Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to want this to happen?

38 replies

Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 16:47

My parents are control freaks, but comparitively wealthy ones:

They have always given the boys a cheque for their birthday /christmas of £300 each - which is great I have invested it in a unit trust for them.

But my dads latest idea is to set up a stakeholder pension for them which they can't access until they are 50. He wants to put in £3500 each for them this year. However we didn't get the £300 for christmas.

His reasoning is that he likes the idea of them thinking of him when he is dead ie; when they are 50 and they access the money.

Yes, i should be grateful and I know lots of kids get nothing from their grand parents bu the whole thing makes me feel uneasy. I would much rather that they had some money when they were 18 to pay for university, go travelling, house deposit or even blow on drink, drugs and loose women.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Freckle · 25/03/2007 20:42

Bugger. Parents' motivation. Sorry.

3easterbunniesandnomore · 25/03/2007 20:42

Drugs, including alcohol and tabacco are all dangerous, and surely we can but try to keep our Kids away from them....!
Like I say, you obviously really have bad issues with your parents and thereofre it would be difficult for others to understand your point of view, iykwim...

Freckle · 25/03/2007 20:41

I don't think you are unreasonable. However, there is clearly a lot more behind your relationship with your parents which you haven't shared with us. Therefore responses are based solely on your OP.

If there are clear reasons to doubt your parents motivation, then possibly responses might differ.

Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 20:00

Lisa - that is a great idea. Compromise is normally the best option.

OP posts:
Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 19:59

I don't take their money - they practically walk over us on the way to see their grandkids. We are an inconvience.

I'll go and do something useful now, like make their packed lunches.

Anyway, thanks for the thoughts - its good to get some outside perspective. When ever I do these threads - I'm always told that i am being unreasonable.

OP posts:
lisad123 · 25/03/2007 19:58

Could you not ask them to put £3000 into pension for them and still give them £300 at christmas?
I think its wonderful you get some much help from grandparents. My inlaws give us sod all for our daugther, and my parents arent in position to give money, but give time.

If not I would be grateful for what they give you and let them do what they want.
Lisa

Kif · 25/03/2007 19:56

I don't get this 'start in life' logic.

NHS gives your kids their 'start in life, followed by state education, followed by excellent unis with minimal upfront payment.

Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 19:56

Why?

Drugs are not the spawn of satan - alcohol and tobacco are just as dangerous in some ways.

For the majority of kids they try it, grow out of it and get on with their lives. Its as much of youth culture as binge drinking, teenage sex, anorexia and yes hating your parents

OP posts:
3easterbunniesandnomore · 25/03/2007 19:52

YOu obvoiusly feel very strongly and badly about your parents, and I am sure you have your reasons...but, if they are that bad, why take money from them at all?

3easterbunniesandnomore · 25/03/2007 19:51

sorry Kaz, I think you are mad, yes....of course, your Kids shall enjoy their youth and must make their own mistakes...but to basically say that you actually wouldn't mind them taking drugs, is shocking...

Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 19:51

Yes, but there will be other money avaliable from them when they are 18+ - that's when I scared they will start to manipulate them.

If they had their own money avaliable to them they would have more chance of making their own choices.

Maybe this only makes sense to me, but I am now 37 and it is only in the last three years or so that I have untangled the mess my life was in. Unfortunately my parents loom large in the mess and i am so scared of them doing it to my kids.

I can make this decision - just still undecided what to do.

OP posts:
prufrock · 25/03/2007 19:38

But once they have put the money into a pension for our kids there is no way they can get it back. So whilst your kids can't get at the money until they are 50, your parents can't refuse them it then. So no possibility of manipulation, which there would be if the moeny was put into a trust with your parents as trustees and deciding when and if they could have access. And having a pension pot started now for the will give huge growth by te time they are 50, is a very tax efficient way for your parents to give (GB will put an extra 20% on top) and will mean better cash flow for your kids when they are 30 as they won't have to put as much into their retirment savings. (Ta 30 you should be putting at least 10% of incoem into pension savings to give same standard of living post retirement)
Honestly, I think this is a brillinat idea all round - go fill in the forms

Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 19:26

Well actually it does, as they can't start the pension without me doing the money laundering things

OP posts:
nikkie · 25/03/2007 19:17

I got mine at 18 and bought a house!

I would think its better at 18 or even up to 30 to get started in life as the better startt htey get on independance the better retirement they'll have.

LucyJones · 25/03/2007 19:17

But if they give it now they can still manipulate them presumably? I really wouldn't worry about it, at the end of the day it doesn't actually have that much to do with you tbh

Kaz33 · 25/03/2007 19:14

Sorry, why can't they blow the money on drink drugs and loose woman - sounds totally reasonable to me and sometimes part of the growing up process.

You think I am mad, but I know that letting my parents any where near my kids future lives and careers is a BAD THING. By giving the money that they want to give in a pension means that they got lots of time to manipulate them in the meantime.

No good will come of it.

OP posts:
Judy1234 · 25/03/2007 18:43

This was part of the problem that this silly labour government caused when it changed tax law last year to make money harder to leave in trust beyond 18 without adverse consequences. Plenty of press articles about the dangers of 18 year olds getting money. 50 is a bit old but that may be the only easy way now because of tax law changes to leave it - either 18, or a complex trust with tax consequences or a pension. I'm not sure.

3easterbunniesandnomore · 25/03/2007 18:23

Kaz:
"or even blow on drink, drugs and loose women. "

Hm...I hope that statement was made flippantly.

I think you are unreasonable, it is their money, they can spend it whichever way they may. In the end they don't have to give any money to you or your children....

myermay · 25/03/2007 18:10

Message withdrawn

DANCESwithaTruckLoadOfMiniEggs · 25/03/2007 18:01

I think 50 is a bit old but I had a friend at university who got his when he was 18 and wasted the lot. I got a small sum from my grandparents when I was 25 and dh and I used it as part of the deposit for our first home. MIL is thinking of leaving dc a bit of money and I've asked for her to say it is not accessible until they are 25 at least.

scatterbrain · 25/03/2007 17:56

I had a trust fund that matured when I was 18 - I blew it on clothes, a car and other fripperies ! I wish I hadn't been able to get it until about 25 - 30 - then it would ahve really really helped with buying first house etc.

My dd has a trust fund from gps too - she will not be wasting it !

I think it is a lovely and generous offer - could you maybe ask him to make it 30 - on the grounds that he could then SEE what good it had done - ie. see the house it allowed to be bought etc ?

wanderingstar · 25/03/2007 17:51

Well I don't think you really get to choose when a third party gives your children money like this, but I do agree it perhaps would be more useful at 25 or 30.

tortoiseSHELL · 25/03/2007 17:45

That sounds a fantastic idea to me - very generous! I think accessing it at 18 would be BAD idea!!!

ArcticRoll · 25/03/2007 17:42

Gosh sound like very generous grandparents and a great idea imo.

beckybrastraps · 25/03/2007 17:37

It is their money. They want to spend it one way. You want them to spend it another. You think they are the control freaks...

Swipe left for the next trending thread