Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want my dd to take part in a fast?

37 replies

Aimsmum · 22/03/2007 19:22

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thcc · 09/04/2023 23:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

pooka · 23/03/2007 10:35

But as Aimsmum said, her dd is currently not eating much breakfast and has been having dizzy spells so presumably relies quite heavily on her morning snack.
Agree that wouldn't really faze me with a child that eats a hearty breakfast and is otherwise well and healthy. But in this case I don't think the OP is being unreasonable.

Judy1234 · 23/03/2007 10:35

In the atholic church just like the jews you are not technically within the requirement for fasting and abstinence on Good Friday and Ash Wednesday until you're about 14 I think it is. It's the same with Muslims - similar exclusions eg if you're ill or pregnant during ramadam. But we're just talking here about not eating between breakfast and lunch time. Arguably it's better not to eat then anyway and have a bit breakfast and big lunch with no snacks. Children eat far too many snacks so it's not really fast at all, just skipping their apple at break time.

SherlockLGJ · 23/03/2007 10:31

And I am aware that AM Jr does not eat breakfast and so it is somewhat different, but the world is going mad it really is.

SherlockLGJ · 23/03/2007 10:30

It is a piece of fruit.

Assuming the child has had a decent breakfast and they are having their lunch I fail to see the issue, I really do.

marialuisa · 23/03/2007 10:27

This is quite a common thing in RC primaries though. The kids just get a drink at morning break rather than a drink with an apple, it's not comparable to a Good Friday fast or fasting during Ramadan!

If you don't want your DD to take part thats' your choice but I don't think missing an apple at 10.30 is particularly extreme.

OrmIrian · 23/03/2007 08:19

We used to have a tear fund fast every term at my school. Actually it wasn't a fast - we had soup and bread for lunch rather than a big cooked meal. But we were secondary level not 6.

earlgrey · 23/03/2007 06:40

Have only read the title, so excuse me if this has been already said.

Have the school gone stark raving mad???? Is it a religious school. DDs school is always asking for money for one charity or another, but ffs, they're PRIMARY school children and need all the calories they can get.

mousiemousie · 23/03/2007 06:29

this is a misplaced idea - I would object to the school

katelyle · 23/03/2007 06:23

I wonder whether it would be better to keep your dd off for the day rather that let her be the odd one out. Seems like a perfect time for a diplomatic illness!

Ladymuck · 22/03/2007 23:05

When I was at primary school we weren't allowed playtime snacks, and I don't remember my friends from other schools having them either - I assumed it was just some new vogue. ds1 is allowed to bring in one snack (fruit), but generally doesn't get round to eating it tbh. I can see that if your dd isn't having breakfast then there may be an issue, but personally i wouldn't be fussed is ds1 had to give up his apple for one day (and I suspect neither would he). Asking him to give up lunch on the other hand would be a very differnt matter.

charlottegeorgiaolivermums · 22/03/2007 23:00

Is the school mad. There must be a number of parents who think this is mad. I'm a Christian and we believe in fasting but not for children.

On the other hand if all the children are doing it will she feel left out if she's not aloud too.

Maybe calling school 1st thing for them to explain is a good idea. If she real wants to do it can you not get her some kind of energy sweets and energy drink so she keeps her strength up. But I agree personally that I wouldn't want my dd to do it but also wouldn't want her to be the only different one in case the other children picked on her.

Blu · 22/03/2007 22:50

I'm not sure that missing a breaktime snack is actually 'fasting', but i still think it's a crap idea!

Blu · 22/03/2007 22:49

I agree 100% with Madamez.

Every summer people sleep out on a local green space in sympathy with homeless people and to raise money. Drives me bonkers. It isn't anything like being homeless, if don't realise that having to sleep rough as a way of life is horrible you don't deserve the brain you were born with, and they would be better off getting a good night's sleep, working extra hard the following day with refershed minds and sending a bit of their salary earned as a result to Shelter!

mummytosteven · 22/03/2007 22:43

btw jewish children aren't expected to fast until bar/bat mitzvah age - 12/13. and it's fine for any child or adult to take food/drink if it's necessary for health reasons.

losty · 22/03/2007 22:41

fasting at 6 is unreasonsable

Rhubarb · 22/03/2007 21:40

OMG I misread the thread title as fart!

madamez · 22/03/2007 21:39

Aimsmum: are you on sufficiently friendly terms with any other parents of kids at that school to see if they feel the same? Because having several parents approach the school and say, look, this is a bunch of stupid bullshit that we do not want you subjecting our kids to, may make the school have a rethink. Might be wroth a try, anyway.

Nightynight · 22/03/2007 21:03

I think this is totally inappropriate as well. They are children, fgs!

PinkTulips · 22/03/2007 20:42

grrr.... this makes me so mad every year!

over here we have the stupid trocaire fast every year and it so upsets me that young children are encouraged to do it, especially as many of them can't go that long without food. many of them faint and are unwell and personally if i'd done it as a child it would have triggered a massive migraine.

you're totally right to be annoyed and i certainly wouldn't allow her to do it given her health

joanna4 · 22/03/2007 20:39

I too think this highly inappropriate I trust this will be regimented right through the school - i do hope not!
Sad to think even one child may think ooh i skipped a break snack wonder if i can do it tomorrow too then it becomes break and lunch and so it becomes the vicious cycle of eating disorders.Or the child who is diabetic and bloody needs that break snack you are right not to want your child to partake.

Caligula · 22/03/2007 20:29

Wankers.

Even catholics and muslims understand that anyone under the age of 7 is too young to participate in any act of religion that involves physical denial - hence anyone who hasn't done first communion (normally done at 7 or at least in the past it was) not participating in Lent, or any child not being expected to fast for Ramadan. From what I remember, Jewish children aren't expected to fast for Rosh Hashana either.

FGS. Six. For catholics, these guys are confused. This is a very inappropriate activity. They'll be doing scourging next.

Aimsmum · 22/03/2007 20:08

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
wanderingstar · 22/03/2007 19:47

You are completely reasonable, even without your dd's circumstances. ^6 is very young for this, though I realise it's only breaktime.

madamez · 22/03/2007 19:46

I despise this sort of thing anyway, it's nothing but posturing when adults do it and totally inappropriate for kids, who actually need to eat little and often. Would suggest to the school that there are better ways to educate pupils about helping others, rather than feeding the gruesome Comic Relief mindset that putting oneself or others through either a painful ordeal or a total humiliation to raise a negligible amount of money is somehow morally better than either handing over a cheque (for those in need at a distance) or doing something practical such as mending someone's fence, fetching their shopping, cooking them a meal or just listening when they want someone to talk to (for those in need of help locally).

Swipe left for the next trending thread