Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel I won't regret not having kids - or will I?

155 replies

pudding24 · 08/07/2017 18:26

Probably been asked a million times, but I need to ask...

I'm in my late twenties, happily married, DH doesn't want kids and I don't think I do either. Reasons being:

  • I've had anxiety (and sometimes depression as a result) all my life and I've managed to reach a place of happiness by keeping my life simple and taking on as few responsibilities as possible. I think I would find being responsible for anything 24/7 stressful to the point of making me unhappy.
  • I was a difficult teenager and my brother (who's some way younger than me so I was/am more like a parent to him) even worse. I was bullied and had anxiety/depression; my brother self-harmed, was suicidal, and has Asperger's and still lives at home unable to work. I have no idea how my mum stayed strong through all that and I know I could not go through that myself.
  • DH and I both hate working and want to work hard now so we can have a future where we are financially more free and can perhaps go part-time and enjoy our lives, maybe see the world, etc.

My worries on the other hand are:

  • Ending up old and alone.
  • Not leaving any trace in the world once I'm gone; not having any purpose.

Pragmatically, I feel like if I do leave it too late and regret it, I could always adopt, but if I have kids, I can never un-have them.

But when you have so little time to decide as a woman, how do you know that you won't regret it?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 16/04/2022 09:35

OP you might find this article useful.

www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/living-single/202003/7-reasons-not-fear-regret-about-not-having-kids

darlingdodo · 16/04/2022 09:33

For every lady with 6 daughters who come to visit there will be another with 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 or 6 sons and/or daughters who never visit her. Having children does not automatically guarantee that they will remain in your life as you get older, and it's certainly not a good enough reason for having children - heaven knows there are enough threads on here that show how fractured families can be.

georgarina · 16/04/2022 09:23

I just always knew I wanted kids so I can't speak for not being sure.

But when I was in hospital I was in a bay with three other women - one was an older woman who had been happily childfree but now her friends were too old to visit her and her husband's mobility wasn't good, and she said to the nurse that she hadn't thought of things like that when she was younger.

Another was in her 30's and needed a hysterectomy for cancer before having children. She said she had not factored this into her family plans (of course) when she was asked how she felt now the decision was taken away from her - obviously nothing she could do about it and she didn't seem to express anything overly emotional but made me think.

The last was an elderly lady with dementia who had six daughters. At least one of them came every day, checked up with the nurses, brought her things, and sat with her.

That experience made a big impact on me.

Poppins17 · 16/04/2022 09:11

@Nouveaunew Greta to hear things worked out for you! We are still childless, and sometimes I question our decision .. but we’re happy and that’s all we can ask for. Life is too incredibly short, and precious to be anything else!

Nouveaunew · 15/04/2022 23:27

@Poppins17 & anyone else who sees this! I googled this too and found this thread! I’d be curious how it worked out for the OP @pudding24 . My own opinion has changed dramatically . I’m 100% I don’t want them - I’m early 40s - whereas i really wanted children when I was younger. I grieved it and mourned & now I’m so at peace with the way things worked out

Poppins17 · 26/01/2020 10:14

I found myself googling this question this morning and came across this old thread.

Three years on I’m just wondering if those who decided not to have children still feel the same way ie no regrets?

reetgood · 09/07/2017 13:22

I think if you commit to a decision, you're unlikely to regret it. I'm pregnant with my first child at 37, and now is the right time. But I always knew that my answer to children was yes, it just took a while for it be yes, now. Oh, and while it's not the case for everyone, it took 6 months of trying very casually for us. You do still have time although it sounds unlikely that you'll change your mind.

Re legacy, you don't need kids for that. I worked with a woman who founded and ran a charity. She was single most of her adult life. Her funeral filled a large church, and was an amazing occasion. She is remembered every day by those who worked with her and the charity continues. It wasn't what she set out to achieve - she just did what she was good at - but it's definitely a legacy to be proud of.

It doesn't need to be big legacy either. You can make a small difference that will be well remembered. You can just be, and people will remember you.

Trills · 09/07/2017 13:08

most people here did decide or end up having children

I wonder how many "ended up" rather than "decided".

JugglingFromHereToThere · 09/07/2017 12:50

Obviously most people here did decide or end up having children, including me. But that doesn't mean I can't see that it's absolutely the right choice for some people not to have them. You can't do everything in this life. If you take one path you can't always take the other as well.

Hope you will feel able to continue to do what feels right for you.

swingofthings · 09/07/2017 12:42

There is no right and wrong answers. There are people who can't wait to have kids, feel very broody, and although I think few actually truly regret their children, many find parenting not as fantastic as they'd imagine and some will say that they wished they'd done it differently.

You do have the opposite though! I have a close friend who always said she wouldn't have children, that she wasn't maternal, that she was too selfish to have children and wouldn't be a good mum. She said she enjoyed her independence too much. When she announced that she got pregnant after being with her partner for only a few months (and never really went over whether it was kind of planned or not!), we were all silently worried. It didn't help that she suffered from horrific morning sickness and at one time I really thought she would resort to an abortion. Yet the moment her son was put on her chest she fell in love with him and turn into this mother earth type of person! She loved being a mum of a newborn (to be fair, he was a little angel!), and suddenly had no interest in doing anything that wasn't baby related. He is now 9, she is still with the dad, and her life revolves around him. I would never ever have thought this to be the outcome.

What you have to accept is that whatever decision you end up making, you'll be stuck with it BUT most people make it work, whether it is having children because however hard work they are, almost all parents do love their children deeply or if you do decide not to have children and sometimes wonder if it was an error, you will get on with it and make the best of your child free life.

Auldspinster · 09/07/2017 12:40

I'm surprised no one has popped up to ask why this thread is on a parenting forum.

I've never wanted children and at 42 my childbearing years are rapidly coming to an end.

I have a toddler nephew who I adore and another one the way but his arrival confirmed motherhood wasn't for me.

It's amazing how many people with children seem to take my childlessness as an afront to their choice. If I had a pound for every time I'd been told I'd change my mind I'd have quite a tidy sum!

GreenHillsOfHome · 09/07/2017 12:33

I'd do anything to not have him here

That's not a 'normal' way to feel IMO - not to that, drastic, degree anyway.

If you seriously feel that way, I'd suggest GP as a first stop to rule out depression and the like and then SS next. If you truly feel that strongly then he'd probably be better off being adopted or in foster care.

DameDiazepamTheDramaQueen · 09/07/2017 12:33

You have a good while yet. Personally,I'd wait and see how you feel at 30, my biological clock suddenly started ticking as loudly as Big Ben when I got to 30.

I think the fact you are posting probably means you aren't sure and will possibly regret it. The majority of people don't regret it, of course there are a few who do but by and large kids are a good thingSmile

Beelzebop · 09/07/2017 12:25

I think if you're thinking about it you will regret it. I do know a fair number er of people who really didn't want kids and then suddenly did as they reached 30, 40, even 50. You're doing the right thing though, having a good think. X

IrritatedUser1960 · 09/07/2017 12:24

Bugger wrong thread - menopause strikes again.

IrritatedUser1960 · 09/07/2017 12:23

Very sorry if I've been insensitive my dear, I am the result of an abusive childhood followed by being a battered wife and now have the menopause. Having a hard shell has helped me to survive life and although I am actually kind and caring it doesn't always come across.
So love and hugs to you and apologies for not understanding Flowers

RestlessTraveller · 09/07/2017 12:20

I love these threads, it's like I've found my people! Yep, I knew being saddled with children wasn't for me in my early 20's and I still have that thought 20 years on.

tinypop4 · 09/07/2017 12:15

minions how old is your Ds? I am really sorry to hear you feel that way, that's really sad for both of you. However, it's not the representative view of most parents for the benefit of the op

tinypop4 · 09/07/2017 12:13

It is better not to have a child for the reasons you say, than to have one because it's the done thing then do not enjoy it or feel resentful.
Don't question yourself- you don't need to justify it to anyone if it's right for you then that is totally fine! It is also fine to change your mind later in life if that's what decision you make.

BadLad · 09/07/2017 12:10

minionsarecute thanks for sharing, a perspective we don't see very often on here.

minionsarecute · 09/07/2017 11:41

I was always desperate for a child. I a=was very nieve and didn't know anything about children.

I regret having my Son with every cell in my body.

Parenting is shit. It's tiring, exhausting, worrying, relentless, restrictive.

I was SO much happier before I had my Son and I feel like I'm living a prison sentence. I cannot wait until he is 18 and gone. Even once he's 18 he may very well have problems.

My brother has aspergers and has been nothing but misery for my parents. I don't know why I was so stupid to have a child.

I have a decent job but my Son means I cannot socialise after work. I can't get a moments peace outside of work. I'd do anything to not have him here.

I don't think you will regret it at all. Parenting is awful and I don't know why anyone chooses to do it!

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 09/07/2017 11:24

To the pp talking about fertility decreasing after the age of 30...yes, that's true however as my obstetric consultant explained to me, those stats need re-evaluated. Women are now living longer with a better quality of life because they're looking after their health. The things that decreased fertility when those stats were valid are no longer dominant factors. Only 10 years ago a pregnant woman in her late 30's was referred to as "geriatric primagravida" (for first pregnancies). Nowadays women having children in their late 30's and early 40's are much more common and this term is no longer used.

OP only you know if you'll regret not having children but perhaps stop worrying about it and enjoy living in the now for a bit x

pudding24 · 08/07/2017 20:53

Thanks everyone it's really helpful to hear others' stories.

Have you spent much time Arline children? How do you feel when you hold a baby

I really like children and babies and sometimes feel sad there are none in my life - I have no close friends or family with babies currently. I did love when my brother was young and I looked after him a lot. I would be a totally willing babysitter. But I do get the feeling I would always be happy to hand them back at the end of the day.

OP posts:
ragged · 08/07/2017 20:33

You're right, you can't know. You just make the best decision you can at the time. Life is full of disappointments regardless -- you could also end up regetting having kids, it can go both ways. Whatever happens you have to make the most of it, so doesn't make sense to worry too much about making a "right" decision. Try to appreciate the luxury that modern women have that we even have choices about our fertility.

After the age of 30, fertility starts to diminish dramatically. With each passing year, your chances of conceiving drops quite rapidly.

I rather wish I had ignored that advice when I heard it 20 yrs ago. Listening to that advice is how I ended up with 3 unplanned children. Come to think of it, my grandmother had a similar experience. They were also unwanted children in her case.

I reckon I would have been fine without kids. I don't understand people gripped by grief about their own fertility. I'm not saying they're wrong, I'm saying I can't imagine I could have ever felt that way. Being child-free is fine.

Trills · 08/07/2017 20:31

I must say if you are coming on here asking 'will I regret not having children?' Then I believe you will regret not having them.

This comes up a lot and I always disagree.

Having children is presented as the default choice. It is presented as the natural thing for a woman to do and to want to do.

A woman debating "do I want to do this" does not necessarily want it. She simply knows that it is expected of her, and is making sure to give it serious consideration before deciding not to. do it. After all, everyone else supposedly wants it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread