Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
Jynxed · 28/10/2017 19:43

I have nothing helpful to add, but just wanted to say that all civilised societies support the vulnerable, and I am ashamed of the current system. I would welcome a higher rate of tax to provide for a decent welfare state.

Jux · 28/10/2017 19:38

What happens in other countries? How do EU nations look after their vulnerable people? I am beginning to think we don’t deserve to be in the EU.

The Tories are disgraceful to a man - how dare they preside over this farcical process without complaint?

There is a special level of hell reserved for IDS.

Lillyringlet · 28/10/2017 18:50

I couldn't walk across the room for half the week... To go to the loo or anything but I was declared fit for work. Yep can't walk half the week so was waiting for my partner to come home after work and during breaks (lucky he was only a 20 minutes walk) to feed me and get me to the loo.

Got no help at all from social services or money from anyone because my disability was intermittent. Basically if one day I walked to the shops at the end of the road I would be unable to get out of bed and be in a lot of pain the next. If I ventured further I would take longer to recover.

Lucky for me though I stumbled upon this research about a possible way to kick start recovery. Contacted the researchers and went for it. Turns out pregnancy can help restart recovery and in some cases even start fixing permanent brain injuries. I've been lucky to be able to walk again and not have to deal with that bullshirt but I do know how awful it is dealing with a system designed to kill disabled people or make it look like they are doing something "positive". It's something like 90%of cases are getting turned over at the moment and costing them more than they are saving so it really isn't working... Seriously f&%k the conservatives.

WhatWouldLeslieKnopeDo · 28/10/2017 18:48

Well said Jux

Jux · 28/10/2017 18:14

For most of my life I was living in a civilised country that was proud to care for its most vulnerable members.

The principle was that it was better to include a few cheats than to miss any who truly deserved help. The principle my current country chases fericiously is the opposite.

I have always lived in the UK and still do.

I am ashamed.

FaveNumberIs2 · 28/10/2017 18:10

Yanbu. I lost ds’s dla because he’s made a small improvement in his personal hygiene. Even though he will never be free from autism.

JonSnowsWife · 28/10/2017 17:29

I actually think it's a disgrace that people aren't up in arms about the cost of the appeals procedure.

They won't be as they believe the lie(s) fed to them. That these are all feckless scroungers. You've only got to see the amount of benefit bashing that goes on on some threads where people still think PIP is purely an out of work benefit.

Those who are up in arms about it are the ones campaigning tirelessly to make a difference and are still not being listened to. The link to the thread I posted earlier procrs this where the ex-assessor says they've tried going to the papers to no avail. This is quite common. MPs will do press release after press release and it'll get buried amongst other stuff.

The system is a bloody lottery, until you get to tribunal, where decisions are made by sensible people.

Yes mostly but do be careful still, DWP were sending their own reps in at one point to be on the panel (not unheard of but they clearly can't be acting unbiased)

kaykay72 · 28/10/2017 17:24

My sisters pip was stopped. When the assessor arrived my nephew let him in. The chap declined a cup of tea offered by nephew because he’d just had one. On the report it stated that her mobility was fine as she’d answered the door and was able to make him a hot drink 🙄

lazymum99 · 28/10/2017 16:56

You are probably right LakieLady. I have seen decisions overturned after the SSCS1 has been sent in with extra evidence and a full appeal looking at each descriptor. i.e.. It didn't need to go to Tribunal.
However, IME the most important thing is to show up at the hearing and have your say. The Judges doing the tribunals seem fair and reasonable. A few decision notices I have seen recently actually refer to the HCP doing a 'too superficial assessment'. Unfortunately, I have dealt with loads of zero to Enhanced in PIP and Zero to Support Group in ESA.

lalalalyra · 28/10/2017 16:52

I actually think it's a disgrace that people aren't up in arms about the cost of the appeals procedure.

When I went with my cousin her panel was a lawyer, a doctor and a welfare rights woman. How much do they cost to hire each day?

There was something like 14 rooms in the place, all with appeals going on, so that cost times 14 x 5 days a week.

Her wait for the date was EIGHTEEN MONTHS so they are obviously busy!

Surely that whole process likely costs far, far more than the benefits they are denying people, and there is no-one held to account. The tribunal judge in her ESA appeal absolutely went through the DWP guy in attendance for being so rude and bullying. She recommended that the DWP didn't reassess cousin for 2-3 years, but since that isn' binding she restarted the whole process 8 months later. It's a farce.

JonSnowsWife · 28/10/2017 16:51

Ime, MRs succeed so rarely that they're pretty much just a time-wasting exercise. If you do the MR by phone, you can get to the appeal stage a bit more quickly.

Yes. But its also not advisory. Doing it over the phone meanss they'll cherry pick the bits you say and then it'll almost certainly come back as a no. At least if done on paper, you cab sit down, think about it, explain and rationale your arguments clearly and where you should have been awarded points for this descriptor and that descriptor.

Always better to have a paper trail.

LakieLady · 28/10/2017 16:46

Lazymum, I don't think it makes any difference.

Ime, MRs succeed so rarely that they're pretty much just a time-wasting exercise. If you do the MR by phone, you can get to the appeal stage a bit more quickly.

I used to spend a long time drafting MR grounds, but the only ones that succeeded were those where the client was only a couple of points short of success.

After a week where I had 3 successful appeals, where the grounds submitted were identical to those in the MR letter, the client had not provided any additional evidence OR attended the tribunal, I decided not to bother. It made no difference to my outcomes overall.

One of those 3 was a client awarded 0 points at assessment and MR, but awarded enhanced rate of both components on appeal. The tribunal had no more evidence than that which was submitted with her original application.

The system is a bloody lottery, until you get to tribunal, where decisions are made by sensible people.

lazymum99 · 28/10/2017 16:16

Please try not to do Mandatory Reconsideration requests on the phone. There will be no further evidence taken into account and it will almost never be overturned.
Do it in writing. Go through each descriptor that is a problem and spell out how your illness/disability means you cannot carry out this activity. Try and send in GP/consultant reports to support this.
The above poster with the 3 year old child in a specialist nursery - if the nursery can write a report on the extra care your child needs while at nursery it would help you a lot.

Anymajordude · 28/10/2017 16:14

I'm not religious but sometimes I hope there's a God so the evil fuckers IDSwho set up this system get their just deserts.

HornyTortoise · 28/10/2017 16:09

Yes totally and utterly agree with this. If they make mistakes 65% of the time why are they in fact not held to account for their fraudulent reports?

because its not a 'mistake'. Its exactly what they are paid to do. To get the disability benefit numbers down, by any means necessary. I know that sound a bit conspiracy theory...but honestly..if they were paid to do fair assessments, they would have had some kind of sanction by now for the extremely high 'failure' rate.

User843022 · 28/10/2017 14:26

'I think there should be some sort of system where any assessor shown to be lying in the reports, and disproved at MR or appeal stage, should be made liable for fraud. Like a claimant is when they fail to declare something. '

Yes totally and utterly agree with this. If they make mistakes 65% of the time why are they in fact not held to account for their fraudulent reports?

JonSnowsWife · 28/10/2017 13:51

If the assessing company had to bear the costs of any successful appeal, I wonder how much difference it would make to the inaccuracy of the reports?

Yes. I've often said this. I think there should be some sort of system where any assessor shown to be lying in the reports, and disproved at MR or appeal stage, should be made liable for fraud. Like a claimant is when they fail to declare something.

I'm sure many will then make sure they do their jobs properly once such a threat hangs over them.

LakieLady · 28/10/2017 13:43

If the assessing company had to bear the costs of any successful appeal, I wonder how much difference it would make to the inaccuracy of the reports?

If they lie get it wrong and the wrong decision is made because of that, they should pay imo.

LakieLady · 28/10/2017 13:38

My evidence for Tribunal so far consists of 34 pages explaining where the Assessor was inaccurate or fabricated evidence. The deadline is next week and I am so wound up about it all I am steadily becoming more incoherent.

As long as you get the basic grounds of appeal in by the deadline, you can submit additional evidence later on.

It's usually better to leave the full evidence until after you get the DWP's bundle of evidence. Then you can rebut every last word of it!

MrsPringles · 28/10/2017 13:05

YANBU

My husband has his stopped without much notice after a consultation with an assessor who had no idea what he was doing, we appealed against the decision and the panel decided it shouldn't have been stopped.

It was reinstated and back dated for the months he had missed.
Appeal OP, it's definitely worth it.

PastysPrincess · 28/10/2017 11:49

I’m awaiting a Mandatory Reconsideration decision for my DS. He was denied DLA as they state he doesn’t need anymore looking after than any other three year old. It’s so frustrating because if he had DLA there is extra help we can access for his developmental needs (which is separate to the money he would be awarded) so hopefully as he grows up we can mitigate his problems. I feel time slipping away, the longer the MR goes on the less time we have to help him.

He is currently attending a specialist nursery that has a referral only admission policy. Your child has to have quite profound problems to get in and is run by the local authority but apparantly that doesn’t count as evidence.

When I rang to ask for Mandatory Reconsideration the person I spoke to said we couldn’t request it as we werent entitled to. Thankfully we have a support service helping us and they told us to write in instead.

mollibu · 28/10/2017 11:07

In my PIP assessment, they asked me to recite the alphabet backwards! .... I have a hip disability Hmm. I appealed and won, fingers crossed for you X

User843022 · 28/10/2017 11:07

'yes I feel a fraud. And useless. '

What we have to do is throw it back at them. The assessors are incompetent. High success rate at tribunal corroborates that. I really do support assessments and understand the need, but in my example my friend who has dysphasia now/can't speak, but had to go to an assessment, to then read she doesn't need support to engage socially is just crazy. If she didn't, why was I sat there answering the questions as she couldn't. Idiots.

Honestly we need to harness the anger and indignation and throw it back at them. They seem to expect people will just accept their incompetence because they're just feel too vulnerable and too exhausted to fight.

Gottagetmoving · 28/10/2017 11:04

I wonder how much money is spent by this government trying to get out of paying benefits.

FuckitAndStartAgain · 28/10/2017 10:49

Myrtle, yes I feel a fraud. And useless. The system is a horrible place to be in.
Some of the lies are straightforward, eg she could assess how many degrees of movement I had in my right foot in every direction, despite it being in a surgical boot. She also absolutely ignored problems with my arm and stated it was fine, despite a ten year history of difficulties and treatments and a three level fusion of neck planned, but after I have had another spinal fusion for my lower back in January. She also reported I could not be faecally incontinent as Imodium works, I don’t think taking it ALL the time to prevent any bowel movements is really a good plan!
I was using a knee scooter following foot surgery and she was told I would start walking a little the following week. She witnessed me scoot but uttterly neglected that the following week I would be back to walking a few steps before pain forces a rest.
Loads more...you can see why I have written so much. I just hope someone reads it.