Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
expatinscotland · 27/10/2017 16:15

'What's UK PLC?'

It's what's going to go bankrupt after we dumped out of the EU in 2019 with no deals in place.

Gottagetmoving · 27/10/2017 16:05

Sorry I'm very slow at typing and cross-posted with you Gottagetmoving. You said it better smile

Ha!....I think you said it better! Grin

WhatWouldLeslieKnopeDo · 27/10/2017 15:59

Sorry I'm very slow at typing and cross-posted with you Gottagetmoving. You said it better :)

WhatWouldLeslieKnopeDo · 27/10/2017 15:58

Benefit fraud is a drop in the ocean compared to things like tax fraud. They're just an easy target, and it appeases the benefit-haters.

Personally I'd rather a few fraudulent claims got through than that anyone suffered or died because they couldn't get the money they desperately need, and had to go through such a degrading and humiliating process, potentially contributing to their health issues.

User843022 · 27/10/2017 15:49

'try to claim for things they really aren't entitled to, the government of the day will prefer to be too strict on assessments than be too lenient'

Yes I'm all for strict assessments but they must be accurate and the assessors have got to have some knowledge on what they are assessing. The bloke assessing my friend did not have a clue. His report confirms it, his terminology is so very simplistic and he's made glaring errors.

Gottagetmoving · 27/10/2017 15:46

It's a shit system, but as long as there are people who are willing to cheat the system and try to claim for things they really aren't entitled to, the government of the day will prefer to be too strict on assessments than be too lenient
Sorry, but that's rubbish. Tory governments don't like welfare.
There are thousands of wealthy people who evade and avoid tax but you don't find the government chasing hard or assessing them. There are only a handful of HMRC inspectors dealing with tax evasion by the rich, but hundreds of investigators targeting benefit fraud, which is a tiny percentage.
There are cheats in all walks of life.
There is no excuse targeting the sick and vulnerable and I would rather a small number of people got away with it rather than genuine cases being made to suffer the way they are.

DonnaMoss · 27/10/2017 15:43

We applied for high rate mobility DLA when my disabled daughter turned 3 on the advice of everyone involved in her care. We won it after going to tribunal but were turned down initially because "on the balance of probability she'll be able to walk in the near future." Oh right, because her leg muscles will just magically grown some tone will they? Guess what she's now 4 and she still can't walk.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 15:35

Blame the scroungers and the fraudsters

No. Ask anyone who is in this line of work. How many times the Work Capability Assessment has been 'revised/'renegotiated' for ESA, all since 2010. Look at how PIP was changed, and when. This hasn't stopped fraudsters from claiming. So far I know of two people (not friends, friends of friends) who have been granted PIP on the basis of a bad back, and another who deliberately didnt take their medication on the day of the assessment. On the other hand, you've got a PIP assessor writing an amputee 'walked across the car park back to their car' 🙈 (thankfully that one was chucked out in the end but the fact it was given any credence in the first place is bloody worrying) and someone with schizophrenia having to appeal for their ESA.

The current processes have very little to do with fraudsters and everything to do with the Welfare Reform Act.

User843022 · 27/10/2017 15:33

That's really helpful Jon thanks for that.

Minidoghugs · 27/10/2017 15:32

I don't blame it on scroungers I just think the disabled are an easy target for money saving.

Gottagetmoving · 27/10/2017 15:31

I can't understand why a report from your own doctor or consultant is not enough for this evil government.

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 15:28

Myrtle yes. That's why they lie through their teeth often often put things in which are discrepancies against the form, so they don't correlate.

That's why I always advise going tribunal. Because there the Tribunal can usually sort out the ones (assessors) who have blatantly tried their luck. There's plenty of cases where claimants have gone from 0 at the Decision Makers to Enhanced at Tribunal. Even if you are to fail at Tribunal, ask for a Statement of Reasons from the Judge. If it is clear there's been an Error of Law then you can apply to the Upper Tribunal.

ProfessorCat · 27/10/2017 15:28

The percentage of disability benefit fraud is incredibly low.

It's proving it that's the problem though - I have no doubt that there are thousands of people who don't need it.

The assessors are horrific.

User843022 · 27/10/2017 15:27

'Blame the scroungers and the fraudsters, not the system.'
Yes I do but in this case I really do blame the assessor too. If you ( you generally, not you personally) had a brain op that left you with deficits including loss of speech why on earth would he tick 'needs no assistance to engage socially' it just seems bizarre.

Viviennemary · 27/10/2017 15:21

I agree. It's the fraudsters and whiners than have ruined it for people who really need the extra money in their daily lives. Benefit fraud is rife. IMHO.

ProfessorCat · 27/10/2017 15:20

Keep going, get press involvement if you can. My zero points magically turned into 72 points when a journo was calling then for comments every day.

My first assessor said that because I could count backwards, my spinal injury didn't cause me any problems. Magic!

ChelleDawg2020 · 27/10/2017 15:17

It's a shit system, but as long as there are people who are willing to cheat the system and try to claim for things they really aren't entitled to, the government of the day will prefer to be too strict on assessments than be too lenient.

If every applicant was genuine, and I'm sure the OP's case is, there would be no need for such harsh assessment processes. Blame the scroungers and the fraudsters, not the system.

User843022 · 27/10/2017 15:13

'The case manager will look at it and see if the answers in the interview correlate with what was put in the original report'
Right, lets hope the case manager looks at the assessor's report for someone who now cant speak which is profoundly distressing and realises that clearly does mean she requires support to engage socially.

She wants me to be an advocate at tribunal for her which I'm happy to do I just worry I'm not qualified for it. I have an extensive medical background but do have my own illness which while challenging is nothing like what she copes with. There aren't any local CAB.

If anyone's been through it and can advise please do. I know we have the evidence to support her claim and she clearly fulfils the criteria on some points.

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 27/10/2017 14:56

Definitely do it, my mums in a wheelchair and she got told she could walk more than 50 metres 8 months later and we finally won at tribunal recently

kingsleysbootlicker · 27/10/2017 14:55

Here's an article on the investigation

www.disabilitynewsservice.com/mps-inquiry-set-to-look-at-pip-assessment-dishonesty-claims/

kingsleysbootlicker · 27/10/2017 14:50

There's a Parliamentary investigation into the claims of lies being told by assessors during people’s assessments... people have until November 10th to submit their experience of it. Please consider doing this if you can

www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/commons-select/work-and-pensions-committee/inquiries/parliament-2017/pip-esa-assessments-17-19/commons-written-submission-form/

www.parliament.uk/documents/commons-committees/work-and-pensions/Easy-read-Call-for-written-submissions-PIP-ESA-Assessments-High-Res.pdf

Beeziekn33ze · 27/10/2017 14:43

This thread just makes me depressed and angry. How did our country descend to this level?
My neighbour's spine has gradually deteriorated for years. At one point he was decreed fit for work, he would have been pleased to be able to work. His doctor was shocked and assured him that he was not fit for work and never again would be.

Bombardier25966 · 27/10/2017 14:43

@MrsWrex, the Communicating descriptor is not intended to score points for people with autism, mental health problems and other related disabilities. It is more aimed at those with hearing impairment and learning difficulties. Your wife should have been given points under the Engaging with Other People section. There's quite an overlap between them, and occasionally points can be scored under both, but they were designed that (unless you had more than one condition) you would fall under one or the other.

I can explain more if it would be helpful. Your appeal must very clearly address the descriptors though, not what you think they should be.

I hate the system, it's degrading and causes endless harm. I would strongly suggest that if you're not entirely sure what you're doing on application or appeal then seek advice from CAB or a relevant charity. As well meaning as every post on here is, some are inaccurate and that could leave you in a mess.

(Someone asked earlier if there was a time limit for appeals - yes, there is. You must request a mandatory reconsideration within one month of the decision being made, and an appeal within one month of the MR outcome. These limits are only waived in exceptional circumstances.)

JonSnowsWife · 27/10/2017 14:34

What's UK PLC?

sunandmoonshine · 27/10/2017 14:31

@AhhhhThatsBass

I wonder if every person who considers themselves to have a disability, be it mental or physical, claimed (and received) disability benefit, what proportion of the country it would be and how quickly UK PLC would go into receivership?

Hmm

Real vile, disablist comments. That's what this thread was missing! Thanks for that! Hmm