Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on Mumsnet there is a smacking minority and in NZ 85% of people seem to want to do it?

245 replies

twentypence · 26/03/2007 02:21

Lies, damn lies and statistics I know. But apparently NZ's new "anti smacking" law is opposed by 85% of New Zealanders.

Now I haven't looked into the proposed law carefully at all - partly because to actually find a fact amongst all the political posturing and soundbites largely because as I don't smack and never will it doesn't matter to me personally whether it becomes illegal or not.

But 85% just seems so high...

OP posts:
flutterbee · 28/03/2007 15:24

Everyone on this thread needs to get a grip, the petty name calling and over exageration of situations is nothing but childish.

Anyone who is truely abusing a child will pay no attention to a law that makes smacking illegal and it infurriates me that decent parents who smack a childs hand from time to time are being lumped into the same group.

But what annjoys me more are people who use bloody reward charts

easywriter · 28/03/2007 15:19

Kittywaitsfornumber6 point taken that you feel you're right and that anti-smackers feel they are but, following through on your smacking train of thought, if you thought an adult had misbehaved, you would be entitled to smack them.

The likely result would be you up on a charge of assault.

If the law protects adults from being hit then why doesn't it protect children. They are people too!

yellowrose · 28/03/2007 15:12

"matildax and Prettybird - why the assumption that a parent that doesn't smack must use time outs or shouting?"

Yes I agree. I think parents that tend to be very stricly opposed to smacking also do not agree with time out or shouting. These are really not the best ways to descipline a child. We all get stressed and fume and froth at the mouth with our children. Ds is a very very active child. I need masses of energy to keep up with him.

They might do something again and again and again, not to piss you off, but because they sometimes just don't have the ability to REMEMBER or focus on what you just said 2 minutes ago. It is that simple. So you have to keep repeating yourself verbally until they are old enough to understand.

I read somewhere that little boys lose some of their hearing when they are going through rapid physical development. I forget the authors name, he is quite famous. I was amazed by this. He said sometimes even if you shout across the room at a little boy, he may just not HEAR you well, because he has gone a bit deaf ! It isn't beacuse he is trying to spite you That explains a lot about ds, now 2.9 yo. He just totally ignores me sometimes, probably because he just can't hear poor lamb and he has never ever had an ear infection in his life, it is a development thing related to hormones !

ekra · 28/03/2007 15:09

And Kitty - what would you do if a complete smacking ban came into force in this country?

And how do you currently ensure you don't leave a mark on your children?

prettybird · 28/03/2007 15:08

Thnkas for that Wildwoman! (and just to clarify - it's not even "taps", it's "tapped" - 3 years ago, without the slightest inclination to do it again.

(OK, I lie, I have been tempted on occasion, when I am getting angry with ds for whatever reason, but like Ekra, I distance myslef from the situation as I recongise that it is wrong)

BTW, Spandex - the scenario I quoted was just that, a quote from another Mumsnetter's posting from another thread. I only have one ds and no other child. But I could see what she was getting at - in her judgement, for the sake of both her kids, that was the strategy that worked best on that occasion.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 28/03/2007 15:04

So Spandex you say it is I say it isn't .
I say I'm right, you say you're right.

Nothing has been proved. Only opinions given.
What I dislike about these threads is the way the anti smackers go round as if they are right just because they think they are.
They are not

I will continue to use smacking as part of my disciplinary repetoire.

ekra · 28/03/2007 15:03

That question was to catASTROPHE

ekra · 28/03/2007 15:01

Are you saying you cannot control your urge to smack and that if the law changed you wouldn't be able to stop yourself?

prettybird · 28/03/2007 15:00

Spandex - You also clearly haven't read my postings. I do abhor violence, and as I have said before, was against corporal punishment (and was brought up to be against it) long before society in general deemed it to be wrong.

Harpsichordcarrier - I know it doesn't hurt bar a momentary sting, because I have done it to myself, probably harder than I did it to ds. Now I acknowledge that I can't know for sure how it felt to him (although he didn't cry), nor can I state with certainty what made him stop. I beleive it was the shock value - it gave him enough pause to stop whatever it was he was doing.

I also don't beleive in hitting other adults - my "invitation" to Spandex was in response to her comment to me. And my comment about "hitting" other peoples hands when stealing my last Rolo was meant tongue in cheek. FFS - there used to be an ad about people doing just that, with no compalints about promoting a culture of violence!

There are things I do with my ds that I wouldn't dream of doing to another adult. I wouldn't dream of forcing another adult to go to bed if they didn't want to. But as a loving mother, I make ds go to bed before he wants to. I wouldn't dream of holding on to another adult's wrist and dragging him/her around a shop unwillingly - yet I have had in the past to do that with ds. The altranitve would have been to leave him unattended - which you can do with an adult.

Children are not the same as adults - we are having to teach them boudaries to make them into good adults. You may disagree with one tiny (and now in the past anyway) technique that I used - but as reposnsible parents, I beleive that we do all have the same obejctives.

catASTROPHE · 28/03/2007 14:49

ekra, I do strive to be perfect in every way I strive not to smack, not to shout, not to ignore, not to have a mean attitude, not to betray my exasperation. I do strive. I do occasionally smack. I'd rather I didn't do any of the above, but I don't think smacking is the worst I have done to my DCs (my shouting has, at times, been far worse)

Greenleeves · 28/03/2007 14:47

Oh, well, one born every minute

matildax · 28/03/2007 14:45

oh what your telling me that you have never raised your voice??? wow you are seriously amazing and a credit to motherhood. im going now, have things to do, i will check in later.

wildwoman · 28/03/2007 14:45

ok so my name may not paint me in a particularly good light...

ekra · 28/03/2007 14:44

"If you answer yes and are suggesting there should be no grey areas, then you too have abused your child. Lets all try not to be so narrow minded eh?"

I suggested that there is no grey area where smacking is concerned. I don't get what you mean???

wildwoman · 28/03/2007 14:43

I really want to leave this alone now becuase no one is getting anywhere, but "scared that you might go for him again" is getting a bit carried away, are you serioulsy picturing prettybird as some derranged red faced abuser becuase she occasionally taps her son's hand?

ekra · 28/03/2007 14:41

matildax and Prettybird - why the assumption that a parent that doesn't smack must use time outs or shouting?

Spandex · 28/03/2007 14:39

But you're assuming all is ticketty boo after you've smacked your child? Just because you go back to cuddling and things appear the same as before, it's all fine.

How do you know? How do you know what your child is internalising as a result of your hitting him? How do you know he's not sitting with you, scared to move in case you go for him again?

In terms of not pushing the other child away, I wouldn't haul him upstairs for time out either. You do sound extreme, I must say.

Continual, calm and repetitive, "No, don't do that," (however dull and boring for you!) usually does the trick. If it doesn't, then the status quo has to be altered which isn't a bad thing necessarily. Maybe he's not happy in the position he's in and pushing the younger child is his way of showing you that. Move the child away so that he can't push the younger one. Much like you would move a hot cup of tea.

The more his aggression escalates, the more solid a calm brick wall you have to be.

matildax · 28/03/2007 14:35

a question........... do you judge a book by its cover????? ......... no, you read it and then and only then can you make a judgement as to whether its very good or not.I wish people on here would do that, then maybe this debate would finally get somewhere. to all the anti smackers in here, ask yourself this have you ever screamed or shouted or done something to upset your dc? If you answer yes and are suggesting there should be no grey areas, then you too have abused your child. Lets all try not to be so narrow minded eh?

prettybird · 28/03/2007 14:30

I do actually agree with Ekra - if I ever feel the desire to lash out, I distance my self from the situation.

Ds knows it is wrong to hit others. I don't think even if he could remember what I did to him (remember, it was only a max. of 5 times, spread over about 18 months, 4 years ago), he would even categorise it as hitting him.

We are always using our controlling power - if not, we are not doing our jobs right. We also use our superior strength to control our children, such as when we force them to stay with us in busy crowds when they are wee (or am I the only mother to have had to hold on hard to ds' hand when he would really rather be somewhere else ). In this particular circumsntace, it wasn't power I used, but shock value.

This is a scenario that another Mumsnetter once outlined, "He got a 'don't push dd away', then a smack on the hand and a 'I told you not do push dd'. Then cuddle resumed exactly as before, with one on each side. Status quo undisturbed. Alternative (time-out) would be: stand up off the couch, pick him up and carry him screaming up the stairs, shut door of room and wait 60 seconds, dd starts wailing because she was enjoying the cuddle with mummy and doesn't want me to leave, I come back to ds and give explanation again about bad behaviour, then a cuddle to help him get over tears, then return to dd who needs to be calmed and settled again... all that palaver involves FAR more of mummy's time and attention than a quick smack, which in this case did not cause tears (just a bottom lip poked out) - the whole thing was over, from smack to resumption of status quo in less than 20-30 seconds. Ds absolutely HATES going to his room - much more than a smack. But the smack seems just as effective at the right moment in curbing the behaviour. So why would I choose the option that distresses him more? Not always, but often, hauling him upstairs for time-out escalates the emotions on both sides. He gets distraught because he regrets it so much and doesn't want to go upstairs, and then he struggles and resists going up to his room, which distresses dd so she starts crying etc - and the whole thing can (doesn't always) become a much more heated, emotional thing than the smack typically does - often a smack situation remains very calm, the point that I'm serious is made, the smack does in fact stop the behaviour, but everyone is allowed to continue on as before (just minus the bad behaviour). Much calmer household, and much more pleasant for both children. "

What would you have suggested instead?

harpsichordcarrier · 28/03/2007 14:27

pretty bird, with all due respect, you have no idea if it hurts or not.
and if it doesn't hurt, then why does it "work" to alter the behaviour? is it just the humiliation?
I also believe that solving disputes with the use of applied force is wrong. I wouldn't dream of hitting another adult. what a strange and bizarre concept in a civilised society.

Spandex · 28/03/2007 14:23

No, prettybird. I won't hit you because I don't believe in it unless it's self defence against an abusive adult. I've been brought up to believe that violence is wrong. You clearly haven't.

Greenleeves · 28/03/2007 14:17

I don't think it's just about how visibly distressed the child is at the point of discipline, though. Nobody is suggesting that children should always enjoy being disciplined. My ds2 "howled with distress" yesterday because I wouldn't let him block up the toilet with big wads of paper.

I think it's more about a fundamental principle that hitting people is wrong, especially a bigger person hitting a smaller person to demonstrate controlling power over them. Some of us think this principle is totally inalienable - no shades of grey - and that children need to learn it absolutely and without nuance too.

prettybird · 28/03/2007 14:11

Unlike Ekra and Spandex I do believe that there are shades of grey. And I know that the alternatives - all of which are deemed to be perefectly acceptable and even suggested in the thread abour "Non Spanking Parenting Alternatives" - would have been far more distressing to ds.

He used to howl with distress if we suggested he should go into the hallway (which was only ever for about a minute).

And Spandex - if I am having a tantrum, or try or steal your last rolo, you are perfectly entitled to hit me as hard as I "hit" ds' hand - because it doesn't hurt*.

wildwoman · 28/03/2007 14:01

unavailable

ekra · 28/03/2007 14:01

catASTROPHE it doesn't have to be a choice between those two things. If you're a loving, affectionate, interested parent why not also strive to be a parent who doesn't smack their child? And I ask that question genuinely? Why did you first smack your child? Did you make a conscious decision to not be a smacker but it just happened or did you leave the idea of smacking open and it happened? I'd genuinely like to know how other people think.

I am not a patient person and I have been driven to the brink by my DD1 on a number of occasions but I have put the idea into my head that smacking her would be so wrong that I manage not to. When I feel like I want to lash out, I take that as my cue to put distance between us. Time out for me so to speak.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.