Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t fair, this is fucking evil.

317 replies

MrsWrex · 27/10/2017 08:59

My wife has had her pip reassessment reduced because of one point.

Her condition hasn’t changed one bit, we have letters from various professionals stating this. Some assessor that knows jack about her condition has stated she has no problems with communication at all because she ‘sounded intelligent’ (yes, that is written in the reply letter, apparently you can’t have autism if you sound intelligent)

You can’t even get a diagnosis of autism without some glaring problems with communication.

Sorry, just needed to vent. Can’t do it at home as dw is stressed enough as it is. I’ve been trying to get her to stop adding up how much this is going to affect us. Dd has been diagnosed with autism too, I just feel terrified for them both in the future.

I’ve called up for a mandatory reconsideration, I am fairly certain we’ve got enough evidence to win a tribunal. This system just seems to be designed to stress us as much as possible, it’s wrong.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Babyroobs · 04/11/2022 20:20

asdfgasdfg · 04/11/2022 05:13

The person I was helping scored 0 in the "able to budget section". She's been bankrupt TWICE running up credit card debts!!!

But does she have a condition that makes budgeting difficult or an illness like bi-polar where she can go on manic spending sprees? Otherwise anyone can run up credit card debts ?

asdfgasdfg · 04/11/2022 05:13

The person I was helping scored 0 in the "able to budget section". She's been bankrupt TWICE running up credit card debts!!!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 03/11/2022 13:19

wineDrinkingMama · 22/10/2022 09:04

I think of all the morality in the world, there's evil.
This is what I think, the problem's a medical problem and I don't think it ever goes away because doctors don't have a cure, curing you will send them out of business, they want you to spend a lifetime being sick, you're powerless against doctors.

I think you've had too much wine

janj2301 · 03/11/2022 10:42

the 10th November deadline was 2017

BlankTimes · 02/11/2022 12:06

.......................Once More...........................

z
o
m
b
i
e

t
h
r
e
a
d

feelthebeatfromthetangerine · 02/11/2022 10:25

I don't understand why PIP assessments aren't effectively made by the individual's health team. I do understand the need for standard questions, but the answers should be assessed by a medical professional who understands the condition and the person and has the discretion to weight some of the answers if appropriate.

It should just be a simple admin case then of processing the forms. Rather than pay 'assesors' to not assess properly, why not pay a fee to someone who actually gets it?

I wouldn't expect a layperson, no matter how competent they are, to be able to assess someone's health in the same way as someone who actually went to med school.

SerendipityJane · 02/11/2022 07:48

Ajl you need to know is there's no online application process. You have to complete a written form.

LaGioconda · 02/11/2022 07:37

wineDrinkingMama · 22/10/2022 09:04

I think of all the morality in the world, there's evil.
This is what I think, the problem's a medical problem and I don't think it ever goes away because doctors don't have a cure, curing you will send them out of business, they want you to spend a lifetime being sick, you're powerless against doctors.

Were you making your name true when you posted?

If only medical science had reached the point where doctors could cure everything but chose not to in order to stay in business. Sadly we're a long, long way off.

janj2301 · 02/11/2022 07:19

It took us 2 years to get PIP for my daughter, the assessors blatantly lied. My husband insists now on all assessments being recorded then pays £60 to a company to transcribe them. We are of the opinion that ATOS or what ever name they are going by now are on a bonus to FAIL claimants.

Nymeria6 · 02/11/2022 06:10

Do you still get pip whilst appealing etc

BlankTimes · 02/11/2022 04:03

Zombie Thread

wineDrinkingMama · 22/10/2022 09:04

I think of all the morality in the world, there's evil.
This is what I think, the problem's a medical problem and I don't think it ever goes away because doctors don't have a cure, curing you will send them out of business, they want you to spend a lifetime being sick, you're powerless against doctors.

JonSnowsWife · 09/11/2017 20:15

You know what inwas saying about the possibility of the DWP being fined/ charged for every case it loses. (I think they should go further smd charge the assessment company too given their 'assessments bear that much weight'. Look what happened earlier.

www.buzzfeed.com/emilydugan/most-dwp-benefits-cases-which-reach-court-are-based-on-bad?utm_term=.qsXnjrn2m#.dqMDo3D2e

FuckitAndStartAgain · 05/11/2017 14:00

Ewan. Oh bother I can’t remember how to link an individual. Brave post, lovely post. Have a hug. Xx

I am going to catch up properly when I get time later.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 18:12

When I had my last assessment the lady who did it was at pains to let me know that its not actually her who makes the decision. Its apparently the decision maker at the DWP, not the HCP. So someone with no medical background at all. I did end up getting support group, which I was quite shocked by mind. Was sure that would be a further tribunal

Ah that's for ESA though HornyTortoise. I've found that ESA seems to be coming a lot more balanced since Maximus took over most of the tender. Although that shit ahout 'claimant not rocking so clearly no mental health problems' seriously needs burning scrapping from both ESA and PIP.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 18:09

The evidence was not a problem, as I do have a genuine health complaint for which I am under a variety of specialists and on very strong meds.

To be fair. Most people have a genuine health complaint but it's how those health complaints affect you. I.e arthritis and struggle around the house. DA says you're fine. Then provide evidence of it at MR. I.e OTs report of adaptations you needed around the house.

HornyTortoise · 04/11/2017 18:09

Oh I know that the assessments are pretty much all the DWP go on most of the time. What I find odd though, is that the assessment alone would be enough to grant an enhanced award with no other 'proof'.

Meaning, I can well believe that the assessments are enough to deny claims even when other evidence is presented. But it seems pretty odd (especially for the DWP) for this to work the other way around.

When I had my last assessment the lady who did it was at pains to let me know that its not actually her who makes the decision. Its apparently the decision maker at the DWP, not the HCP. So someone with no medical background at all. I did end up getting support group, which I was quite shocked by mind. Was sure that would be a further tribunal

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 17:59

find this quite extraordinary though, that people can simply act on the day of the assessment

I know the DWP say otherwise and I'm being very careful here as you'd be surprised to find certain organisations can be rather litigious. But the assessments do carry quite a bit a little weight in what ever decision the decision makers come to.

Some assessors are just and fair, some of them are simply in it for the money, the wages alone are enough of an incentive to try and whistle down a few claimants who can be said to 'not really need it'.

Witsender · 04/11/2017 17:47

Tbh, if you go down the route of awarding benefits dependent on whether problems are self inflicted, then you have a whole other kettle of fish. What about those who drive too fast and crash resulting in disability? Poorly managed diabetes? Smoking related illnesses? Obesity related illnesses? Etc etc.

HornyTortoise · 04/11/2017 17:44

Fraudwise too...it seems an unpopular view but I have always been of the opinion that I would rather the people claiming fraudulently were able to claim fraudulently, than have them 'weeded out' but taking with them people who should have the award. If a way existed to get rid of fraud whilst allowing those who need it to keep it, that would obviously be preferable. But that can't happen in reality.

HornyTortoise · 04/11/2017 17:42

They're meant to 'catch' these ones out but in reality it really rarely does.

The ones swinging the lead know how to swing the lead. In any system there will be an element of fraud. I find this quite extraordinary though, that people can simply act on the day of the assessment. As my experience of PIP is that everything I said had to be backed up. So unless someone is also fooling their own doctors too, I don't see how they could be awarded it? Unless I have simply been unlucky with the amount of evidence I was expected to provide of course. The evidence was not a problem, as I do have a genuine health complaint for which I am under a variety of specialists and on very strong meds...

The PIP system is pretty flawed from the offset, with so much weight being given to the assessment day. Especially with conditions such as my own which fluctuate to a ridiculous degree. One day I could run a marathon (though would suffer badly for a coming days) where others I cannot move at all. This obvious flaw is before even taking into account that assessors are rewarded for denying benefits, or that any 'targets' can exist...its similar to sanctions. Sanction targets make NO sense, given sanctions are only meant to be given if someone does something 'wrong'.

Its all just fucked up. The lot of it.

JonSnowsWife · 04/11/2017 17:12

that you can get PIP just for saying you have a bad back

Only I know of someone who actually did manage to get PIP just by saying that (friend of a friend). They simply acted and did all the 'right' things on the day of the assessment and got enhanced on both (I mentioned this upthread).

But that in a way is part of the problem with PIP. They're meant to 'catch' these ones out but in reality it really rarely does.

HornyTortoise · 04/11/2017 15:19

ewen1234 Flowers

What a terrible post that was. Need to start previewing before sending

HornyTortoise · 04/11/2017 15:18

ewen1234 [flower]

Its easy to get carried away, especially when in a bad situation yourself. The problem is, so many people do this and direct anger at the wrong people, and the government get away with it again.

If for example, people get wound up about alcoholics getting PIP, then the next thing will be announcements to PIP that will 'stop' alcoholics getting it, followed by support from the public and a shitload of stories in the daily mail. And what will actually happen is that less people qualify overall. Not 'just' the alcoholics. So even mroe ill people are stripped of what they are entitled to...and with widespread support as the public believe its the 'right' thing. Kind of like how at the moment, so many think there are a bunch of fraudulent disability claims, or that you can get PIP just for saying you have a bad back

HornyTortoise · 04/11/2017 15:12

If person A gets benefits it does not affect person B.

Well yes, I don;t see why some feel the need to insist this is the case when its clearly not. There are something like 10bn worth of benefit claims that go unclaimed every year. So surely, using the logic that some seem to have on this matter, that would mean that everyone else who IS claiming their benefits would get a large raise? Of course it doesn't mean that, and why some insist that these things are true is beyond me.