Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on Mumsnet there is a smacking minority and in NZ 85% of people seem to want to do it?

245 replies

twentypence · 26/03/2007 02:21

Lies, damn lies and statistics I know. But apparently NZ's new "anti smacking" law is opposed by 85% of New Zealanders.

Now I haven't looked into the proposed law carefully at all - partly because to actually find a fact amongst all the political posturing and soundbites largely because as I don't smack and never will it doesn't matter to me personally whether it becomes illegal or not.

But 85% just seems so high...

OP posts:
fannyannie · 26/03/2007 17:50

Xenia - the internet is "littered" with controversial websites on all subject matter if you want to look for it - it's also littered with plenty of Christian sites that aren't as you described.

estar · 26/03/2007 17:23

Fannyannie and kiwinat, well spoken.

Xenia, I was referring to the idea of wife beating being totally against Christian principles. As FA said, there is a huge onus in the bible placed on men to protect and love their wives.

And lol at the idea of people like James Dobson being described as 'child-beating Christian fundamentalist' Please get some perpsective and read some of his material.

doggiesayswoof · 26/03/2007 15:58

Yep, we had the fundamentalist Christians on the other smacking thread too.

Greenshoots · 26/03/2007 15:57

Xenia is right about the hardline Christian child-beating contingent, there have been plenty of threads on MN referring to these lunatics. They believe the Bible not only commands that parents physically chastise their children, but also details how and with what implement it should be done.

Famous child-beating Christian fundamentalist evangelists include Garry Ezzo, Michael and Debi Pearl, James Dobson and many others. Their "ministries" are thriving and very influential, unfortunately.

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 15:31

You are probably right. I haven't done a statistically analysis but the internet is littered with Christian domestic discipline sites and Christian groups where that is a key issue and there are plenty of books on it.

fannyannie · 26/03/2007 15:27

"Many also believe it is a biblical imperative that wives submit to their husbands who may also physically chastise the wives."

I'll agree with the first bit of that

"Many also believe it is a biblical imperative that wives submit to their husbands" - as if you study that whole passage properly woman get a MUCH better deal out of than the men do. All we have to do is look after them, they have to love us as much as God loves the church - a much bigger ask.

The 2nd bit - I have to disagree that it's "many" of them that believe that husband physicallyh chastise their wives......again it's only a tiny majority.

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 15:24

fa, I am a Catholice. We certainly don't believe you have to beat children and most Christians don't but there is a very very large movement for it in conservative bits of the US and lots of groups in the UK. It is by no means a small lot I'm afraid. Many also believe it is a biblical imperative that wives submit to their husbands who may also physically chastise the wives.

fannyannie · 26/03/2007 15:18

"Masses of them world wide."

actually I think you'll find it's a minority of them worldwide - that's why we hear about it because it makes "news".

kiwinat · 26/03/2007 15:15

These "christians" who are saying the bible tells them to smack/beat/whip their children are incorrect. I always used to think "spare the rod, spoil the child" meant a good smack was needed. But have learned the rod talked about is the type used by a shepherd to guide their sheep, so rather a guiding, reasoned influence should be used to discipline children, from biblical viewpoint.

However for v. young children who can't process a situation and don't understand all the reasoning words yet, a smacked hand on occasion is probably the way to get their attention.

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 14:49

In the UK if it leaves a mark. I think the Act was in 2004.

BB web site

"New smacking law comes into force

Parents in England and Wales who smack children so hard it leaves a mark will face up to five years in jail under new laws in force from Saturday.

Mild smacking is allowed under a "reasonable chastisement" defence against common assault.

But any punishment which causes visible bruising, grazes, scratches, minor swellings or cuts can face action.

The law is flawed and there should be a total ban on smacking, according to child protection charity the NSPCC.

It said the new law will only confuse parents and leave children still at risk of abuse.

It should be as wrong to hit a child as an adult

NSPCC boss Mary Marsh said: "There is a risk parents may choose to hit children on parts of their body where injury is less visible, such as the head, which can cause serious harm.

"Defining acceptable ways to hit children should become a thing of the past.

"It should be just as wrong to hit a child as it is to hit an adult." "

Twiglett · 26/03/2007 14:48

ok I've found the netherlands so far

anywhere else?

Twiglett · 26/03/2007 14:44

where is smacking your children banned Xenia

just interested

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 14:42

A certain brand of Christian, loads of them. Some take their children out of school to home educate in the US so they can whip them or cane them at home as the bible they say teachers. Others in the EU have brought test cases saying it breaches their religious freedoms not to be able to paddle their children with special instruments. Masses of them world wide. Dreadful business.

If it's right to slap a child other than in anger then I don't see why a husband can't do it to his wife either etc. It's just dreadful violence we should never countenance and thankfully is gradually getting banned worldwide.

estar · 26/03/2007 14:15

I'm surprised that most people seem to think smacking is something that is done when people lose their temper. Although I do occasionally smack my children, if I've lost my temper, I won't because I don't want to do it too hard. I will do it in a very carefully controlled manner though. I do prefer to use other forms of discipline but when my kids were eighteen months, making them stand in the naughty corner for trying to touch a live fire didn't really work!

My oldest is now five and I can't remember the last time I smacked him as there are many more appropriate forms of discipline I can use. I certainly won't use it as they get older.

In response to your question, Xenia, I do not think its okay for adults to smack each other. The whole point of smacking is that it communicates to a small child that something is negative when words are beyond them - you can't say that about adults. That also implies that you see smacking as a really violent and power-enforcing thing rather than a sharp tap on the hand (or wherever) to let a child know he/she has overstepped a mark. Hitting an adult really would have to be a forceful thing and yes, that would count as abuse.

Also - where are these 'Christian domestic discipline religious relationships'? I know Christians all over the world and don't know anyone who practices that! Most Christians I know would see that as totally against biblical teaching.

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 13:55

Well the smackers are in a minority and in the UK the law is on my side. NZ won't waste money on this. It will be like the UK seatbelt law and speed limit. If it's broken you may not get found out but it will deter those who might otherwise smack and a good thing too.

By the way do you think a husband should have a right to smack his wife within certain limits?

Twiglett · 26/03/2007 13:50

my mother and father both smacked me (all of us actually)

my mother used to lose her temper and come at us like a whirlwind .. once I fell backwards because I was backing away and knocked myself out for a short time

my father used to make us hold our hands out and then smack our hands

do you know something .. I didn't and don't find it abusive .. I don't look back and resent it either .. I have loving, sane and wonderful parents who have raised 4 fairly fabulous, although inordinately strange of course, children

Now I don't take the same approach to parenting but I really object to the whole abuse mentality .. it pisses me orf which is why I don't enter the fray

welliemum · 26/03/2007 13:45

Xenia, I don't think anyone is saying that smacking is OK because it's not as bad as other things parents might do ie I don't believe your analogy applies here.

Rather, it's that NZ has a finite amount of public money to spend on improving children's lives, and to me anyway, it makes little sense to spend that on stopping people smacking their children instead of stopping people murdering their children.

Actually, I think that any intervention which consists of punishing troubled families is doomed to fail anyway.

catASTROPHE · 26/03/2007 13:33

and when I say 'them', I mean 'us'.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 26/03/2007 13:32

Greeny, in all honesty, I think you are FAR too hard on yourself.

catASTROPHE · 26/03/2007 13:32

Wow, this thread is the most sane and sensible smacking thread I've ever read on Mumsnet - didn't know it was possible!

I agree about those who don't see eye to eye with the very vocal (and, dare I say it, agressive) majority not bothering to post. There are many issues I never post about.

I agree that smacking is not a thoughtful or ideal discipline technique. Also agree that a one off or occasional smack is not criminal, and to make it so is to scapegoat good parents who make mistakes, rather than help them.

Greenshoots · 26/03/2007 13:30

In other words - no, I don't think you are a "child abuser" - but I do think that the time you smacked your child, you abused him at that moment. I abused my son when I screamed at him and made him cry too, and I felt mortified and apologised to him, just as any other basically non-abusive person would having done something abusive in temper.

Greenshoots · 26/03/2007 13:28

I've replied on the other thread Psycho

in brief, I think the smack, even as an isolated act in temper, is an abusive act - but I wouldn't call a parent who lost their temper, smacked once, then apologised "a child abuser", because as a label attached to a person's identity, it would need to be sustained/deliberate. It's an interesting distinction though.

Psycho · 26/03/2007 13:26

I think the term 'child abuse' suggests extreme and sustained abuse greeny.

What about my emotional abuse example where a one off or rare derogatory verbal comment to a child is indefensible, but would we say it is child abuse?

My only difficulty withg your argument Greeny is that you feel (I think) that even people who smack on a one off, from an 'end of the tether' type scenario, are child abusers.

I agree with the moral and intellectual stance of yout anti smacking arguemnt.

I however have very regrettably smacked, do you view me as a child abuser?
O, have I abused my child?

I just think these are very emotive terms that need to be very carefully used, and imply much more than one off failures of parenting.

Judy1234 · 26/03/2007 13:20

That's like saying people murder so let's not make rape illegal as it's not as bad.

I think a lot of emotional abuse is dreadful but it's harder to ban that but that doesn't mean we shouldn't ban the smacking. It's worked fine in the UK although we could do with its total abolition even if no marks etc are left.

Twiglett · 26/03/2007 13:19

oh yes indeedy annie

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.