Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on Mumsnet there is a smacking minority and in NZ 85% of people seem to want to do it?

245 replies

twentypence · 26/03/2007 02:21

Lies, damn lies and statistics I know. But apparently NZ's new "anti smacking" law is opposed by 85% of New Zealanders.

Now I haven't looked into the proposed law carefully at all - partly because to actually find a fact amongst all the political posturing and soundbites largely because as I don't smack and never will it doesn't matter to me personally whether it becomes illegal or not.

But 85% just seems so high...

OP posts:
anniemac · 26/03/2007 13:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Greenshoots · 26/03/2007 13:17

Psycho, I'm not sure abuse has to be sustained or prolonged to qualify as abusive - signs such as "Or staff will not tolerate verbal or physical abuse" tend to suggest that a single act of violence can be defined as abusive.

And Kitty, if the definition of an abusive act depended on the abuser's own sense of what was defensible, there would be no such thing as child abuse.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 26/03/2007 13:16

I think you're spot on there twiglet.

fannyannie · 26/03/2007 13:15

but abuse doesn't have to be physical - so therefore one could say taking away priveledges, grounding, being made to sit on the "time out" "Naughty step" (whatever you call it) is demeaning and therefore also abusive........ certainly if I were to tell one of the elderly residents at work that I wasn't going to let them watch their TV because they'd spoken to me nastily I could be sacked for abuse.

But tell a child the same thing and it's ok???

Twiglett · 26/03/2007 13:13

that should be "vast bulk of mumsnet posts"

Twiglett · 26/03/2007 13:13

I don't actually think there is a smacking minority if I'm honest

I think like many of 'Mumsnet opinions' people can't be bothered to enter the fray when they hold a different opinion to the vocally strident minority who make up the vast bulk of mumsnet posters

Psycho · 26/03/2007 13:11

hello Greeny, just asked you something on the other thread.

I guess abuse, tends to suggest, if not strictly derivatively correct, something, sustained or quite extreme.

For instance with emotional abuse, if a parent in temper shouts 'for Gods sake you're a bloody pain in the neck today' that's unplaeasnt and not defensible but not 'abuse' unless such language is used reguarly to such an extent it damages the child.

And with smacking, a very rare smack, is not defensible butwould not be abuse unless, regular or done to the extent that the child is harmed-which is pretty much what the law is at present-I think?

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 26/03/2007 13:09

But I find it quite defensible therefore it's not abuse

Greenshoots · 26/03/2007 12:56

Abuse simply means indefensible ill-treatment though, doesn't it? So HOW can there be a line between hitting a child and abusing it? It's a mild form of physical abuse.

Psycho · 26/03/2007 12:53

'I'm anti-smacking but also against any anti-smacking laws.'

'For one thing, I don't agree that the very occasional last resort smack is child-damaging (there are better ways of discipline, almost certainly, but when can anyone claim to use the best parenting method for the right situation every single second of the day?!)'

Agree with rubberduck on this.

Smacking children acnnot be morally justified, but there has to be a distinctuon between this and 'abuse' or criminal behaviour.Most people recognise that thare is a distinction between the two and a line has to be drawn between that indefensible 'very occasional last resort smack' and criminal abuse.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 26/03/2007 12:37

Well, welliemum, it's like banning foxhunting whilst allowing other barbaric treatments of animals such as battery hens to continue. It's all arse about tit and I think it's about paying lip service, picking on the easiest thing to abolish in order to keep certain parties happy.

GreenandBlackOtter · 26/03/2007 12:34

sorry second line was in response to the op

GreenandBlackOtter · 26/03/2007 12:34

well said wellie mum

because no one DARE admit it on here

welliemum · 26/03/2007 12:30

I'm in NZ and I agree with Sibble.

Last year, a couple of days before dd2 was born, 2 little twin boys were murdered in Auckland. No-one has yet been convicted but only family members were in the house at the time.

I just can't imagine how a smacking bill is going to help children like those little twins and while I don't think smacking is an ideal parenting tool, there is so much worse abuse going on that it seems crazy to be focusing on smacking as a problem.

anniemac · 26/03/2007 11:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 11:49

The smackers are too busy herding their sheep and their children with birch rods I suppose....

MellowMa · 26/03/2007 11:39

Message withdrawn

ghosty · 26/03/2007 11:36

Um xenia, you've lost me.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 26/03/2007 10:25

Perhaps it's only the anti smackers who can be bothered to post??????

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 10:09

We don't in the UK allow an adult to smack their wife to bring her into line although that's standard practice in many parts of the world and indeed part of many Christian domestic discipline religious relationships. Just because other people are idiots or think violence particularly if the other person is smaller or weaker if fine doesn't mean we have to think so.

All the sheep in NZ may be? More sheep than people so lots of farmers who would discipline sheep with whistles and presumably sticks perhaps or do some people think it's fine to beat a child but not an animal?

Pitchounette · 26/03/2007 09:42

Message withdrawn

LieselVentouse · 26/03/2007 09:41

Its not that Im against smacking I just feel that IMHO it has no effect - it works better if we take privileges away like no swimming for a week, no DVDs for a week etc.

sibble · 26/03/2007 09:11

I am in NZ and if they'd phoned me I would have said no to the bill too. Not that I think smacking children is right but I don't believe the bill stops people who beat their children from beating them - and at the end of the day this is who it is aimed at. Adults should know right from wrong and beating children is wrong, people who beat their chilren continue to do so because they live by their own 'moral' or immoral code. I don't believe any thought has been put into implementing the bill here, the police, social servies etc. are already stretched to the limit - add to the equation monitoring calls about parents who have smacked their children as opposed to beating them senseless and those who need support and help will now go without. There is also a cultural undercurrent which is in question, it is culturally acceptable for maori and islanders to hit their children and whether we think it is right or wrong, IMO education through the generations is the way to progress and not a law that nobody has any intention to adhere to. Personnally I feel very strongly it should not go ahead and hope they phone me soon!

ENTP · 26/03/2007 09:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Saggarmakersbottomknocker · 26/03/2007 09:01

Like RubberDuck I'm anti-smacking but also anti a no-smacking law.

I have smacked my children - well the youngest - the simple reason being that I was an inexperienced parent. As my parenting skills improved, and I learned other techniques I found the need to smack my subsequent children diminished. I needed help to improve my parenting not be criminalised.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.