Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to disagree with DH over DCh sharing room on holiday?

64 replies

tearinghairout · 03/04/2007 20:34

We have twins, a DS and a DD. They are 13. They have their own rooms at home, but when booking a holiday flat, DH said they ought to have their own rooms, which means a 3-bed which can take six ppl, rather than a 2-bed for four. It will cost about £130 more, which would pay for carhire, & I resent that.

They always share at ILs, no prob, but DH thinks they're getting 'to old'. He said this in front of them and of course they agree, but otherwise it wouldn't have occurred to them. What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PickledSmeg · 09/08/2022 12:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WideWebWitch · 05/04/2007 10:54

Pay the extra. Have only read OP though.

fennel · 05/04/2007 10:51

I do agree with everyone who says yes they should just have to share. Apart from my own personal experience with my brother, in which case it would have been totally unreasonable to expect us to share and I'm very glad my parents saw it as unacceptable

ghosty · 05/04/2007 10:51

One year the 6 of us + my eldest brother's girlfriend went on holiday together. To a 2 bedroomed place in Spain.
Mum and Dad had a room. Sis, me and younger of my brothers had a room. Older brother and his bird had sofa bed in living room.
One bathroom.
3 weeks.

Best holiday EVER! We were 21, 20, 18 and 16 at the time. I was the 16 year old.

ghosty · 05/04/2007 10:48

Blimey, I am one of 4 and we would never have had a family holiday if we moaned about sharing. Aren't holidays all about 'mucking in together'?

fennel · 05/04/2007 10:42

I have to say at 13 I would have totally and utterly loathed sharing a room with my very smelly brother. It's the sort of thing which would have been memorable about the holiday.

I knew one family where the mother and daughter shared a room, and the father and son.

What about the possibility of someone sleeping in the living room?

yomellamoHelly · 05/04/2007 10:40

Would appproch it another way tbh and find various flats of different sizes and make a decision based on which one you all like best.
Certainlt when booking accommodation the last 3 years we've been really limited asto what is still avail;ablr 6 months in advance and not all the points on our wishlist have been ticked.

ernest · 05/04/2007 10:38

we're going away tomorrow and all 5 of us will be staying in a family room (for 4, omg, must be crazy)

I think it's madness to pay an extra £130 for a bedrrom each. bloody hell, it's only the room they have to share, not the bed, right? And like you said, they're going to be up together in the evenings, only actually sleeping in the room, it's NOT the same as having your own bedroom at home, where you might disappear off to for privacy, with mates etc.

Don't do it!

And next time get dopey dh to air these fab ideas NOT in front of the kids!

If you have to give them the choice, then phrase it so they choose, eg if you share, we'll be able to hire a car and do x, y, z, if you have your own room we'll be stranded in appartment/hotel the whole time and only be able to eat sawdust. or somehting like that

BabiesEverywhere · 05/04/2007 10:28

Of course they can share.

On our family holidays there was three kids and two parents sharing either a tent or caravan and I only remember being happy that we were having a holiday,as it was touch and go a couple of years as to if we were having one at all.

At the last family holiday I was 15 my sister 13 and my brother 10 and we shared a double bed with a single bunk bed above between us three, my parents had a double maybe 2 foot away from our beds and the bathroom was a walk away in the toilet block...we managed fine.

twentypence · 05/04/2007 01:41

Colditz - you can't sleep in a bathroom but you can change a tampon or have a wank in one.

BassMama · 05/04/2007 00:05

Whenever we went on family holidays, which was usually 4 or 5 times a year (rich parents..) I would pretty much always share with my brother. Even though they could have easily afforded two rooms, it was more fun for us to share. We liked it. It felt like we were on 'our' own holiday. We could come and go as we pleased.
And, as we had our own bedrooms at home from birth, it was a novelty.

We did this until I was 15, as I stopped going on family holidays since I was old enough to be left at home alone. My brother went on all the holidays for the next 2 years with my parents and not me and said he didnt enjoy the holidays as I wasn't there

Me and my brother are really close, very good friends, and I think that sharing on holiday definitely helped that.

Sometimes, when we were little, we used to 'stay the night' in each others bedrooms now and again and pretend we were on holiday!

colditz · 04/04/2007 23:47

You can't sleep in a bathroom.

twentypence · 04/04/2007 23:44

There are two bathrooms though.

edam · 04/04/2007 23:37

Agree with Colditz, a 13yo who has just started her periods is not going to want to share with her brother and a bit unreasonable to ask her to given you do have the money to spend.

JodieG1 · 04/04/2007 23:35

Agree with Colditz, I think it's not on to expect 13 year old girl and boy to share.

colditz · 04/04/2007 23:30

I would have slit my wrists rather than have my brother sleeping in the same room as me. I started sleeping in a tent on my own when we went camping as a family because i refused point blank to share with my brother - and why the hell should I?

Yes, a period is only a period when you are 32 and have had 2 kids - when you are 13 and only just getting used to them, and the person you are sharing a room with is your 13 year old brother NO WAY.

And sorry to be awful, but what about the lad's privacy to have a wangle if he feels like it? He can't do it with his sister there! What if he has a wet dream?

I would never even consider putting 2 thirteen year olds of opposite sex in the same room, even if they did once share a room, they aren't babies any more, and they have a right to privacy levels they are comfortable with. It's nothing to do with being spoiled - I* gave up a warm bed in a caravan to sleep on the floor outside to get away from my brother, that's how strong the urge for privacy can be.

merlotmama · 04/04/2007 23:22

I wouldn't ask them - you're paying for it so you state terms and conditions.
£130 for the week..that could be a couple of meals out....a couple of meals not needing cooked. It's your holiday too.

tearinghairout · 04/04/2007 21:01

Thanks. I suppose I don't know these things because I haven't got bros or sisters. And I could't share with DD - see post below - would drive me nuts! Not much of a holiday. (I do expect some you-know-what you know - it's a holiday!)

And as for camping, powder28, you forgot to mention the simple joy of eating charred chicken on your throwaway barbie whilst quaffing whatever Lambrusco the local Spar can offer, thinking 'This is OK', before realising that it's getting cold and dark, and everyone else has got electric hook-up and radio and a table to play cards round, while you're wondering if there's enough battery left in the torch to finish your chapter, before realising that you have still to wash up the greasy plates in cold water. You end up with the sleeping bag zip digging into your neck, and spend the night wondering how you can be so well-padded yet still ache everywhere, and finally drop off to sleep as dawn breaks, only to be awoken by someone's kisses and fetid breath - no, not DH this time but the DDog who had howled in the car and had to be let in, to perfume the tent. Ah, there's nothing like camping, is there? Like you, I love the Great Outdoors.

OP posts:
twentypence · 04/04/2007 06:17

I would have shared with my 13 year old brother when I was 16 and not thought about it at all.

Your dh could always share with ds and you share with dd. That's what my mum's parents had to do as they had 5 kids and a 2 bedroom house.

jasper · 03/04/2007 22:59

I think your dh is being unreasonable.

Nothing wrong with sharing .

powder28 · 03/04/2007 22:57

Yes, I can work the old guilt trip on my mum, not so much on my dad. His response would be 'i dont think so'

3easterbunniesandnomore · 03/04/2007 22:49

lol powder...somehow I doubt they will go for that swap...although...depends possible on your selling power...along the lines...serious quality time with your gorgeous grandkids...yaddayaddayadda, lol

powder28 · 03/04/2007 22:35

I wonder if i should ask my parents if they would like to swap their holiday for ours. we're staying in a caravan in devon for a week. They're off to Barbados, all inclusive, adults only

tearinghairout · 03/04/2007 22:29

Hairymclary you're right - thanks.

OP posts:
3easterbunniesandnomore · 03/04/2007 22:25

lol, compo..thing is the op is wondering if that is £130 well spend and that those £130 could pay for other pleasures...therefore, my comment on people getting spoiled....if you can afofrd it then whatever...go and have 5 star holidays and be happy with yerself...do I look BOVVERED? ;)

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.