Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
backaftera2yearbreak · 29/10/2017 18:20

I work for a well known cancer charity as a benefits advisor. One of my clients was given the less than 6 months to live certificate. Atos refused it. Twice. It's a joke.

CatchingBabies · 29/10/2017 18:14

This is disgusting.

My mum had her PIP denied recently. She has ushers syndrome, was born deaf and went blind later. They said she could plan and follow a familiar route so lost points there, lets ignore the fact she can't see where she's going so no route will ever be familiar!

At appeal she was given high rate care and mobility.

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 18:12

We as disabled people shouldn't have to appeal what we are rightfully entitled to

Of course disabled people shouldn't have to appeal. This is not the fault of other people who try to claim for their own illness though.

Again, anger directed at the wrong place.

expatinscotland · 29/10/2017 18:10

'No sympathy, sorry. Yes people cope differently but it's still a choice. People don't choose to put cancer into their bodies.'

Some people do get cancer due to their addictions. They are ill and deserve just as much help as any other disabled person.

brasty · 29/10/2017 18:07

What about people who self harm are anorexic, should they also be denied sickness benefits because "they did it to themselves"

brasty · 29/10/2017 18:06

Lots of illnesses and disability are caused by our own actions. Going skiing, horse riding, road traffic accidents, etc. Most of my friends do sports, and many have had time off with injuries that require surgery.

ProfessorCat · 29/10/2017 18:02

I have full disability benefits. I did appeal and was awarded what I needed.

Of course they go out of their way to take drugs or drink alcohol. They're not forced to visit a pub or find a dealer.

Viviennemary · 29/10/2017 18:00

If you have a physical disability that prevents you from working or you need help with daily living then you should get the benefits. Others have suggested you should appeal if you think you have been wrongly denied the payments or seek help from one of the associations mentioned on this thread.

People don't go out deliberately to become alcoholics and drug addicts.

ProfessorCat · 29/10/2017 17:51

They're ill because they made themselves ill. We as disabled people shouldn't have to appeal what we are rightfully entitled to. I didn't give myself my disabilities.

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:50

So SO wrong that they get support over real ill people.

They don;t get support over 'real' ill people though. Its not either/or.

If those turned down for sickness benefits who are actually entitled appealed, then they would get the benefits they were entitled to. Its shit that appeals have to be done as the right decision should be made to start with, but thats the shitty system we have to deal with.

Directing anger at other ill people is wrong. Direct anger at the system and those who made it so hard for disabled people to get what they are entitled to tbh

Viviennemary · 29/10/2017 17:40

I think it is fair that people should get sickness benefit for diseases and conditions caused by alcohol and drug addictions. And of course they are proper illnesses.

ProfessorCat · 29/10/2017 17:26

So SO wrong that they get support over real ill people.

If I had a drug or alcohol problem I'd get so much help.

Because I have PTSD and a physical disability I get bugger all without having to wait for years. It's disgusting and wrong.

No sympathy, sorry. Yes people cope differently but it's still a choice. People don't choose to put cancer into their bodies.

lazymum99 · 29/10/2017 17:20

Alcohol and drug addiction come with associated physical and mental health issues. They need support just as much as other ill/disabled. Ewan1234 it is not a matter of choosing one claimant over another and never will be. Cutting off their in work/out of work benefits will only make the situation worse in the long run. Your son really should have appealed as difficult as it might have seemed. If he needs help with the care descriptors in PIP you need to persevere. Please reapply and appeal if he is turned down again. Use a CAB/welfare rights/community law centre to help.

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:11

Though really really doubt that there are many claimants that are passed for alcoholism or drug addiction ALONE

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:10

Hmm apparently the DWP views alcohol related disorders
as a recognized psychiatric disorder.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/medical-guidance-for-dla-and-aa-decision-makers-adult-cases-staff-guide

I understand that I think tbh. Though really really doubt that there are many claimants that are passed for alcoholism or drug addiction.

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:08

Heh nevermind, those are american

Pretty sure the same rules apply to us though

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:05

www.disabilitysecrets.com/topics/disability-alcohol-or-drug-addiction

Since 1996, you can no longer get Social Security disability insurance (SSDI) or SSI benefits for alcoholism or drug addiction alone. You can, however, get disability benefits for damage caused by the alcohol or drug abuse, such as liver damage, emotional problems, cardiovascular disease, or cancer. But this is true only if you are no longer drinking or abusing drugs, or if your medical condition is so severe that the damage caused by the drinking or drugs is irreversible.

Also

So despite the daily mail and its ilk claiming this is so common and people get paid money for drugs/alcohol..its not the case and hasn't been for a long time. You can however get help for disabilities caused by addictions. As you should be able to. Despite the addictions being 'self inflicted'

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:03

www.disabilitysecrets.com/resources/social-security-disability-coverage/benefits-chronic-alhoholism.htm

The Social Security Administration (SSA) cannot find you disabled based solely on your diagnosis of chronic alcoholism. However, many people who suffer from chronic alcoholism have physical or behavioral changes that limit their ability to function in a work situation and that are caused by their chronic use of alcohol. The SSA will not treat your claim any worse because your impairment is a result of chronic alcoholism.

However, if you are still drinking, and the SSA believes that if you stopped drinking your medical conditions would improve to the point where you would not be disabled, you won't get disability benefits.

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 17:00

The alcoholics or addicts you are talking about, probably were refused when they applied, but they appealed.

I refuse to believe that these make up a large number of PIP claim ants like you seem to be implying.

Yes, illnesses and self inflicted conditions are different. But both can require help and support.

ewen1234 · 29/10/2017 16:57

Please dont bombard me with hate posts but I still cannot get past the point of seeing that these two things are completely separate. There are those who are "self-inflicting" and those who are born with an affliction (albeit it may not come to light until later years!!).. What do you think an alcoholic, or a drug addict for that matter would spend PIP money on??? As for biscuits, cakes and cigarettes...totally different issue..

If there was only one more PIP payment to be made and the choice was to either give it to the alcoholic, (who would probably piss it up against a wall) or the poor drug addict (who would probably use it to shoot up somewhere) or a child with a serious illness (that they never asked for)...OK, the alcoholic or the drug addict got it!! What a fuckin uproar this would cause!!

I urge anyone to try and explain this to me in a way that I can understand the fairness of this because this is whats happening, the wrong people are being helped here and people who really also need it are not getting it because...??? why???

Again, please dont bother posting if it is to just give me a tongue-lashing. I genuinely dont get this and dont understand why so many people want to defend those who have mainly brought their own problems on....(Ill bet there are loads of people out there who think the way I do but probably just not able to say it!!!)

HornyTortoise · 29/10/2017 16:57

My son is 18 and was diagnosed with Crohns Disease ( a very serious form of Crohns) and he applied for PIP. He was told he would have to go for a Face to Face consultation and I went with him. He received a letter about 10 weeks later to say that he did not qualify, but if he wanted to, he could appeal. He has not done this..

Your son should have appealed. Many many people who are actually entitled are refused after their 'medical'. 60% I believe...over half, at least. Some sources say 90% of decisions are overturned.

Please reapply, then appeal.

DHs cousin gets pip at standard rate for chrons.

HadronCollider · 29/10/2017 16:52

But just because you've had those experiences and never turned to alcohol to assuage your pain professor doesn't mean another person can cope as well. I'm a CSA survivor too, and have never touched drugs etc, but I have met others who have resorted to more drastic ways of coping with traumatic experiences by cutting themselves, or attempting suicide, or being extremely risky or sexually promiscuous. Individual differences, socialisation and degrees of support, how much negative experiences are internalised, account a great deal for how people cope with grim experiences. I have been extremely depressed in the past as a result of mine. I have never reached my potential or achieved a great career for e.g. But there are others with similar or worse experiences who have achieved a great many things, even amazing world changing things, and could turn around and say 'your trauma is no excuse'. Anecdotal comparison is a bit moot in my opinion.

lazymum99 · 29/10/2017 16:37

Well woopy woo for you professorcat. No one forces the cakes and biscuits on the morbidly obese or Type II diabetes amputees. No one forces the cigarettes on some of the lung cancer/heart disease patients. Where are you going to draw the line.
If this country could provide drug and alcohol services which go beyond the simple detox phase and give further support for many months it would solve some of these issues. And stop imprisoning drug addicts instead of trying to get them better.
Anyway we digress......PIP/ESA seems to be a bit of a lottery at the moment but having experience of appeals for about the last 3/4 years I have rarely seen a tribunal decision that is not fair.

ProfessorCat · 29/10/2017 16:07

Sorry but you cannot compare druggies and alcoholics with cancer sufferers, MND etc.

There is ALWAYS a choice. No one forces anyone to inject poison into themselves or buy that vodka.

Traumatic experiences is just an excuse. I'm a CSA survivor, DA and have severe PTSD as a result of an extremely traumatic death. I have never turned to either.

ewen1234 · 29/10/2017 13:21

This is just one of these subjects Im afraid that can go on and on forever. Dont think/know if there are any right/wrong answers here but we are all entitled to our opinion.

I have mine and I dont expect everyone to agree with me at the end of the day the system still sucks!!