Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on Mumsnet there is a smacking minority and in NZ 85% of people seem to want to do it?

245 replies

twentypence · 26/03/2007 02:21

Lies, damn lies and statistics I know. But apparently NZ's new "anti smacking" law is opposed by 85% of New Zealanders.

Now I haven't looked into the proposed law carefully at all - partly because to actually find a fact amongst all the political posturing and soundbites largely because as I don't smack and never will it doesn't matter to me personally whether it becomes illegal or not.

But 85% just seems so high...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tundrawells · 09/08/2022 12:26

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 29/03/2007 12:32

Ekra I couldn't give two hoots about what other parents do in the privacy of their own homes.

When I smack it is a choice, it has nothing to do with losing control.

AspartameGoddessOfCatAstrophe · 29/03/2007 10:24

you may be right ekra. It may help. But it may also just marginalise people who are actually good parents who need some help. And we all need some help sometimes. I would love some! I'd love to do a positive parenting course (with free creche available for my DCs), I'd love to have even a small amount of tine with just DH and me, and would love someone to help me with the house work once a week for a few hours. Wouldn't we all!? A pipe dream I know, but these things would make far more difference to how I can cope with my DCs than any law. Its much, much cheaper to pass a law though, and then the government can wash their hands of it.

ekra · 29/03/2007 09:45

catastrophe ? my post isn?t meant to sound like I think I am a better parent because I manage not to smack and you sometimes do. I have made the idea of smacking my child a no-no from the start. It doesn?t register in my repertoire of techniques to deal with my dd1. In my head it would be akin to me hitting my DH. I?d be overstepping the mark in the most severe manner.

My point is that if society at large adhere to the idea of smacking as taboo, reinforced by the law, fewer parents would over-step the mark and those who randomly and casually smack, would be able to stop.

ekra · 29/03/2007 09:32

"Ekra, tbh, my attitude is what I do in the privacy of my own home is my business. I hate all these bloody laws. I suppose I wouldn't be able to smack in puiblic then?"

And my attitude is that children deserve to be afforded the same right (not to be hit) as other human beings, whether that is in public or in the privacy of their parents' home.

What else do you think parents should be allowed to do to their children in the privacy of their own homes? {{{{shudder}}}}

powder28 · 29/03/2007 09:24

I agree with you Ekra, this is about self-control.

ekra · 29/03/2007 09:17

"I'm sure you're thinking I must be a terrible psychopath who is out of control. Can you see though, that we all lose control at some times, otherwise we would all be able to adhere to our own moral code all of the time and be perfect. Which would be nice."

No, I don't think you are a psycopath, at all. I have been pushed to the brink by my dd1 and felt the urge to lash out and smack her. I don't. I am trying to understand why other people cannot stop themselves.

If a smacking ban came into force in this country, I actually think more parents could stop themselves. I'm not interested in judging people's past behaviour, but going forward, I am sure most people would be able to stop smacking if it were deemed illegal. (teachers managed to stop caning pupils when that became illegal)

Those parents that were not able to stop themselves from lashing out at their children in anger clearly need some help.

A few generations on, the casual smacking of children would be deemed alien and only real abusers would be doing it.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 29/03/2007 07:29

catASTROPHE I am

matildax · 28/03/2007 21:14

flutterbee, very well said. i now, to the relief of some im assuming, will definitely rest my case. goodnight to you all x x

catASTROPHE · 28/03/2007 21:00

so kittywaits, you are usually kittywits?

harpsichordcarrier · 28/03/2007 20:34

lol at kittylette being mistaken for kittywits
er, not even close

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 28/03/2007 17:17

Now that would be amazing.
I was due last week, haven't had it yet mine are always late.

catASTROPHE · 28/03/2007 16:42

Oh, congrats! What did you have?

Oh, can't keep up with the names on MN... was imagining you pregnant with your 5 kids in tow, pole dancing in a white dress!

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 28/03/2007 16:35

No, sadly not, did see that thread though. She sounds like a really game girl !!!!!

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 28/03/2007 16:35

LAST WEEK

catASTROPHE · 28/03/2007 16:35

are you the same kitty who was going to pole dance at your wedding or something?

catASTROPHE · 28/03/2007 16:33

wow kitty, just looked at your profile..6...wow! When is next one due?

PeckaRolloverAgain · 28/03/2007 16:33

MATILDAX

sorry for thread hijack but matildax, its R and i cant find your email address to send you pics of H's hat - can you email me if you still have it

Judy1234 · 28/03/2007 16:33

We need to issue the children of the smackers with childline or NSPCC calling cards so they can take advice when they are smacked. Thank goodness the law regulates what people do to their children at home - every day children are abused, burned, beaten, sodomised and the like. A light smack is entirely different and I wouldn't call it abuse but it still can be illegal if it leaves a mark and no one in 2007 really needs to have that as part of their armoury. I'm glad we changed the law as we did and I'm sure it will go further in due course.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 28/03/2007 16:29

Ekra, tbh, my attitude is what I do in the privacy of my own home is my business. I hate all these bloody laws. I suppose I wouldn't be able to smack in puiblic then ?
It's some what of an irrelvance to me as smacking is always a last resort and certainly I don't remember ever having to smack in public anyway as my children are always very well behaved in the great outdoors.

About leaving a mark? I don't know, I've never checked.

Judy1234 · 28/03/2007 16:28

Cat, we can all lose control. Plenty of husbands and wives hit each other never mind hit their children but that doesn't mean I'd like to see wife beating decriminalised.

Judy1234 · 28/03/2007 16:27

ekra, I was trying to get across the fact that for most practical purposes we do have a smacking ban - (if it leaves a mark etc which it usually does) so those admitting it on this thread risk prosecution which is a good thing too. It is never right to use physical force against a child. Obviously I would prefer if it were banned even if it didn't leave marks as that's a clearer message to the smackers.

And yes if someone isn't coping with their chidlern they need help not a vindication and pat on the back, carry on smacking if it works for you which is why for some mothers and fathers it's just not right to be with the children 24/7. Some children are in effect saved from a parent who doesn't really cope well with being ap arent 24/7 by going to nursery.

catASTROPHE · 28/03/2007 16:23

ekra "Are you saying you cannot control your urge to smack and that if the law changed you wouldn't be able to stop yourself? "

well, yes and no. I'm not saying I have no control over my bahavior - of course I do, and I am responsible for my own actions.

But when (if?) you have shouted at your kids, or at your DH for that matter, you probably did it in a moment of anger or whatever, so in that sense it was not 'controlled' behaviour.

I'm sure you're thinking I must be a terrible psychopath who is out of control. Can you see though, that we all lose control at some times, otherwise we would all be able to adhere to our own moral code all of the time and be perfect. Which would be nice.

QueenBrenda · 28/03/2007 15:26

"the petty name calling and over exageration of situations is nothing but childish. "

never a truer word ....

prettybird · 28/03/2007 15:26

Wellowrose: Nowhere have I assumed that - I have used them purely as exmaples of alternatives that could to some children be worse than smacking.

What I have done, to be construcitve is to satart a thread Non-smacking parenting for really challenging kids and incredibly hard situations for people to suggest alternatives to those (not just catASTROPHE) who are finding it hard to cope.

Even though I no longer smack (through my own choice and not as a result of these threads), and do not consider that I am struggling, I have found some useful suggestions there.

I look forweard to seeing your contributions on the other thread!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread