Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want MIL to wash hands?

188 replies

archiesmummy · 25/03/2007 16:48

Hiya all, I'm back on MN after quite a long absense. For you who don't remember me I have a DS who is now 15 montsh old (wow, where did all that time go?).

I was in te room next to the bathroom recently when MIL used the toilet and she never washed her hands and now I've become paranoid about it.

We are hardly ever there, becuase they smoke in the house, but sometimes (rarely though as I must admit to not trusting v many ppl with ds) mil comes here to sit ds and now I don't want her to touch him at all. Surely the bacteria will spread to my ds and can be dangerous?

She also wiped DS face with a tissue she spat on to get it wet before I had a chance to get a flannel.
And she let DS steal a spoon from a coffee shop because it kept him quiet and when I confronted her about this she said "They have so many spoons" (doh)

I think because of her lack of basic hygiene and morals she shouldn't spend too much time with DS but DH thinks I'm overreacting.

Am I being unreasonable? What would you do about this?

OP posts:
mousiemousie · 25/03/2007 17:35

Think of all the "how clean is your house" programmes.

They find numerous colonies of potentially dangerous bacteria in the frankly shocking kitchens and bathrooms but the owners of the houses have lived like this for donkeys years without getting ill from them.

The actual danger to your ds is probably considerably lower than at a playgroup with shared toys.

Relax!

hunkermunker · 25/03/2007 17:30

AM, how is your sister?

hunkermunker · 25/03/2007 17:30

No, I use leaves and a shitty stick.

archiesmummy · 25/03/2007 17:29

Yes there is a huge difference between dirt and poo (or even wee).
Of course DS is walking and putting things in his mouth. The other day he even managed to suck on a cigarette butt before I managed to take it from him, and before anyone says anything, yes i did feel like a bad mum....

Well done Hillary for asking people if they have washed their hands, I wish I was brave enough for that.

Thanx hunker for support, felt a bit lonely there for a while

OP posts:
Katy44 · 25/03/2007 17:29

Do one-offs happen? Surely hand washing is a habit - I sometimes think I don't need to wash my hands (if for example I'm going to empty the bin - I'll wash them thoroughly after that) but find that I've done it anyway without thinking.

Blandmum · 25/03/2007 17:29

I'm not saying we shouldn't wasjh hands, I'm saying one shouldn't go OOT about it.

This is all about relative risk.

If someone is making food for large numbers of people, and has poor hygine, the relative risk is far worse. In part because the bacteria will get directly into the food.

Touching the skin, which forms an impermiable barrier to bacteria is far less risky. The surface of the skin is the first layer of the immune system.

trillium · 25/03/2007 17:28

Do all those on here who are a bit anal (see what I did there?)about the washing of hands after you've been to the loo not use toilet paper? Personally my hands never touch my nether regions, that's what the paper is for.

Every child has to have their face wiped with a spitted hanky - it's a rite of passage surely?

SherlockLGJ · 25/03/2007 17:27

My dinner is not brown MB, you carry on...

hunkermunker · 25/03/2007 17:25

Then why the fuss re staff in catering establishments washing their hands?

Blandmum · 25/03/2007 17:25

The Curse of The Biology Teacher

We have a lasagne on the go!

SquareSausage · 25/03/2007 17:24

This is a nice teatime conversation MB!
i think I'll go check on the beef casserole!

HillarysDancingInTheFairyField · 25/03/2007 17:23

yes my dd1 also became very ill after getting a nasty bug from someone not washing their hands she had to be admitted to hospital as she wasnt keeping down fluids. I dont care what remarks i get amymore
i always ask.

Blandmum · 25/03/2007 17:22

Oh and if it wasn't for the bateria in your shitm you'd be cronically constipated. !/3 to 1/2 of your turns are made up of dead bacteria, mostly E coli

Blandmum · 25/03/2007 17:21

We all have between 200-250 different species of bacteria on us at all times. In fact the other layer of our skin is actually protected by a layer of bacteria.

Bacterial cells on and in us, outnumber our own cells 10 to 1! (this is possible since bacteria are 1000 times smaller than our cells).

Excessive washing is actually harmful, since it strips our skins of this protective layer.

Washing after defication is a good idea, but I wouldn't get het up about it. Urine is sterile.

hunkermunker · 25/03/2007 17:21

Dirt, maybe, but difference between a bit of grubbiness and germs from shit.

tissy · 25/03/2007 17:20

Your 15 month old will no doubt be crawling or even walking by now. I expect he has put/ will put all sorts of things in his mouth that you will not be able to disinfect first. I think you need to relax a bit- for a start you don't know your MIL didn't wash her hands, you only think so. You don't know it wasn't a one-off.

If you make an issue out of this, then you will alienate your dh's family and probably him as well, do you really want that?

You eat a peck of dirt before you die!

hunkermunker · 25/03/2007 17:19
SquareSausage · 25/03/2007 17:19

You admit to not being very trusting about leaving ds with many people. Maybe thats the real issue.
MIL loves ds as much as you and will look after him to the best of her ability.
Let DH take you out so you can relax and see if you can leave DS with her for a bit.
He will come back in one piece!
I do agree with you about the handwashing though.
However my DS is 18mnths old and puts his shoes in his mouth, so I try and keep a wee bit of perspective about how much bacteria he is being exposed to!

violetsmum · 25/03/2007 17:19

Would you really ask everyone if they've washed their hands Hilary ? How old are your dcs. I could understand if a few weeks old , but after that, surely exposure to a few germs does them good.

How about if dcs hold onto a bar on the bus, that other people have touched, or touch a door handle etc, do you get`out the sanitary wipes then?

Kids should wash their hands before meals, imo, but asking others to wash their hands before holding kids?

Of course I would expect most people to wash their hands after going to the toilet...

McCadburysDreamyegg · 25/03/2007 17:18

You'd find many victims at a motorway service station I watch many people flush and go

hunkermunker · 25/03/2007 17:17

I don't ask people if they've washed their hands before going near the DSs.

But I do set fire to people who I know are habitual offenders in the flush and go stakes.

Boco · 25/03/2007 17:16

did she do a poo or a pee? Maybe she didn't do either, maybe she was just checking her makeup, and flushed a tissue away?

CanAiry · 25/03/2007 17:14

Message deleted

Blandmum · 25/03/2007 17:12

Goodness, if Old Lady Spittle was dangerous, none of my generation would still be alive!

Unless she has TB or hepatitis I'd try not to worry

lulumama · 25/03/2007 17:12

that is the most intelligent thing i have mustered up today sherlock !!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread