Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel I won't regret not having kids - or will I?

155 replies

pudding24 · 08/07/2017 18:26

Probably been asked a million times, but I need to ask...

I'm in my late twenties, happily married, DH doesn't want kids and I don't think I do either. Reasons being:

  • I've had anxiety (and sometimes depression as a result) all my life and I've managed to reach a place of happiness by keeping my life simple and taking on as few responsibilities as possible. I think I would find being responsible for anything 24/7 stressful to the point of making me unhappy.
  • I was a difficult teenager and my brother (who's some way younger than me so I was/am more like a parent to him) even worse. I was bullied and had anxiety/depression; my brother self-harmed, was suicidal, and has Asperger's and still lives at home unable to work. I have no idea how my mum stayed strong through all that and I know I could not go through that myself.
  • DH and I both hate working and want to work hard now so we can have a future where we are financially more free and can perhaps go part-time and enjoy our lives, maybe see the world, etc.

My worries on the other hand are:

  • Ending up old and alone.
  • Not leaving any trace in the world once I'm gone; not having any purpose.

Pragmatically, I feel like if I do leave it too late and regret it, I could always adopt, but if I have kids, I can never un-have them.

But when you have so little time to decide as a woman, how do you know that you won't regret it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sbqprules · 22/04/2022 23:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

tsmainsqueeze · 22/04/2022 23:33

I have 3 kids , its been fun ,its also been bloody awful at times.
I am glad i have them but i can also see the other side and i know that life can be totally fulfilling without them.
I have no expectations of being looked after in my old age .
They are totally loved but i worry a lot about them and that can never be switched off, i think at times i annoy them and they definitely annoy me .
I do sometimes fantasise about a worry free life with no ties and responsibility.
Currently i am not enjoying being a mother to teenage /young adult children as much as i did when they were younger , the older ones need their own space now i think.
As in any relationship there are ups and downs , i think the mother and child one is probably the most intense.
No one can answer your question ,but as time passes i think if you do start to want them it becomes a very persistent niggle that you just can't ignore .
That became my experience after feeling a very definite no to kids until my mid 20's.

Nouveaunew · 22/04/2022 23:00

I know there are exceptions, but few people get their social life through their adult children

I never wanted children for this reason. I wanted children because I love children and I think I’d be a good mother. However, it sadly wasn’t meant to be.

however, it’s not the social life from children in old age that many childless people think about but the care. There have been horror stories from some nursing homes and what frightens me, if I’m honest, are the thoughts of losing my mind in old age and no-one being close enough to notice or to protect or help me …

darlingdodo · 22/04/2022 20:20

Murmurating, tbh, the people on Mumsnet saying motherhood is shit are those who have children. I don't know whether motherhood is shit or not, because I don't have children. I see it from the outside. Some parents seem to enjoy life with their children, others don't.

I think generally the motives of people who start such threads are to find out if women who choose not to have children (choose being the operative word - very different to women who can't have children) are happy with their decision and their childfree lives. It seems sensible to garner such opinions before deciding whether to embark on what will probably be the biggest journey of your life, for good or bad.

Childfree women are often told they'll never know real love, they're selfish, unnatural.

Women can't win - doesn't matter what we do.

MurmuratingStarling · 22/04/2022 13:19

Neverreturntoathread · 21/04/2022 16:37

There have been sooooooo many versions of this thread on Mumsnet through the years. I find them in very poor taste. Why come on a mums’ support site to muse on how crap you think it must be to be a mum?

This. ^ It's very unpleasant. Like I said though, it seems to be acceptable (on here) to berate motherhood and say it's a shit life being a mother, but God FORBID you berate child-free people. Hmm

What infuriates me, is that some people who bash motherhood are actually mothers themselves! (So they claim!) Wink I hate these threads, and I do wonder about the motives of people who start them.

MurmuratingStarling · 22/04/2022 13:14

TweetTweetMF · 21/04/2022 15:07

This is a zombie thread from 5 years ago....

Probably bumped up by someone who didn't notice the date it started. Like YOU don't seem to have noticed that about a dozen posters have already said (in the last few days) that this is a zombie thread! Wink

veronicagoldberg · 22/04/2022 09:56

@Neverreturntoathread

There have been sooooooo many versions of this thread on Mumsnet through the years. I find them in very poor taste. Why come on a mums’ support site to muse on how crap you think it must be to be a mum?
That isn't what it's about at all. Maybe try and develop some nuance in your thinking.
707smile · 21/04/2022 23:19

If you were with someone other than your husband and they wanted to start a family, would you want to have kids in that situation?

If you make a decision, partly based on your DH, you're much more likely to regret it. If you really don't want kids yourself then your DH not wanting them won't factor into your decision.

Nouveaunew · 21/04/2022 22:45

@Neverreturntoathread
i can’t speak for everyone else but i came on this thread after a Google search to somehow make peace with my dream of having children not coming true.

I guess everyone is different. I think lots of people don’t want kids but are afraid they’ll change their mind. I say go with how you feel instead of projecting too far forward if you don’t want them. On the other hand, if you do want them, projecting forward is your friend and planning required, as I learned. I think people should be allowed to come on mumsnet for all kinds of reasons and the sheer variety of threads surely means it needn’t be exclusionary or prescriptive.

Goldijobsandthe3bears · 21/04/2022 16:48

This was from 5 years ago, I wonder if the OP remains child free 😄

Neverreturntoathread · 21/04/2022 16:37

There have been sooooooo many versions of this thread on Mumsnet through the years. I find them in very poor taste. Why come on a mums’ support site to muse on how crap you think it must be to be a mum?

CounsellorTroi · 21/04/2022 16:31

splishsplashsploshsplish · 21/04/2022 16:28

@TweetTweetMF

This is a zombie thread from 5 years ago....
We know... still an interesting discussion on a public forum though.

Yes it is.

splishsplashsploshsplish · 21/04/2022 16:28

@TweetTweetMF

This is a zombie thread from 5 years ago....
We know... still an interesting discussion on a public forum though.
TweetTweetMF · 21/04/2022 15:07

This is a zombie thread from 5 years ago....

konasana · 21/04/2022 14:06

You do not need to decide right now anyway - you can think 'not right now' and just see how your feelings towards it change over time. Anyone could end up old and alone, whether they have children or not, and there are loads of ways to have an impact on the world that are less stressful!

If it helps at all, I am quite an anxious person sometimes and the feeling of responsibility for my child is sometimes overwhelming. I have a bad sibling relationship too and only have one child. I've found that the cost issue is less with one, I get tonnes more time to myself and a much calmer life with one child than is possible with two. Having a child, being a mother, is incredible. The love and joy it brings you on a day to day basis is very difficult to explain. The stress and worry when they are ill, or when you are exhausted and can't rest, are very challenging.

UhtredsLatestPaganHussy · 21/04/2022 14:00

It's impossible to regret having children.

That's a pretty silly thing to say. I would guess most people do not regret parenthood but to state categorically that it's impossible to regret it? Goodness me.

emmakenny · 21/04/2022 13:56

@MiniTheMinx

I was never keen on the idea. But then I got round to thinking about it.....and concluded you couldn't regret having children after the fact because your love for them is incompatible with regret. You could regret not having them. In short a void is more likely to cause regret. That doesn't mean that I don't or can't acknowledge how wonderful life might have been without them, only that my life now without them would be a very sorry one. It's impossible to regret having children.
I certainly do not regret my child at all but you are very wrong. It is not impossible to regret having a child. Look at all the posts you see on here. Look at parents who murder their children.
IcedPurple · 21/04/2022 13:44

Now in my 50s, I have always known I didn't want children. No regrets.

As for you, nobody can make the decision other than you yourself. You're still young so have a few years to make up your mind. I would say don't have kids just because 'it's what you do'. Children will change your life totally and permanently, and it's not something you should do just because it's the 'done thing'.

MiniTheMinx · 21/04/2022 13:36

I was never keen on the idea. But then I got round to thinking about it.....and concluded you couldn't regret having children after the fact because your love for them is incompatible with regret. You could regret not having them. In short a void is more likely to cause regret. That doesn't mean that I don't or can't acknowledge how wonderful life might have been without them, only that my life now without them would be a very sorry one. It's impossible to regret having children.

caringcarer · 21/04/2022 13:28

If you are unsure better not to have children who you don't want and might struggle to Manage given your MH issues, than live a perfectly content life without children. If you feel broody you could borrow a friend's children to take them for a day out and hand them back at end of the day. Too many parents have children they either don't really want or have no way to properly care for them.

MurmuratingStarling · 21/04/2022 13:20

Lhddujvf · 21/04/2022 08:23

I wish more people had told me how wonderful having a baby is. I left it until I was nearly 41. I too suffered with anxiety, in fact I was hospitalised 10 years ago on a mental health unit. I can honestly say having children has personally made me mentally stronger and more resilient as there's nothing I wouldn't do for my child. I, like a lot of people on here have done a lot with my life but I can honestly say having a baby has tops the lot, it has been incredible. If I'd have known I wouldn't have left it so late. I wake up and everyday I wake up feeling so happy. I wanted to say all of this as I see threads like this and read many 'negative' posts but I'm not sure how representative a thread is to real life experiences outside of here. As with threads in generally, you're more likely to read negativity and perhaps that's because some people don't like to feel like they're bragging about how great their life is. I only wish I had time for another one.

Lovely post. 😘

MurmuratingStarling · 21/04/2022 13:18

CounsellorTroi · 21/04/2022 13:12

I don’t see much motherhood bashing but what I do see comes from people who resent being pitied, patronised and condescended to by mothers because they don’t have children.

Now I don't see any of that. I just see motherhood bashing. Funny that isn't it?

CounsellorTroi · 21/04/2022 13:12

I don’t see much motherhood bashing but what I do see comes from people who resent being pitied, patronised and condescended to by mothers because they don’t have children.

MurmuratingStarling · 21/04/2022 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Very well put! 😘

MurmuratingStarling · 21/04/2022 13:07

@CounsellorTroi
Lots of people on here have said they regret having children and would not do so if they had their time again. Do you think they are saying this to make hypothetical people without children feel better, and that really they feel like you? I am not saying everyone feels like this but not everyone feels like you either.

Lots of people on here say they have a vile toxic abusive gaslighting husband too, or a nasty, catty, narcissistic mother in law. But in real life, many women DON'T have this kind of husband or mother in law. People only usually post when there is discord or misery. If people posted to say 'my husband is adorable, and we have a great life together, and he's my soulmate, and I love him so much,' they'd very likely be mocked and derided.

So just because 'lots of posters' come on here to say they regret motherhood, there are still many MANY more who don't. Again, if a poster came on and said she loved and adored her children so much, they're the best thing to happen to her - ever, and she would do it all over again, she would be mocked and derided, with lots of roll-eyes emojis.

I 'get' that some people are happy childfree, but the whole narrative that you get on here, that being a mum just stalls your life, and it will be just full of drudgery and misery forevermore, just fucks me right off tbh. As I said, these posters do NOT speak for me.

And it seems like it's OK to bash motherhood (and mothers,) and mock and deride them, and say 'your life will be ruined if you have kids and you will never sleep in again or travel again' but it's not OK to bash and deride childfree people, and the choice to NOT have children. And some of the derision and bashing comes from other mothers!

I don't know if they're trying to make childfree people feel better, but as I said they certainly do NOT speak for me. Becoming a mother is one of the best things to happen in my life. (and please spare me the 'you must have had a weak, boring, eventless life' comments people!)

I KNOW some people regret it, my auntie did actually, as her husband was emotionally abusive, and a useless husband AND father. She said (when my 2 cousins were 8 and 10,) that she would have had a much better life if she had never had children, as she would have found it much easier to leave him. He died when they had been married 35 years and the kids were in their early 30s. She is very much thrilled NOW that she had her 2 children, as they are her world now, and she has 3 adorable grandchildren, but at the time, yes she regretted it.

BUT, as I said, it's the whole motherhood bashing narrative that really irks me, and like I said before, it somehow doesn't seem quite so acceptable to bash childfree people. Some may say it's because childfree maybe get more of a hard time for having no children, but I (and some other mothers I know) had some HORRIBLE catty snide bitchy comments from childfree people when we first had children. Looking back, I think they were projecting, as they went on to have children 5-10 years later, but it was still upsetting to deal with at the time.