routine procedure to be approved. This isn't just anecdata, though I can provide you with plenty of examples. The insurance does a good job of preserving their profits through gatekeeping. And even if your insurance does approve a procedure without question, you still have to wait for a provider and a facility, same as the NHS. Some areas are better resourced than others, same as the NHS.

I've never experienced this with any American insurance company. The only grounds they have for denying coverage for a procedure is if it is experimental or medically unnecessary, and it they do, there is an appeals process. I recently had hip surgery and no prior approval was required. I had to wait 10 days for the surgery to be scheduled because the surgeon was on holiday for a week.

ShamelessCurtainTwitcher · 03/08/2021 15:39

Ciaobaby92 you said it all right there. Absolutely correct.

Ciaobaby92 · 03/08/2021 15:36

The healthcare system is shameful here in the US. Deductibles are the least of people's worries - even worse are the hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills that a person can rack up just for being sick. I have a terminally ill cousin who has finally exhausted the family finances, and simply cannot keep up with the bills. So on top of worrying about dying, he and his family have to worry about losing their home.

I know of people who have committed suicide due to this problem. I think one reason we have such a terrible problem with gun violence - in addition to the obvious reason that guns are way too available - is because people here just do not get access to adequate mental health care. They are usually held for a couple days, then kicked right back into the same situation they came from, with no long term help if they're poor.

ShamelessCurtainTwitcher · 03/08/2021 15:31

@CraftyGin

It would be much more interesting to hear from Americans who are under-insured, rather than those who gloat.
I am certainly not gloating.
gwenneh · 03/08/2021 15:27

@sst1234

Let’s not be smug about healthcare in this country. NHS is a second class system where people wait for months, sometimes years for routine procedures. You calm the GP and have to fight am with a receptionist who thinks she is the gatekeeper for an appointment. It’s all very well saying Americans pay a lot, but then they don’t have to suffer in agony and get the treatment.
Yes, they do.

Even if you have insurance and can pay, you will still deal with the same gatekeeping through the insurer. It can take months for a routine procedure to be approved. This isn't just anecdata, though I can provide you with plenty of examples. The insurance does a good job of preserving their profits through gatekeeping. And even if your insurance does approve a procedure without question, you still have to wait for a provider and a facility, same as the NHS. Some areas are better resourced than others, same as the NHS.

CraftyGin · 03/08/2021 15:23

It would be much more interesting to hear from Americans who are under-insured, rather than those who gloat.

Cameleongirl · 03/08/2021 14:51

We have a high-deductible insurance plan for our family and the deductible is $6K per year. As a PP said, we have a special health savings account that we use to cover medical and dental costs. Certain things, like annual physicals, mammograms, immunizations, etc. are fully covered by our insurance (no deductible). But I recently had a 15-minute video visit with my GP for an existing condition and just received the $170 bill.

The positive side is that we can access pretty much any medical treatment we need, we don’t need a referral to see a consultant. My kids see a pediatrician and I easily made an appointment with a dermatologist when DD had a mysterious rash, etc. But everything has to be paid for.

sst1234 · 03/08/2021 14:50

Let’s not be smug about healthcare in this country. NHS is a second class system where people wait for months, sometimes years for routine procedures. You calm the GP and have to fight am with a receptionist who thinks she is the gatekeeper for an appointment. It’s all very well saying Americans pay a lot, but then they don’t have to suffer in agony and get the treatment.