Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not contribute to a private school's fundraising group

39 replies

Mcakes · 15/09/2017 12:19

My nephew goes to a small private school which regularly has fundraising activities (cake sales, fetes, barbecues etc) all coordinated voluntarily by a small group of parents. Other parents are expected to contribute (bake cakes, run stalls etc).
I had assumed all money raised was going to charity but apparently it all goes into a fund to 'enrich the children's education'. In the past, the fund has paid towards a new minibus and replacement windows on the school building.
Am I unreasonable to thing that these are normal running expenses that should already be covered by the school fees???
Flummoxed why the parents would willingly give their time and money to help a private education business that they already pay ££££ to.
I live nearby and sometimes pick DN up from school so am occasionally asked to contribute, which makes me uncomfortable. DN's parents can't see anything amiss. Is it just me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnaïsM · 09/07/2022 15:27

FenceSitter01 · 17/09/2017 15:34

Did you post this before?

Having worked in a private school , about a third were on FSM. They were scholarship pupils. The money for the disadvantaged has to come from somewhere.

This was one of the things that pushed us to choose a state school, the idea that our £20,000 per year per child was not all going to fund their education, a significant amount was going to pay for other children whose parents were still well off but not well enough off to afford the fees.

I’ve no problem with my taxes funding education, but the school asking us to also cover the fees of other people’s children felt very different.

Ticktockwoof · 09/07/2022 14:45

Wow this is an old post, but the schools fees pay the teachers salaries, building upkeep, support staff, utilities, books, resources, stationary… unless it’s a massive and rich school like Eton, there isn’t a huge pot of spare money to buy minibuses and big play equipment.

stealthninjamum · 09/07/2022 12:54

My school raises money for loads of charities and the PTA and at first I was a bit surprised to be fundraising for a private school. But actually the PTA organise quite a lot - coffee mornings, second hand uniform shop, second hand book sales, picnics, summer fete, movie nights for the kids, discos - and do seem to do a lot to promote a community feeling in the school. Some of the money goes towards bursaries for children from lower income families and the rest, as far as I know, has been spent on equipment for clubs, minibuses, a sensory play area. The PTA have also paid for a dozen Ukrainian students’ uniforms and entrance to events when a lot of the local state schools couldn’t offer places and I think it’s great that my daughter’s class have really welcomed their new Ukrainian friend.

karmakameleon · 09/07/2022 12:52

I agree with you OP. At our school bake sales and other smaller events raise money for charities chosen by the children, and the PTA does larger events which mostly contribute to the bursary fund. But every now and then, the PTA will fund something like playground equipment, which I think is just part of the normal running costs and the school should pay. Our school is a business rather than a charity but don’t think that makes a difference.

Timus · 09/07/2022 12:44

I'm with the OP here. I think Ragusa has it spot on- you only need to look at the profit they are making. For example GDST is run as a charity. It made £260mn in annual profit in 2016-17. Where is that money going? Why is that not being used to fund the activities that the PTA is raising for?

5rivers7hills · 17/09/2017 17:26

The idea that a third of pupils at independent schools are FSM eligible is absolutely laughable. Maybe at a few

Maybe christs hospital? But that is pretty unique.

Bursaries aren't funded via bake sales - funded through old endowments and land usually!

Ragusa · 17/09/2017 16:47

And before I contributed a single penny to an indy school fundraising venture I would want to know that the school was not turning a profit. Even then I would find it very hard to stomach.

Ragusa · 17/09/2017 16:44

The idea that a third of pupils at independent schools are FSM eligible is absolutely laughable. Maybe at a few. Only around half of indy schools have charitable status. The rest do not.

brasty · 17/09/2017 16:35

I think it depends where you live in London. In knightsbridge, 52% of children attend private school. In Enfield, 3% do.

londondatastore-upload.s3.amazonaws.com/images/Independent-schools.bmp

Nationally only 7% of children attend private school. Lets not pretend that poor pupils have equal access.

FenceSitter01 · 17/09/2017 16:03

Brasty I suppose it depends on the area. Private schools are ten a penny in London and poverty is but a post code away. There is also a high West African Christian immigrant demographic who place a high value on education. They are the ones working three jobs to pay for music and language lessons to access scholarships.

brasty · 17/09/2017 15:52

Of course they are businesses.

timshortfforthalia · 17/09/2017 15:45

The schools which fund lots of scholarships and bursaries don't do it through pta coffee mornings Hmm mostly it's through rents on land and property they own. The smaller schools which don't have extra income like this do really struggle. But no, they're not businesses, the model is almost always that they're run as charities and as such are not looking to make profit.

SparklyUnicornPoo · 17/09/2017 15:40

I agree, I work in a state school, DD's at private, her PTA ask for approximately three times as much each term as ours do (and my school's PTA is very active). I don't mind contributing a bit but I am starting to wonder where the fees actually go.

brasty · 17/09/2017 15:38

That is incredibly rare to have a third on FSM. I know the number of children on FSM in private sector as a while is incredibly small.

FenceSitter01 · 17/09/2017 15:34

Did you post this before?

Having worked in a private school , about a third were on FSM. They were scholarship pupils. The money for the disadvantaged has to come from somewhere.

brasty · 17/09/2017 15:32

Totally agree. Why should you subsidise a business. And if it isn't making money, then like all businesses, it needs to close. Ridiculous.

SingingMySong · 17/09/2017 15:30

If you were paying said fees you might be happy to help with bits and pieces to allow them to keep fees down.

You don't need to contribute to the fund though.

Pandoraphile · 17/09/2017 15:21

The fundraising gives money for things like climbing frames, common room stuff, showjumps, new piano, etc. It's for things to benefit the pupils that aren't academic. I think it's great and the fundraising events are always fun! Think balls, BBQs, quiz nights, etc.

BUT - elder dd private school sent an email out recently asking straight out for money. Just donations. There was also the suggestion that provision could be made for the school in your WILL. I was Shock at that. This is a £10,000/term school!!

BeALert · 17/09/2017 14:47

More worthy causes than not upheaving a child out of their school and away from their friends after the death of a parent?

DH was one of these children. When his parent died they lost their income and house, had to move country, and his other parent was crippled with grief. Being able to stay at his boarding school was pretty much the only thing that kept him going in an appalling time.

PinkHeart5913 · 17/09/2017 14:25

Why don't you see a minibus or fixing windows on the school building as a good cause? Surely it's obviously the fees won't cover every single little thing which is why the parents give the time they can to cake sales and so on.

Fair enough if you don't want to donate but yabu to think they shouldn't fund raise and it's all paid for with the fees

Whatamesshaslunch · 17/09/2017 14:16

More worthy causes than not upheaving a child out of their school and away from their friends after the death of a parent? I'm sure there are plenty but this seems pretty high up there.

rookiemere · 17/09/2017 14:02

YANBU.

DS goes to a private school and the pta fund raising goes to the family foundation which pays for children to stay at the school if a parent dies or loses their job. In the first circumstance then fine I suppose, but no one has ever been able to give me any clear criteria on how its awarded and for how long. Also if they don't get the funding then the local schools are pretty good so its not like it would be the worst thing in the world.

I therefore prefer not to raise money for it, although i will help out at the fair as DS enjoys going. There are lots of more worthy causes so YANBU.

Mcakes · 17/09/2017 13:32

Really interesting answers with perspectives I hadn't thought of - thanks all!
It is v small school and, having read some of these replies, I wouldn't be surprised if it is not running a profit so the fundraising makes a bit more sense now. Still prefer to give my money to more needy causes but at least I don't feel as indignant at being asked now 😁

OP posts:
Belindaboom · 15/09/2017 14:24

Most likely the school is a registered charity.

OlennasWimple · 15/09/2017 14:21

I'd rather that fundraising activities were held so that those who want to contribute can, as opposed to raising school fees so that everyone has to pay more.

Many fundraising events are also fun activities that help cement a sense of school community

Swipe left for the next trending thread