Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sorry for women having to work till they're 66

383 replies

lazylab · 01/07/2017 11:11

I have 2 friends, one 60 the other 61 who are just so tired and worn out. The 60 year old works full time in a factory, she's totally shatttered at the end of her shift. Basically they're just desperate for retirement, but no chance of that till they're 66. Both these women are single, still paying mortgages, one of them earning fairly good money but the other is basically working just to live, can't afford luxuries or holidays etc. It's just soul destroying. These are just two examples of the plight of those affected by the changes to pension age.

Working full time as a young woman is definitely not the same once you hit 60, the body struggles to cope. I realise it's the same for men too, especially the ones doing physical jobs.
Sorry if it sounds like i'm moaning, but isn't life just shit for some people. Sad

OP posts:
Lweji · 01/07/2017 14:18

People shouldn't be expected to work til they drop dead. Capitalism is a shit system.

The main current problem is longer life expectancy and low birth rates.

Lweji · 01/07/2017 14:17

Surely it's one in one out?

Not strictly. People at work also generate jobs.

DJBaggySmalls · 01/07/2017 14:13

'suck it up, you wanted equality now you got it' is exactly the kind of attitude that got us into this mess.
People shouldn't be expected to work til they drop dead. Capitalism is a shit system.

ImNotWhoYouThinkIAmOhNo · 01/07/2017 14:10

The unfair aspect was not the change itself but the short time in which major changes happened, giving some women no time to adjust their financial planning. My DSIL died recently at 63 and hadn't seen a penny of her pension. My FIL and MIL have both been enjoying pensions for over 30 years (34 for FIL). Is it any wonder some women are angry?

sheephead · 01/07/2017 14:10

It's hard, especially for women (and men) who have worked in manual jobs or have specific health issues. My neighbours were fortunate in being able to stop work in their late 50s/early 60s, and go on pension credit. The eligibility was only based on the man's age of 63. But they only had one income for a long time (the man couldn't work due to health issues, and the woman worked in a shop), and after getting a benefits check they found out that their overall income would work out the same on pension credit as it was with one person working, because all their council tax and prescriptions were paid. So the woman stopped work and they have effectively retired because the pension credit rules allowed them to. Apparently they are changing the rules so that isn't possible any more, and the DWP have increased the minimum age.

StillDrivingMeBonkers · 01/07/2017 14:10

But correct me if i'm wrong but surely making people work till 66 and beyond will make jobs for young people and school leavers few and far between

We are an aging population. Retirees now outnumber sub 16yer olds. The biggest demographic is my age group - the 50-somethings - 1 in 3 of my age group will to be 100+. we are far fitter and healthier than ever before. Do you really think it fair the burden of paying pensions for 40 years (60-100) should fall on the subsequent generations.

And before someone comes out with the line "we paid into it, t'is ours", you need to remember the day the Welfare State was created it started paying out. Todays tax payers pay for todays pensions - there is no collecting your own little pot of gold.

deugain · 01/07/2017 14:07

Both these women are single, still paying mortgages, one of them earning fairly good money but the other is basically working just to live, can't afford luxuries or holidays etc

On plus side they won't have to fund increasing rent from fixed pensions - or keep working so they keep a roof over their heads.

I think as so many now can't afford to buy at all this will be an increasing issue.

MajorasMask · 01/07/2017 14:07

My mum is only 51 and had to take ill health retirement. She developed a neurological problem and chronic pain from her job as a postwoman for 14 years. Now she is better and she has to start looking at work again for her rent (plus she is bored!) but so many places have turned her down. She can't do the physical work she once did but wants to go back into retail. Then people get funny about her needing part time work due to her condition and offer contracts where you're obligated to work a full week if asked with only half guaranteed hours. She volunteers but even unpaid positions are difficult to find.

Me otoh - I'm 25 and doing fine in office work, don't expect the state pension to be there at all. I have the option of a private one but right now I can't really afford to put the money aside, but I know it's a bloody good offer (public sector) and I have to sort it out sooner rather than later. To be honest I feel like my mum gets the worse deal, she didn't know how much retirement age would increase and she's done a lot of physical work, most posties she worked with are knackered but have to carry on.

cardibach · 01/07/2017 14:03

Sorry, isn't the better option. Lost track of my syntax.

cardibach · 01/07/2017 14:03

Lweji why will you have a larger unproductive group which has to be paid by those in work?
Surely it's one in one out? You either pay 1 pensioner their pension having had the benefit of their ideas and effort, or 1 young person unemployment benefits while wasting their potential contributions in terms of ideas etc. I really don't see why paying the pension is the better option here.

JaneEyre70 · 01/07/2017 14:00

My Mum is 70 and still working more or less full time, but she's beyond exhausted and is suffering with ill health as a result. She and my stepdad are terrible spenders, they are now thinking of equity release meaning they will lose their one and only asset but that's a whole other thread. It doesn't help that Mum is in partnership with my sister, who doesn't seem to recognise Mum's age or health being an issue. Hence we have a very fractured family dynamic because of it. If someone is working through choice for company and socialisation, I have no issue but when it's affecting their quality of life then it's really upsetting.

lljkk · 01/07/2017 13:53

Today's 65yo woman can expect to live another 20 yrs before dying.
Hooray for modern medicine but no way is it economically realistic for everyone to spend almost 1/3 of adult life in full retirement on a pension.

SleightOfHand · 01/07/2017 13:53

Not everyone can have a good career Ganoush, we would fall apart if we were all doctors and lawyers etc. Exactly.

AfunaMbatata · 01/07/2017 13:48

I work in a nursing home, I'm probably going to have to work there untill I need to move in there myself! Confused

sashh · 01/07/2017 13:46

It is right that women are brought in line with men

True, but it should only apply to women born after the sex discrimination act became law.

VestalVirgin · 01/07/2017 13:40

People should be allowed to work as long as they like. For people who have jobs they like, retiring isn't always beneficial.

But factory work? No way.

It should be acknowledged that not all jobs are created equal. A 90 year old may well enjoy working as university professor, but someone of that age shouldn't be forced to do physical work!

And yes, women's reproductive labour should be taken into consideration with regard to retirement age and money.

Women living longer doesn't mean much. Longevity has little to do with ability to work. With modern medicine, people can be chronically sick for years, and some chronic diseases are much more common in women than men.
If a man drops dead from heart attack at age 60, that doesn't mean he was too weakened to work at age 50.

kiddietoysnetwork · 01/07/2017 13:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JaceLancs · 01/07/2017 13:38

I will be working till 68 just not sure what I will be able to do by then
Will probably have to work part time after that as tiny pension and no savings
My mortgage will be paid off when I'm 65 at least
In contrast DM took early retirement at 51 DF 65 (26 years ago) both are on final salary pensions and have a standard of living I dream of

AllPizzasGreatAndSmall · 01/07/2017 13:37

How about the physical toll carrying children has on the body? Don't want to go into detail, but having two children has definitely changed my body for the worse, problems which DH doesn't have.

Not all women have children and of those that do, the vast majority are not physically affected in a way that is detrimental to their ability to work.

juneau · 01/07/2017 13:36

I do have some sympathy with people who have had pension age changes sprung on them and their retirement age drastically adjusted upwards. These people (mainly women), did not realise they should be saving to make up that difference when they were young enough to be able to do so. It is, of course, fair that men and women get to retire at the same age and I think it's good that those two ages are being brought into line.

I think too that there needs to be a complete shift in thinking. Young people should be starting a pension as soon as start work and they should pay into it every month. I'm in my early 40s I know lots of people with hardly any savings who did not do this and they are going to be basically fucked if they want or need to retire before 70, because the state pension is already at barely subsistence/poverty levels. In 25 years' time it will be worthless.

WE ARE ALL ON OUR OWN and the sooner we realise this and save accordingly for old age, the better.

Mysterycat23 · 01/07/2017 13:35

The majority of people won't be working until the state pension age. They will be let go, downsized, off long term sick. They will be forced to claim ESA or JSA until state pension age.

But those payments are lower than the state pension per week so I guess the numbers are preferable?

It is all completely insane, tragic, and I have no clue what a solution would look like.

Parker231 · 01/07/2017 13:34

Retirement in your mid/late 60's is going to be grim but I agree that the state retirement age should be the same for men and women.

TestTubeTeen · 01/07/2017 13:34

Women of that age started their working lives being told they could draw state pension at 60. Then it was equalised with men's 65, then put to 66 for all.

I think it iniquitous that people cannot retire at 65, unless they have been lucky / well paid enough to have a big enough private pension pot to draw on,

skyzumarubble · 01/07/2017 13:32

I fully expect there to be no state pension when I'm older. I do have a private pension but can't imagine being able to afford to take it at 60.

Malfoyy · 01/07/2017 13:31

My fil is 76 and retired at 53. DH will be 70 if he's lucky.

It's shit but this is reality.

Also how do you think they'll pay their mortgages if they retired now?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread