Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 'chin up' insensitive, dismissive or just the right thing to say to someone (a friend)?

84 replies

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 21:26

Suppose you had a friend who you knew was/had told you they you they were going through a bit of a hard time. You want to help them, so you give them advice etc., but you might not be physically able to meet up with them due to distance/commitments etc.

Is saying 'chin up' appropriate? Is it the kind of phrase that a friend would say/ write to you?

OP posts:
Bohemond · 26/11/2017 06:57

Perhaps it would be better to phone them.....

Kittymum03 · 26/11/2017 06:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

picklemepopcorn · 26/11/2017 06:12

I use "hang in there" rather than chin up. It's a little softer.

Message her saying you are worried your advice was too blunt and you'd hate to think you've upset her.

She may just be processing what you said

PurpleDaisies · 26/11/2017 05:35

It sounds like they’ve got a lot going on, so I’d question whether sending messages asking if what you wrote was ok is really the best thing to do. It kind of makes it about you now.

You sound genuinely concerned for your friend which is really nice. I’d give them a few days and see about meeting for coffee.

Graphista · 26/11/2017 05:23

Specifically contacted you BUT did they specifically ask for advice?

Unsolicited advice - especially of the 'hard to hear' variety is NEVER a good idea.

I suspect many of us have been guilty of it at some point as it comes from a desire to help but it's not helpful.

I have mh issues and a very dear friend who TRIES to help but really doesn't get it, its souring our friendship to be honest.

You're being quite vague about the situation they're going through but maybe Google 'how to support...' 'What to say to...' 'What not to say to...' Someone going through X.

I've had some very hurtful, thoughtless comments made about various things I've gone through, I would take 'chin up' as dismissive.

cremedelashite · 26/11/2017 04:56

Op, it was just 2 words in a generally supportive relationship/ exchange. People don't scrutinise each word to such a degree. and it's absolutely not in the same league as don't be silly. I'm sure your pal took it in the spirit intended. People know who cares and who is glib and dismissive. It was fine. Follow up with "how are you", if you want to be sure.

Rolf38 · 26/11/2017 00:09

@chestylarue52 - Yes, they specifically contacted me, and I feel such a failure for letting them down.

OP posts:
chestylarue52 · 26/11/2017 00:00

Had they asked you for advice? Sometimes unsolicited advice can be quite annoying.

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 23:50

If there is one thing that I have learnt is that perhaps I might just need to step back from giving advice etc. altogether. I really wanted to help my friend, and thought that I was doing so. However, perhaps I am just not naturally good at emotions giving advice and theyd'do be betters ff getting advice from elsewhere. Th last thing I wanted to do was sound dismissive/insincere by using 'chin up' as a part of my last sentences.

OP posts:
Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 23:47

Also, the advice I gave in my message was genuine. It was advice that I know would have been hard for them to hear, however, I know that if they follow it it would REALLY help them. I hope they understand that. My response to them wasn't half hearted - I really did think about their situation and offer genuine advice that sought to help them in the long term - not just half hearted advice that would make them feel better for a week or so.

My use of 'chin up' was part of a sentence - something like 'chin up you've got your whole life ahead of you - this is only a small part'. It wasn't just like 'chin up, mate'.

OP posts:
MrsAJ27 · 25/11/2017 23:46

It sounds like you are not comfortable talking to your friend about this over the phone....follow up with another text saying something like "how are you feeling?" or "I am here if you need me"

Dozer · 25/11/2017 23:41

You tried, and care enough to reflect on your words and actions. Phone or in person is better for this kind of thing.

NaughtToThreeSadOnions · 25/11/2017 23:40

Why use platitudes why not just say sorry your having a hard time you know where I am if you need me? I do find it patronising and I would be annoyed if a friend said it.

Personally I hate things like this, I find them a bit weird, slightly different to your situation but I have quite a emotionaless resting face. I don't walk around grinning my head off. I get random strangers going chin up or cheer up when I'm just walking to the damn bus stop.

Once after one of my close friends had died suddenly I was on the way home and I hear this bloke going 'what's up with her' I look up and he goes 'cheer up it might never happen' (yeah it was only a week after my friend had died and I felt shit)

Only a few weeks ago I was walking to the bus stop to go to work and a old bloke went 'cheer up it will soon be christmas' I did go I hate Christmas and you have no idea what's going on in my life. I was perfectly happy I enjoy going to work. Just people seem to think they need to tell me to cheer up

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 23:40

@mrsAJ27 - my message to them contained a lot more than just 'chin up'.

OP posts:
Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 23:39

I feel a bit bad about sending it now - to be honest, I really am quite bad at emotional chats etc. and was a bit lost in what to say. I spent a good few few hours thinking about what they sent me and thinking of and writing a response which I hoped would sound sincere and give them good advice. I'm just not really that good at emotional chats etc. Perhaps I should have just asked someone else first how to respond more sincerely - i just wanted to help them.

OP posts:
MrsAJ27 · 25/11/2017 23:38

If a good friend said "Chin up" to me when I was going though a shit time I honestly think I would tell them to Fuck off!

How is saying that going to help??

PickAChew · 25/11/2017 23:32

It's a twee way of saying "you're on your own, mate".

Dozer · 25/11/2017 23:30

In your shoes, if you like and care about the person, would give it a few days then send chit chat and ask how they are, perhaps suggest a chat or meeting up.

Dozer · 25/11/2017 23:28

The message you sent them sounds dismissive. “Feel free to rant” is a more subtle form of “chin up, it implies that you think their problems are minor and could be solved by virtual “venting”. Insensitive.

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 23:28

@spongeface - I'm sorry to hear that. When I said 'chin up' to my friend yesterday it was only two words of a long, supportive and advisory message. I also followed up this evening just to ask if what I wrote was ok.

OP posts:
Spongeface · 25/11/2017 23:23

Agree, agree with pp that it feels dismissive. I had a bad break up once and a friend I thought was close to told me to 'chin up'. Wasn't very helpful... no longer friends. She wasnt offering any other advice or help tho. Hope your friend is ok.

Sienna333 · 25/11/2017 23:15

I don't think it's appropriate. I also hate being told "Don't be silly", it's very condescending.

teaandtoast · 25/11/2017 22:58

Ha! I used it today at the end of a message to an adult dc who is abroad and is slightly ill.

To me, at the end of a supportive message, it definitely has the flavour of 'keep strong' that a pp suggested.

KeepTheBloodyNoiseDown · 25/11/2017 22:56

I think it depends on the friendship more than anything. I have a friend that I often say things like that to. But we’re very close and very upfront with each other, and we’ve been friends since school (both had lots of problems) so that’s probably why. After going through a very traumatic experience, she told me to pull myself together, because she knew what I needed to hear, if anyone else had said that I doubt I would have spoken to them again.

Rolf38 · 25/11/2017 22:52

creamdelashite - that's exactly as I used it - at the end of a long message offering advice. It was one of the last sentences, the last being something like 'feel free to get in touch/rant/vent again, anytime'. I do hope they saw my message as supportive of them.

OP posts: