Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 'chin up' insensitive, dismissive or just the right thing to say to someone (a friend)?

84 replies

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 21:26

Suppose you had a friend who you knew was/had told you they you they were going through a bit of a hard time. You want to help them, so you give them advice etc., but you might not be physically able to meet up with them due to distance/commitments etc.

Is saying 'chin up' appropriate? Is it the kind of phrase that a friend would say/ write to you?

OP posts:
thecatfromjapan · 25/11/2017 22:45

In some situations, there really isn't a right thing to say - everything is trite.

Follow up with a phone call and just listen and let her talk.

Don't over-think it.

Kpo58 · 25/11/2017 22:43

Chin up to me translates as Piss off and stop whinging, I don't want to hear about your problems.

cremedelashite · 25/11/2017 22:43

If used at the end of other supportive conversation, then I think it's quite a sweet goodbye. If people say to me, I take it as hold on, it'll get better, keep going.

DullAndOld · 25/11/2017 22:42

if someone said 'chin up' to me in that kind of message I would immediately cancel the friendship tbh. (rider- this could be why I have very few friends)
But you must know it might sound off or you wouldn't be asking.

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 22:39

By 'true friend' I sort of meant a good friend. Basically I have known this person for a long time and wanted to give a response that reflects that - not suggest that I am being dismissive or that I don't genuinely care (like a 'fair weather' friend) . Basically I sent this person a message yesterday morning incorporating 'chin up' and have yet to receive a response. I am trying to consider whether I haven't because they took offence/were annoyed at my use of 'chin up' (which was incorporated into a very well meaning sentence) or just haven't replied because they couldn't etc.

OP posts:
DontBuyANewMumCashmere · 25/11/2017 22:33

OP re your last post - in a single message I think that just Chin Up would be insincere, but if having said 'I'm really sorry you're going through this' etc there were repeated messages I personally would sign off with Chin Up, amongst other things.
Only the giver and recipient of this message can work out if it was glib and trite or not.

CotswoldStrife · 25/11/2017 22:31

'true friend' is a bit dramatic Hmm It is beginning to sound more like a test of the friend giving the response which isn't nice.

DullAndOld · 25/11/2017 22:26

sorry but i find it a bit patronising and dismissive,. however that could just be the context I have heard it in (kids in year 4 class used to shout it at my son when he was being bullied)

thecatfromjapan · 25/11/2017 22:26

It totally depends on context. You might well say "chin up" because you both know that words are inadequate, that the person needs a lot, from different people, and that ultimately, only stoicism on their part is going to get them through.

Or it might be dismissive.

You can only tell by knowing the person who said it and making an estimate from there.

I'd suggest not over-thinking it and just assuming it was well-intentioned.

If it was you who said it, and your friend has taken offence, I'd put it down to them feeling vulnerable at the moment, make it clear that it wasn't meant dismissively, and leave them to find their way back in their own time.

Oysterbabe · 25/11/2017 22:25

It's a meaningless platitude.

DontBuyANewMumCashmere · 25/11/2017 22:24

Reading through some other messages - yes I use it as more of a Keep Strong than a Cheer Up...

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 22:22

Would 'I'm so sorry to hear you've had/are having a hard time' be more appropriate/a response that a true friend would give?

OP posts:
DontBuyANewMumCashmere · 25/11/2017 22:22

Oh God I say this all the fucking time and I'm the advice giver in a very similar situation as in your OP. Blush
What I would say is that during conversations I give much more thorough and useful advice, give constant reassurance that I'm there for them (hopefully!) slag off their 'aggravator' and emotionally support them. Hopefully.

But by the end of a stream of messages I often sign off with a Chin Up. (Friend isn't depressed, as far as I know.)
Argh!

Bambamber · 25/11/2017 22:22

I only ever use it in a vague, lighthearted way in situations that aren't all that bad. For example recently someone's biscuit broke while dunking and half dropped in their tea. So i said 'chin up, at least you can be guilt free about having another biscuit'. I wouldnt use it in a serious situation or if someone was eeally opening up to me

CotswoldStrife · 25/11/2017 22:18

I also thought it was a reverse as soon as I read it!

I don't think chin up is dismissive, sometimes it's the only thing you can do - just push through the tough times. It recognises that you are finding the situation hard and that you need a bit of strength to get through it.

Did someone say it to you and you felt it was dismissive, OP?

Ski4130 · 25/11/2017 22:13

I use chin up a fair bit, but never as a ‘cheer up’ more in the context of ‘keep your head held high, you’ll get through this’.

DontTouchTheMoustache · 25/11/2017 22:12

I told a close friend i was having a bad day (depression related) after some bad news. She said some vaguely friendly things plus "chin up" and yeah it felt dismissive, impersonal and patronising. Made me feel like absolute shit for thinking my feelings were even worthwhile sharing. Sorry but its a really bad phrase to use, it feels really impersonal and uncaring.

AnUtterIdiot · 25/11/2017 22:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MaisyPops · 25/11/2017 22:06

It depends on the situation and the person.

If someone is irritated by something I migjt say 'chin up. At least it's friday tomorrow'

Equally, if I'm 30 mins into a circular conversation that isn't going anywhere (think - friend asks for advice. You give advice. Friend dismisses advice and continues ti wallow and asks what thru shpuld do. You givr advice. They tell you all about why nobody will ever solve it because everything is so awful etc) then I have gone for the chin up approach as in you can do x y z or you can keep wallowing in self pity. Chin up. You've got a range of options what are you going yi do?'

But if someone is struggling with a bereavement/divorce etx then it's totally not ok.

trilbydoll · 25/11/2017 22:01

Me and my friend say it at the end of the conversation, so after all the usual sympathy, suggesting solutions (depending on the exact situation obviously) we will end it with 'chin up chuck' she's said it for years! It would be a bit strange as an initial response though.

Allthewaves · 25/11/2017 21:58

Wouldn't bother me as I interpret it as - you doing great dealing with everything and things will get better.

Mymycherrypie · 25/11/2017 21:53

My friends and I say chin up to each other all the time. We mean it to say - walk proudly, don't let this thing break you, whatever is happening to you right now will not be forever, we will always be there for you whenever you need it etc. We say all of those things too.

Not chin up, go away and stop moaning Hmm

Straycatblue · 25/11/2017 21:49

Saying chin up to someone who is going through a rough time is dismissive and patronising.

People often say it because they don't know what else to say or because its a cop out and want to seem like theyre being sympathetic without getting emotionally involved but it makes the person they are saying it to feel even worse in most situations.

Why not instead be honest with your friend, acknowledge that what shes going through is unpleasant ie say it to her or write it, most people get uncomfortable and don't want to make things worse but often the person struggling just wants someone to say "Im sorry you're having a tough time, its shit and its not fair and Im sorry I cant be there in person but Im thinking of you."

PenelopeStoppit · 25/11/2017 21:43

It's hard to say. It depends on the relationship the people have and where the sentiment is coming from. My dad said it to me once when I was having a hard time and I found it old fashioned, as people have mentioned, but rather touching. It stayed with me and I do think of him saying it when I feel down from time to time. In another context and different relationship it could sound belittling.

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 21:39

Sorry I should of added a bit more context - I didn't mean saying 'chin up' as a stand alone. I meant saying it alongside things like 'feel free to rant again - anytime' and giving advice on their situation.

OP posts: