Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
GlitterGlue · 27/10/2017 17:46

Lalalyra, has your friend thought of using the Access to Work scheme if she is able to work again? It can pay for taxi transport.

LakieLady · 27/10/2017 17:39

when you submit a MR do you just type a letter with sub sections relating to the assessors report and what you dispute

I go through each descriptor for which I think points should be awarded, explain how the conditions affect the client's ability to undertake the task safely, repeatedly, to a reasonable standard etc, the sort of help they need to do it/aids they have to use etc and then tell them how many points I think they should be awarded! I only refer to the assessor's report if there's a glaring piece of idiocy, as in the case of the lady who was assessed at home, in her level access bungalow, but somehow was able to demonstrate that she could climb stairs!

LakieLady · 27/10/2017 17:31

I am sure they routinely turn down everyone and then reassess on appeal.

I know it can seem like that, but I've done plenty of applications that have been successful without appealing. My client got enhanced for both components, which was a nice surprise, as I was only expecting the standard rate.

Always appeal. The tribunals are far more fair than the DWP asshats who make the initial decisions.

Don't necessarily blame the assessors, either. They are told to rewrite their reports until they bear no resemblance to the original. My friend was an assessor for about a year, until she lost her rag at being told to lie and walked out.

Gazelda · 27/10/2017 17:25

It’s total shit OP. I strongly echo other posters who’ve recommended getting support to prepare your appeal. So many appeals are going through successfully now (although at a snails pace). Charities, CAB, etc are getting very good at knowing how to construct a successful appeal.

HornyTortoise · 27/10/2017 17:22

MRs can take months though. usually they are faster, but they technically do not have a timescale so could be indefinite. Once MR is complete and appeal is lodged, you can go back on assessment rate though. Its the inbetween thats the issue.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 17:19

Sorry lazyarse do the MR. If refused. Then lodge an appeal with HMCTs. You can lodge an appeal quite soon after you get a 'no' from an MR. It's not unusual given the Decision Makers more often than not have zero medical knowledge.

HornyTortoise · 27/10/2017 17:17

The ridiculous thing for my son is that he has been told by DWP that he is entitled to claim jobseekers while the appeal goes through. I told them that is fraud as he can not work.

I had huge issues with this when I had to appeal a few years back. They told me I could claim JSA. I told them I wasn't fit for work and they said that was my only option. So made an appointment to claim JSA and they took one look at me and said they would be breaking the law to sign me onto JSA as I clearly cannot work Hmm

Until MR was accepted I had no income at all as this went back and forth a few times. Was told to use 'special circumstances' but they would not accept that. In the end I had to contact my MP who sped the process along a bit.

Might have changed now. This was about 3 years back

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 17:17

lazyarse I'm a bit sketchy so it might be worth checking with CAB but I'm sure that once an appeal is lodged the DWP has to then pay you, well your son, the assessment rate of ESA until his appeal is heard. The jobcentre advisor should know this.

InfiniteCurve · 27/10/2017 17:16

Those posters who are saying part of the problem is false claims - well,no.Even if that was a significant number we as a society could decide that it is better for some false claims to be paid than for any genuine claimants to be denied help.
That would cost more but it's still a decision we could make.
Also,surely to God if you want to detect someone claiming falsely iF you think that's an issue you need to use properly trained and qualified assessors and pay attention to the reports of the qualified people who are already in contact with claimants,many of whom must be in registered professions who could be penalised for lying,if that's what the Govt are worried about...Hmm)

Not chosen to do that either,it's appalling and all of you going through this have my sympathy ( not that that helps at all Sad)

lazyarse123 · 27/10/2017 17:10

The ridiculous thing for my son is that he has been told by DWP that he is entitled to claim jobseekers while the appeal goes through. I told them that is fraud as he can not work. Apparently "special circumstances" means that he can claim He just has to make an effort to search for work for 2hours 3 times a week. Makes a mockery of the whole system.

WhatWouldLeslieKnopeDo · 27/10/2017 17:08

Horny probably even higher as some people are so broken by the process that they cannot appeal. Though I suspect they see it as success rather than failure because they're making the process as unpleasant as possible and maybe saving a few pennies at the expense of someone's health and dignity.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 17:05

Ceto it will do eventually. It will just be another shitstorm from the media where all the evidence built up against them means they're backed into a corner and the Government will drop the PIP tender quicker than a hot potato. Just like they did with ATOS.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 17:02

I would love to know the cost to the DWP of a tribunal.

Sadly the effects and results of that wont be evident in full for a good few years yet. But people are being awarded thousands if they win at Tribunal stage so you can imagine the scale.

I'm sure we'll just get the 'we had to make difficult decisions' tagline then too though.

Ceto · 27/10/2017 17:01

I came across someone who was originally assessed at zero, then got awarded full points on mandatory reconsideration. Surely questions should be asked about the competence of the original assessor when there is such a massive discrepancy?

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 17:01

but they put in the report that I refused to do the movements! Because I can’t you frigging idiots.

Elsie please Appeal, and please complain to the centre you had the assessment from. It was extremely unsafe for you to do the movements for obvious reasons (dislocation) and you are well within your rights to refuse to do the movements if you feel/fear you are going to experience pain (or more) as a result. Attitudes wont like this wont change, unless they are challenged, repeatedly. Get your MP involved too.

User843022 · 27/10/2017 17:00

'65% of appeals are upheld in the claimants favour. Why is a 65% failure rate on original assessments tolerated?'

Yes assessors are failing to do their job correctly 65% of the time. What other job would that failure be accepted? Confused

I would love to know the cost to the DWP of a tribunal.

HornyTortoise · 27/10/2017 16:56

65% of appeals are upheld in the claimants favour. Why is a 65% failure rate on original assessments tolerated?

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 16:55

Oh thanks for that expatinscotland had me wondering for a moment then! Grin

HornyTortoise · 27/10/2017 16:54

Elise, please get welfare rights to represent you if you do need a tribunal. They have helped so many people I know..and helped me not long ago too to go from 2 points in daily living, to standard award on both mobility and daily living.

On notes too... My doctors told me I would need to pay 50 quid to them, 50 to the pain clinic and 50 to a+E for full notes to back me up ..which I obviously could not do with bulk of income stopped. BUT, the judge requested my details rather than me having to pay for them. SO you do not have to pay out fortunes as it seems if the judges think you have a case, they will request the details themselves

Just helping auntie through it all now. Seems most people are initially turned down. I expect this is because many will just accept the decision, even though they ARE entitled to help. So the government saves money. Its not the fault of the few fraudsters at all...any system has an element of fraud, it would be impossible to have a system without any. Disability fraud is sooo rare though. But the few who do manage to do it are paraded around for frothing mail readers at regular intervals to make out its common.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 16:54

that I'm sure recording as in Police interviews will have to be allowed soon.

blanklook sorry if I've not understood your post correctly but just wanted ti point out that recordings are already allowed. They just don't like to tell you that. Ask the assessment centre beforehand. It has to be double sided (there's another technical word for it) and you have to provide it.

It is illegal for them to say a recording will not be permitted. As long as it is double sided. You can.

EliseC1965 · 27/10/2017 16:47

I just got turned down. 0 points on everything despite having received DLA for the past 22 years for Hypermobility. Seems dislocating everything every time I do anything has spontaneously been cured. I’ve also developed osteoporosis now, had breast cancer with god awful side effects, cut myself regularly when doing food prep, but I have a husband who can do it for me (assessors words). I can't wash my hair properly or raisemy arms properly after mastectomy, but they put in the report that I refused to do the movements! Because I can’t you frigging idiots. Same with having to touch my toes. Osteoporosis in my back won’t let me bend much at all, but again, I refused. Sigh.
No mention in the report of my hidradenitis suppuravita (don’t google if you’re eating), which is hideously painful, gross and disgusting. And I actually did say when asked, that I have seriously considered topping myself.
But no, I look smart and sound intelligent so nil pointes. Wtf had that got to do with being barely able to walk some days due to hideous pain in n my groin?
I wrote up my reply using one of the many PIP assistance websites for MR, and posted it ‘track and trace’. In case they decided that I didn’t reply in time.
I couldn’t get anything from my gp either, but m having no private physio, so I may be able to get something f I’m them (at a huge cost no doubt)

Just have to wait and see now.

HornyTortoise · 27/10/2017 16:45

I can't understand why a report from your own doctor or consultant is not enough for this evil government.

Well yes. My auntie is going through reassessment at the moment and has so much medical evidence behind her (but still got 0 points). Fairly certain when tribunal is heard she will get it back but still....its months and months without her lifeline (her car...only reason she can work PT)

Oddly enough, a sicknote is enough for her employer. A sicknote has always been enough for my employers too when I was ill. But...not enough for the government. Infact, not even mountains of consultant reports, GP notes, hospital admissions, and so on are enough. Instead they take the word of someone who has 2 weeks 'disability training' and gets bonuses for each person they remove from benefits over the word of specialists. Fuckers.

blanklook · 27/10/2017 16:42

Here's a relevant part of my post from a thread on DLA for children this morning, about going from DLA to PIP

Apparently there are great groups on FB. I don't have FB.

I really regret not making sure the face to face interview was recorded. So many people are exposing the "misunderstandings" of assessors that I'm sure recording as in Police interviews will have to be allowed soon.

My dd had indefinite DLA, we are now transferring to PIP and suddenly their face to face assessor "doesn't see" dd's disabilities and DWP are trying to uphold that against reports from Consultants. Tribunal imminent. Even with medical evidence, the DWP argue against it.

Tip - always send your submissions by PO Next Day Signed for, it's £7 or so but you need to take a screenshot of the time and signature of the person who received it.

One of their "month from the date of this letter" deadlines arrived 2 weeks after that letter's date and then there was a Bank Holiday so I only actually had a few days to submit within their "month" They then argued my submission was late so the claim would be cancelled, until I produced a screenshot of the time and date they had received it, which was two days before their deadline. Despite asking for an explanation, none was given.

From what I understand, judges are becoming very tired of the attitude of ATOS and CAPITA assessors.

lazyarse123 · 27/10/2017 16:33

My son had his ESA stopped, he has mh problems. Their reasons were: he made eye contact. Could get himself to the assessment centre (yes because I took him there) he can wash himself (he can but doesn't always) he can answer his door (he can if he is expecting someone). We (I) have appealed. But it has caused him so much stress and anxiety his condition is now 100% worse. They have knocked his recovery back months.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 16:23

MyrtleMaracas and OP. Take a look here.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/2764894--to-give-people-assistance-with-claiming-PIP