Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel I won't regret not having kids - or will I?

155 replies

pudding24 · 08/07/2017 18:26

Probably been asked a million times, but I need to ask...

I'm in my late twenties, happily married, DH doesn't want kids and I don't think I do either. Reasons being:

  • I've had anxiety (and sometimes depression as a result) all my life and I've managed to reach a place of happiness by keeping my life simple and taking on as few responsibilities as possible. I think I would find being responsible for anything 24/7 stressful to the point of making me unhappy.
  • I was a difficult teenager and my brother (who's some way younger than me so I was/am more like a parent to him) even worse. I was bullied and had anxiety/depression; my brother self-harmed, was suicidal, and has Asperger's and still lives at home unable to work. I have no idea how my mum stayed strong through all that and I know I could not go through that myself.
  • DH and I both hate working and want to work hard now so we can have a future where we are financially more free and can perhaps go part-time and enjoy our lives, maybe see the world, etc.

My worries on the other hand are:

  • Ending up old and alone.
  • Not leaving any trace in the world once I'm gone; not having any purpose.

Pragmatically, I feel like if I do leave it too late and regret it, I could always adopt, but if I have kids, I can never un-have them.

But when you have so little time to decide as a woman, how do you know that you won't regret it?

OP posts:
Barbieshoe · 21/04/2022 09:07

I don’t think you are being unreasonable at all OP.
At 36 and single by choice and childfree for similar reasons to you. I am aware that my choices wouldn’t be for everyone, but they are right for me. I have felt the same way since I was a teen. Sometimes the road less travelled is the one we’re destined to take.
It takes courage to do things differently, when most people do things one way, it’s natural to question the decision to do things differently and wonder if we’ll regret it. There is social pressure to do what others do, and so many people are happy with children and will tell you so, and we are naturally inclined to want what others want / seem to value. But that doesn’t mean it is right for you!

I have the same fears about being elderly and alone, but my mum is teaching me a lot abiut how to get through old age:

She lost my dad when she was just 60, and it coincided with me and my brother leaving home to go to uni. So she has been living on her own for nearly 20 years now. Many of her friends have also lost husbands. Their children are my age and older, with children and careers of their own. From what I can see, it is friendship networks that really matter when you get to be in your 70s and 80s. Other retired, single people who are your age or slightly younger. Our family gets together every Christmas and birthday and it’s lovely to do that. But we’re also welcoming of our old ‘aunties’ into these gatherings, and if my mum didn’t have us, I think she would be invited into the families of some of her dear friends. I hope my old age will be like this. And when is comes to serious old age and declining health, when I am bedridden and at the of my days, I want a) to have saved up money to pay for the care I may need and b) to look back at my life and know that I lived it the best way I knew how. And be glad that my life brought happiness to others, including my parents, and that my death will not be the cause of too much misery for anyone.

Make the decision that feels right in your bones, you can be open to changing your mind, but only do so when and if you feel differently about it.

bbgxd · 21/04/2022 08:48

@NevaehMind

*My worries on the other hand are:
  • Ending up old and alone.
  • Not leaving any trace in the world once I'm gone; not having any purpose*

None if the above are reasons to have kids.

Yes it's true adult children abandon their parents, but realistically, it's about family. When your parents are gone, and it's just your siblings (if you have them, who may or may not even have their own kids)... it can feel aimless. I say this as a young person with basically no family.

So yeah, it does make sense to want to create your own. Also, if you have kids younger, it's different to at the last minute, say 20 vs 42.

When the 42yo is 80, their child will be 38. When the 20yo is 80, their child will be 60, a more similar age. It's not spoken about, but I think this pays a role too in loneliness in older people.

Bottom line is, you should never depend on your children for company because you can't predict how they'll act. Yes, have friends, but equally lots of people want to continue their family through children and maybe grandchildren.

Lhddujvf · 21/04/2022 08:23

I wish more people had told me how wonderful having a baby is. I left it until I was nearly 41. I too suffered with anxiety, in fact I was hospitalised 10 years ago on a mental health unit. I can honestly say having children has personally made me mentally stronger and more resilient as there's nothing I wouldn't do for my child. I, like a lot of people on here have done a lot with my life but I can honestly say having a baby has tops the lot, it has been incredible. If I'd have known I wouldn't have left it so late. I wake up and everyday I wake up feeling so happy. I wanted to say all of this as I see threads like this and read many 'negative' posts but I'm not sure how representative a thread is to real life experiences outside of here. As with threads in generally, you're more likely to read negativity and perhaps that's because some people don't like to feel like they're bragging about how great their life is. I only wish I had time for another one.

Rinatinabina · 21/04/2022 08:20

I love DD but my life was a lot easier and mental health was a lot better before I had her. I think I could have been very happy childfree. If you had a difficult time growing up children can trigger an enormous amout of anxiety in you. I wouldn’t have them unless you really really want them. Lot of work, beautiful and funny but extremely time consuming and for me I know I will never feel quite at peace again, I’ll always worry about DD.

I absolutely don’t expect DD to keep me company in my old age, we’ve moved around as a couple and I kind of assumed she would do the same. Don’t assume your kids will stick around.

I really am surprised that people who choose not to have kids are still questioned over it. I don’t know anyone who would care whether someone else had kids or not (except MIL, who is very lovely generally) Makes you think society really hasn’t moved on much if that’s still a surprise.

Sofasogood1 · 21/04/2022 08:08

'Marry, and you will regret it; don’t marry, you will also regret it; marry or don’t marry, you will regret it either way. Laugh at the world’s foolishness, you will regret it; weep over it, you will regret that too; laugh at the world’s foolishness or weep over it, you will regret both. Believe a woman, you will regret it; believe her not, you will also regret it… Hang yourself, you will regret it; do not hang yourself, and you will regret that too; hang yourself or don’t hang yourself, you’ll regret it either way; whether you hang yourself or do not hang yourself, you will regret both. This, gentlemen, is the essence of all philosophy.'

Søren Kierkegaard

iloveeverykindofcat · 21/04/2022 07:26

I know I won't regret it because my genes are shite and it would be irresponsible. My family is absolutely riddled with mental and physical health problems on both sides. Its irresponsible to have a child because you fear loneliness. Children are people. You can't create them for the sake of giving them responsibility for your happiness (well you can, but you shouldn't). I still feel responsible for my mother's happiness or lack thereof, but that's another story. Anyway you sound like you know this really. Sounds like you've got a good head on your shoulders OP.

SScoobiedoo · 21/04/2022 06:16

You don't have to have children - you could have one child so put aside 18 years of varying responsibility - having , say, 3 can span many more years

lameasahorse · 20/04/2022 23:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

fruitcakepie · 20/04/2022 23:21

We have a lot of child free friends in their forties and they're never the ones moaning and groaning about life. They're off travelling and living life while us knackered, grumpy parents try to make ourselves feel better by telling them how much joy our kids have brought to our lives ha !

TheOGCCL · 20/04/2022 23:16

That last point about not leaving a trace. Most people stay in others' memories for a generation max. Not long in the scheme of human kind. Agree with others that having children doesn't mean you won't end up alone, we are all ultimately alone (lots of stories of people with plenty of family who died alone in Covid wards), and it's just not a good enough reason to have kids.

I don't regret not having children as I can't make it that I wanted them. I kind of wish I had had that biological, innate desire many women say they had, as the road less traveled is still slightly judged and everyone loves a wedding and babies - this pronatalism narrative is very pervasive and often persuasive.

In my view the people who think they can offer a great life to children, and are happy to make some sacrifices, should do it, not people who aren't convinced. There are some brilliant parents around and I take my hat off to them.

Finally just to note 'we can always adopt' is bandied around a lot. The adoption process is incredibly challenging and that is before you take on a child with a history. It's definitely not a back up option and something to be embraced in its own right.

NevaehMind · 20/04/2022 22:36

*My worries on the other hand are:

  • Ending up old and alone.
  • Not leaving any trace in the world once I'm gone; not having any purpose*

None if the above are reasons to have kids.

Duchess379 · 20/04/2022 21:20

I decided at a very early age that I didn't want kids. I was very careful with contraceptives to ensure no accidents occurred. Then, due to a medical condition, I had a hysterectomy at 38. I was elated. I'm 8 yrs down the road and have never regretted my decision not to have kids. I don't have maternal instincts at all.

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 16/04/2022 18:11

I know that I won't regret it because I've made an active, considered choice every single day of my adult life not to have kids.
People have regrets when they have'nt had autonomy over their own lives and bodies, or they've drifted through life without thought, or they've unquestioningly followed the herd.

CounsellorTroi · 16/04/2022 17:56

@MurmuratingStarling

Going against the grain.

Even though having children is no guarantee you won't end up alone in old age; in the experience of quite a number of people I know, you are more likely to end up alone in old age if you don't have children.

I know 4 women right now who live alone - all over 50 - who never had children (all by choice,) and they have been terribly lonely over the last 5-8 years. Lockdown really made it hit home.

3 of them have admitted they regret having no children, and it stings, and makes them sad, when they see their peers with young adult children, and grandchildren.

I also know of 3 men (over 65) who had no children, (2 of them are quite infirm now and struggle to get about anywhere.) And they have all struggled with loneliness over the past few years, and having no-one to help them with day to day stuff. The loneliness is a struggle for them, and it doesn't help seeing their neighbours with adult children and grandchildren visiting, and helping them out.

And before anyone has a go at me, my views and opinions are as valid as anyone else's.

Older people without children often put more effort into maintaining social networks and staying connected, precisely because they know they will not have children to rely on when they get older.
MargaretThursday · 16/04/2022 17:05

Thing is you won't necessarily know.

Friends of my parents "knew" at mid 20s. In fact they were so sure she got her tubes tied.

Mid 40s they changed their mind. Unfortunately the untying didn't work and they never had children. She's in her 80s and still refers to it as "her biggest regret". Which is really sad.

However I do know another couple who chose not to due to family history and are perfectly happy. They foster troubled older teens and love doing it and are absolutely brilliant at it. They say they've never had any regrets.

AmericanStickInsect · 16/04/2022 16:56

You don't need to know/make the decision now but for what it's worth your reasons for wanting to have children don't sway me to think you should, and your reasons for not wanting to are totally legit!
From observation, you will most likely be ok and happy whatever. I've known couples truly ache for children and have heartbreaking losses and infertility who have accepted and are authentically enjoying a life without children.
So if you're starting point is that you don't want them, and you come to experience times of regret, I think this will be manageable, acceptable and not define your life.
I'd you get to your thirties and desperately crave to have them in the current moment - that's a different situation and a time to reassess.
Go with you current plan now, reassess if/when necessary. You have time and don't need to be scared of a theoretical regret you're bit even sure you will have.

lameasahorse · 16/04/2022 16:25

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Coffeetree · 16/04/2022 16:14

"You can always adopt" is not true at all. Adoption is enormously expensive and was beyond my reach.

Rno3gfr · 16/04/2022 15:48

Op, after reading your update about how you do love babies and children it sort of changed my opinion on the advice I was planning to give. Also, given your reasons for not wanting them.

I was 20 when I accidentally fell pregnant and now have a 3 year old. Me and dp are low income but degree educated, so in many ways we’re lucky we have options. I’ve also always suffered with anxiety and depression, I’m also a massive introvert and I need my space. I found having a baby to be amazing, I loved it. I was alone but not alone in many ways with a baby. I had periods to recover while he was napping and I was at ease with it. However, I’ve found age 2.5+ very hard. He’s stopped napping, he’s very extroverted and speaks to other adults and children with ease when out and about all day (meaning I have to engage too) and generally he doesn’t stop talking- ever. I’m not the mum I thought I’d be and the logistics of having a child are difficult. However, I can manage with one child. We have good family support and I get a little time to myself every now and again. I don’t think I could manage without the family support. He’s going to be at nursery, so now I’m focusing time on my career and doing well. Financially, children are expensive but it depends what you spend your money on. With one child I don’t find our food bill is higher, there are lots of holidays where the child is free, I can get bargains at Tesco for his clothes. Basically, nursery fees are the brunt of the cost but he’ll be in full time school soon. In the long term, I think one child and future early retirement is manageable on two mid incomes, depending on what decisions are made.

My reason for explaining this is that if you desire a child but find the idea of it stressful, well, stop at one child. You kind of have the benefits from raising a kid but also a lot less stress as it’s a lot easier to concentrate on career and just one child.

I’m not trying to persuade you to have a child if you don’t want one, if you feel like you seriously don’t have children then don’t! You’ll have a great life either way. But if you are maternal, and you do have an inclination that you want a child, then maybe take the time to think about it so you don’t regret not doing it later on. I think everyone, whether they want kids or not should have a good think about it first. Also, having kids is no guarantee you won’t be alone when old, and you can definitely have a legacy without kids. I think if you were firm in your decision, you may not have posted on here? However, if it is societal pressure to conform to the ‘kids make a family’ stereotype then please ignore what I’ve posed and do your own thing.

PersonIrresponsible · 16/04/2022 15:33

Up until you hit your mid-forties, you'll constantly hear "You'll change your mind one day", then you'll hit your late forties and everyone will tell you how lucky you are.

And then there's those who will constantly tell you you don't understand (how fraught/awful life their life is) because you don't have children.

Meh. We're not all programmed to have children. Currently around 1/5 of women opt not to have children - a number that is increasing.

ChairCareOh · 16/04/2022 15:21

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

AlexaShutUp · 16/04/2022 15:10

The simple answer is, you can't know if you will regret it either way. I know child-free people who are extremely happy with their lives and I know child-free people who bitterly regret not having had children. Equally, I know parents who are blissfully happy with their lives and others who wish with all their hearts that they had never gone down the parenthood path.

None of us can insure ourselves against future regrets, as we can't possibly predict how we will feel about our lives several years from now and we can't possibly know how anything will pan out. All we can do is make considered decisions in the present, based on what we know in the here and now, and hope that we will look back on all of our decisions with the knowledge that they were made for the right reasons at the time.

There are no right or wrong answers to the question of whether or not you will be happier for having children or not having them. There are so many variables. All you can do is make whatever decision feels like the right fit for you.

Ilady · 16/04/2022 14:57

My feeling in life is that not every woman wants a family and your better off not having a child unless it's something that both you and your dh really want as a couple. Don't let family and friends push you into doing this because long term it not fair to have a child unless you're happy doing so.
You have suffered from anixity and depression in the past. What helps you with this to keep your life simple and not have a stressful job. For some people having a child can lead to post natal depression or bring other mental illness to the fore.
You have also told us that your husband does not want a child either.
Then you and your husband don't want to stay in full time work long term or perhaps you both want to retire early. So at the moment your working hard so you have the option of doing less hours or retiring early.
Also having a child or children in the hope that they will mind/support you in your old age may not happen. Children become adults with their own lives. They can't give up work to mind elderly parents or move back to family homes to do this.

MiladyBerserko · 16/04/2022 14:24

FGS. Why resurrect a zombie thread?

MiladyBerserko · 16/04/2022 14:23

Surely it's better to regret not having them, than to regret having them. If you aren't sure, don't do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread