Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
SunnySkiesSleepsintheMorning · 01/11/2017 21:51

@ProfessorCat a blue badge application is not just sending off a form for many people. It is not an easy form for many people and some people are called for an assessment.

HadronCollider · 01/11/2017 20:39

Yes Ewen it is much harder to prove illnesses that aren't visible, which is a really HUGE flaw in the system. There's an article in the Guardian on this same issue right now, people with mental health problems being refused PIP because they don't 'look' ill.

I myself have Fibromyalgia and some days my feet hurt so much I literally cannot walk. I have missed loads of my uni course, and am considering dropping out. When it flares up the pain is simply crippling, I never have a night of uninterrupted sleep, I can barely eat because of the stomach pain and am shattered everyday, also experience really unsettling neuropathic sensations, today I have had a feeling of ants crawling across my face and my eyes on and off all bloody day. Yet I sincerely doubt I'll qualify for PIP, despite me spending a small fortune on Uber, needing to buy more books as I can't into to library to keep up, not being able to carry shopping bags, or stand (or even sit sometimes for that matter) for longer than 20 mins without my butt, ankles and legs burning and sometimes fingers so painful I need my sons to open jars or chop hard veg or lift heavy pots, that's if I'm not lying on the sofa. Even hoovering is challenging.

There are plenty of people in your son's position. It's a shit situation. Please try again and appeal. And yes, whilst I doubt it will help, dig out some leggings and scruffy trainersGrin

ewen1234 · 01/11/2017 20:03

Just read my last message back and realise it sounds terrible. !!...But it just goes to prove that people DO judge on appearances,..and I do think this happens...

I wish I could win hundreds of thousands of pounds on the Lotto and I would be only too happy to give to the people who really need it!!

ewen1234 · 01/11/2017 19:57

To be honest Babyroobs, when we went for our consultation, we (in my opinion) stuck out like a pair of sore thumbs!! I was dressed as I usually am, nice clothes, make up, hair done, lovely bag etc. My son was well turned out, clean and tidy (because we thought we had to make the effort).. The people sitting with us, hobbled in on crutches (couple I am referring to were laughing and joking and carrying on with one another before they went in because I saw them), looking as though they had just rolled out of their beds. My son actually said to me "mum, im not going to get this, because they are going to take one look at you and think "she looks like she can afford to keep him, we don't need to give them any money"...That was his thought.!!

What they don't realise is that I buy most of my clothes from charity shops but im a proud person and still like to make the best of myself. Just because I didn't have a bath and turn up in jeggings and a long t-shirt doesn't meant to say that my son didn't deserve any less!!!

XXX

Babyroobs · 01/11/2017 19:41

Vivienne. I agree with your post. I try to help people apply for PIP every day and it's frustrating. So many people think it is some kind of compensation for being ill, they don't realise that it is all about how your illness affects you on a daily basis. There is a lot of abuse of it but then genuinely ill people with a lot of problems get turned down. A lot just depends on the assessor on the day. The whole system is messed up.

ewen1234 · 01/11/2017 19:40

Lazymum99...."Addiction affects the brain"!! ...If they HAD a fucking brain in the first place, then they would know what to and what NOT to be addicted to....??

What an insult!!....

The brain is only "ill" if you decide to make it that way. Again this is a choice!!..Feed your body crap and your brain will eventually cave in as well..

My son had NO CHOICE but to give up his college education because the GP appointments, hospital appointments, time off to give blood, time off for "fusion treatment" (look it up if you are not familiar with the term), meant that he was so far behind in his course that he could not keep up with it and felt it was only fair to leave because he felt he was keeping the rest of his class back!!

He had a video link when he was in hospital and was able to see his tutor and his class mates on his laptop to take part in lessons but before the end of the lesson he was usually asleep because of his meds. He exhausted every avenue to try and keep his course going but in the end he gave up... Even as ill as he was, he was still considering someone else, he actually thought he was doing someone else out of a place in college when he was so ill he could not attend, so he gave up his course in the hope that in a while he could go back and do his course again. He lost his College Bursery Money and his EMA (Education Maintenance Allowance) but all because of his illness. His PIP money would have went towards what he would have needed to keep up with his education (he was studying to be a Bio-Chemist), be that books, private tuition to get him up to speed with the rest of his class, but certainly nothing recreational i.e. drugs or alcohol.

Cant anyone understand this??

Viviennemary · 01/11/2017 19:28

I do agree that it's how it affects the person. If a disease or complications from a disease makes a person unable to look after themselves and do basic household tasks then they should be eligible for PIP. The system has been abused and that's a fact. Which is why it's got so strict with so many chancers. They have ruined everything for the really deserving and genuine cases.

milliemolliemou · 01/11/2017 18:40

I would suggest if any of you have the time or energy you

contact SCOPE on freefone 0808 800 3333 for advice

complain to the Department of Work & Pensions - look for the how to complain bit down the page
www.gov.uk/government/organisations/department-for-work-pensions/about/complaints-procedure

email your MP.
www.parliament.uk/mps-lords-and-offices/mps/

and let them know briefly how you feel.

ProfessorCat · 01/11/2017 18:27

Sorry Mustang, I agree with you there. I've had a blue badge since my mid twenties and have had it ripped from my hand, thrown on the ground, been accused of stealing it, been screamed at over ten times etc. all by elderly people because I look "too young" to be disabled. It's really awful and has made me fear confrontation.

I have invisible illnesses but since I've started using a wheelchair, it doesn't happen as much. It's awful that we have to be afraid though.

brasty · 01/11/2017 18:13

PIP is assessed on how a condition affects someone, not on a diagnosis. Most conditions can vary widely in their impact.

dataandspot · 01/11/2017 17:52

Vivienne

Both my mother and one of my children has crohns. It affects them entirely differently.

Some people with crohns develop sepsis , have parts of their bowels removed, have colostomy bags.

You are very wrong to say PIP is not for people with crohns and your attitude makes it very hard for my child for whom crohns is a chronic condition.

Mustang27 · 01/11/2017 17:47

I’m very much aware of that professorcat. Sorry if that suggested I compared them. I’m just nervous of all the stigma attached to it all plus the horror stories of the pip assessments. I’m relatively young and invisible disabilities to a degree I have friends in similar situations that have actually been called out with their blue badges by random strangers.

ProfessorCat · 01/11/2017 17:04

A blue badge claim is just sending off a form for a blue badge.

A Pip claim is infinitely more difficult, harrowing, disheartening.

The two aren't comparable.

Mustang27 · 01/11/2017 13:10

@thenightsky you are kidding right? I just can’t even think how anyone would think that was a reasonable question.

I have me/fibromyalgia and absolutely have a pip claim but I won’t even do a blue badge claim as I just find the whole thing terrifying.

brasty · 01/11/2017 13:07

Yes lots of people with chronic illnesses get tired, but are ineligible for PIP.

Mustang27 · 01/11/2017 13:06

Pip assessments are the epitome of unfair, end of conversation. I’d keep pushing how can her claim be worth less now than it was before if there have been no changes. What a disgrace I’m sorry for you and your family. I hope this can be rectified.

Viviennemary · 01/11/2017 12:59

I know somebody with Crohns and they do get tired but it wouldn't occur to me they'd be on PIP. I think the general public and everyone needs to be educated on what PIP is actually for. It was my understanding that it was to help people to pay for care to do things they weren't able to do themselves like get washed and dressed or do basic housework if they simply couldn't on a day to day basis.

lazymum99 · 01/11/2017 12:17

I could be flamed for this but:
EWAN1234 unfortunately if your son can manage all the daily living descriptors 50% of the time then he won't qualify for PIP. Fluctuating illnesses are very difficult to claim for.
Stop dwelling on who else qualifies and concentrate your son's application. It is not affected by anyone else claims. You may be able to go for a late appeal if you were given the wrong information by the DWP which you were.
And LakieLady is absolutely correct. Addiction affects the brain in such a way that no amount of willpower will help them stop. Try thinking about refusing water when stuck in the dessert. Its the same part of the brain stopping them refusing drugs.

Jux · 01/11/2017 10:04

Hive, my dd’s too.

When I was a teen we were expected to soldier on regardless, but that was in the 60s/early 70s and the war still wasn’t that far behind.

Headofthehive55 · 01/11/2017 08:22

My DDs entire friendship group are now describing themselves as having hidden illnesses or mental health problems.

Headofthehive55 · 01/11/2017 08:19

I think there is a lot if issues with payments due to disability because so many of our population are considered disabled / less well. There isn't enough money to go round.

ProfessorCat · 01/11/2017 08:16

I completely agree with you Ewen. It's beyond.

ewen1234 · 01/11/2017 08:13

Cant be arsed reading all this shite anymore about how drug addicts didnt set out to be junkies and alcoholics didnt set out to be alcoholics. YES!!! THEY BROUGHT IT ON THEMSELVES!!!

Tell you what...I wont bother getting up every morning to go to work. Instead I'll just head of to the Off License first then go to the local dealer and buy a wee bag of whatever is going to send me into oblivion so I dont have to face reality. (And before any more fucking dogooders come on here with their support for the junkies and alckies of the world and all their suffering, I have suffered trauma and loss in my life too). If I continue to do this for a while, using my trauma and loss as an excuse, then maybe I will eventually be addicted too. And I can do this because this is a CHOICE I have made, this has been totally MY DECISION!!...Because it seems to me right now these "vulnerable" people are getting more help and support over people who DO DESERVE the help and are being passed over for every other fucking junkie and alkie who put THEMSELVES in this position.

I totally get that if someone has trauma or loss in their lives, yeah I can see that getting blitz out your head can take the hurt away for a while but it doesnt need to become a way of life, but then again why not, if it means the state throw money at you for fuck all...

I will NEVER understand this....NEVER!!!

A mother's natural instinct (and no matter what age your children are!!) is to care, look after, protect and do the best for her child/children and that is why I am angry that I know my son has probably been passed over for someone else who has brought their own shite to their own door.

Dont bother to reply to this, I dont really care if dont agree with me. This will be my last post on the matter..

HornyTortoise · 01/11/2017 03:42

I think we've crossed wires. I know it's easy to become an addict. I work in welfare rights. I meet people addicted to things everyday

I was agreeing with your post. Welfare rights have been a godsend to me and a few I know. Thanks for all the hard work I know you do. My award was decided before I even got to the tribunal centre apparently..as when I arrived before even seeing the panel I was told my award had been reinstated, and that I only had to go in for the panel to tell me in person, welfare rights had clearly been working behind the scenes. The only question I was actually asked by the panel, was if I had any further treatments in the pipeline as they said a 30 year old should not be spending her time alternating between painkiller hazes and excruciating pain and they hoped it got better for me soon. It hasn't, clearly. Still waiting for physio but have been told its unlikely to be sucessful..but theres a bit of hope

Jux · 31/10/2017 19:09

Ewen, I am honestly angry that your son hasn’t got PIP. Please do try again - don’t give the bastards what they want, fight them.

We should all be converging on our so-called represntatives screaming blue murder about this.

They want us to cower in our homes feeling helpless.

Swipe left for the next trending thread