Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that DD's dp is cruel for not sending her anything for her first Mother's Day?

44 replies

BettyBarclay1511 · 23/03/2007 11:54

Their first baby is just three weeks old. I rang him a week before Mother's Day and asked him what he was doing - he replied "nothing". I said surely he would be doing something on my dd's first Mother's Day? He was adamant he was going to do nothing. I said that it was "normal" that dad's would send things on behalf of their children when the children are too little to do something themselves. I was astonished that he would be so cruel. His own mother died some years ago and I thought that he would have been a little more understanding. I knew that she would be heartbroken so I send her a bouquet of flowers via a courier - posted 2 cards (I couldn't decide which one was the nicest as I liked them both) and sent a box of chocs from her little baby boy. Her best friend even sent her a card from the baby and he's a man. So am I being unreasonable in thinking that my DD dp is cruel? After this episode I have lost every bit of respect I had for him.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thecranberiezzzz · 02/09/2023 23:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Kif · 23/03/2007 17:22

I'm a little mystified by this thread. My eldest is 3 - and I've never had anything for mothers day and never felt the least deprived.

pelvicflawed · 23/03/2007 15:35

My DH is lovely, thoughtful, caring etc but after getting his mothers card and present and my own it took a massive hint before the penny dropped that this year it was my first mothers day and just a little memento would be nice. In the end after a horrid week with DS in which we were both exhausted he finally remembered - in a not very subtle manner- at about 4pm on Saturday and rushed off to town. It was lovely to get a card and a gift but I was peeved after sorting out his own mothers present he forgot about me!!!!!. Of course I managed to sort out Fathers Day when DS was only about 5 weeks old without hints!!!! My mum sent me a small gift and to be honest that meant much more even though I didn't expect it. I know its over commercialised but all the same its nice to celebrate being a mum especially the first time.

baffledbybaby · 23/03/2007 15:32

My DD is 15 weeks and I didn't get a card from DP, but he knows me well enough to know it wouldn't bother me.
He didn't even get me a bouquet/card when DD was born again I wasn't bothered. neither of us bothered with valentines.
He concluded early on in our relationship that romantic gestures were lost on me apart from slap up meals
Agree you probably got his back up.

Stigaloid · 23/03/2007 15:16

I don't think you are being unreasonable. Having just gone through 9 months of pregnancy and recently given birth, a small token to celebrate your DD's new role as mother would have been kind and considerate.

Odd that he flat our refused to make such a gesture, but each person is different.

I don't think you should lose all respect for him - he may turn out to be a great husband and father in many other respects.

If it had been my DH and he hadn't got me something i would have been a little hurt. But then my DH is inredibly thoughtful and tends to make small but important gestures towards me that i really appreciate.

Your DD may love the fact that her DH doesn't buy into mother's day or do the small things. He may be brilliant and the big things - each relationship is different and you have to respect their marriage and roles towards one another.

A bit OTT in your gifts IMO but then again, this is a big day for you too as Grandma so can understand you getting over-excited.

juuule · 23/03/2007 15:03

You are being unreasonable.

"After this episode I have lost every bit of respect I had for him."

What because he didn't get a card? Seems a bit extreme. Your dd isn't his mother. My dh doesn't even get his own mother a card (although he probably would if I didn't). I wouldn't expect him to get me one.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 23/03/2007 15:02

you are being unreasonable. your dd lives with her dp now, not with you. you are her mother but she is no longer a child and it is not your responsibility to ensure that certain things happen on certain days.

And I'm not even sure I agree with your gesture of sending a card/flowers tbh.

How would anyone on here feel if their mil sent cards to your dh's/dp's on fathersday? I can see the thread titles already!

MerryMarigold · 23/03/2007 15:00

ummm....'them' being your dd and her dp.

also, last year as it was my 1st mother's day, my mum bought me a little mug 'because you are such a good mum to your ds' and it actually meant more from her than it would from dh.

beckybrastraps · 23/03/2007 15:00

He's not cruel. That is overstating it rather wildly. My sister's dp has 'issues' around Mother's Day, but I know she would feel a bit flat if there was nothing at all for her on her first mother's day. I sent her an e-card, so that she got something, but so that it wasn't in-your-face, as I'm afraid I think your contribution was.

MerryMarigold · 23/03/2007 14:58

i don't thinnk it's very nice of him, but i wouldn't call it CRUEL. sounds like you two have some history for you to get so upset over it.

i got nothing from dh for mother's day. last year i basically told him he should get something - surprise, surprise i did! he does not come from a present or card giving family so he is not used to all this malarky. this year, i just told him i was going to get my mum stuff and showed him what i'd bought. he did not get the hint. i was upset! i feel like it's the one 'official' day that appreciation is felt and shown.

but tbh i would be annoyed if my mum had a go at dh about it. it is between them.

powder28 · 23/03/2007 14:54

I bought my dh a silver rolo for valentines day once and he just looked at it and said 'thanks, what do i want a silver rolo for?'
He did buy me one of those huge cards for my birthday once. it was bigger than me and he was very pleased with himself. ifelt really embarrassed opening it in front of my smirking family.

mishw · 23/03/2007 14:53

I don't think you were being unreasonable - a little over the top with your gifts maybe!

Some people just don't celebrate all the festivals in the same way, I know my DH never really got into Christmas until we got together and saw just how my family celebrated it - he now loves Christmas (pretty much the same with birthdays too!) It didn;t make him a cruel person - his priorities were just different.

However saying all that, my DH knew that MD was important to me so he and DD1 (3yrs) made a card for me (with a squiggle from DD2 - 6m!) and DD1 bought me breakfast in bed and it was wonderful.

I don't think that MD needs to be comercialised, its just the thought and the appreciation from you DH/DP when the kids are too young or the children that makes it special.

What did your DD think by the way?

PrincessPeaHead · 23/03/2007 14:49

oh for god's sake.

beating her up is cruel, not doing a fake card from a baby on mothers day is just a difference of opinion. lighten up. and stop trying to control every aspect of her life.

I couldn't give a toss about mother's day and I've got 4 children

now I'll read the rest of the thread and see if anyone agrees with me!

McCadburysDreamyegg · 23/03/2007 14:49

I started a thread like this the day before mothers day as my DH doesn't do anything for me and I think this is unreasonable.

As far as I'm concerned there are 2 days a year that I expect a card and that's my birthday and mother's day. It makes me feel very unappreciated.

For DH's first father's day I bought him an engraved gentlemans fob watch as a momento of becoming a father!
Rant over

AnneJones · 23/03/2007 14:47

I too think it's sad that her DP didn't feel moved to thank her for being the mother of his first child and moved enough to show it. I can understand how you have got upset, Betty.

Trouble is, if you do the things he's supposed to do, he sounds like the type who will think 'oh well, I don't need to bother then'.

I sent my sis a tiny present for Mother's Day this year; it's her first and I felt moved to mark the occasion. I won't make it an annual thing. I don't think her DP bothered, but then he's cut from the same cloth as your son-in-law from the sound of it.

Skyler · 23/03/2007 14:46

It is always the fourth sunday in Lent in the UK.

Skyler · 23/03/2007 14:44

Hi Eleusis

Was wondering what had happened to you. Hope all is well.

vimfuego - Mothering Sunday is a Christian festival. I do not think Clinton cards have much to do with arranging that one. Just exploiting it.

Eleusis · 23/03/2007 14:42

I don't think this is about the the cost of it. It is about saying "Happy mother's day. Let ME change the nappies today"

Eleusis · 23/03/2007 14:41

Hi Skyler

Eleusis (firmerly Uwila)

vimfuego · 23/03/2007 14:40

Your DD's DP should be paying his tithe to the twin gods of Hallmark and Interflora like a good consumer. How dare he decide when and how to give gifts to his partner. This is not our place - the dates are carefully set by Clinton Cards and we must obey them.

Skyler · 23/03/2007 14:37

Gosh I am actually surprised people think you are being unreasonable. My dh organised two cards this year, one from each dd which I felt was a bit OTT. We had agreed no presents as we are a bit strapped this month.
I would have been very upset if he hadn't done anything and I am afraid I would have seen it as an example of him not appreciating me as the dd's are too young to.
My first Mothering Sunday was when dd1 was 6 days old and I had a lovely card, and printed digital photo in one of those clip things. I was over the moon he had thought to do that for me and it meant an awful lot to me and I felt it was a lovely supportive gesture from him towards me as a Mother.
I do not see Mothers Day/ Mothering Sunday as a wholly commercial thing as for us it is celebrated at our Church too. I do the same for dh on Fathers Day (even though that is a commercial American import) but I will not get involved with Grandparents day. Please!
I do not send to my step-mum as she has her own children.
So yes I think your dd's DP was being unreasonable.
However sending two cards and flowers and chocs was a bit OTT. One card and flowers or chocs would have been lovely.

Eleusis · 23/03/2007 14:30

I think your DD's DP ia a complete and utter arse for neglecting her first mother's Day.

My first mother's day was a big disappointment and not likely to be forgotten.

But,even worse than mine, your DD's DP had it explained to him before the day. So, he new it would be expected and still did nothing.

How does your DD feel about all of this?

PinkTulips · 23/03/2007 14:12

my friends mother died when he was a teen and he still has trouble dealing with mothers' day. maybe dd's dp has the same issues and just can't deal with it all?

mammaduck · 23/03/2007 14:10

My DH "forgot" to do anything for my first mother's day, when DS was 6 months old, and I was hurt.

As I have said on other threads, I think that until children are old enough to sort Mother's Day cards for themselves, they should be helped to make one, or scribble in one that the DH/DP has bought.

I see Mother's Day as much as an opportunity for men to just take stock and say "thank you" to the women who are the mother of their children for all those women do for the children.

Having said that, there's no way I would have sent cards, flowers and chocs to another woman. Agree this is way too much interfering. My son's godmother said to me she nearly sent me a card on my first mother's day, but felt that it was my DH's job and she's right - it was. A shame he didn't see it that way, but he's been put straight.

It's not just a commercialised thing for some people. It's actually a recognised festival in the church we belong to, so it's only right that it is acknowledged.

Come on, how hard is it to get a child to scribble on a piece of paper, fold the paper in half and write "Happy Mother's Day" on it? But I think it's a gesture that can mean a lot.

suejonez · 23/03/2007 14:09

my mum bought me a card and very small bunch od flowers from DS, I thought it was very sweet as he carried the flowers to me. Mind you I have no DP so I guess she didn;t have anyone to interfere with.

You can choose to celebrate Mothers Day (and Fathers Day and Xmas and ...) without it being a "commercial rip-off" - a card and a small bunch of flowers and a lovely day wth my DS was all I needed. I don't understand why so many people are so vitriolic about Mothers day - you can celebrate your mother without it being a rip off.

(But for the record I think 2 cards and chocolates and flowers was a little OTT - he no dount thinks you are trying to show him up rather than being nice to your DD)

Swipe left for the next trending thread