Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to wish my friend would stop moaning about how skint she is when she is working full-time and not paying childcare costs??

31 replies

Ceebee74 · 26/03/2007 13:50

My friend had a baby a month after me - we both went back to work at about the same time. I went back 3 days a week and my Ds is in nursery so obviously the reduction in pay and paying out child-care costs has had a dramatic effect on our finances and we have had to make sacrifices to do this.

My friend is back full-time (has negotiated 1 day a week to work from home) and is not paying out childcare costs (has family to do it)

I admit I moan about having no money and not being able to afford to do things, buy things etc - but it annoys me that she somehow thinks her position is comparable to mine - yes, babies are expensive so they will have had to make savings somewhere but her and DH are pretty much as they have always been.

I know that I would much rather do what I have done and make the sacrifices to be able to go part-time and spend 2 extra days with my DS but am I unreasonable to what to tell her to stop moaning and think herself lucky???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tundrawells · 09/08/2022 12:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Ceebee74 · 26/03/2007 21:15

Ebenezer - thanks for your wise words. I do agree with you about the benefits of nursery - my DS has been at nursery for 2 months now and really has come on in leaps and bounds during that time (obviously we don't know if he would have developed at that rate anyway) and my friend does keep asking me about it and if I think it is doing him good.

But, it is generally her DH who looks after their DS as he works a 2-day 2-night shift pattern and then 4 days off - her 1 day at home changes according to his shift pattern - (although her DS is on long-term sick at the moment so is looking after DS every day) and then grandparents, SIL on any other days that need covering - so I don't think she does have those concerns.

OP posts:
ebenezer · 26/03/2007 21:10

Try not to worry about it.I found that friends of mine who had unpaid childcare from relatives were the same - they just have no idea of the cost of childcare. But I think what other people have said is true - you don't really know what's going on in her head. Maybe she's secretly envious that u work 3 days and she's fulltime? Also, even though I would have LOVED free childcare, I honestly believe that my children benefited hugely from their childminder and later their nursery. They developed great independence and social skills and found the transition to school very smooth. I wouldn't have wanted grandparents or other family to be providing free childcare for several reasons: I believe a grandparents role is to enjoy their grandchildren - I still remember as a young girl the excitement of visiting my grandparents and how special it was, precisely because it wasn't just an everydat event. And when I have grandchildren one day, I want to feel I can love and support them without having to give up my own life to look after them. Maybe your friend feels horribly 'in debt' to her relatives, maybe they aren't bringing up her child in the way she wants and so she feels compromised but can't do anything about it. Just give her the benefit of the doubt, and you'll feel a whole lot better.

suejonez · 26/03/2007 20:15

CristinaTheAstonishing - nt surprisingly the M&S credit card 0.5% on all non-M&S purchses and 1% on all M&S purchases. I know I could probably get a better cash back rate somehwere else but when I have done that its just disappeared into paying off the bill. With the vouchers I save them and se them for Xmas or treats and it really feels like I'm getting something for free. (Spot the accountant!)

2shoesonanegghunt · 26/03/2007 15:58

sorry fio you know I love you

CristinaTheAstonishing · 26/03/2007 15:50

What CC gives M&S vouchers?

suejonez · 26/03/2007 15:39

just no left overs

suejonez · 26/03/2007 15:39

and I should add that I'm not seriously skint in the way some people are, just to left overs for luxuries like holidays but I can afford to run a decent car and shop in M&S (very) occasionally (using M&S &more vouchers earned on my credit card)

suejonez · 26/03/2007 15:34

thats not always true - I was well aware that I was better off than some of my friends before IVF/adoption/house/child care and wouldn't have dreamed of complaining to them about being hard up.

My rich sister never tries to identify wiht me about being skint. Some people will always moan, some will never moan and some are trying to identify/commiserate with you when they sound like they're complaining.

zippitippitoes · 26/03/2007 15:31

whatever people have they always moan because no one ever believes they have enough

FioFio · 26/03/2007 15:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

lizziemun · 26/03/2007 15:29

She just like my SIL and BIL, but as some people have said some people idea of being skint are different.

As you say my idea od being skint is not being able to afford what we need, their idea of being skint not being able to afford what they want.

2shoesonanegghunt · 26/03/2007 15:16

oh well felt better for having a moan

fannyannie · 26/03/2007 14:36

Ceebee - I think you need to tred carefully here. DH and I both work (I work 28hrs a week, he works 37.5) but have no childcare costs. However, we are still skint.......we debts which we are currently paying off, and DC3 on the way in not too many weeks.

From the "outside" it probably looks like we're doing ok - quite a nice house, brand new washing machine delivered today, etc etc - but infact we're only tredding water some months.

CristinaTheAstonishing · 26/03/2007 14:29

2shoes

2shoesonanegghunt · 26/03/2007 14:26

guess who just posted on the wrong thread

FioFio · 26/03/2007 14:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ScummyMummy · 26/03/2007 14:20

Do you think she could be joining in with your moaning as a kind of shared interest thing? I sometimes moan when i'm with people who are moaning in case they think I'm boringly problem free iykwim and thus can't relate to their moaning.

2shoesonanegghunt · 26/03/2007 14:18

oh Fio I am so grateful
We owned our own house(2 bed terrace) dd cam along with severe cp. house couldn't be adapted due to it's design so we were given A HA house,( Disabled access)
Yes we are gratefull as some people have to wait years and we only had to wait 1.
so grateful because we now live in a HA house so people can now judge us and look down on us.

contentiouscat · 26/03/2007 14:15

I dont think you are unreasonable to FEEL like that - you would be unreasonable though if you said anything to her!

Bite your tongue and change the subject she will soon get the message that you are not interested.

FioFio · 26/03/2007 14:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

CristinaTheAstonishing · 26/03/2007 14:13

Ceebee74 - that's what my DH thinks too and doesn't understand why I put up with her (she's been my friend for 7.5 years now). I just honestly don't think she realises it, or at least I hope so. Another great one was when I told her I was looking for jobs in Geneva. She was genuinely surprised "What? Would you move abroad? I'd never do that. But then I DO have a nice house..." A few months later she told me her DH was looking for jobs, and nowhere else than Geneva. And I was stupid enough to forget to remind her of her earlier stance on the subject!

suejonez · 26/03/2007 14:09

No not unreasonable but pointless as someone said being skint is all relative. I'm sure loads of people think I must be well off - well job, nice house etc but they don't take into account childcare and mortgage costs which clean me out every month and holidays are a thing of the past.

Best to vent on here, and smile nicely when she compares you - I am in a similar position with a friend whose ex-H pays her sones private school fees plus enough maintenance to cover her mortgage and she gets paid more than me and her childcare costs are minimal. Still, she means well when she tries to identify with me and how skint I am.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 26/03/2007 14:06

Different people have different priorities though, and if you?re used to living a certain lifestyle, then it can be hard to have to make sacrifices when a baby comes along.

In order to maintain her lifestyle, she?s had to sacrifice spending five days a week with her child so she could go back to work. It?s possible she wants to tell you how lucky you are that you can afford to only work three days a week iyswim.

Ceebee74 · 26/03/2007 14:04

Cristina - how bitchy of her!! Don't you just love friends like that....

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread