Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sorry for women having to work till they're 66

383 replies

lazylab · 01/07/2017 11:11

I have 2 friends, one 60 the other 61 who are just so tired and worn out. The 60 year old works full time in a factory, she's totally shatttered at the end of her shift. Basically they're just desperate for retirement, but no chance of that till they're 66. Both these women are single, still paying mortgages, one of them earning fairly good money but the other is basically working just to live, can't afford luxuries or holidays etc. It's just soul destroying. These are just two examples of the plight of those affected by the changes to pension age.

Working full time as a young woman is definitely not the same once you hit 60, the body struggles to cope. I realise it's the same for men too, especially the ones doing physical jobs.
Sorry if it sounds like i'm moaning, but isn't life just shit for some people. Sad

OP posts:
BrexitSucks · 02/07/2017 08:50

So the security robot will wrestle a real name, whip the hoody & balaclava off the face, know the vandal's address to send court summons to? I guess all because the robot's kid went to school with the vandal, or has seen the vandal in the shopping centre with his mother & knows where she lives, too.

Customer service in my life Yesterday...
When I went into the leisure centre, a robot didn't swipe my card thru, keep moving equipment for different sessions, wiggle the swimtag back or deal with moaning customers with highly variable complaints.
When I went to the cobbler, a robot didn't explain what I needed or have the skills to do the work.
When I went to the bike shop, a robot couldn't discuss options & point out other repair work that needed doing.
At the charity shop, a robot didn't explain where to put the donations bag or know they accept rags, too.
No robots in the pet shop, or drug store, or the library. Real people helping everywhere.

The public library is understaffed, true -- due to austerity!!

Today, A robot won't stack the shelves at supermarket & tell me where to find something.

user1471545174 · 02/07/2017 08:30

Thank you InvisibleKittenAttack. Between last night and this morning I'd been feeling gaslighted about my own memories of those brief years of real social mobility post-war to the end of the 80s (roughly).

makeourfuture · 02/07/2017 08:23

Technology doesn't replace customer service

It already has. Try calling customer service lines or using website forms. As for the security robot, it will simply register a miscreant's details and issue a court summons.

We are looking at the dire need for a basic income system. We can start it now and do it right. Or wait and panic.

user1487175389 · 02/07/2017 08:18

It's not equality. Women's lives are generally spent in an unpaid caring role that they're expected to juggle alongside paid work their entire adult lives. Men generally don't. Therefore women are twice as worn out by 60 and usually have grandchildren and/ or ancient parents they care for regularly. Until this burden is shared equally, women should have a lower retirement age.

InvisibleKittenAttack · 02/07/2017 08:18

makeourfuture - no, the 60s-80s was a great time for social movement via higher education- full grants covered all fees and were easily enough to live off - for example my mothers full grant was enough to pay her rent, buy books and food and in the last term, she had enough spare cash to buy her wedding dress. Students could also claim unemployment benefit in the uni holidays.

Throw in the golden years of grammar schools (not tutored), and in the 60s & 70s there were very high numbers of working class students.

It was a system that worked, but then got dismantled as it's failings for those who didn't benefit from it were prioritised.

BrexitSucks · 02/07/2017 08:13

Technology doesn't replace customer service. Tech doesn't stack shelves or clean floors & notice that a "Beware wet floor" sign needs putting out or removing. Tech doesn't sort the bad potatoes from good ones in the harvesting trailer. Tech doesn't fix itself when it wears out.

According to recent hype articles, here is a security guard robot that will take human security guard jobs. It can scan large areas quickly & report vandalism.

Too bad it has no arms to stop miscreants from pushing it over. Do you see legs to chase badly behaved kids up the escalator? Thought not.

Remember the household appliance revolution of the 1950s: every wife would start to have a life of leisure with so many conveniences to help her clean the home & easily cook the food. well, THAT really happened, didn't it? Oh, and there was hype in the 1960s that we would all be heading towards a life of mostly leisure due to technological change. And THAT really happened, didn't it. PAH.

To feel sorry for women having to work till they're 66
user1471545174 · 02/07/2017 08:10

I've been watching Tomorrow's World forever waiting for that to happen, bluetongue Grin

From observation and experience a lot of office work now is directed at fixing other work - IYSWIM - so replacing systems, correcting past errors, making new ones... Obviously in manufacturing a lot of work has already gone to technology.

I don't think the number crunchers give that much thought, they just crunch on the basis of current job patterns.

bluetongue · 02/07/2017 07:54

What about the expectations of technology making huge numbers of jobs obsolete? How does having the workforce work longer fit into this world view?

While on the one hand I'm expecting to work well I to my sixties the whole working landscape will be massively different once I'm that old.

user1471545174 · 02/07/2017 07:54

makeourfuture is incorrect but I am not going to continue that debate with makeourfuture. It may have been true in earlier decades but not after the Butler Education Act had made a difference.

Oldsu, you're absolutely right about paying in, taxation etc. I get mad when people who've only worked a couple of years start this, as though they are more productive (and therefore important) by virtue of being young Confused

Lweji · 02/07/2017 07:53

Oldsu

I wasn't talking about tax.

JustDanceAddict · 02/07/2017 07:39

My mum worked, albeit v part time, til she died at 71. She didn't need the money Andi asked her why she still worked in her late 60d and she said it got her out of the house & gave her something to do. I get that completely as she was a widow who lived on her own by then. She worked 3 mornings a week as a secretary a bus ride away. A bit different if you're doing a full time physical job though.
I expect to work for the next 20 years too. We certainly need the income. Even if we didn't, I need to 'do' something with my days!

PussCatTheGoldfish · 02/07/2017 07:20

DH has worked since he was 15 in the same physical, heavy job.

He is in his early 50s and has arthritis in his hands, knees, shoulders, elbows and neck. There is no way he can carry on into his 60s. His private pension will give him around £20 a week. Not quite enough to retire on!

There's a fair age gap so I won't retire for around 30 years or more. By which time the state pension probably won't exist.

makeourfuture · 02/07/2017 06:45

only the brightest people went to university in the 60's, 70s and 80s

When I speak of Social Darwinism this is what I mean. The truth, as stated above, is that only the wealthy could afford university.

But we have this ingrained in our thoughts. That the wealthy ARE more intelligent/better. That opening up university to lesser classes somehow compromised it.

It is not true.

SomeOtherFuckers · 02/07/2017 04:25

I'm only 22 ... I doubt I'll get to retire before in 75

Out2pasture · 02/07/2017 04:05

that money was not sitting in an empty pot...

BoomBoomsCousin · 02/07/2017 03:49

We're talking here about the state retirement age, i.e. when you get the state pension. And the state pension is not a plan based on investment. State pensions are paid out of current revenues - i.e. the tax base. It's the biggest part of the welfare state and the government in the 80s, when I was in school, knew that it was not sustainable as people were living a lot longer and the working people/retired people ratio was going to deteriorate.

Also, in the 80s we had a massive recession and investments tanked, hitting many people who didn't have final salary schemes and causing some final salary schemes to go bankrupt. So it wasn't a no brainer for private pensions either, but they did at least adjust earlier than the state did.

Out2pasture · 02/07/2017 03:17

but the investment schemes the pension plans were invested in were probably doing very well in the 80's and 90's.

BoomBoomsCousin · 02/07/2017 03:02

I don't think, generally, that it's unfair for people to be working when they are capable of it. I think it was unfair that so many in the 80s, 90s and 00's got to retire so early, despite such improved health at 60 and average life expectancy. Especially since we knew then that it was totally unsustainable and not raising the age then was shoring up a problems for those younger.

AvaCrowder2 · 02/07/2017 02:12

My mum received a letter saying she'd get a state pension at 62, then she got a letter saying it would be 65.5. My mum has worked as far as I know. They only do Toss women around like this.

Out2pasture · 02/07/2017 01:43

it's really sad that the goalpost has been moved.
I don't think there is much that can be done for those in the middle of this but going forward the discussion with our children about retirement planning has to happen beginning early on.

the one thing I have found disappointing with my retirement planning was the pension plan changes. I signed up to a certain plan and already they have changed it twice (deductible and coverage both dental and medical)

Oldsu · 02/07/2017 01:27

Lweji I get fed up with ignorant statements like yours Yes, but you'll have a larger unproductive group which has to be paid by those in work My 'unproductive' pensioner husband still pays tax how the hell can someone who still pays into the system be called unproductive, and just how many of 'those in work' who seem to be paying for everything are themselves getting tax free benefits like tax credits and child tax credits they may pay in but they themselves are taking out.

My dad worked for 70 years and paid tax for 70 years when I was child in the 50s/60s he worked 3 jobs 6 days a week, 18 hours a day, nowadays he would only have to work a fraction of those hours and then claim tax free benefits, actually I am bloody glad he no longer works and is unproductive - he has every right to be

user1471545174 · 02/07/2017 00:05

Cross post. Sorry I don't know what the WP is.

TalkinPeece · 02/07/2017 00:02

user1471545174
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence,
I was at Uni in the 80's - I know the ratio
you think I'm wrong (and the whole WP industry of the last 30 years was a lie)
PROVE IT

user1471545174 · 02/07/2017 00:02

That sounded unintentionally rude! What I meant to say was I have read lots of articles to support this, just not sure I could find one.

user1471545174 · 01/07/2017 23:53

No, do your own research, I was there.