Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 13:08

ewen1234 I can't speak for others but in my own view it's fine.

These things get very emotive. Flowers

That's the rub you see. They don't see what stress it causes, they just see you as a national insurance number.

ewen1234 · 04/11/2017 12:54

I have read back a lot of my posts on here and yes, I do put my hand up, they seem to come from a very angry person.. I am totally focused (and it is clear to see) on me and mine and maybe i should try casting my net a bit further and be a bit more understanding of other people.

I would like to apologise wholeheartedly to anyone I have offended or upset by my comments as this was not my intention.

I have directed my anger at the wrong people and not the actual source of the problem.

I hope you can forgive this...its almost as though this post has grown arms and legs and I have allowed myself to get caught up in it.. My own experiences are NOT everyone else's and I had no right to expect people to try to come round to my way of thinking.

Clearly I have my own issues and maybe this was not the right place to vent my anger.

I'm sorry!!

Flowerfae · 04/11/2017 12:06

Hi JonSnowsWife, no I didn't (husband can think for me, cheeky sods... its like there's been a time warp back to the 1950's) maybe it is because I'm married, I don't know how it would work if I were a single parent..

I really do think they are starting to ignore large chunks of problems people have, in order to refuse the claim. If someone has a diagnosis of something which causes them pain, over something as simple as a school run, they really should take that into account.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 11:48

Did you get yours flowerfae?

But you see therein lies the problem. Your DH can do it all for you.

Problems arise when there are plenty of single parents living with a disability. They have no choice but to adapt, to do what they minimally can. For example, a lot of the time, if a single parent does the school run = no mobility problems. It doesn't matter that that person is in pain before during and afterwards. They do it. So can 'manage' in the eyes of the assessor. Even though they clearly can't.

How many single parents are there in the UK? That's thousands knocked off the mobility component straight away, despite the fact not all single parents have a vast support network of friends and family and so have to do the school runs themselves.

Flowerfae · 04/11/2017 11:39

I think they are trying really hard not to give it to people. My son has DLA, he has autism, learning difficulties and epilepsy. He was on high rate care but without his needs changing whatsover he has been reduced to middle rate.

I applied (I didn't really expect to get it though just thought it was worth a try) because stress towards the end of a nursing degree caused chronic migraine which triggered off epilepsy (I had it as a child) I had to leave nursing during the final placement. The medication I am on affects my memory and concentration (well its a mixture of the epilepsy and medication really) I wouldn't cope if I lived alone with the children, DH has to be responsible for finances because I can't do it, on a bad day I can't cross a road because I've nearly been hit twice. I don't remember what people tell me and sometimes my speech completely goes and I just speak complete babble.

According to PIP, it doesn't matter that I have communication problems, mostly when I have nervous, I don't have to be able to concentrate, I don't have to be able to remember anything and I don't have to be responsible for everything.. basically I don't have to be able to think.. because my husband can do it all for me.

From what I have heard, PIP mostly refuse first time because they rely on the fact that most people will not appeal the decision, so appeal it. I'm not going to appeal because I didn't really expect to get it (its just their reply that annoyed me).

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 11:26

I actually think the philosophy behind PIP, that is how people manage usual daily activities (does not include housework unfortunately) is pretty good

PIP is about how your conditions affect your daily activities. If you can not do them safely, reliably and repeatedly. Their three key words. I'll have to do some digging but PIP used to say that walking through pain was an acceptable standard. There was a ruling that expecting someone to walk through pain is not an acceptable standard, and after that PIP conveniently changed their requirements again. The 20metres etc. 50metres etc.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 11:18

ewen1234 I know you didn't. Flowers

But the energies need to br focused on fighting THE system. Not pointing out how it is an unfair system as it favours some and discriminates others. Just fighting the system. They want us arguing amongst ourselves.

ewen1234 · 04/11/2017 11:08

Lot of people on here just twisting things!!

Sometimes in life, its your own personal experiences that form your opinions and bias and this cannot be helped.

You cannot force someone to feel/think a certain way when that person cannot help thinking how they do, and they ONLY think a certain way because of personal experience. (Vicious cycle).

I never came on here to insult or upset anyone. I thought this was a site where people could put across their thoughts, opinions and experiences.

No matter what has been written here, trying to constantly justify yourself is very tiring.

A lot of you obviously dont understand and never will!!....I was always told in order to back up anything you have to say, you should always use examples and if you look through all of my posts there have been plenty of examples.

It cant ALL be wrong....

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 09:55

you do not get PIP based on how you dress

That's not entirely true. How you dress is always taken in as a factor where mental health conditions are mentioned.

Take 10 reports and every single one would mention 'well kempt'.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 09:53

FuckItAndStartAgain sadly PIP is one of the worst things for people suffering with mental health problems.

Their MSEs would be out of place in the 60s never mind in 2017.

DJBaggySmalls · 04/11/2017 09:52

If person A gets benefits it does not affect person B.
You do not get PIP based on how you dress.
And you do not get PIP for things like housework or shopping. Its for personal care only.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 09:52

For those who haven't seen it yet. There was a big development this week re PIP.

Do keep your eyes out for such articles as they're normally just squirrelled away somewhere.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/thousands-disabled-people-higher-benefits-11455561#ICID=sharebar_facebook

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 09:45

ewen1234 and this right here is exactly why this shitshower of a government get away with what they are doing.

As I said previously I have little sympathy for them, BUT they are not the enemy here, they are just a convenient one for others to blame. I have been on a respiratory ward before as an in-patient, and been lectured about my weight (I'm a stone overweight so hardly morbidly obese level), at the same time, I was the only patient on a respiratory ward who didnt smoke. None of the smokers were lectured, they were all pandered too. So were the two alcoholics who ended up in the same ward, both declaring they were teetotal but damn those blasted CT scans showing up how fucked up their livers actually were. There was also a recovering heroin addict on the bay, I know because they kept informing the nurses they needed their methadone by x day so wanted to know when they were likely to be discharged. They were scared that not being able to access it would mean they'd relapse completely. The hospital kept telling them they don't stock it and it's something they'd have to discuss with their worker. Because we were both in for a while, they got talking and found out that this person had been through a monumentally shit childhood. I will always remember that patient, they were so kind to me, shared their fruit with me and made a very shitty and scary experience for me so much more bearable. I've often wondered how that person is getting on they left such a lasting impression on me. I doubt had it not been for that persons life experience they'd have turned out to be the kind compassionate person they were.

You need to direct your anger towards the right people. Lobby your MP. Put in official complaints to the health centre that did the assessments. Let your local papers know. Even if they're not interested it builds up a caseload and it's plenty of evidence for the press to come after them just like they did with the ATOS shambles.

VivienneMary I'm intrigued as to which benefit reforms you agree with. There was a news article recently about a lady who's been left housebound and unable to get yo her job because the government have taken away her mobility car. There was another recent one where a patient had to be taken to their appeal in an ambulance. These examples are all a product of these benefit 'reforms'. They're not reforms in any shape or form and the tories will go down in history for such cruelty.

ewen1234 · 04/11/2017 09:10

Yes well.....we are ALL entitled to our opinion and quite frankly I dont really care what you think of me...

Viviennemary · 03/11/2017 22:19

Yes Ewen you are out of order on this one. I agree with some of the benefit reforms. But to say drug addicts don't deserve benefits because they've brought it on themselves is ridiculous. If they have disabilities due to their drug addiction or alcohol addiction then they are meeting the criteria for the benefits. Addiction is a mental health problem and physical problem IMHO.

FuckitAndStartAgain · 03/11/2017 10:53

This has ruined a supportive thread. Shame.

ewen1234 · 03/11/2017 08:20

I think a lot of people judge and are arrogant/ignorant because they dont understand. But, I will never change my opinion on people doing things through their own choice.

I feel sorry for the lady with the addict parents, because (and Im sure I will no doubt get slated for this), but how selfish can some people be when even their CHILDREN are not enough for them to want to kick their habit!!!

I also have a brother who is in his forties. His wife was found behind the bathroom door two years ago, having died after taking an overdose of pills , leaving her young son motherless and heart broken!! She was a drug addict and my brother still is). My mother, who is nearly 70 now has sole care of their wee boy who has just started High School. His dad comes to visit him every Sunday and my brother seems to think that he should get a medal for going out of his way to come and visit his son....He has been offered all sorts of treatment but it is up to him to take that help, but he CHOOSES not to....Like a lot of drug addicts I know, he is selfish, constantly take, take, take and never gives back...Maybe thats why I feel so angry. I was brought up under the same roof (my brother is only 3 years younger than me). Had the same mum and dad, same holidays etc. Just like the rest of them, he CHOSE his way of life. There is ALWAYS a choice!!!....So, yes I am bitter about the fact that people like this seem to always get a leg up the ladder when ordinary people have to fight to get on the first wrung!!!

FuckitAndStartAgain · 02/11/2017 20:10

I claimed PIP and have been turned down. I am now appealing. I am GLAD if people with mental health disorders and/or addiction get it. I am sad our NHS can not always help them. Alcoholism is but a step away for many. My parents were both addicts, as was my younger brother. I am angry that people judge without real understanding. Self medication is the starting point for many. I am shocked that people are so ignorant.

I am obese (now, three and a half stone on in four months on starting pregabalin), my mobility problems are so much worse but it stops some of the pain but no doubt I would recover faster from surgery than I do now.

I actually think the philosophy behind PIP, that is how people manage usual daily activities (does not include housework unfortunately) is pretty good. Even if this means people who are not incapable enough despite having a tough time don’t get it. Many many people have a tough time and cope.

I am angry about the implementation. The assessment system is a joke and the cost to the country of appeals with full tribunals etc immense. The cost to the well being of the individual even greater. Oh and yes, I look pretty good a lot of the time. For various reasons washing dressing and make up are a priority. My Assessor used me being well kempt as proof I can wipe my own bottom!! No way am I turning up to the Tribunal in a long tee shirt and leggings, but that is just one of my coping mechanisms.

I am going to stop having wiped out huge amounts of writing about the judgmental intolerant ignorance of some people and media ☹️ If you think you, or a son, should be entitled to PIP then you appeal, open your eyes to the way the system is implemented.

www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/work-and-pensions-committee/pip-esa-assessments-forum-17-19/

sanddune11 · 02/11/2017 00:36

I agree, we all have our struggles, some have had really bad starts in life and just find life hard to get through. Somewhere along the way we seem to have lost our compassion. If we can't look after our sick and vulnerable then we're lost. I'm afraid it's only going to get worse. The tories will make sure of that.

HadronCollider · 02/11/2017 00:26

Thanks SunduneFlowers. My stance is that everyone is suffering to a greater or lesser degree, addicts included. Even those without disbilities or illnesses. Society is becoming increasingly disconnected? Cold? Not quite sure what the word is ......maybe apathetic is the ond I'm searching for (despite so many virtual connections ironically). It stands to reason that there will only be an increase in mental health problems and associated addictions.

If I had the choice I'd still take my condition over being an crack head or a heroin addict, alcoholic etc. Addictions take more than just your health, they take your reputation, your conscience, your friends, your family, your dignity, your self-respect and even your sanity. I don't begrudge them PIP. If people who should get help aren't getting it then the blame lies with the government, who are all too happy to give massive tax breaks to corporations and 'benefits' in the form of land subsidies to some of the wealthiest landowners in Britain to the tune of tens to hundreds of thousands a year, whilst reducing financial help to people in desperate need for daring to get ill, and then demonisin those that do receive help.

sanddune11 · 01/11/2017 22:31

Hadron that sounds horrendous, so sorry you have to go through that. Flowers

ewen1234 · 01/11/2017 22:30

Lazymum99...... Read back your previous message....???

ProfessorCat · 01/11/2017 22:13

Strange, Sunnyskies. I'm guessing it varies by Local Authority then. I found it an incredibly simple process and have renewed twice and it was just as easy.

PIP on the other hand...

lazymum99 · 01/11/2017 22:10

'If they HAD a fucking brain in the first place, then they would know what to and what NOT to be addicted to....??'

ewan1234 what on earth should they choose to be addicted to. This statement makes no sense and is extremely insulting to anyone who finds themselves with an addiction issue.

SunnySkiesSleepsintheMorning · 01/11/2017 21:56

I’d be interested to know how many people are awarded PIP for substance addiction and they don’t have any comorbid health problems.

I’ve succssfully helped people appeal PIP and ESA decisions and I’m going through the process for myself. It’s soul destroying but I don’t feel I have the right to judge those who do get PIP for other reasons. If we are going to judge addicts, I suppose we should judge people like me; I am slightly overweight which is hardly ideal for someone with a progressive mobility condition.