Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want my 20 year old son to grow up and leave home

85 replies

Ilovecrisps22 · 18/10/2017 11:14

My oldest DS is 20, but acts like he’s 14. My 12 year old acts older than him.

He has always been lazy, he never bothered with school (he went, but only did what he needed to do), he doesn’t care about how he looks, spends all his money on shite (thankfully not alcohol or drugs, but computer games, crisps, sweets, fizzy pop, biscuits etc) and generally just acts extremely immature.

He is at college, his dad and I personally think he is kidding himself on with college, it’s to be a personal trainer, but he doesn’t eat properly or train, doesn’t study, so we can’t see this going anyway. Of course we don’t tell him this, and we try to encourage him as much as possible, and try to get him to show us his college work and tell us what he’s doing but he doesn’t tell/show us, and just tells us he is passing his test!

His room is disgusting and I mean disgusting. Whenever he opens his bedroom door, the smell that comes from it is terrible and even my younger children complain about it. He leaves clean clothes which I’ve washed and ironed on the floor in a pile, mixed with dirty clothes. He takes food upstairs and it gets left uneaten for days, so the plates are encrusted with food, he never uses a bin so the rubbish is scattered all over the floor.
He shares a bathroom with his younger brother but he never takes his turn to clean it, smelly towels left all over the floor, his empty shampoo/soap bottles cluttering up the shower.

He has eczema and has to get special cleaning products from the doctor, but he hasn’t been back to see the doctor in months, and the products have run out.

He constantly argues with us.

Now this is something he has always done, and it doesn’t matter what we do/say to him it doesn’t make any difference. I have tried helping him clean the room, to show how lovely it can be when it’s nice, it doesn’t matter, I have tried not cleaning his clothes, he just wears dirty clothes and will take his dads socks/underwear and wear that. We have tried speaking to him in a calm manner (I have been in tears in front of him), it doesn’t work, I have screamed and shouted at him, it doesn’t matter, nothing works.

He has a girlfriend (which we are really pleased about) we thought this would make him buck up his ideas, it it didn’t. Again we spoke to him about this, and all he said was “girlfriends room is like that too”.
He has started to stay at his girlfriends parents house and whenever he is away, the calm that descends on the house is fabulous, and TBH I actually dread when he returns home.

He works with an agency so it works round about his college hours, but he wants to do minimum hours as possible so he can spend it with his girlfriend. I’ve tried to tell him he can’t do this as his student loan won’t cover everything and that he needs to work to help boost his funds. He never has any money as he spends it all, so therefore he needs to ask me, and if I say I’m not giving you any money he just says, well I just won’t bother going to college or work. He also threatens not to babysit his younger siblings if I don’t give him money (we don’t have any other family that we could ask to babysit).

AIBU I’m feeling like this, can anyone give me any ideas as to how I can make his see what he is like. My other 2 children are not like this, they are the complete opposite.

OP posts:
millifiori · 18/10/2017 11:32

With tough love stuff like this, (not been in this position but in other ones) I always make it very clear to DC why I'm apparently being mean. That it's because I love them and want them to make the connection between effort and outcome, and that I dislike doing it this way but the more reasonable ways aren;t working.

If you do that, you defuse him turning you into a cold-hearted monster who has thrown him out. he gets to see that he's throwing himself out because he can't be arsed to clean his room.

Ilovecrisps22 · 18/10/2017 11:31

Thanks everyone for your replies.

He isn’t asked to babysit often, probably twice a month. I compare him to my other children because they act older than him, they put away their clothes, they clean their rooms, the bring down their washing, they even rinse their dinner plates.

AND, I’ve done the contract thing before, didn’t work.

I think I’m really going to have to just give him his marching orders.

OP posts:
millifiori · 18/10/2017 11:29

That sounds incredibly difficult. He seems to have backed you into a corner by not caring about any outcomes.
First, stop giving him any money at all. If he refuses to babysit, explain that babysitting twice a week is how he pays his way, living at home. And if he actually leaves the house when you're due to go out, just cancel your plans but bolt the door. If he refuses to go to college, tell him that's his choice. That's his successful future he's impacting on, not yours. It sounds as though he seems to think he;s doing you a favour by going to college or borrowing money from you. He needs to get into a state where he is uncomfortable.

Have you also treated him like an adult, sat him down on a good day, when you're all getting along, and gone through bank statements so he sees how much mortgage/rent, utilities and food cost. That he needs to plan his life a bit if he doesn't want to end up the sad kid who lives with his mum in his old childhood bedroom and has no money and no life.

Finally, is it possible that he has mild depression. Living in squalor, having no desire to go to college and achieve your dreams, those can be indicators. If he has, you might need to support him for a while until he can get his energy and focus back. But he still needs a plan of action to get back on track.

AnneLovesGilbert · 18/10/2017 11:28

x post on rent. The younger DC will still be able to see him when he's moved out. If you don't give him his marching orders now, when will you? I know it seems impossible to see another way, but you'll all be happier when he's living somewhere else and you can enjoy him for visits rather than enduring him as an inconsiderate resident who doesn't pull his weight and lives in filth.

bridgetreilly · 18/10/2017 11:27

Okay, so he pays rent. That's a start.

Draw up a contract that specifies exactly what you expect from him as a tenant and member of the household. It could include a certain amount of babysitting, as well as basic standards of cleanliness in his room and so on. Explain that this time you are serious and if he is not going to meet these standards, you will box up his things and put him out. He's 20. He's an adult. He needs to grow up.

AnnabelleLecter · 18/10/2017 11:26

Stop doing his washing and ironing. Let him make his own meals. Ignore his room.
Don't let him blackmail you over money. Say fair enough don't go to college. Your choice.
OTOH he shouldn't be expected to babysit. Your other DC are younger- not helpful to compare.

AnneLovesGilbert · 18/10/2017 11:25

He sounds like a nightmare.

Don't give him any money, pay a proper sitter (you're paying him anyway) if you want to go out and don't have any sort of arrangement with him.

Who cares if he's wearing dirty clothes? It's disgusting but he's an adult and it's no reflection on you. Stop doing anything for him. He might be at college but he's got a job and should be paying rent. If you don't tackle his behaviour your other children, though lovely now, will expect the same when they're 20 and want to use your home as a doss house. Or the resentment of what he's allowed to get away with while drive them away.

He's living in your home, he has to uphold basic standards of decency which includes keeping his room clean and tidy.

It's ultimatum time. Give him 2 months to get his shit together, to sort out his room, to start being a proper member of your family. He has an income, if he wants to live in a pig sty he can go rent a room somewhere.

You have a right to a pleasant peaceful home, your younger DC deserve to live somewhere clean, tidy and not plagued by a selfish adult who causes arguments through his appalling disdain for your home and upsets you and DH.

bridgetreilly · 18/10/2017 11:24

Call his bluff and stop giving him money at all. If he's studying and working, he should be able to support himself and pay you rent. Put him on notice that if he doesn't start doing that, he will need to move out and set a date when this will happen. He's 20 years old, he needs to start taking responsibility for himself, and he needs tough love from you to make that happen.

Ilovecrisps22 · 18/10/2017 11:23

dinosaursandtea. I have threatened him before that I would put him out the house, but he doesn’t bother. Whenever I’ve done that, my younger 2 get upset. He does pay rent, but we put this by for him as we don’t actually need the money (he doesn’t know we put the money by for him).

OP posts:
dinosaursandtea · 18/10/2017 11:17

Give him his marching orders. Tell him to leave - maybe that will buck his ideas up. Does he pay rent?