Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on Mumsnet there is a smacking minority and in NZ 85% of people seem to want to do it?

245 replies

twentypence · 26/03/2007 02:21

Lies, damn lies and statistics I know. But apparently NZ's new "anti smacking" law is opposed by 85% of New Zealanders.

Now I haven't looked into the proposed law carefully at all - partly because to actually find a fact amongst all the political posturing and soundbites largely because as I don't smack and never will it doesn't matter to me personally whether it becomes illegal or not.

But 85% just seems so high...

OP posts:
Soapbox · 28/03/2007 01:18

Well I certainly cannot pretend that it doesn;t shock me beyond belief that people in this day and age believe that deliberately hurting your own child is a valid choice of parenting method

MerryMarigold · 28/03/2007 01:13

oh. and i have a first class degree from warwick university if that helps label me into some sort of group.

MerryMarigold · 28/03/2007 01:12

Thanks UCM, and others, for being willing to say these things. I too smack my son sometimes. I thought about it a lot - after the stuff I read on here - but in the end decided it was the best for both of us. When he is able to understand removal or privileges etc. that can be used, but right now he is too young. I think children and adults are totally different and you can't treat them in the same way, just as you treat children differently at different ages. I would not tolerate my dh 'smacking' me.

Personally I do believe a controlled smack - after 3 warnings - is better than losing it, shouting and getting out of control, even hitting in anger. I was shouting a lot and feeling very unhappy about it, and this decision has helped me. Smacks are rare but I feel a lot more in control of myself and therefore able to be a lot more loving to my ds.

I thought about changing my name as I don't want to be known as 'that one that smacks'. But anyway, I am probably not on here enough for it to matter.

Twiglett, you are right, I was always too petrified of being jumped on to say it! And btw, the smacks never leave a mark.

ucm · 27/03/2007 23:32

Right I am trying to word this properly so bear with me. I smack my son and in my opinion I am not abusing him. I am teaching him right from wrong in MY way.

I do hope Sophable & Greensleeves that you are perfect parents. Because if you are suffering from depression, have mood swings, are always on your pc, bicker/row in front of you partner, don't get on with your families, then you are also showing your children that life isn't perfect, in another abusive way. You only have to read the posts on here which include, my mother didn't beat me but she had terrible mood swings. So before you both head off thinking that you are bloody perfect, I suggest you think again.

I have not had a proper chance to post about this, and I applaud anyone who doesn't smack as they can deal with bad behaviour with other options. To me, its about showing my son that something is hugely wrong, at that time, and it does have to be really really wrong. I walked out of the room for 10 seconds yesterday and as his sister started to cry (8 weeks) he tried to stop her by putting his hand over her mouth & nose. OMG you are all going to think. Did I smack for that..... No. I had a very long chat with him about dangerous things.

However, he went to walk into the road without looking a few days back, did I smack, YES.

I respect both of your postings normally but to have you both congratulating each other on (as it seems to me) that you are SO right and we are all thick, illiterate and stupid, I felt the need to post.

Heathcliffscathy · 27/03/2007 21:31

yup

Judy1234 · 27/03/2007 21:29

There is a serious physical child abuse problem in most countries of the world.
Whenever there's a murder of adult or child the most likely culprit is a family member. It's not on the streets we're at risk. It's in the home.

Heathcliffscathy · 27/03/2007 21:06

if this was RL i would grab you and give you a big half hug half kiss as that is my wont.

as it isn't you'll have to just imagine it.

Greenleeves · 27/03/2007 21:04

LOL sophable, I nearly swallowed my own head with pure rage last night

Sodding bloody thread.

Heathcliffscathy · 27/03/2007 21:03

OHMIGOD.

have read thread.

pmsl and almost crying and just rolling around in DISBELIEF that someone is trying to defend james dobson. ffs.

smacking is abusive. absolutely. it is the last recourse of those who've lost it (and any one of us could lose it...) and the thick.

now come and get me.

yellowrose · 27/03/2007 21:01

sophable - if that is the case - they need to get some real legislation into place very very quickly.

Heathcliffscathy · 27/03/2007 20:53

don't know if someone has posted this as have only read op, but there is a serious physical child abuse problem in NZ as far as i could gather from spending 4 months there and watching news/current affairs progs

yellowrose · 27/03/2007 20:46

The CHEAPEST care a child can get is their own parent

yellowrose · 27/03/2007 20:44

There is no ABSOLUTE right to do anything to a child or anyone as vulnerable as a child. There are certain things children need to be protected from, sadly in some cases they need to be protected from their own parents, relatives, carers, etc.

I think the problem with smacking is that it can become so much more than smacking. A slap on the wrist may become a smack in the face, etc. I am not saying it always WILL, just saying that it is a possibility. Some humans need LAW to stop them from taking things further. I think smacking ANYONE, child or adult, is morally wrong, don't really care about any form of legislation. Some people don't see it as morally wrong, which is why they need the law.

Judy1234 · 27/03/2007 20:27

Actually I may have said cheaper care was one solution (presumably Government funded) but as a free market sort of person I wouldn't really go for interference in that market by trying artifically bringing prices down. If we could get tax rates a lot lower we could afford to pay nannies more easily which would help.

Anna8888 · 27/03/2007 19:57

The point I was making was not about the French in particular, but about the realities of cheap childcare.

Xenia has often written about the cost of childcare, and how it should be cheaper in the UK as it is in many continental European countries. The reality of cheap childcare is the reality of cheap anything - pay peanuts, get monkeys.

Twiglett · 27/03/2007 18:47

most mothers I've met are pretty fabulous at the job of parenting their children tbh

Twiglett · 27/03/2007 18:44

"We weren't too keen on the French after 1066 etc and I'm not sure we wholly approve of them now." are you for real??

Judy1234 · 27/03/2007 18:37

We weren't too keen on the French after 1066 etc and I'm not sure we wholly approve of them now. But lots of good English nannies work abroad all ove rthe world for Saudi princes etc. My grandmother worked for an English family as a nanny in India in the 1920s.

Anna8888 · 27/03/2007 18:03

All very well thinking you have the choice. But in countries where childcare is cheap and unqualified, you just can't get really good nannies because the "profession" is so devalued. Decent people just don't go in for it. The only option here is to import a British or Australian girl, but then they tend to be really miserable because everyone looks down on them, there's no-one to be friends with etc.

Anyway, in France parents and nannies alike can hit children just about anywhere without anyone taking the blindest bit of notice.

Judy1234 · 27/03/2007 17:51

Nor any legislation that parents must be trained and many mothers frankly are pretty bad at the job. But parents choose childcare that is good and in fact in practice having employed nannies who have done the 2 year course and one who hasn't I haven't found much difference and never found one who was in favour of corporal punishment of children.

Anna8888 · 27/03/2007 17:49

OK. But in countries like France (or Spain, or Italy) where childcare is cheap, it is also, very often, nasty.

Trained nannies cost a lot more.

Twiglett · 27/03/2007 17:00

there is no legislation in place to say that a nanny has to be qualified in any way, shape or form .. of course then it is up to the employer to decide for themselves and no right-minded individual would employ a nanny with no epxperience / training

Judy1234 · 27/03/2007 16:54

In the UK nannies would usually do a 2 year child course. They're very good. Weren't we the first country in the world to provide trained nannies to the world?

Anna8888 · 27/03/2007 16:34

Hmm - most nannies here have small children of their own, which they outsource to relatives so they can work during the day.

And lots of nannies sleep most of the day, leaving their charges in a playpen or in front of the TV, because they're too exhausted to do anything else.

That's the cheap childcare economy for you...

Anna8888 · 27/03/2007 16:31

Xenia - nanny courses????????

Where I live, people become nannies precisely because it requires no qualifications at all.

And I have seen nannies hit children in public places (playgrounds and shops) just because they're interrupting their chit-chat with other nannies, and no-one bats an eyelid.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.